Portugal’s Mad Queen

In the late 18th century, a French invasion force marched into Portugal. Napoleon was insisting that Portugal must close its ports to British shipping. When it failed to comply, the invading army was given orders to march on Lisbon and seize the royal family. The Queen and her family fled to Brazil, and by this time, Maria I of Portugal had been insane for more than fifteen years. 

On December 17th, 1788, Queen Maria I held an official audience to celebrate her fifty-fourth birthday. The occasion took place in the palace of Ajuda in Lisbon and the British envoy, Robert Walpole, wrote that the widowed Queen ‘exhibited a considerable degree of affliction’.

Maria had suffered a string of tragedies over the previous three months. Her elder son, José, died of smallpox on September 11th. Her only daughter, Mariana (who had married into the Spanish royal family), died of the same disease on  November 2nd, followed by Mariana’s husband and newborn son. And on November 29th, Inácio de São Caetano – Maria’s confessor for more than thirty years, the man on whom she placed her entire trust and confidence – died of a massive stroke in the palace of Queluz.

Despite her grief, the Queen went through the birthday formalities with her usual grace. She engaged Robert Walpole in conversation and they spoke of the mental health of George III who was suffering his first attack of dementia, a symptom of porphyria which the doctors mistook for madness. The illness had first appeared six weeks earlier and George was in the care of Dr Francis Willis (1718-1807), who specialized in treatment of the insane. During her conversation with Walpole, Maria ‘expressed concern for His Majesty’ and asked him to pass on ‘her sincere wishes for a speedy re-establishment of his health’.

This was a poignant request, for Maria herself was on the cusp of insanity. Her maternal grandfather, Philip V of Spain (1683-1746), and her uncle, Ferdinand VI (1713-59), both suffered from mental illness and both were completely mad by the end of their lives. There are many parallels between their symptoms and Maria’s illness which began to appear at about this time.

Suffering his first bout of madness in 1717, Philip believed that fire was consuming him from within, divine punishment for his personal failings. He would swing from extreme lethargy to outbursts of violent frenzy. He screamed for hours at a time, he sang aloud and bit himself. He refused to have his beard shaved or his hair and toenails cut. He believed himself unable to walk because his feet were of different sizes.

Ferdinand inherited his father’s illness. He lived in fear of sudden death, convinced that his body was being destroyed internally and that he would die if he lay down. He refused to be washed, shaved or dressed. He refused food, taking liquid refreshment only. He banged his head against the wall and attacked his servants. In a manic phase, he would spend ten days or more without sleep. At other times, he would collapse into lethargy, becoming completely inert.

This was the illness that lay in wait for Maria, whose conscience had – for more than thirty years – been troubled by the tyranny of her father’s first minister, the Marquis of Pombal (Sebastião de Carvalho e Melo). Pombal was a man of the Enlightenment with strongly anti-church opinions. At the same time, he was a despot, executing members of the aristocracy and filling the dungeons with people arrested and imprisoned without trial.

José I (1714–77) had allowed Pombal to rule the country as he pleased and Maria, who suffered from what used to be called ‘religious mania’, was convinced her father’s soul would suffer eternal damnation for complicity in the persecution of so many of his subjects. She could do nothing to repair the damage, so she came to believe that she too was damned and would burn forever in the infernal flames.

Alone among her advisers, her old confessor had the ability to soothe her troubled mind. São Caetano had made light of her fears (‘be easy concerning your soul, I shall take that upon myself’) but her new confessor – appointed twelve days before her birthday audience – was the worst possible choice. The young José Maria de Melo, Bishop of Algarve, enjoyed preaching about the terrors of hell and gave his Queen no comfort, preferring to heighten her dread of hellfire which, he told her, was waiting for her just around the corner.

Seven months later, the outbreak of the French Revolution gave rise to ‘much seriousness at court’. In September 1789, Maria banned the editor of the Lisbon Gazette from publishing any further bulletins from Paris (‘which have produced some shrewd observations from the lower class of persons here’) and as the French King was stripped of his powers, she lived in fear that the mob would also rise in Portugal.

