Botanist Explorers of Two Continents

Plants have been hunted since the days of the Pharaohs, writes William Seymour; but, in more recent times, two resolute Scottish botanists led particularly adventurous and courageous lives.

At the beginning of the nineteenth century Loudon noted that out of 13,140 plants being cultivated in Britain, only 1,400 were native. Perhaps not many of those who now visit our gardens and parks, are aware of the sweat and agony that went into the introduction of so many of the plants they see.

‘Good God! When I consider the melancholy fate of so many of botany’s votaries I am tempted to ask whether men are in their right minds who so desperately risk life and everything else through their love of collecting plants.’

Thus Carl Linnaeus, the great Swedish botanist, writing in 1737. But it all began many years before that; indeed, the first recorded plant-hunting expedition was mounted on orders of Queen Hatshepsut of Egypt in 1482 B.C., when she sent ships to the coast of East Africa to collect seeds and plants for her gardens at Kar-nak.

And there followed a long series, stretching over the centuries and the countries, of intrepid adventurers, who, for little reward save the thrill of discovery, spent much of their lives scrambling over mountains, through forests and valleys, searching for the hitherto unknown. Nor were the perils any less in the centuries after Linnaeus had despaired of botanists’ sanity, as can be seen from even a brief account of the adventures of two rugged, resolute Scotsmen, David Douglas and George Forrest.

Before their perils are recounted, something must first be said of the difficulties confronting collectors after they have gathered their seeds or plants. Transportation - even of seed - from distant continents presented an enormous problem in the days of sail, and even later. There were two distinct phases in the journey of a collector’s treasures from the place of discovery to the nursery in Britain.

There was the trek across miles of difficult country or down treacherous rivers, and the long sea voyage. In both cases the hazards were equally great, and no matter how carefully the cargo may have been packed and guarded, only a small percentage could hope to survive.

During the long overland journey the collector had to contend with constant changes of temperature, delays brought about by the change of porters, finding mules, canoes or rafts, mending broken-down bridges, circumventing flooded tracks, and often fighting off bandits. In the course of a journey plants had to be unpacked, examined and repacked.

When eventually port was reached, and the precious packages safely embarked, the collector had the agony of knowing that, though he had done all that was humanly possible to ensure survival, most ships’ crews were not likely to put the safety of the plants before their own duties and comfort. Salt water carelessly sloshed over them was usually fatal; the rats that infested every ship relished a mouthful of seed; and a plant was an acceptable alternative.

Not until 1834, when Nathaniel Ward produced his sealed, glazed cases, did plant transporting become very much less of a hazard; but even then collectors lacked the luxury of polythene bags. Strangely enough, in the early days plants were more commonly collected than seed. This was probably due to the unreliable behaviour of seed, and to the difficulty of collecting in the wild and the raising at home of certain species.

David Douglas was born on June 25th 1799(some authorities give the date as 1798). He was the son of a stonemason in the employ of the third Earl of Mansfield, and received his education mainly at the parish school of Kinnoul, where we are told he was more fond of wandering over meadow and through woodland, collecting plants and observing birds, than working at his books, a boyish hobby that lasted all his life. He left school at an early age, and for seven years was employed as an apprentice in the gardens of Scone Palace under the head gardener, Mr Beattie.

Beattie saw that Douglas had considerable talent in all matters pertaining to botany and natural history, and when the boy was 18 arranged for his transfer to Valleyfield, the home of Sir Robert Preston, whose gardens contained the best collection of exotic plants in all Scotland. But the turning point in Douglas’s career came when he obtained a post on the staff at the famous botanical garden at Glasgow. Here he was able to attend the lectures on botany that were given by the Regius Professor at Glasgow University, Doctor (afterwards Sir) William Jackson Hooker.

By now Douglas had matured into a young man of considerable character. It was apparent at this early age that he was endowed with great courage, a restless and enquiring nature, and a short temper, which led him at times to be quarrelsome; but essentially he was warm-hearted. It was perhaps this last virtue, coupled with his zeal, that endeared Douglas to Hooker.

It was not long before he singled him out for special favour, choosing him as a companion for a tour of the Highlands and Islands. Thus began an intimate friendship between the two men that was to last until Douglas’s death, and to which posterity is indebted for much of Douglas’s work and some invaluable correspondence.

Hooker was a friend of Sabine, the secretary of the Horticultural Society of London (now the Royal Horticultural Society), and discovering that in Douglas there was a botanist of exceptional merit he solicited his friend to appoint him as botanical collector for the Society. They had recently moved to their new garden at Chiswick, where they grew a great variety of roses, ornamental shrubs and a collection of fruit-trees that, at the time, was probably the finest in the world.

