Gerald of Wales, Part I: Early Life and Works
The son of a Norman Marcher lord and a Welsh princess, J.J.N. McGurk writes, ‘Giraldus Cambrensis’ was a brilliant recorder of British life in the twelfth century.
No twelfth-century writer is more familiar to English readers than Gerald of Wales - more commonly known by the scholastic form Giraldus Cambrensis. In the great mass of Anglo-Norman literature of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, much of it serious and dull, none blends information and entertainment more successfully in a wide range of works than Giraldus. Readers need little skill in criticism to see his vanity, credulity and lack of consistency; yet all who read him are attracted by his wit, charm and learning, no less than by his deep love of the natural beauties of Wales and Ireland, described with topographical detail.
It would be a mistake to write of Giraldus as a self-opinionated buffoon, with a gift for garrulity; for he is reckoned among the most learned of a learned age, versed in languages, a master of rhetoric, and keen observer of the many tempestuous events, intrigues and controversies of the second half of the twelfth century. A brilliant stylist, yet of prodigious output, Giraldus self-consciously wrote for posterity, ensuring in his books (as did the fortunate survival of his manuscripts) that no serious student of the twelfth century would fail to notice him.
Gerald’s life was one of travel, intrigue and controversy; on account of this, and of his own aristocratic origins, he was in a position to know the eminent of his age; kings, popes, statesmen and scholars were among his familiars. Three times a potential Bishop to the see of his beloved St David’s, Gerald was never to achieve his lifelong ambition to have the see raised to metropolitan status - its ancient position as he passionately believed - and to gain the see for himself. Not to have been Bishop of St David’s was the greatest failure of his life; he could have had at least four other bishoprics, two in Ireland and two others in Wales; but, as he put it, ‘all these offers he trod underfoot as a hindrance to his studies, which he assiduously pursued.’
It is not surprising in a writer of such prodigal self-revelation that he could not resist writing his autobiography, De Rebus a se Gestis. Here is a treasure unique in medieval English writing, but characteristically inaccurate at times as to chronology, persons and places. The work ends abruptly; but the narrative of his long and varied life’s story, as supplemented from the De iure et statu Meneunensis Ecclesiae, or The Rights of St David's, is practically complete.
It is erroneous to style him ‘Gerald the Welshman’ as several Welsh writers have done, for on his father’s side he was Norman, and on his mother’s half a Norman. His father, William de Barri, belonged to the Norman Marcher lordly family, which had settled in Pembrokeshire; his mother Angharad, the daughter of Gerald of Windsor and of Nesta, daughter of King or Prince Rhys ap Tewdwr, and so the celebrated ‘Helen of Wales’, therefore gave Gerald descent from the Welsh royal house.
Gerald was inordinately proud of his lineage and of his family, not without reason. He was born at Manorbier Castle, about 1146, lived into his late seventies and died in the early years of Henry III’s reign, probably in 1223. His active and uneasy life was passed under the three Plantagenet Kings of England, Henry II, Richard I and John. His attachment to his birthplace was deep; and of it he lyrically wrote in the famous Itinerary of Wales:
The land is well stored with wheat, fish, and wine is imported, and better than every other advantage, from its nearness to Ireland, it enjoys a salubrious climate. As Demetia is the fairest of all the seven cantreds of Wales, and Pembroke the fairest of Demetia, it follows that Manorbier is the most pleasant spot in all Wales.’
When Gerald was only two years old his maternal uncle, David FitzGerald, was elected Bishop of St David’s; and the event was to have a decisive effect on his future career; Gerald always refers to his uncle as David II to distinguish him from the patron saint of Wales. His father entrusted this uncle with Gerald’s education, and pointedly used to refer to his youngest son as ‘his little bishop’. Much later in life, Gerald said of himself that he ‘wanted nothing so much on earth as the great glory of Christ’s Church; and of this period of his early life he tells us unashamedly that he outstripped all his Welsh contemporaries in learning.
