Gilbert Burnet: Bishop and Historian

The author of the History of My Own Time was both a keen churchman and a compulsive writer. Mary Delorme describes how Burnet's style, whether graphic, humorous or pompous, was usually as free and expansive as the historian himself.

Gilbert Burnet was born in 1643, when England and Scotland were vexed by religious and political conflict; and he became a churchman early in life. He was a compulsive writer, whose expressed hatred of sectarian persecution soon lost him the favour of his bishops; and, after receiving a commission to write the Memoirs of the Dukes of Hamilton, he became an historian. Of his two greatest works, the first, A History of the Reformation of the Church of England, has its tercentenary this year.

It was immediately successful, and is still a useful work, like his History of My Own Time. The latter was written during the years between his late twenties and his death in 1715, recounting events as they occurred; it was intended for posthumous publication. Clerical influence returned to him only in middle age, when, as Bishop of Salisbury, he was able to put his advanced pastoral theories into practice.

The Burnets, though not aristocratic, were an ancient Scottish family. During Gilbert’s youth, Scotland was torn by sectarian struggles even more strongly than England; Episcopalians and Presbyterians alternately gained the ascendancy, and both were merciless. Gilbert’s father, Robert, was an unusually tolerant Episcopalian lawyer; but the family was divided; for his wife had been Rachel Warriston, and, despite a happy marriage, she could never relinquish her parents’ fierce Presbyterianism.

Gilbert, her youngest child, was only a few months old when Robert had to escape to Paris. His exile lasted several years, during which he admonished his bigoted brother-in-law. ‘Be not too violent then,’ he wrote, ‘and do as you would be done to, for you know not how the world will turn yet.’

The political situation changed, however, and Robert returned in time to undertake Gilbert’s early education, instilling physical self-discipline and a love of learning. The boy was talented; when still only seventeen, he passed the stringent examination for intending priests of the Episcopalian Church. He was even offered a living, but sensibly refused and continued his studies. Meanwhile, the Commonwealth had died with Cromwell; and early in 1660 King Charles II returned. Zealots such as Warriston fled, many of them settling safely abroad.

There was a tacit agreement whereby those not suspected of the worst brutalities were warned when warrants were issued for their extradition. Significantly, no one warned Warriston, who was brought home, imprisoned in the Tower, and, although his family made strenuous efforts to save him, eventually tried and condemned. During this time his brother-in-law, Robert, had died; and it fell to Warriston’s twenty-year-old nephew, as a priest, to console him on the scaffold.

Next, Gilbert travelled extensively in Europe; and, having observed with horror the devastation left by war, taxation and fierce religious persecution, particularly on the Papist side, he returned home convinced of the need for toleration between Protestants. Through his Parish work he made unpleasant discoveries. The Archbishops in southern Scotland still forced Presbyterians to attend church by flogging, fines and imprisonment.

Six years after the Restoration of the monarchy, persecution was being kept up by his own church. While he himself lived frugally, using his stipend to help needy parishoners, many priests took the stipend without visiting their parishes. They merely followed the bishops’ example; and Burnet was goaded into action. Disregarding the possible consequences, he addressed a Memorial to his superiors, each of whom received a copy. Persecution, absenteeism, services too pedantic for the ordinary laity to understand - he covered every shortcoming; and his most aggravating quality was his accuracy:

‘How contrary it is to the meek and rational spirit of the gospel,’ he declared, ‘to drive any into our Society by force... Now I must say it’s pretty odd, that Papists have masses without trouble, and are not forced to keep Church... and yet the Presbyterians are tossed and harrassed if they go not... I am confident that many of them have the fear of God before their eyes and therefore they deserve compassion from all.’

When he was summoned before the bishops, he needed more than eloquence to escape severe punishment; but help came from an unlikely source. Archbishop Sharp of Glasgow was so brutal that even his fellow bishops disliked him, and he was eventually murdered by Presbyterians who had suffered at his hands. On this occasion, his outbursts were so violent and dictatorial that his fellow bishops turned against him. They refused to excommunicate Burnet, and he received instead a stern rebuke.

Then, slowly, matters improved; for King Charles could not afford to permit continued strife, and began attempts at reconciliation. Burnet, now well-known to be an opponent of persecution, was an obvious choice as one of the mediators. He was also befriended by the Duke and Duchess of Hamilton and their friend, Lady Margaret Kennedy, daughter of the Earl of Cassilis.

