Great Strafford?
C.V. Wedgwood analyses the life, death, and influence of Thomas Wentworth, first earl of Strafford.
‘Great Strafford! worthy of that name though all Of thee could be forgotten, but thy fall...’
So wrote the Royalist poet Sir John Denham who was one of the many spectators of Strafford’s trial in Westminster Hall in 1641. Denham proved a prophet, for Strafford’s trial and execution assured him of far greater fame than he would have gained had he avoided his fate by a timely flight and died in exile of natural causes. Then he would have left only the memory of an energetic, efficient and unpopular administrator. But the last six months of his life made him a memorable and dramatic figure in the conflict between King and Parliament.
Thomas Wentworth, Earl of Strafford, was by far the ablest minister in the service of King Charles I during the eleven years of his personal rule. It is possible that the King found his indefatigable energy rather tiring at close quarters, for he employed him most of the time at a considerable distance from the Court, first at York as Lord President of the North and then in Dublin as Lord Deputy of Ireland. In both places Strafford used his quasi-autocratic power to enforce law, order and respect for the Crown. Charles never gave him the post he longed for, that of Lord Treasurer, and this was Charles’s loss for Strafford was remarkably astute in all money matters and lack of money was the basic weakness of the Crown.
Only in 1640, in the disastrous concluding year of the King’s personal rule, with the Scottish Covenanters in rebellion and widespread unrest in England, did Charles turn to the ambitious indomitable Wentworth to get him out of his difficulties. Only then did he make him Earl of Strafford - an honour he had previously refused him.
Throughout 1640 Strafford battled against insuperable odds. He advised the calling of an English Parliament which he thought he could control, as he had controlled Irish Parliaments. He was wrong; the Short Parliament of May 1640 attacked the King’s policy and had to be hastily dissolved. The next problem was to raise an army to repel the Scots, but the troops unwillingly brought together were useless; ‘all the rogues in the kingdom,’ declared one disheartened officer. The Scots triumphantly crossed the border and occupied the northern counties. Many of the discontented English regarded them as friends and allies against the King’s unpopular government. Strafford had failed in the impossible task, and the bankrupt King was compelled to call a new Parliament.
As the King’s most powerful adviser, and by this time the worst hated man in the country, Strafford was the first object of attack. He still had time to go abroad, but the King leaned on him for advice, commanded him to come to London and gave him his word that, whatever happened, he would not let him suffer in life or fortune.
Parliament in November 1640 had a formidable leader in John Pym, one of the ablest managers of Parliamentary affairs that the House of Commons has ever known. He was also, with some others who remembered earlier times, an irreconcilable enemy of Strafford. Twelve years before, as Sir Thomas Wentworth, Strafford had been a leading opponent of the Court and an ally of Pym; his desertion to the King’s side was something they could not forgive. Within twenty-four hours of his arrival in London, he was impeached of High Treason and imprisoned in the Tower while evidence was collected against him. His trial before the Peers in Westminster Hall began in March 1641. The King was, so far, powerless to protect him.
The charge of High Treason was somewhat awkward to prove against a man who had acted throughout with the King’s authority. But it was, in effect, the King’s manner of government which was on trial and in Strafford it had an eloquent champion. He conducted his defence with great assurance, easily demolished a number of ill-considered charges and never lost an opportunity for expressing his respect for the institution of Parliament and the balanced constitution of England to which, in his opinion, he had always been true:
It hath been once my opinion, he said, which I learnt in the House of Commons... that the prerogative of the Crown and the liberty of the subject should be equally looked upon, and served together but not apart...
and again:
The prerogative of the Crown and the propriety of the subject... are fellows and companions that have been and ever must be inseparable in a well-governed kingdom; and no way so fitting to nourish both as the frequent use of Parliaments... the happiness of a kingdom consists in the just poise of the King’s prerogative and the subjects’ liberty... and things shall never be well till these went hand in hand together.
His well-ordered arguments and the dry wit with which he sometimes turned the tables on the prosecution made so strong an impression that the Commons began to fear that the Lords would acquit him. A Bill of Attainder was therefore hurriedly introduced and passed in the Commons. Attainder was a sinister and unusual measure for putting a man to death by Act of Parliament regardless of judicial niceties.
Meanwhile the fears and passions of the London mob were fanned by rumours of non-existent Popish plots and a military coup, planned with staggering ineptitude by hot-heads at Court and leaked before it was ripe. Angry crowds demonstrated outside the House of Lords and prevented known friends of Strafford from taking their seats. A very thin House of Lords passed the Bill of Attainder by 26 votes to 11.
The mob now milled threateningly round Whitehall where the Bill awaited the King’s consent. Strafford had written from the Tower a nobly phrased letter releasing the King from his promise to preserve his life. ‘Sir...my consent shall more acquit you herein to God than all the world can do besides. To a willing man there is no injury done...
