Magnus Maximus at Trier

Towards the end of the fourth century, writes David Jones, a Spanish emperor from Britain and his Welsh empress held their spendid court in a city on the Moselle.

In A.D. 383 Magnus Maximus, the Governor of Roman Wales, was proclaimed Emperor by the legions occupying Britain. He crossed the Channel at the head of the army, accompanied by a personal bodyguard of Caernarvon men and a Welsh wife known to medieval legend as Helen of the Hosts. His invasion of Gaul led to the desertion of the Emperor Gratian’s troops, and Gratian himself was killed by his own men on August 15th.

In the following year Maximus was recognized as western Emperor by Theodosius, ruler of the eastern half of the Roman Empire. The usurper set up his court at Trier in Gratian’s palace, and surrounded himself with the leading figures of the western world. For three years this Spanish-born officer, who had risen to power in Britain entirely by his own military and administrative ability, presided over a brilliant circle of literary and clerical figures, which included the poet Ausonius and Martin, Bishop of Tours, the founder of western monasticism.

Magnus Maximus was a native of Galicia in Spain. In 369 he had fought under Count Theodosius in Britain to suppress a co-ordinated attack on the province by the Saxons, Piets and Scots. He defeated Valentinus, a rebel leader, and rebuilt Hadrian’s Wall, which had been wrecked by the northern invaders. This victory over the Piets and Scots enabled the Romans to resume the administration of many parts of Wales that had for several years been entrusted to a native militia.

The contemporary historian Am-mianus Marcellinus says that Count Theodosius ‘so completely restored to its former state the province which he had yielded to the enemy that it had now a regular governor rector legitimus, and the Emperor (Valentinian I) as if to celebrate a triumph ordered it (modern Wales) to be called Valentia’. The new Governor was Magnus Maximus, for whom the ruined fort at Caernarvon was rebuilt as an official residence.

But Maximus’ position was a strange anomaly in the Roman military system. Not only was he Governor of a province, but also the commander of native militia troops. In the Notitia Dignitatum, a Roman list of military officials and installations at the end of the fourth century, there is a reference to the consularis of Valentia (Wales), which must have been Maximus’ official title; but to his Welsh militia he was wledig, the commander—as he appears in the native tradition.

This strange post must have been a slight to a man of great ability. Maximus was virtually an exile in Caernarvon, and his part in the defeat of the Piets and Scots was ignored by Ammianus Marcellinus, working at the court of Theodosius, whose father took all the credit for the victory and reconstruction of 369. Maximus was related to the house of Theodosius, and it must have been galling to be abandoned in this distant corner of the Empire, while his young kinsman was ruler in the east.

In 383 came the rising of the British legions. Maximus was hailed as Emperor: he stripped Hadrian’s Wall of its troops, crossed to Gaul and settled amid the imperial grandeurs of Trier, exchanging the lonely fort in Snowdonia for the cosmopolitan world of the Moselle. Trier, the oldest town in Germany, was a settlement of the Treveri, a Celto-Germanic tribe speaking a distinctive dialect and said by Julius Caesar to have the best cavalry in Gaul.

Under the early Emperors a typical civitas—urban capital of a tribal area—was created, Augusta Treverorum. At the site where the Moselle widens into the plain the new town was laid out in the chess-board pattern characteristic of Roman cities throughout the Empire. A bridge was built, and the prehistoric trackways were metalled, turning Trier into an important centre of communications—the nodal point for routes from Paris and Reims, from the Rhone valley, from Strasburg and Metz, which all meet here, and then go on to the Rhine in three different directions, to Cologne, to Coblenz and to Mainz.

Trier became the supply centre for the Rhine armies. Business flourished, pottery became an important industry, and wine-merchants from Trier travelled throughout Gaul. Wealthy citizens built splendid villas in the nearby Eifel and Hunsruck mountains and a university was set up. The tombstones in the Landesmuseum are evidence today of the skill and taste of local sculptors and their patrons.

During the civil wars of the third century the first waves of barbarians burst through the limes, the frontier wall on the right bank of the Rhine, and Trier was partially destroyed in the great attacks of the Franks and Alemanns in 275/276. Order was eventually restored throughout the Roman world by Diocletian. Shortly after his accession, the new Emperor divided the empire into two, and later four, parts. Constantius Chlorus (father of Constantine the Great) was appointed Caesar of Gaul: he chose Trier as his residence and as the seat of both the imperial court and his civil service.