Douglas was accepted; and his first journey for the Society was to be in the eastern half of North America. This was to be no voyage of discovery; for other botanists, scientists and collectors had been there before. The main purpose of his visit was to investigate developments in fruit-growing, with an additional charter to collect any interesting plants, and permission to travel as far west as Amherstburg in Upper Canada.

This first journey lasted some seven months, of which three were spent at sea. Besides giving due attention to the methods of fruit-culture, Douglas collected seed and a number of plants; his introduction of the honeysuckle Lonicera hirsuta. caused great interest. He also made numerous notes on the many varieties of American oaks, thorns, hickories and walnuts; but, although this comparatively short visit was of considerable interest to botanists, it neither stirred the imagination nor produced the same results as did his later pioneering adventures in the area of the Columbia river.

The first of his two journeys to the north-west coast of America began in July 1824; and, as he travelled in one of Hudson’s Bay Company’s ships round Cape Horn, it was nearly nine months before he landed near Astoria in the present state of Washington. There were many calls en route; but for Douglas the most notable was the six-hour visit to James Island, one of the Galapagos group, where he collected, and carefully preserved, 175 plant specimens and 45 birds of 19 varieties - the latter so tame and unfamiliar with man that they could be killed with a stick.

During this expedition Douglas spent 28 months in North America, the greater part of the time around the Columbia river. His ship entered the river on April 7th 1825. It is strange that so great a river with its perilous rapids, cataracts and falls (now smothered under concrete dams) should have been discovered only thirty-three years earlier, when Captain Robert Grey entered its vast estuary from the Pacific ocean and named the river after his ship.

The first Indians that Douglas encountered were the Chinooks. He found them - and indeed most Indians - friendly and usually prepared to barter. They called him the Grass Man, and thought that he must have been sent to collect seed for a mad king, which, although a few years wide of the mark, helped him, because for them an aura of mystery surrounds anyone connected with derangement of the mind.

One or two tribes, however, were dangerous; and part of an entry in the diary for October 26th 1826, the day on which he discovered the noblest of all the pines, the sugar pine, and was nearly killed by Indians when collecting its seed, reads: ‘With hostile Indians and incessant rains... fatigued and broken down I could have but little zeal to continue my exertions.’ And Douglas was not a man easily given to despair.

In spite of a diary entry, ‘I am nearly destitute of civilized society’, Douglas did meet a few Europeans trading or working in those parts, most of whom were helpful and proved pleasant companions. One at least, Finan McDonald, owed his life to Douglas’s rudimentary but adequate medical skill when he was badly gored by a buffalo five-and-a-half-days’ journey from civilization.

This incident occurred during the closing stages of Douglas’s mission, when, travelling with the Hudson’s Bay Express, he trekked across the breadth of the continent from Fort Vancouver in the west to York Factory on the shores of Hudson Bay. A day or two before McDonald’s accident, the enormously energetic Douglas had taken time off from the Express camp in the Athabaska Pass to tackle two previously unclimbed peaks in the Rocky Mountains, one of which (10,782 feet) he named Mount Hooker after his friend.

The conditions under which Douglas had to work in these North American missions were invariably difficult. The climate was harsh and liable to rapid changes in temperature; medical facilities were few, food often scarce - there were times when he had to eat the precious seeds he had so painfully collected, and even his horse; and travel was mainly by canoe over fast-flowing rivers, which at least twice proved too strong for his slender craft.

On these occasions Douglas was lucky enough to make the bank; but he lost his whole collection of plants, seeds and botanical notes. He suffered from fever and festering wounds; and his eyes (always a weak point) became seriously infected at one stage. No wonder his temper shortened; but his courage increased.

The Express reached its destination in June 1827; and Douglas spent nearly two months botanizing at the Red River Colony before going on to York Factory and the boat home. During his travels on the Columbia, from ocean to Rocky Mountains, he had covered 7,032 miles; and the journey to York Factory was almost another 3,000. Besides the sugar pine already mentioned and the Douglas fir (which assures him eponymous fame), Douglas sent home from his expedition seeds of many other trees and plants that now enrich our woods and gardens.

Among these were 25 different lupins, three kinds of spiraea, 14 varieties of ribes, the lovely red-branched Madrona, the Oregon maple, the Noble fir and the Sitka spruce. The latter tree, as well as the Douglas fir, was first discovered by a fellow Scot, Archibald Menzies, at the end of the eighteenth century; but he had not the facilities to bring back the seed or living plants.

Douglas spent the next two years being lionized at home, and becoming very bored. Boredom brought out the cantankerous side of his nature, and his friends were probably relieved when, after some difficulty, he persuaded the Horticultural Society to send him on another expedition to North America. In October 1829 he left England on what was to be his longest and last expedition. Much of the time he was on familiar ground; but he paid two visits to the Sandwich Islands (now Hawaiian), and travelled as far south as Monterey, where he discovered the Monterey pine.