At Hamilton Palace, he met the Rector of Glasgow University who had read his pamphlet ‘Thoughts on Education’, which was similar in philosophy to the work of Roger Ascham’s famous book The Scholemaster. The Rector was impressed, and offered Burnet the Professorship of Divinity. He accepted, and remained at Glasgow four years.

Meanwhile, his occasional visits to Hamilton Palace were agreeable; and, the family having been distressed by criticisms of the conduct of Dukes James and William during the Civil War, Burnet decided to write a vindication. The Duchess gave him a mass of family documents, ‘materials’, he said, ‘for a very large history’.

Revealingly, he added, ‘I got through that work in a few months’. He had all the necessary documents to hand; many eyewitnesses of the story could still be consulted; and the scholar Sir Robert Moray had persuaded him to discard his plan of a general narrative and quote many documents in full.

Commissioned to restore the Hamilton reputation, Burnet saw that he might reveal facts unpalatable to others equally concerned. In the Hamilton Memoirs the Dukes must be presented favourably; yet the late King’s memory must not be smirched, even though he and the Hamiltons were frequently opposed. The same problem arose with other protagonists; and it took so long to achieve some sort of balance that the Memoirs, ‘got through’ in a few months, awaited publication from 1673 until 1677.

But the manuscript was widely read; and the King himself read it without objection. The Duke of Lauderdale, Scotland’s most powerful nobleman, who temporarily regarded Burnet as his protege, asked him to bring it to London; ‘he was sure’, Lauderdale remarked, ‘he could give it a finishing’. The visit enabled Burnet to go to Court, where the King and his brother, the Duke of York, liked him, and he became a royal chaplain.

It was now that he formed his first serious attachment; his courtship of Lady Margaret Kennedy, a woman eighteen years his senior, whom he had first met at Hamilton Palace, had ended in a secret marriage. Burnet did not wish to remain in London any longer than was necessary to oblige Lauderdale and obtain a licence for the publication of his book; but, even in so short a time, he talked himself into trouble. Privately, he lectured the Duke of York about his Popish sympathies, and the King about his immorality.

The brothers remained amicable; but the Lauderdales resented Burnet’s apparent intimacy, and the Duchess demanded to be told the substance of his conversations. Her* directness took him by surprise. ‘As to the Duke,’ he admitted, ‘my conversation with him was about religion; with the King I had talked of the course of life he led.’

He reached home the night before the Scottish Parliament met. Lauderdale expected to carry a motion supporting Charles’s hostility to Holland; but Hamilton led a long series of speeches, demanding prior consideration of Scotland’s grievances. Lauderdale, having assured Charles that he was able to order the course of the debate, was enraged; and, looking for a scapegoat, he turned on Burnet. Charles was told that Burnet had boasted of his moral remonstrations, and the Chaplain was dismissed.

When Lauderdale was impeached by the Commons, Burnet was recalled to London as a witness. Examined by a committee, he admitted having heard Lauderdale wish that the Scottish Presbyterians would rise, so that he could ‘bring over the Irish Papists to cut their throats’. He himself had also dropped hints of Lauderdale’s plan to invade England and plunder the Presbyterians; but he now refused to confirm or deny it.

When he appeared before the Commons, initially he stood firm; but on his fourth appearance, the House became threatening, and he submitted. There was little choice; but his action was considered reprehensible. His own feeling was that ‘it was a great errour in me to appear in that matter’.

Of one extenuating circumstance he said little, except that he had been for above a year in perpetual agitation; his marriage had recently been discovered. In his Memorial he had scorned bishops who ‘married their daughters to gentlemen instead of other clergy,’ and now he, the youngest and the least, had married the daughter of an earl.

He had declared that women and clergy should avoid politics; yet his present trouble was the result of political activity, and his wife was politically-minded. Lauderdale’s anger made a return to Scotland unwise, and he resigned his professorship. Though Charles tried to prevent the appointment, Burnet became preacher in the Rolls Chapel, a post he held for ten years.

In many ways this was a period of content. His sermons were popular; his pamphlets sold well; and the Hamilton Memoirs were published in 1678. Though Burnet’s omissions and bias have been criticised, and he has been accused of downright dishonesty, there appears to be little difference between his method and that of a twentieth-century historian. For a modern writer objectivity is still elusive. Western historians can hardly be expected to give an impartial account of Nazism; and Popery, as Burnet had seen it, was similarly brutal.