Two of his uncle’s chaplains reproved him for wasting his time; one made him repeatedly decline, durus, durior, dnrrissimus, and the other stultus, stultior, stultis-sifnus, and henceforth, he says, he never looked back in his studies. After he had left the care of his uncle, Gerald went to the school at St Peter’s Abbey, Gloucester, where under the tutorship of the learned Haimon he became proficient in the classics. From Gloucester Gerald went to the university at Paris for higher studies, where according to his own testimonial he was pointed out by his masters as a model of piety and good scholarship.
While he was studying at Paris, two of his brothers and a large number of his cousins, the FitzGeralds, FitzHenrys, the FitzStephens, the Barrys, the Cogans and Carews had become the vanguard of the Cambro-Norman invasion of Ireland in 1169, and ensured its initial success. Proud of the martial exploits of his kinsmen, as, indeed, he was of the Norman successes in England, Wales, Sicily and in the East, Gerald returned to England in 1172, being then about twenty-five years old. He may then have been ordained priest; but this is uncertain. Certainly, as the nephew of a Bishop he did not lack the opportunity for acquiring benefices. Livings in Pembrokeshire, Llanwnda, Tenby and Angle, in Oxfordshire, St Mary’s Chesterton, a prebendary of Hereford and a canonry of St David’s all eventually came his way.
But what proved to be the climax of ecclesiastical preferment came to him in 1174/5, when his uncle appointed him Archdeacon of Brecon; a young, zealous and self-confident Archdeacon, Gerald of Wales, the would-be archbishop of St David’s would end his long life still an Archdeacon - though in retirement at Lincoln, he reported there was some talk among the canons that he would be raised to the cardinalate! As Archdeacon, Gerald gained a kind of reputation in Wales; for he thoroughly enjoyed the reforming and disciplinary role of the office, castigating the lamentable condition of the Welsh clergy, their disregard for celibacy and lack of learning and failure to collect long-standing arrears of tithe. His efficient manner, added to the unpopularity of his task, necessarily made him enemies among clergy and native Welsh alike.
Gerald relates with relish how he brought the royal official, the sheriff William Carquit, to heel when out of contempt for Gerald’s authority the sheriff and the native Welsh plundered the priory of Pembroke and dared the Archdeacon to excommunicate the King’s officer in his own castle. Gerald replied that, when Carquit heard the triple bells of Pembroke, he would know that he was in the process of being excommunicated. The next day the bells rang out; the sheriff meekly went to the Bishop of St David’s for absolution and had the stolen cattle restored. The renowned clash with Adam, Bishop of St Asaph, tells us so much about the Archdeacon’s character that it is worth re-telling at greater length than this clash with the sheriff.
Adam claimed jurisdiction over the church at Kerry, on the border between the dioceses of St Asaph and of St David’s, but formerly administered by the latter. He proposed to dedicate the church at Kerry on a certain Sunday; Gerald heard of this, hurriedly travelled to Kerry, gathered an entourage of clergy and armed men and was already in occupation of the church to await the Bishop’s arrival for the dedication. Messengers came from the Bishop to say that he firmly insisted on his rights to perform the ceremony. Eventually the two processions came to a confrontation at the cemetery gates; a fierce argument ensued in which Gerald reminded Adam that, since his uncle, the Bishop of St David’s, had recently died, the diocese was in the King’s custody. Undaunted, Adam read out the Archbishop’s letters confirming him in his rights to the see of St Asaph, which included the church at Kerry. Books were also produced. Gerald retorted that anybody could write anything in a book, and demanded charter evidence. Mutual threats of excommunication were then exchanged. But how could an Archdeacon excommunicate a Bishop? Neither can a Bishop,
Gerald snapped back, excommunicate an Archdeacon not in his diocese. The Bishop dismounted, clapped on his mitre, advanced with pastoral staff and proceeded to a general excommunication of all who resisted the rights of St Asaph. In a voice louder than the Bishop’s, Gerald began his own excommunication against the Bishop and his followers; and on his orders a peal at triple intervals rang out to confirm Gerald’s sentence. Adam lost his nerve, retreated in confusion amid shouts and a shower of sticks and stones from the Archdeacon’s supporters. Gerald, the younger and less learned man, was no respecter of persons; he tells the tale with vigour, characteristically calling Adam a fellow student in Paris, whereas Adam was none other than the Adam of Petit Pont, renowned as a teacher in his school over the Seine at Paris. The story reached Henry II’s court and caused much merriment there to Gerald’s great satisfaction. Gerald wrote of the incident twenty years later with every detail of the excommunication ritual, the lighted candles, the bells, the solemn condemnation, recalling his own part particularly in every dramatic detail.