A gleaming new city rose from the ashes. The amphitheatre and baths were restored, a hippodrome was constructed. A great palace (the present Basilica) and the first cathedral were built in Constantine’s reign. Warehouses for grain were put up by the harbour on the Moselle. Finally, the town wall was completed by the magnificent Porta Nigra, which still dominates the busy road from Coblenz where it enters the city.

In the mid-fourth century, Trier was the splendid capital of a ‘diocese’ that stretched from Hadrian’s Wall to the south of Spain, from the Atlantic to the Rhine. The administration of this vast area was in the hands of the praetorian prefect of the Gauls, with a staff of two thousand civil servants; while around the person of the western Emperor gathered the ambitious and distinguished men of the day.

In 376 Gratian, aged seventeen, succeeded his father Valentinian I as western Emperor. According to a contemporary he was ‘alien by temperament and training to the art of government’. His trouble was, partly, that he was too fond of hunting, and, partly, that his tutor Ausonius, although keenly aware of the honour and rewards of office, had enjoyed teaching literature and writing poetry far more than instructing the young prince in political science.

Ausonius had been called from his professorial chair at Bordeaux University to the imperial palace at Trier as tutor to Gratian in 364. For the next ten years the professor took his young pupil through the orthodox courses of ‘grammar’ and ‘rhetoric’.

The monotony was broken in 368/9 when both Gratian and Ausonius accompanied Valentinian on a campaign against the Germans—the professor getting drunk in the mess on one occasion, and having an affair with ‘a slip of a Swabian girl’. On Gratian’s accession to the throne, Ausonius rose rapidly to high office. He was prefect of the Gauls in 378, and consul of Rome in 379. He could go no further, and, deeply grateful to his former pupil, he retired to his family estates near Bordeaux.

In 383 Ausonius returned to the court at Trier to visit Gratian. While he was there, the bottom fell out of his world. The army of Britain revolted; Trier was occupied by Magnus Maximus and Gratian killed at Lyons. The usurper had become master of the western Empire. The old professor was kept at Trier against his will, to add distinction to Maximus’ court.

Ausonius, now in his seventies, wrote to his son in Bordeaux: ‘Alone I pace up and down the deserted shores of the river, crunching the pebbles and slipping on the turf and willow shoots.’ The old man’s beloved Moselle, ‘mighty mother of fruits and men,’ had become at this sad time ‘a cold and sluggish stream’.

But life at Trier cannot have been all gloom. Ausonius enjoyed a quiet and orderly old age, and Maximus does not seem to have disturbed its even tenor. In the Ephemeris Ausonius describes his daily routine. He wakes and calls to his servant to bring his clothes and water for washing. ‘Open up the chapel—but no incense or offerings—I leave that to the pagans.’ After prayers he decides to go out to pass the time of day with his friends.

But it is ten o’clock and he must remember to tell the cook about lunch. While the servant hurries off to invite five neighbours—‘more than six round a table is not a meal, it’s a melee’—Ausonius tells Sosias the cook to keep tasting the stew. ‘Quick, dip your fingers in the hot sauce.’ After the lunch party the rest of the day is spent in work. He has a young secretary, ‘expert in shorthand.’ ‘As the words fall thick and fast like hail the boy gets them down on to the wax tablet.’

Ausonius was typical of Gibbon’s pagan philosophers in a Christian Empire, who ‘could disguise a smile of contempt under the mask of devotion’. But he was a valuable asset to the court circle at Trier. Maximus, ‘a vigorous and honest man, fit to be an Emperor if he had not broken his oath of allegiance and rebelled,’ as a contemporary said, was keen to bolster up his position by a display of religious orthodoxy.

After the conversion of Constantine, religion had become the major intellectual interest of the Roman world. Orthodox belief guaranteed not only personal salvation but also the prosperity of the Empire. And so, with the notable exception of Julian the Apostate, successive Emperors felt it their duty to persuade the Church to define true orthodoxy, and then to suppress heresy.

Valentinian I was the only Christian Emperor who refused to intervene in the religious disputes of the age. It was not the job for a layman, he said. But his son Gratian, under the influence of Ambrose, Bishop of Milan, revived the persecution of heretics.