The plight of Louis XVI preyed on a mind already weakened by grief. Maria began to suffer anxieties and night-panics, and in October 1791, Robert Walpole wrote that she had ‘descended into great melancholy, with night-time distress, interrupted sleep and a sinking of the spirits’. Official audiences were cancelled and on November 29th, with masterly understatement, he reported that ‘Her Majesty does not think herself perfectly well; she complains of pains in her stomach and want of sleep’.

In December, the doctors were called to ‘consult upon the causes of her uneasiness and apprehensions’. On January 4th, she was ‘blooded’, a procedure she found distressing and which had to be administered by force. Ten days later, she was taken upriver to the royal hunting lodge at Salvaterra where, on January 26th 1792, she descended into a frenzy from which there was little respite.

Long hours of ‘ranting and raging’ were broken by ‘some moments of lucidity and coherent speech’; the nights were spent in violent agitation. Finally, during an opera performance on February 2nd, she threw a fit far worse than any she had suffered in recent days. She screamed and howled all night, and the following morning, she was hustled on to a royal barge for the journey downriver to Lisbon.

On February 4th, all public entertainments were cancelled. Prayers were intoned in churches and convents, and religious images brought in procession to the palace. Maria’s foreign minister, Luís Pinto, wrote to the Portuguese ambassador in London:

It is with great sadness that I inform you that Her Majesty is suffering from a melancholic affliction which has descended into insanity, into what is feared to be a total frenzy. In view of this unfortunate situation, I believe it would be helpful for Dr Willis, the principal doctor who assisted His British Majesty in similar circumstances, to come to this court as soon as possible. You will provide him with all the money he might request, with no limitations. You will agree to all he proposes, should you enter into a contract with him, and will leave the remuneration to the generous discretion of this court.

He continued by giving the background to Maria’s illness:

Her Majesty has always been of a gloomy temperament and subject to nervous afflictions. Her disposition is one of great meekness and a certain shyness, her imagination vivid, her habits inclined towards spirituality. For years she has suffered from stomach ailments and spasms of the abdomen, which are worsened by the aversion she has to purgative medicines, especially enemas to which she would never consent.

He ended the letter with the hope that Dr Willis would arrive promptly in Portugal, ‘to save Her Majesty from the danger that threatens her and re-establish her former state of health’.

During the next few weeks, Maria’s behaviour swung between extreme lassitude (‘she appears dead at times and cannot be roused at all’) and violent excitement (‘almost constant delirium’). She was bled again on February 11th. She was taken to the baths at Alcaçarias near Lisbon and struggled violently as she was placed in the water. She complained of uneasiness in her head, pains in her stomach, and ‘an impediment in her throat which prevents her swallowing’. She refused to eat. She refused to take medicine, so the doctors held her down and administered enemas. She remained awake at night, screaming in fear and distress.

Religion – and fear of damnation – caused her the greatest anguish. Sometimes she was quieter, with ‘intervals of reminiscence and reasonable talk’, but she became agitated if she was taken to the chapel or saw a religious procession from the windows of the palace. And when she did speak coherently, ‘she returns to the first idea that afflicted her, that she is condemned, that there is no hope for her salvation’.

On February 10th, her surviving son (Prince João, 1767-1826) was forced to take over affairs of state in his mother’s name. He was twenty-four years old, with little useful education and few interests beyond his accustomed activities of riding and hunting. Shy, timid and indecisive, he found it impossible to conquer what Walpole referred to as ‘his respect and condescension to the Queen’. He was unwilling to pick up the reins of government and no state business was transacted for several months.

Meanwhile, the ambassador in London was negotiating with the doctor on whom the entire country rested its hopes. Dr Francis Willis ran a private lunatic asylum in Lincolnshire. He had been called to treat George III in December 1788 and his reputation was greatly enhanced when the King recovered his senses a few months later. Now he was summoned to Lisbon and paid £20,000 (more than £1 million in today’s values) to treat the Queen of Portugal.