Some points were omitted through ignorance rather than with intent. Thus, the Carisbrooke agreement between Charles I and the Scots in 1647 was not a creditable transaction, and he glossed over what he knew of it; but full details were not available until many years later. Neither did he care to insist that Charles II, during his early years in Scotland, had taken the Covenant to please the Presbyterians. For all his faults, Charles was regarded with affection by many Englishmen; and it was unlikely that an Episcopal Scot would be explicit on the subject.

In fact, the work was a history of a critical period, written as most contemporaries wished to read it. The book was warmly received; and the author seemed the right man to produce a History of the English Reformation, for which there had been a demand since the publication of a grossly inaccurate account by Sanders in 1676. Burnet began, and found difficulties.

He had been accustomed to dealing with original and readily accessible material; all the documentary evidence on the Reformation was uncatalogued and scattered among various arc hives. The State Paper Office, which had not been instituted until the reign of James I, contained only sparse records. The Bodleian contained more, but was so chaotic that it baffled researchers. The great collection owned by Sir John Cotton was far more promising. Sir John, however, being an acquaintance of Lauderdale, refused to admit Burnet.

Then a chance meeting with Sir John’s nephew solved the problem. The family were away for ten days; the nephew had access to the library; and Burnet, with his amanuensis Adam Angus, used that time to the full. Enough material was gathered for the first volume. On its publication in 1679 its success was immediate, and Lords and Commons hastened to thank the author and encourage him to write a second. The Cotton library was now officially opened to him; the manuscripts of Corpus Christi were made available, and funds contributed.

As the first enthusiasm began to diminish, informed readers became aware of error in the work. One, Mr Fulham, sent a list, and Burnet responded in his most disarming manner. Always willing to admit his faults, he would also accept adverse comment from others; and Mr Fulman’s corrections were printed at the end of the second volume with a gracious acknowledgement.

Mr Baker, Fellow of St John’s, and, later, the historian Strype, listed faults in the second volume and were accorded equal courtesy; Mr Baker remained a good friend until Burnet’s death. Like his words and actions, Burnet’s writing was impulsive.

People and events enthralled him; dates were secondary details. ‘Man is a strange, foolish and mad creature,’ he decided ‘...the providence of God, and the conduct of the world are the greatest of all mysteries.’ Even his strongest detractors, such as the Earl of Dartmouth, grasped his fundamental honesty: ‘I do not think he designedly published anything he believed to be false’. Swept along by the excitement of his narrative, Burnet often pronounced hasty judgements, modifying them later when the time came to summarise.

His predecessor’s flights of fancy were frequently exasperating; and, when he reached the cases of Fisher and More, Burnet became impatient:

He [Sanders] runs out in an high commendation of Fisher, and among other things mentions his Episcopal and Apostolic charity. His charity was burning indeed. He was a merciless prosecutor of hereticks, for that the rigor of the law under which he fell, was the same measure that he had measured out to others.

More’s personal attention to whipping and racking was similarly emphasised; ‘he showed them no mercy, but the extremity of the law...’ Yet toleration remained the basis of Burnet’s thought; his summaries were charity itself. Of More he wrote: ‘for justice, contempt of money, and true generosity of mind, he was an example to the age in which he lived’. Of Fisher, he was ‘a learned and devout man, but much addicted to the superstitions in which he had been bred up’.

After careful analysis of the evidence in the Boleyn trial, he turned to Henry Tudor’s state of mind: ‘Many circumstances were brought to the King, which working upon his aversion to the Queen, together with his affection to Mistress Seymour, made him conclude her guilty’. The view he develops of Henry is that of megalomania, bloated by the praise of sycophants, and one of Burnet’s comments therefore appears naive at first sight: ‘the severity of the law bordering sometimes on rigor and cruelty, he came to be called a cruel tyrant’. Yet, as Burnet had already shown, the rigour and cruelty were not invariably based upon law, but also upon personal whim.

Burnet’s informal style and his display of tolerance tempt one to forget the society in which he lived. Henry’s death was separated by less than a century from Burnet’s birth; and, close to ourselves though he seems in spirit, he was well accustomed to the sights and sounds of the scaffold.

