The Staff of Life

Maggie Black on the history of bread and breadmaking.

Derived from Western man's most abundant raw food, grass seeds and grains, bread has been since before recorded time his staple and most valued solid sustenance. Naturally, therefore, it has a vital place in our folklore and in the record of our social and political development. For this reason, I want to look, this month, at the types of bread baked and eaten in the past, at their uses and what they signified.

The first breads we know about for certain in the West were Celtic, unleavened buns of mixed whole grains; but the Romans soon greatly improved the quality and quantity of bread-corns and of bread-making equipment. They introduced club wheat, and made wheaten white and spiced, enriched breads (sometimes whitened with chalk) for the aristocracy, coarser 'military' or 'secondary' brown and bran breads from mixed grains for lesser men. Wheat was however still scanty, so their Saxon successors used more barley, and favoured the mixed wheat and rye crop called maslin as a hedge against failure of the wheat crop.

Under the Normans, the Roman social grading of breads (white for the rich, brown for the poor) was set in a fixed pattern; partly because only the rich could afford to grow wheat, partly because they charged for the use of their manorial or monastic mills and ovens. Poor countrymen therefore made branny brown bread from coarse, home-ground bread-corn. They used whatever grain grew best locally, clean rye, maslin, or the oats and barley which were the staple spring-grown grains of colder areas such as Scotland and Wales.

In towns, as in Roman times, professional bakers made all types of bread and also baked the poor's own dough. Like the manorial millers and bakers, they were notorious for giving short weight and using adulterants. Their sins were exposed and punishments laid down in the Assize of Bread which, from at least 1266, regulated the weights and prices of the breads Englishmen bought.

Since early loaves were usually raised with leaven (sourdough), they were very crumbly so could not be cut. The 'breaking' of bread began as both a real and a symbolic action.

By the time of the Assize, several different grades of bread were recognised. Wastel or pandemayne was the finest white bread, later made in 6 oz small loaves or rolls called manchets . Treet , sometimes called tourte (brown) bread contained all the husk and flour, and was half the price of white bread. Cheaper still were maslin (mixed wheat and rye) bread, and horse-bread made mostly of peas or beans. All these types were still eaten in country areas in the eighteenth century, and some in the nineteenth.

The rich were fussy about reserving white bread for their own use, not just because it was finer but because everyone's bread defined his status. The Percy household's breakfast, for instance, in 1512, included manchets for the family but just household bread for 'my lady's gentilwoman'.

The coarser breads were resented. From the fourteenth century at least, even the poorest were demanding whiter bread for themselves, for its digestibility - and because it was their betters' food. The rich retorted, with some reason, that brown bread was better for those doing hard outdoor toil, but caused heartburn and wind in sedentary stomachs. Nonetheless, the demand grew as living standards slowly rose generally, and by 1750, townsfolk ate no maslin, only white bread – usually adulterated with alum. Even the desperate shortages of the late 1700s did not make city-dwellers accept a darker, cheaper, 'standard' loaf specially made to increase the supply (although country folk continued to eat coarser local breads until the invention of roller mills in the later nineteenth century). Such is the power of the status symbol.

The rich had, however, kept ahead in the race. By the fifteenth century, milk breads called French breads were popular, and by the eighteenth, wiggs such as Sally Lunns were more like Danish pastries than breads. The rich still had and valued their finer plain bread too, and this situation lasted until, in the nineteenth century, cake replaced bread as their luxury 'status' food.

More closely linked than social labelling to its vital, primary use as food, however, were bread's religious and magical functions. Western faiths and folklore abound with examples of its use, from its consumption as the sacramental Host to divination by making and eating Dumb Cakes.

Many of these uses go back to ancient pagan rites designed to bribe the earth spirits – and more often to coax them to give life, wealth or knowledge than to appease them; such gifts are the special breads still baked for Easter and Harvest Festivals which became popular 'treats' for men as well as spirits. Bread, more than any other food, has always had happy, hopeful associations with the concepts of birth and resurrection or cyclical re-birth, of life-giving.

The idea of bread as life-giver lies behind its use as the principal food offered as charity or as a token of safety. Old almsgiving, for instance, almost always included bread, and early medieval feasts always began with the host 'breaking bread' and sharing it with his guest as a promise of protection.

Neither act was, however, wholly disinterested. Charity was, more often than not, offered to save the donor's own soul; the ritual bread, when accepted by the guest, symbolised that he too would offer no violence.

Likewise, five hundred years later, bread broken and eaten together by early puritans at their communal meals was an act by which each member promised not to break faith or disrupt the group, and was, in turn, assured the status of one of the Elect and the benefit of eternal life.

Bread has always, more than any other symbol, represented a promise of safety and spiritual profit as well as a defined social status, however lowly, within a group. The outstanding feature of the main uses of bread, is that they did not change essentially, although elaborated, from ancient times until the nineteenth century. This consistency gives them almost unique value as historical evidence. If you know what breads a man ate at any given time, you can make a shrewd guess at where and how he lived, at his economic and social standing and, quite possibly, at his spiritual and social outlook as well.

Maslin or Mixed Grain Bread

'Ale-barm' would have been used to raise this bread and dark unrefined honey to sweeten it. The cream would have been skimmed off the milk to make butter.

For four 6-inch round loaves : 1 oz fresh yeast; ½ pt warm water; 2 Ib white flour; 1 Ib coarse rye flour; 4 teaspoons salt; 1 tablespoon medium oatmeal; 1 pt skim milk; 4 tablespoons molasses; 4 tablespoons sunflower oil; extra warm water.

Cream, then dissolve the yeast in the water and leave until frothy. Mix the flours, salt and oatmeal in a big bowl. Work in the skim milk, molasses and oil to make a soft dough. Knead in the bowl. Put the bowl in an oiled polythene bag and let the dough rise for 1½ -2 hours. Shape it into 4 round loaves. Place on a greased baking sheet, and cut a cross in the top of each. Return to the bag to prove for 30 minutes. Sprinkle with warm water. Bake at 375'F/190'C/Gas 5 for about 40 minutes until loaves sound hollow when tapped. Cool on a wire rack.

Further Reading
  • Elizabeth David,English Bread and Yeast Cookery , Allen Lane (London, 1977)
  • A.Wright,  British Calender Customs (ed.) T Lones, Folklore Society (1940)
  • H.D. Renner, The Origin of Food Habits , Faber (London, 1944)