Dr Willis had considerable psychological insight, but treatments of the mentally ill were brutal at the time and he favoured the straitjacket, coercion, blistering, and water baths. An elderly man with little self-doubt, he insisted on complete physical and mental domination over his patients.

He arrived in Lisbon on March 15th and soon found that Maria’s condition was not susceptible to his ‘scientific’ treatments. She herself held this view: ‘Her Majesty was firmly persuaded that she was in Hell, saying that a skilful physician may sometimes cure madness, but could never reverse the decrees of fate’. While the King of England’s condition was a symptom of physical disease (porphyria), Maria’s illness seems to have been a rare and particularly severe form of bi-polar disorder. But medical knowledge at the time did not distinguish between the two conditions and Dr Willis used the same treatments on the Queen of Portugal as he had on George III.

His first suggestion was that the royal family should move to the palace of Queluz, a few miles west of Lisbon. It was more peaceful outside the city and Maria could be taken into the gardens away from public scrutiny. He also hoped to remove her from the courtiers and secretaries of state (her prime minister being one of the worst offenders) who were encouraging her to attend mass, say prayers and sing the Te Deum. But the Portuguese court was rigid with protocol; etiquette demanded that courtiers pay their respects to the Queen every day and Prince João was too timid and immature to direct otherwise.

Maria’s condition deteriorated during the next few weeks. Sometimes she was violent and distressed (‘returned to her state of despair upon the subject of her salvation’). At other times she was more cheerful (‘in a humour of singing which I very much doubt is a favourable symptom’). Now Dr Willis began to use his more brutal treatments. The Queen was constrained in a straitjacket; she had blistering ointments applied to her legs; she was immersed in ice-cold baths, a procedure ‘which occasioned a considerable amount of resistance and was followed by an aguish fever and a great deal of agitation’. She was given enemas and emetics, and because she refused to eat, an instrument was made ‘for the conveying of nourishment down her throat’.

The doctor may have used brutal methods, but he understood – in a way that no member of the court was willing to accept – that her condition was exacerbated by religious imagery. He was unable to prevent ‘the bustle and preparations’ for a Corpus Christi procession at Queluz and, realizing that his only hope was to remove her from the source of her terror, he recommended a sea voyage. This led to a misunderstanding. Whereas Dr Willis intended to remove Maria from the priests and courtiers who surrounded her, Prince João simply assumed that the government and the entire court would embark with her. He ordered several ships to be fitted out for the purpose.

When the doctor explained that this was not what he had in mind, ministers, nobles and bishops were all asked for their opinions. Most of them raised objections and the Queen was warned of the dangers of a sea voyage, giving her ‘an aversion to the idea which she had never discovered until lately’. So the idea was abandoned and Dr Willis, aware that he could do no more, made plans to return to England.

Maria was distressed that the doctor was leaving. He had gained her confidence and she feared ‘she will grow worse when he has left the country’. As indeed she did. In August, she became increasingly obstinate (‘she is more intractable and makes difficulties on the smallest trifles’). A few days later, ‘upon a desire to hear mass, she was carried to chapel but behaved in a most extravagant manner and has since been so disturbed that her attendants have had to use constraint’. By September, she was ‘declining towards a state of childishness’.

Prince João appointed a new doctor from Coimbra, a man with no experience of mental illness, and Maria sank further into her private world of despair. In March the following year, when she had been brought back to the palace in Lisbon:

Her Majesty is in a most melancholy state. Her memory has left her and she has but a confused idea of persons and things. She has had a disorder in one of her eyes which threatened to be of a gangrenous nature. An operation has been performed, with success as to the cure but possibly fatal as to sight.

Her ministers gave up any hope of recovery. They tried to persuade João to accept a regency but the prince was too frightened. He continued to make all decisions in his mother’s name and it was not until July 1799 (‘after the long experience of seven years in which the care and assistance of the most able physicians have been of no effect’) that he finally agreed to the title of Prince Regent.