Gerald already saw himself as the champion of canonical order; but rejection by the King, Henry II, of the canons’ choice to succeed David FitzGerald in 1176 would gradually drive Gerald to champion the rights of the Welsh church against all comers - the King, the Pope and Canterbury. His Celtic strain was to make him sympathize with the native Welsh; but to call him a typical Welsh patriot of the clerical class is to exaggerate his own protestations of affinity with Wales. As his writings on Wales admirably illustrate, Gerald was a child of a foreign culture that was finding its feet in Welsh society. The land and its people were bound up with his ambitions.
Henry II was bent on keeping Wales and the Welsh church in submission. Had he not after all survived the great crisis of Thomas Becket’s murder and the revolts of 1173? Understandably his choice for St David’s was the English Cluniac monk, Peter de Leia, whom Gerald described as a craven creature, unknown in name as in face to those who elected him. Though Gerald plied him with exhortations to support the independence of his church and evade the oath of subjection to Canterbury, the Bishop-elect remained unmoved. The greater crisis over St David’s, which came more than twenty years later, will be treated elsewhere.
Meanwhile, Gerald packed his books, left Brecon for Paris once more to learn and to lecture. He tells us that he wished to complete his studies in theology and law. Though he lectured on Gratian, he appears never to have studied law at the medieval home of legal studies, Bologna. Characteristically, he also tells us that, whenever it became known he was to lecture, so great was the audience that the most spacious hall could scarcely hold it, and that the listeners hung on his every word and could not hear enough of his eloquence. His autobiography contains an introduction to one of those lectures, which, allowing for the apparent dryness of the subject - canon law - and the change of lecturing styles, hardly merits such self-praise.
By 1179 Gerald was back in Wales, at a time when the Bishop of St David’s was having great difficulties in controlling the diocese; in fact, the burden became so much that for a time he deserted it. Gerald was appointed the diocesan vicar to restore order; but he took the part of the canons against the Bishop, and by 1183 had to resign his post. It was on this occasion that he made his first visit to Ireland in company with his brother Philip, who recruited armed aid for their uncle FitzStephen, then hard-pressed by the Gaelic Irish in Cork. Gerald spent the year collecting material for his two celebrated works on Ireland, The Topography of Ireland and the Conquest of Ireland; though both are blatantly Norman propaganda, the latter is a main source for the history of the Cambro-Norman invasion. The Topography of Ireland, the earliest of his works, was his own favourite, the most frequently revised and quoted from in his later writings.
He dedicated it to Henry II, which he later regretted doing, arranged to read it, over three days before selected audiences at Oxford, and generously sustained his listeners with food and drink. To judge from the many manuscript copies that have survived, as well as from his own testimony, the work was highly popular. Archbishop Baldwin took it on his tour of Wales in 1188; Innocent III kept it at his bedside as light reading. For centuries, the work remained the storm-centre in the controversies over the nature and value of early Irish society.
In 1622 John Lynch would write the Cambrensis Eversus to dispute its authority; but during the twelfth century there was no one to challenge his lamentable picture of the Irish, as ‘living on beasts, live like beasts, who think the highest pleasure is not to work and their greatest wealth is to enjoy liberty, but above all are treacherous, ill-instructed in the Faith by the ignorance and neglect of their pastors.’ Half a century earlier, St Bernard of Clairvaux in his life of St Malachy had painted a similar picture of the Church in Ireland. Perhaps Gerald had relied too much on St Bernard, and swallowed wholesale the tall stories told by the Irish themselves, who quickly discovered their guest’s appetite for the miraculous.