Maximus was not to be outdone. A year after his seizure of power, a council of Bishops at Bordeaux condemned as heretics a Spanish sect led by Priscillian. Priscillian appealed to Maximus but the Emperor found it convenient to listen to the Bishops. He decided to try the case in a civil court, but a powerful advocate for Priscillian argued that it was unheard of, and monstrous, to bring an ecclesiastical matter before a secular court. Priscillian’s defender was Martin, Bishop of Tours, already a legendary figure in Gaul.

Martin and Maximus were to evolve a strange relationship, based on mutual respect, but befogged by mutual incomprehension. Both were self-made men, who had risen to the top by a mixture of determination and recklessness. Both commanded enthusiastic support from devoted followers, and aroused suspicion and hatred in conventional circles. Martin was already a familiar figure in the palace at Trier. After he became Bishop of Tours, he travelled widely in northern Gaul, and frequently visited the imperial capital.

His first visit, soon after his consecration, was to Valentinian I, whose tolerance of religious unorthodoxy had extended to embracing Arianism, under the influence of a fanatical wife. The Emperor refused to see the Bishop, but a week in sackcloth and ashes and constant prayer so impressed Valentinian with the Bishop’s persistence that Martin gained his entree to the court, and became a regular guest at the imperial table.

Maximus inherited Martin as an established, if irregular, member of the court circle. His fellow Bishops described him as ‘a contemptible person... of despicable appearance, with dirty clothes and unbrushed hair’. Two vignettes in the contemporary biography by Sulpicius Severus, whose step-mother lived in Trier, show the Emperor and the Bishop working out their uneasy relationship.

In the first, Martin is the only Bishop who refuses to be the Emperor’s guest, when the Priscillian issue is at its peak. The Bishop declares that he will not sit down to dinner with a usurper. Maximus replies that he has not seized the throne of his own will, but that the troops in Britain wanted him to rebel against Gratian; and he clinches the argument by pointing out that God could not be against a man who wins victories in such circumstances.

So Martin joined the dinner party. He was placed next to the Emperor, even though the other guests included Maximus’ brother and uncle, and Evodius, the Prefect of Gaul. During the meal a servant brought the communal goblet to the Emperor, who ordered it to be given first to Martin. He wanted to receive the cup straight from the hands of the great man.

But after he had drunk Martin passed the cup to his chaplain—not even the Emperor came before another priest. Even Maximus, says Severus, joined in the applause: ‘it was told with enthusiasm throughout the palace that Martin had done at the Emperor’s table what no Bishop had ever dared to do at the table of even minor officials.’

But on this occasion Martin’s influence did not survive his departure. While the Bishop stayed in Trier, the Emperor put off Priscillian’s trial. But he went back on his promise to Martin after the Bishop had left. Priscillian was tried before Evodius, found guilty on a technical charge of immorality, and sentenced to death. The Emperor upheld the sentence.

On his next visit to Trier, Martin found Maximus surrounded by Bishops urging a full-scale purge of Priscillianists in Spain. Severus suggests that the Emperor was also quite glad of the opportunity to replenish public funds from the Spaniards’ property.

Again Martin confronted the Emperor, and again, after making certain concessions to his fellow Bishops, Martin had his way—and this time Maximus stood by his word. The full witch-hunt was called off, although two leading Priscillianists were exiled to the Scilly Isles.

Martin’s unkempt figure was a familiar sight in the streets of Trier. He cured people of paralysis and cast out demons, according to Severus: more credibly, he cured Ausonius’ favourite pupil, Paulinus of Nola, of cataract in one eye. Martin had a widespread reputation as a healer, and succeeded in making a great impression on the Empress Helen.

Helen is the heroine of a story in the thirteenth-century collection of Welsh tales known as the Mabinogion. Inspired by a dream, Maxen Wledig crossed the sea to woo and win a lovely princess at Caernarvon, and then returned to win the throne at Rome. The legend is a clear echo of the historical career of Magnus Maximus, and the Welsh Helen will have been his Empress at Trier.

Severus’ second picture of the court shows another dinner party, at which the Empress waited at table on the Bishop, after begging her husband to invite Martin to a quiet family meal. ‘No woman had ever before touched the holy man, but he could not repulse the eager, humble ministrations of the Empress.