Meanwhile, the French Revolution led to the outbreak of war in April 1792, just ten weeks after João took over affairs of state in his mother’s name. He declared a state of ‘the most perfect neutrality’, but after Britain entered the war in 1793, he also agreed to provide ‘mutual aid’ during the hostilities. The most important aid that Portugal could offer its oldest ally was a safe harbour in Lisbon, so the closure of Portuguese ports to British shipping became an important objective in French military strategy.

João did little to defend his country; his lack of education, limited intelligence and indecisive personality left him paralysed in an increasingly dangerous situation. And while he was under pressure from France to close his ports to British vessels, British officials began urging him to seek safety in Brazil.

In November 1806, Napoleon’s Berlin Decree closed the ports of continental Europe to British shipping, an effective blockade of Britain and her colonies. Eight months later, Prince João received an ultimatum. Portugal must also close its ports or face invasion. He failed to comply and, when the French and Spanish ministers left the country on October 1st, he informed the people of his ‘well-grounded hopes that their absence will be temporary and that no hostile act will follow’.

When he finally closed his ports on October 20th, it was too late. A French army had crossed the border into Spain two days earlier, with orders to march on Lisbon and seize the royal family. The Portuguese fleet was anchored in the harbour but João continued to wait, refusing to leave until the last possible moment. On November 24th, news arrived that the invading army was less than sixty miles from the city. It was time to leave.

Maria had a fit of hysterics when she was brought to the quayside on the morning of November 27th. She refused to step down from the carriage, so she had to be picked up bodily and dropped into the galley which would row her to the flagship.

By the evening, a strong wind was blowing from the south-west, trapping the ships in the harbour. They lay at anchor all the following day while the invasion force was marching closer by the hour. It was not until the morning of the 29th that the wind shifted to the north-east and the ships set sail towards the open sea. The royal family was safe, but only by the smallest of margins.

A few hours later, the wind veered to the west. The sea took on a heavy swell, and by the time it grew dark, the winds were at gale force. All night and through most of the following day, the ships tacked into the wind, the waves dousing the decks with water. Maria was unaware of the reason for this dramatic flight to Brazil, this sudden plunge into discomfort. But the movement seemed to soothe her anxieties and, as Dr Willis had predicted, she became quiet and pliable during the voyage. For three months, she had some respite from anxiety.

Her demons returned when the ships sailed into Rio harbour during the afternoon of March 7th, 1808. Maria was frightened by loud noises and the flagship was greeted by cannon fire, ‘booming salutes that could be heard for miles around’. Three days later, a demented and terrified old woman was led ashore to the sounds of rifle fire, twenty-one-gun salutes and peals of church bells. Shrieking in fear, covering her face with her hands, she was bundled into a sedan chair and carried to her new home in an old Carmelite convent. By the time she died here in 1816, she had been insane for almost a quarter of a century.

Meanwhile, the Peninsular War had taken its toll on Portugal, with three French invasions and appalling destruction and loss of life. When peace was declared in 1814, it was assumed that Prince João would sail home to reinvigorate a country exhausted and disorganized after eight years of war. But he was only persuaded to return home after a revolution in Portugal brought a constitutional government to power in November 1820. João VI had been King for five years when he returned to Lisbon in 1821. His eldest son, Pedro, remained in Rio and would declare himself emperor of an independent Brazil in 1822.

And Dr Willis? After leaving Lisbon in the summer of 1792, he returned to private practice in Lincolnshire. His ‘cure’ of George III had increased his fame and he soon opened a second asylum to accommodate a growing number of patients. Two of his sons joined him in the business and he was still in practice when he died (aged eighty-nine) on December 5th, 1807 – six days after the ship carrying his former patient headed south-west into the Atlantic Ocean.

Jenifer Roberts is author of Maria I, Maria A Louca: The Tragic Life of Maria I of Portugal.