Part of this expedition was taken up in making magnetic and geographical observations on behalf of the Colonial Office, for which purpose Douglas had studied several weeks at Greenwich. Important though his work was, botanizing was always his first love; and this expedition, like the others, was highly productive. Before his death, Douglas had sent home 19 new genera and numerous species, which included three new pines, the giant fir, Delphinium Menziesii, the mountain pink and mariposa lily. And the Zoological Society had received a pair of live Sandwich Island geese.

It was during his second visit to Hawaii, where he had climbed to the summit of the great peaks Mauna Kea and Mauna Loa, that disaster overtook him. In July 1834, while on his way to Hilo, Douglas called on an English cattle-hunter named Edward Gurney, a man of dubious reputation, who trapped his animals by carefully camouflaged pits. Gurney warned Douglas of these pits; and the explorer set off on the last stage of his journey.

What exactly happened no one will ever know; from his tracks it appears that Douglas inspected an unoccupied pit, and then, taking off his pack and coat (by which his terrier, Billy, was still sitting several hours later) walked towards - and into - an open pit, occupied by an infuriated bull.

At the time, there was some question whether he had died through foul play; but it seems almost certain that Douglas’s intense curriosity and extremely poor eyesight were responsible for the tragedy. The Douglas fir will always be his memorial; and it was therefore fitting that, exactly one hundred years after his death, the site should have been marked by the planting of a grove of these fine trees.

But the tribute that David Douglas would have liked best came from the pen of his friend and mentor Sir William Jackson Hooker, when he wrote, ‘There is scarcely a spot of ground deserving the name of a garden, which does not owe many of its most powerful attractions to the living roots and seeds which have been sent by him to the Horticultural Society of London.’ George Forrest, like Douglas, disdained the pleasures and comforts of life. He was a stocky man of great physical strength and energy, and of undoubted courage, a keen shot and fisherman.

Born at Falkirk on March 13th, 1873, Forrest went to school in the Ayrshire town of Kilmarnock. His first job was in articles to a pharmaceutical chemist, which he quickly found was not to his liking, although the meagre study of medicines and elementary surgery it afforded him was to be of use later. There followed a trip to Australia, where he obtained work in the outback; but in 1902 he returned to Scotland.

There Forrest obtained a job in the Edinburgh Botanic Garden; and, although at first he did not like the drudgery of cataloguing and arranging plants, his dour perseverance gradually converted tedium into enjoyment; and his work so much impressed his chief, Professor Sir Isaac Bayley Balfour, that, when he was asked to recommend someone for a botanical exploration in Western China, he nominated Forrest. Forrest was overjoyed; and, between 1904 and his death in 1932, he made seven highly successful trips to China.

He was by no means the first Briton to botanize in China; for, as a result of the treaty that followed the discreditable Opium War of 1840, large tracts inland from the Treaty Ports were opened to botanists; and the Horticultural Society was not slow in taking advantage of their chance. Forrest was not the first plant-collector to work in Yunnan.

Augustine Henry and French missionaries had been there before him; and Ernest Wilson - whose hair-raising adventures, while making invaluable collections, form a book of their own - had worked extensively in the neighbouring province of Szechuan. But a great deal of the land that Forrest explored had never seen a European; and when, at the age of thirty-one, he started his first perilous journey, the province was as wild as it was beautiful; and among its mountains and valleys dwelt a people as cruel as they were cunning.

Forrest did not keep a journal; and what we know ol his journeys comes mostly trom letters; in particular from those he wrote to John Williams of Caerhays during his third expedition, the most complete that have survived. But we may perhaps get a better idea of the perils and difficulties he had to face by looking at his first adventure, which, if not entirely typical, indicates the problems facing a plant-collector in the twilight days of Manchu China.

North-west Yunnan, south-east Tibet and western Szechuan were to become Forrest’s permanent hunting grounds; and, when he first set out -entering Yunnan through the north-east corner of Burma- the country was in a state of turmoil.

The Chinese were making one of their periodic armed forays into Tibet; and Colonel Young-husband’s recent expedition to Lhasa had only exacerbated the situation. The Batang Lamas were in revolt, and did not trouble to discriminate between the Chinese and other foreigners; and Chinese war-lords and bandits added to the general dangers of the place.1 A territory that possesses some of the richest flora in China was not a place one would choose for a picnic.

Having established a base at Teng-Yueh-Ting in the Lung-Chiang valley between the Taiping and Shweli rivers, Forrest set about enrolling servants and collectors. In the many years that he spent in China he came to know and like the people with whom he lived and worked. Before long he had trained a faithful band of men, who were capable of going long distances to given areas, and could be trusted to collect seed from special plants.