She forgot her imperial rank, her diadem and her purple robe, she cast herself upon the earth and clung to Martin’s feet.’ The excess of piety fills out the character of the Celtic princess from Snowdonia, now mistress of an Emperor’s court at the centre of the western world.

By this time Maximus and Martin were on the best of terms. Severus describes the frequent invitations to the palace and the long conversations. ‘They discussed the present and the future, they talked of the glory of the saints and the eternal happiness of the faithful.’ Whatever Maximus’ motives for rebellion, during his short reign he displayed a messianic fervour, seeking to purge corruption in government and heresy in high places.

Martin provided both inspiration and restraint. Maximus’ other ecclesiastical contacts were provided by the Bishop of Rome, with whom he corresponded, Ambrose, who came from Milan to see him, and the crowd of heretic-hunting Bishops who thronged the palace. Ambrose was probably a native of Trier, where his father had been Prefect of Gaul.

Maximus’ career as Emperor ended as it had begun, in civil war. In 384 he had been recognized as Augustus, senior ruler in the west, by Gratian’s half brother Valentinian II, who was twelve years old at the time, and very much under the influence of his mother Justina. Justina, who was a fervent Arian, in effect ruled Italy and Illyricum from the court at Milan. The heretical Queen Mother even clashed with Ambrose over her proposal to allocate a church in the city to the Arian community.

By 387 Maximus was so convinced of the rightness of his mission to root out heresy and to rule the west as an orthodox Emperor, that he called for reinforcements from Britain, where the island garrison still formed the hard core of his military support. He crossed the Alps and invaded Italy. Justina and Valentinian fled to Theodosius, the eastern Emperor, and Maximus swept on to Rome, entering the city in 388.

But now he was up against a tougher opponent. Theodosius converted the refugees from Milan to the orthodox faith, and married Valentinian’s sister. In a swift campaign round the head of the Adriatic he reunited the Empire, defeating the rebels and killing Maximus at Aquileia. Valentinian was installed as orthodox ruler of the west, and the brief reign of the usurper from Britain was officially forgotten.

But Maximus had made a distinct contribution towards the spread of orthodox Christianity in the western Empire, and focused, almost for the last time, the attention of the civilized world on the island province across the Channel. His court had been a hotbed of religious controversy, and had been distinguished by the presence of Martin, the founder of monasticism in the western world, and of Ausonius, the philosopher and poet.

Ausonius had spent his exile composing his poem in celebration of twenty famous cities. He finished with a panegyric on his native Bordeaux, ‘where skies are temperate and mild, where spring is long and winters grow warm with the new born sun.’ After the death of Maximus he returned to his country estates.

But his last years were marred by the disappearance of his beloved pupil Paulinus, who withdrew to Spain to practise an ascetic monasticism that was totally alien to Ausonius’ own tolerant approach to the spiritual life. In a series of letters, the old man appealed to Paulinus to reconsider this strange madness and to resume his promising career in public life. Most of the letters went unanswered, and Ausonius died at eighty-four, sad and perplexed.

Maximus and Helen survived in British legend until the middle ages. Gildas, the sixth-century monk who wrote to rebuke contemporary British leaders for the lawlessness that had allowed the Saxons to make such inroads, traced the end of Roman Britain to Maximus’ withdrawal of the legions. He took with him the flower of the island’s youth, and ‘fixed the throne of his iniquitous Empire at Trier, where he raged with such madness against his lords that he drove out two legitimate Emperors, one from Rome, the other from a most pious life’.

Later Welsh Kings incorporated Maximus and Helen into their pedigrees, to give their claims to royal power the imprint of antiquity. Later still, a seventeenth-century antiquary read Maximus’ name on a standing stone at Llangollen in North Wales. A Roman road in Caernarvonshire is to this day known as Sarn Helen, Helen’s causeway, which may be an echo of Maximus’ road-building programme, carried out during his reconstruction of the Welsh fort system in the years of his governorship.

Finally, Maximus’ ill-starred campaign against Theodosius left a detachment of his own Welsh guards marooned in the Balkans. Far from Snowdonia they appear in the Roman army list as Seguntienses, men of Caernarvon, guarding the Illyrian frontier in the last years of the western Empire.