In the first part Gerald deals with Irish flora and fauna, and with the causes of the ever-prevalent rain, attributes the absence of poisonous reptiles to physical causes and denies the story of their expulsion by St Patrick, yet accepts the legend that barnacles on the sea-shore turn into geese. He also observes that, among birds of prey, the female is stronger than the male, which, he says, shows the superior capability for mischief in the female of every species. He refutes Bede, who had declared that Ireland possessed vineyards, and in part two describes the marvels and miracles attributed to Ireland’s Celtic saints, and other wonders, which he might have considered impossible, he protests, had he not seen them with his own eyes or received reliable reports. He then writes of witches in the form of hares, of miraculous wells, including one in Leinster that had the property of preventing hair from growing grey; of mills that would not work on Sundays; and in typical Celtic fashion, he connects his curious tales with every odd topographical feature that he comes across.
It was the third part, dealing with the origins of the Irish, their characteristics, dress and customs, that aroused so much heated argument. In his sketch of previous Irish history he omits all mention of the Golden Age of monastic and missionary endeavour abroad. Yet, with his usual inconsistency, he praises the Irish people’s skill in music, admires their illuminated manuscripts, remarks on their excellent physique, and says that, unlike the Welsh clergy, Irish priests are notable for the observance of the rule of celibacy.
Allowing for the fact that Gerald’s second book on Ireland, the Expugnatio Hiberniae, is a virtual chanson des gestes composed in honour of his war-like kinsmen, his sustained narrative of events from 1166 to 1185, based on his own memory and on what credible witnesses had reported to him, is still our main source for the history of Norman invasion of Ireland. Gerald finished writing it about 1188, and dedicated it to Richard I, another regrettable dedication; for in a revised version (c. 1208) he re-dedicated the work to King John, whom he had accompanied to Ireland in 1185 as royal chaplain from the court of the Prince’s father, Henry II.
The narrative of the Conquest ends with the disasters of that visit, which was intended to win over the Gaelic chieftains to John as the ‘lord of Ireland’, but whose puerile conduct, and that of his following, served only to increase their alienation. Gerald’s record of the invasion is invaluable for the light it throws on the intrigues among the Normans, on the suspicions Henry II entertained of Strong-bow, Earl of Pembroke, ‘whose pedigree was longer than his purse’, and for his vivid portraits of all the chief actors in the drama. From the pages of the Conquest the character and actions of Dermot McMurrough, the wronged King of Leinster, of Maurice FitzGerald, ‘a model of his country and his times’, of Robert FitzStephen, ‘too fond of women and wine’, and of such later arrivals as William FitzAudlin, ‘the snake in the grass’, come vividly to life.
But the Conquest is a one-sided account. We do not hear much from Gerald of what the native chieftains planned or thought. We must remember that he paid but three visits, saw only part of the land, and could not, therefore, fathom the Irish mind. Gerald makes Irish war-leaders animate their followers with set harangues from Greek and Roman history. The reader’s attention, however, is riveted as he describes the taking of Waterford and Wexford, the march on Dublin, the visit of King Henry II, the later daring adventures of John de Courcy in the north-east, and his twenty-seven-year rule of Ulster. But Gerald did not live to see the conquest of Connaught by the de Burgos, the de Lacys and the ubiquitous FitzGeralds. He lamented the fact that Ireland was never thoroughly subjugated to the English Crown, but quotes the ancient prophecy that Ireland shall be subdued by the English from the centre to the sea - some time before the Day of Judgement!
Prince John returned to England at Christmas 1185, having failed either to win over the native Irish or to secure the loyalty of Gerald’s kinsmen. For his own part, Gerald refused the Prince’s offer of the vacant bishoprics of Ferns and Leighlin, but stayed on in Ireland until Easter 1186, when he returned to Wales. St David’s and Wales became the main pre-occupation of his life both as a man of action and as a man of letters.
Two major works on Wales would follow, the Tour Through Wales and the Description of Wales. There are indications that he planned similar books on Scotland, which he did not write, but with his writings on Ireland and on Wales Gerald had established a claim to being the medieval historian of the Celtic fringe.