Fearing for the safety of the Queen and his children, the King gave in. Three days later on May 12th, 1641 Strafford met his death on Tower Hill with dignified resignation, defending his political creed to the last:
My conscience bears me witness, that in all the honour I had to serve his Majesty I had not any intention in my heart but what did aim at the joint and individual prosperity of the King and his people... I wish that every man would lay his hand on his heart and consider seriously whether the beginnings of the people’s happiness should be written in letters of blood. I fear they are in a wrong way...
His words would seem prophetic when, fifteen months later, Englishmen were killing Englishmen in a war between King and Parliament. Strafford now became the proto-martyr of the Cavaliers. His name heads the lengthening lists of heroes who had died for their King circulated by Royalist printers as the war proceeded, lists often embellished with crude woodcuts of the martyrs - Strafford, Northampton, Carnarvon, Falkland... and, as the years went on, the King himself.
After the Restoration of the monarchy, Anglicans and Royalists honoured Strafford as the King’s loyal servant, the first to lay down his life for his master. Puritans, Nonconformists and later the Whigs hated him as the unforgiven villain, Black Tom Tyrant, who had betrayed the Parliamentary cause to serve the despot Charles.
Generally speaking, his reputation for a century after his death rested on party prejudice alone, though a few who wanted to know more of his case could consult the record of his trial in the edition published in 1680.
Then, in 1739, appeared a selection from his letters and papers, in two folio volumes, edited by the Reverend William Knowler, chaplain to Strafford’s great-great-grandson, Lord Rockingham, to whom the manuscripts had descended. Knowler’s majestic volumes, a pleasure to look at but rather heavy to handle, were for the next two centuries a principal source for Strafford’s biographers.
They give a vivid, varied and on the whole favourable picture of his personal and public life. But, shortly after the Second World War, Earl Fitzwilliam, to whom the papers had finally descended, deposited them in the Sheffield Central Library where historians have been able to consult them ever since.
It immediately became apparent that Knowler’s selection, large though it was, was only a fraction of the whole, a mere tip of the iceberg. When I first consulted the magnificent new material I was impressed (as I still am) by Knowler’s choice among Strafford’s personal letters to illustrate his character and private life - his selection reveals Strafford’s ambition, his impatience with incapacity and sloth, his belief in law and order - but especially order - his irritable temper, his confidence in his own judgement which was none the less combined with a great desire for praise and approbation, the fondness for rather silly jokes which he shared with his friend Archbishop Laud, his deep family affections and loyalty to his true friends - a select few, for he was better at making enemies. In all these personal matters the new material added many details of fact and atmosphere, but seemed on the whole to confirm what we already knew.
Knowler included some evidence of Strafford’s business affairs, both public and private, but very little in comparison to the great mass of new evidence on these and on more complex legal and political matters and quarrels with adversaries which can be found in the vast mine of the complete documents. I think the relatively little attention given to these things by Knowler, especially to financial affairs, was due to the taste of the eighteenth century, when readers of history were not much interested in such matters. But one cannot rule out a desire to conceal the darker shadows which he must have come upon in the course of his selection.
In the last twenty years, thanks to the availability of the Strafford papers, a fuller, much more complicated and less favourable picture has emerged. Strafford certainly enriched himself, and did not deny it, though he was indignant at being criticised for it. After all, everyone in high office did the same and it was expected that they should do so- within reason. It was more a question of what was, and what was not reasonable. Strafford thought, and indeed said in some of his letters, that what he got for himself was nobody’s business provided that he also increased the revenue of the King, which, to do him justice, was his continual concern.
When he took over the management of the Irish Customs from Lord Mountnorris he certainly made them pay better. Mountnorris, Vice Treasurer in Ireland, was making a good thing out of the Customs and was obstinately unwilling to resign his post. Strafford, determined to get him out by fair means or foul, made use of some indiscreet words he had spoken at a dinner party to try him by Court Martial for treason and sentence him to death. He neither carried out nor meant to carry out the sentence but it got rid of Mountnorris at the Treasury, and made Strafford another deadly enemy. There were several other occasions when Strafford got rid of men in high position by distinctly unscrupulous pressure.
In smaller matters of private speculation, Strafford conformed to the rather low financial morality of his time. In the words of the late J. P. Cooper, in his study of Strafford’s private fortune, he was not unwilling to frequent ‘the murky and devious by-ways where courtiers, great officers of state and businessmen jostled and exchanged tips.’
But unlike others he had astonishing powers of self-deception or duplicity. It is a psychologist’s problem to decide which term to use. He does seem, however, to have been much better at deceiving himself than at deceiving other people. His candid friend, Archbishop Laud, was sometimes startled by the vehemence of Strafford’s injured innocence when he heard of the spiteful rumours about his finances spread by his enemies. After all, there was a certain amount of smoke to cause the fire.
One case which occurred early in his career is interesting. In the winter of 1630-1 there was a serious famine in some parts of England. Strafford was then in London attending the King’s Council which issued stringent orders that corn should be sold at a fixed price and all engrossing and profiteering should be punished.