They were also trained to dry and pack seed, and manipulate the drying presses. Forrest then started north, working principally in the river-valleys between the Shweli, Salween and Mekong, which are flanked by the high ranges that form the watersheds. Plant collecting in the upper valleys was comparatively easy; but the majestic snowscape of mountains, their crests often veiled by pennons of cloud, dominates land that is easier on the eye than the feet; and crossing the watersheds was a tough and tedious business.

Nor was the area one big paradise for collectors; considerable islands of luxuriance, where rhododendrons, lilies, primula and many other plants clustered, were set in a sea of arid hill and scrub.

After botanizing his way north for some 200 miles, Forrest arrived in the summer of 1905 at Tsu-ku on the Mekong, where he made an advanced base at the home of an aged French missionary-botanist, Pere Dubernard. He had not been there long before another missionary, Pere Bourdonnec, from nearby Yu-ra-gan, staggered into the compound to report that he was the sole survivor of a massacre by Tibetan monks.

The Chinese garrison at A-tun-tzu, thirty miles to the north, had been wiped out; and the Lamas would soon attack Tsu-ku. By the light of the moon on the night of July 19th, Forrest walking, the two aged missionaries on mules, and a small band of native Christians, left Tsu-ku in search of safety, which only two of them were to find, and then only after three weeks of misery.

The party had scarcely covered ten miles down the Mekong valley, when, on passing the Lamasery of Patong, their presence was detected; and early the next morning they were attacked. Pere Bourdonnec was quickly riddled with poisoned arrows; the other Father was captured and later tortured to death; but Forrest with one of his colleagues managed to escape. Their troubles had only just begun. The Tibetans scoured the countryside for them with tracker dogs and even tracker women. Forrest was forced to discard his boots - he had poisoned his foot on a bamboo-stake- and wade through icy streams waist deep to avoid leaving tracks.

‘At the end of eight days’, he later wrote, ‘I had ceased to care whether I lived or died; my feet swollen out of all shape... all the food I had for that time consisted of two dozen ears of wheat and a handful of parched peas.’ And, but for the kindness of a friendly village headman, who hid him almost under the noses of a party of thirty Lamas in full war-paint - and not before they had put two shots through his hat - he would certainly have perished.

As it was, he and his companion eventually got back to the Mekong, having been pursued and harried for more than fifty miles. Forrest had kept his life; but rifle, revolver, camera, clothes, camp equipment and seeds had all gone.

Nothing daunted, he set out again two months later with the British Consul, G.L. Litton, along the Salween valley, and then across a steep mountain pass on the Salween-Mekong Divide. Litton died of blackwater fever; but, meanwhile, he and Forrest had explored much new territory, to which Forrest returned in March 1906, collecting seed and plants along the foothills of the Lu-Chiang range. He continued collecting on both sides of this vast range for another five years, and did not return home until 1911, and then for less than a year; he was back on the Nmai Hka-Salween and Salween-Shweli divides by March 1912.

Judging from a letter written to Caerhays soon after his return, the political situation was just as turbulent and dangerous for the plant-hunter then as it was in 1905. The Viceroy of the province was an ex-bandit; and ‘Squeezing and beheading was the order of the day’, Forrest writes. The important town of Yang-Chang Fu, right in the middle of Forrest’s area, had recently been destroyed by rebels; and a large number of the survivors had been executed.

In spite of these fearful perils and problems, the hardy and masterful Scot continued over a period of twenty-eight years to collect - usually under immense difficulties- plants and seeds to enrich our gardens, parks and woods. During this time, he sent home 31,000 sheets of dried plants, and the same number of separate parcels of seed. In 1913 alone he collected sixty-seven distinct species of primula.

Altogether he introduced 309 new species of rhododendron, among them the beautiful R.sinogrande that he found on the western side of the Shweli-Salween Divide, and the deep crimson dwarf that bears his name, from the Mekong-Salween Divide.

One of the silver firs he found now bears his name; but to list even a few of the many conifers, magnolias, camellias and primulas he discovered would be tedious. It is worth mentioning, however, that the progeny from the seed of the ninety-foot Maidenhair Tree he found are of exceptional quality.2

On January 5th 1932, with two mule loads of between 130 and 150 lbs of seed, representing some 400 to 500 species, safely packed and ready for despatch, George Forrest went off to enjoy his favourite sport. He had not been well; and so they carried him to the paddy fields; but a high snipe got him reaching for a long shot.

As the bird fell dead, so did Forrest. He was only fifty-eight, and had escaped the infirmities and indignities of old age; but through his early death we are deprived of a full account of his achievements. Perhaps he would never have written them; for the crafty hunter of the wilderness takes uneasily to the drudgery of the desk.

1 When the present writer walked some 600 miles over tracks in the same province almost forty years later, bandits were still capable of giving one a lively surprise.

2 Forrest did not discover the Maidenhair tree. It was first introduced from Japan (where it is not indigenous) in 1758. It is probably a native of Yunnan, but is seldom, if ever, found in the wild.