Of the punishments inflicted by Henry, possibly the only one not witnessed by the historian was that reserved for poisoners, who were boiled alive. Thus, laws that now seem ferocious, to him were comparatively understandable; and, by appropriating another writer’s description of Luther, he aptly summarised the King’s achievements:

‘Henry... who, as the postilion of the Reformation, made way for it through a great deal of mire and filth’. His deep veneration for Elizabeth I is expressed with similar felicity: ‘She was admired even in Rome itself...’

Burnet’s inaccuracies, moreover, were not entirely due to haste. He and Adam Angus found the documents of the previous century difficult to decipher. He had also personal troubles; his wife was seriously ill; and, in his History of My Own Time, he mentions that he had to make excuses for staying so much at home. In spite of such difficulties, he was successful; and temporarily he became overconfident. He again reproved Charles for immorality. After a flurry of anger, the King generously offered him the bishopric of Chichester; but Burnet curtly refused.

Unknown to him, his friends Essex and Russell were involved in the Insurrection Plot. Essex committed suicide; Russell faced trial and execution. Between his fears for Russell, his horror at Essex’s apparent admission of guilt, and the danger of his own position, he behaved at first with seeming cowardice. He wrote to a friend at Court.

I had not the least suspicion of this matter... upon this I pass my word and faith to you. I do not doubt but you will make the like engagements in my name to the King... I do beg of you that no discourse be made of this.

Having opposed the King in spiritual questions, he was shocked to find his friends preparing to take stronger measures; the reign of the immoral Charles appeared infinitely preferable to civil war. The mood soon passed. Visiting Russell, he observed such gracious courage that his own fears dissolved. Indeed, his conduct now gave rise to more suspicion than before.

He supported the Russells throughout. A poor speaker, Russell wrote his last speech; and his wife had it printed and distributed immediately after the execution. Burnet, suspected of its authorship, was summoned before the Council, but would admit only that he had been consulted.

Charles was furious. ‘Burnet’, he announced, ‘would be content to be hanged, to have the pleasure to make a speech on the scaffold.’ Dismissed from his employment, he escaped temporarily to Paris; but Lady Margaret was dying. He returned after James’s accession, although he was still a prime suspect; and, although his wife no longer recognised him, he remained in England, trying to find a nurse of whom her family approved. His danger increased hourly; at the last possible moment, he returned to Paris. Before he arrived, Lady Margaret was dead.

Lady Russell’s warm recommendation had preceded him to The Hague, where William of Orange was biding his time. So was James, in London. Burnet had escaped to join the intending usurper; his anti-Catholic writings were a constant irritation; and, after a year, came the news that he was to be married ‘to a considerable fortune’. Mary Scott returned his affection; but, the day before the wedding, Burnet learnt that James had charged him with treason; next morning, he applied for naturalisation as a citizen of the States of Holland.

That afternoon he married his fellow-citizen. Hearing that ruffians had been hired to abduct him, he remarked whimsically, ‘They may make an attempt upon me that shall only go half way, and of all things in the world an operation of surgery is that which I apprehend most’.

By sailing to England as William’s chaplain, Burnet ran the risk of capture; and then James, under Scottish law, might have tortured him. But all went well; he was even able to calm William’s apprehensions that he might be forced into a position subordinate to that of his wife Mary, who as James’s daughter was legally Queen.

‘He said, that he had been married nine years and had never the confidence to press this matter on the Queen, which I had now brought about in one day.’ This was another period of content. Burnet’s new marriage was very happy; and, early in the new reign, the Toleration Act was passed. His father’s plea, ‘Do as you would be done to’, was at last on the Statute book.

When William III made him Bishop of Salisbury in 1689, Queen Mary remarked that ‘she hoped he would now put into practice those notions with which he had taken the liberty often to entertain her’. A priest since early manhood, he had always longed for reform. As a clerical enfant terrible, a professor, an historian and Sunday preacher, or as political dilettante in The Hague, his energies were rarely directed into ecclesiastical channels; but his Memorial remained fresh in his mind. If any doubts about his sincerity linger, his record in Salisbury must disperse them.

For twenty-six years he assisted the lower-paid clergy, many of whom laboured at starvation level, but not in his diocese; for he shared his stipend between them and the poor laity. No part of his see remained unvisited; ‘No words, no weather, no floods detained him’. He also strove for the better education of clergy and laity alike. He wished them a freedom that he felt was denied Papists - ‘the becoming a Christian by an act of their own’.