Yet Strafford instructed his steward in Yorkshire to buy in all the wheat he could and send it to London where it could be sold for a high price. The steward was not very happy about this but Strafford persisted. However, by the time the wheat arrived in London, the dearth was over. ‘God be thanked,’ wrote Strafford, ‘gains there will be none...’ a comment which suggests a singularly confused approach to the moral aspects of what he had been doing.
Yet his belief in the duty of government to give justice to all and protection to the weak against the strong was sincere. He fought for the country folk of Hatfield Chase in Yorkshire against the wealthy shareholders in a drainage scheme which was causing havoc by flooding their crops. He was tireless in organising the care and relief of the plague-stricken in York in a bad plague year. But he indulged in what Professor Aylmer justifiably describes as ‘sinister double think’ on almost everything that affected his own advancement.
He was the first to condemn others for holding several important and profitable offices at the same time, but he was an unrepentant pluralist himself. He even refused to give up his place as Lord President of the North when he went to Ireland, but held it conjointly with that of Lord Deputy of Ireland - leaving his responsibilities in England to a reliable Vice-President.
Even that noble act of self-sacrifice, his letter releasing the King from his promise to preserve his life, was not as straightforward as it appeared. He wrote it from the Tower after the fatal Bill of Attainder was passed by the Commons, but before the House of Lords had voted on it. The King himself had in the interim informed the Lords that he had given his word to Strafford and that he could not in conscience consent to the Bill. Strafford, much clearer-headed than the King, had seen at once that this was a dangerous mistake: the speech had hardened and provoked the enmity of his opponents in the House of Lords.
A few months earlier a Catholic priest, John Goodman, sentenced to death under the ferocious penal laws of the time, had been reprieved by the King. This action had aroused the rage of London Puritans and the mob, resulting in demonstrations against the King. Goodman had petitioned Charles to withdraw the reprieve because he would rather die than be the cause of dissension between the King and his people.
This petition had caused a reaction in Goodman’s favour and the clamour for his death had died away. Strafford can hardly have failed to have had this precedent in mind, and one passage in his letter indicated a clear connection with the Goodman case coupled with an attempt to refer his fate to the unhampered judgment of the Lords.
I put myself wholly upon the honour and justice of my peers, so clearly as to wish Your Majesty might please to have spared that declaration of yours on Saturday last and entirely to have left me to their lordships; so now to set your Majesty’s conscience at liberty, I do most humble beseech your Majesty for prevention of evils which may happen by your refusal to pass this Bill, and by this means to remove I cannot say this accursed, but I confess this unfortunate thing, forth of the way towards that blessed agreement which God I trust shall ever establish between you and your subjects.
This letter in fact is another, but wholly creditable example of Strafford’s ability to think and act on two levels at once. He can hardly have failed to hope that his letter of self-sacrifice - in order to preserve the unity of King and people - might have the same effect as Goodman’s petition in arousing sympathy with the Lords and perhaps wiping out the unhappy effect of the King’s well-meant but ill-advised statement.
But he must have known that it was only a chance and a slim one, and that it would only work that way if the King understood how to use it. The King made no political use of the letter. The Lords passed the Bill of Attainder and the King, released of his promise, consented to it.
It is impossible to sum up fairly a character at once so complex and so simple as Strafford’s -simple in his self-deception, in his ingenuous astonishment that people thought ill of him, complex in his mixture of genuine loyalty to the King and to his friends, with ambition, a keen appetite for power and money, and a sincere belief in his responsibilities and duties to the people - always provided they themselves did their duty in that station in life to which God had called them. Once or twice in his letters we find his true friends cautiously pointing out that he is giving cause for criticism and arousing enmity, only to be met by genuine amazement from Strafford. He never understood the working of other men’s minds. It was not his greatest fault, but it was his greatest handicap.
NOTES ON FURTHER READING
G. E. Aylmer, The King’s Servants: The Civil Service of Charles 1, 1625-1642, Routledge & Kegan Paul (London, 1961, 2nd ed, 1974) - of great interest on the character and problems of the administration, pluralism, corruption etc.;
J. P. Cooper, ‘The Fortune of Thomas Wentworth, Earl of Strafford’, Economic History Review, 2nd Ser., XI, December 1958, pp. 227-248 - basic for the background to Strafford’s enrichment;
Hugh F. Kearney, Strafford in Ireland, Manchester University Press (Manchester, 1959) - a very full study;
Valerie Pearl, London and the Outbreak of the Puritan Revolution, Oxford University Press (Oxford, 1961) - interesting on the Goodman letter;
Terence Ranger, ‘Strafford in Ireland: a Revaluation’, Past & Present, XIX, April, 1961 - a very perceptive estimate;
C. V. Wedgwood, Thomas Wentworth, Earl of Strafford, a revaluation, Jonathan Cape (London, 1961) - entirely replaces the author’s Strafford, Jonathan Cape (London 1935); revised in relation to the new evidence.