Inevitably, he aroused antagonism. A man known to his diocese as ‘The Good Bishop’, whose tireless activities put more sedentary clerics to shame, must have left some bruised pride in his wake, particularly when tactlessness was an inherent quality of his character. He even tried to influence the outcome of an election in favour of the candidate preferred by Queen Anne, and was never forgiven.

He had also a personal tragedy. Mary Burnet died of smallpox, leaving her husband with five surviving children, all under ten years old. After two bleak years, he married Mary’s friend, Elizabeth Berkeley: ‘One of the most heavenly-minded persons I have ever known’.

For many years he had kept a journal, to which he euphemistically referred as his ‘secret memoirs’. He had experienced stirring events; and naturally he wrote about them. Following the success of his other works, a contemporary history was the obvious next step, A History of my Own Time. Though caution led him to avoid publication, vanity compelled him to show it to friends as it progressed.

I have lived in such intimacy with all who have had the chief conduct of affairs, and have been so much trusted and on so many important occasions employed, that I have been able to penetrate far into the true secrets of counsel and designs.

So he wrote, with an almost childlike egotism. The History was written, re-written, and even then revised, and parts were printed against his wish; for which he himself was largely to blame, since he was over-fond of lending the manuscript to anyone who asked. Versions varied considerably, affected by the passing of time or by the death of people who might have contested his views. His first opinion of Charles II was restrained:

The King is certainly the best-bred man in the world... civil rather to an excess and has a softness and gentleness with him that has a charm in it... his love of pleasure and his vast expense with his women is the chief load that will lay on him.

But, after revision, came the sting:

He had great vices, but scarce any virtues to correct them... . He delivered himself up to a most enormous course of vice without any sort of restraint.

Heneage Finch, Attorney-General, had begun comfortably free from vices and passions; but hindsight was more complex:

He had no sort of knowledge of foreign affairs, yet he loved to talk of them perpetually... He was an incorrupt judge.

Though accused of a prejudiced attitude towards the disputed origins of James’s last son, Burnet’s conclusion is surprisingly open-minded:

I only name the reports without giving credit to them, for when there is such an occasion given to discourse... stories will always be made to supply all defects.

The work has a pleasing eye-witness quality; he re-creates scenes with photographic ease. Charles, bored and ageing, would recount his youthful adventures: ‘All who had been long accustomed to them grew very weary... so that he often began them in a full audience, and before he had done there were not above four or five about him’.

Occasionally, there is an unconscious humour. Lord Grey, brought before the Council, was ordered to the Tower, though it was closed for the night; so he was left in the care of a messenger. Visiting friends plied the man with wine until he was drunk; but Grey made no attempt to escape:

Next morning by six o’clock the messenger and he went alone in a hackney coach to the Tower. The messenger again fell asleep; so Grey went out and knocked and bid the sentinel call the lieutenant to come and receive a prisoner; but then he bethought himself of his danger... so he stept down the water-stairs and called a boat.

Whether graphic, humorous or pompous, the style is usually as expansive as the writer; yet, when he was deeply moved, he pared it down to compassionate brevity. On the last night of Lord Russell:

He parted with his lady in a composed silence, and as soon as she was gone, he said to me, ‘The bitterness of death is past’.

Burnet’s contemporary History has been criticised for perfunctory treatment of the arts and sciences; but his stated aim was to give an account of affairs. To him, affairs were governmental; and government was by Church as well as by State. His History of the Reformation of the Church of England recounts England’s first repudiation of Rome. A History of My Own Time is largely a sequel, describing the final severance; and his sermon, preached before William and Mary after their accession, shows his train of thought:

You all know what you both felt and feared... the ruin of the protestant religion and the public liberty. We see now before us the most glorious beginning of a noble change of the whole face of affairs... If we raise our minds above every narrowness of thought we may hope to see this blessed morning grow up to a perfect day.

He did his best. Early in 1715, Mr Baker wrote that Bedford, Burnet’s most virulent critic, was in jail, undergoing great hardship. Wearied by family and diocesan troubles, the bishop replied promptly: ‘When things are come to a more quiet state I promise you I will do what I can to deliver Mr Bedford out of his trouble; and in the meantime will contribute to his support’. A month later, in his seventy-second year, Gilbert Burnet died.