Welsh Chapels in Crisis

According to Capel, the Chapels Heritage Society, Welsh chapels are closing at an alarming rate of one per week. This is a real crisis, not just for folks who enjoy rescuing old architecture, but for Wales as a nation. In many ways, Welsh chapels represent the heart and soul of Wales. They symbolise the history of Wales as it transformed from an agricultural nation in the seventeenth century into a leader of the Industrial Revolution. Anthony Jones, author of Welsh Chapels (1996) describes these often peculiar and not always pleasant-looking structures as ‘the national architecture of Wales,’ yet for too long their influence has been overlooked. Often, they have been criticised as a blight on the landscape.

Where other forms of architecture in Wales have received listed status and the state has taken them into its care, the chapel – the one structure that represents the impact of Nonconformity on virtually every aspect of Welsh society, culture and politics – has been rejected, at least until recently. In 2000, the Royal Commission for Ancient and Historic Monuments in Wales finally completed an extensive undertaking, surveying and documenting every chapel in Wales. Their intent was to ensure that a record and photographs survive for this vital element of Welsh history, to record for posterity the existence and appearance of these chapels before they disappear without trace.

The Welsh chapel is the only architectural development that Wales can claim as its own. Whereas the castles for which the country is acclaimed were built by outsiders and imposed upon them, the Welsh willingly erected chapels to serve themselves. Virtually every community has at least one. While their distinctive features make them readily recognisable, each is different, emphasising the independence of congregations from each other.

In the early seventeenth century, when Nonconformity was illegal, people came together to worship in private homes, barns and even public houses. The first chapel buildings were converted barns or farm houses, unobtrusive places where preaching could be carried out without attracting unwanted attention. A chapel meant much more than a structure where people worshipped together; the chapel was the congregation itself, the group of people who gathered to hear sermons, often by itinerant preachers.
After the Act of Toleration of 1689, Nonconformity gathered momentum and chapel-building spread. By the end of the eighteenth century, over a hundred new chapels had sprung up in Wales. During the first fifty years of the nineteenth century, a chapel was completed there every eight days: by 1851, some 2,800 existed throughout the countryside. Ultimately, Welsh Nonconformists built some 5,000 chapels within about 250 years.

The first chapels were plain and austere and designed to focus attention on the pulpit, placed at the centre of the wall toward which the worshippers faced. Within 150 years, chapel ornamentation evolved dramatically, and façades became more elaborate. The changing styles reflected the distinct identities and changes within individual Nonconformist communities, who were increasingly playing a role in politics as well as being the social and cultural focus of those they served.

In the census of 1851, Wales boasted that almost a million people, around five-sixths of the population, attended weekly chapel. Chapels were not only  places of worship, but they were also places in which people were educated, instilled with basic literacy, and which fostered the continued use of the Welsh language, the growth of the Welsh press and the publication of reading materials. Locally, chapels were used for lectures, preaching festivals, concerts and eisteddfodau, penny readings and temperance meetings. Members were encouraged to speak before their fellow worshippers, and political aspirations sprouted. Notably, the classlessness emphasised by Nonconformity strengthened cohesiveness and sparked political expression and involvement.

In the mid-1800s, Nonconformity aligned itself with the Liberation Society; many chapel-goers became politically active and increasingly more radical. Nonconformity – its chapels and use of the Welsh language – soon became incontrovertibly linked with ‘Welshness’. Nonconformists saw themselves as ‘gwerin’, and even Prime Minister Gladstone observed, ‘the Nonconformist of Wales ARE the people of Wales’.
During the first half of the twentieth century, the Welsh continued to attend chapel, albeit at a decreasing rate. As the ability to speak Welsh declined across Wales, so did attendance at chapel. Other activities began to grip the population, and chapel-going declined steadily, particularly after the Second World War. Leisure pursuits – sports, the cinema, television and pubs open on Sundays – took the people out of the chapels and into other establishments. Politically, the Labour Party and socialism became increasingly attractive to workers whose income depended on industry and lured away members from the Liberal Party. For these and other reasons, chapels started to become redundant.

By the end of the twentieth century, only 13 per cent of the Welsh population regularly attended chapel. Consequently, many of the buildings became derelict. Many were demolished, while others have been converted into houses, shops or garages, bingo halls, squash courts, or factories. Some conversions have been ruthless, the essence of the original architecture gutted, while others, like The Academy in Aberystwyth (now a popular public house), retain the fittings and preserve the integrity of the original chapel. Some chapels are now used as museums, heritage centres or art galleries, including the Tabernacles in Machynlleth and Pontypridd and the Chapel of Art in Criccieth. Many others still serve the chapel-going community. One company near Swansea not only dismantles and transports chapels onto private land, but they also sell chapels for private use!

Welsh chapels have variously been described as ‘national architecture’, ‘Welsh folk-architecture’ and, according to John Hilling author of The Historic Architecture of Wales (1976), ‘a unity of expression in design. ... which forms a kind of Celtic Vernacular’. Now, as Wales strives to recreate its national image and to improve its position within the global community, it is appropriate to reconsider the role of the chapel and Nonconformity in the development of the modern Welsh mindset.

  • For further details on the Chapels Heritage Society, contact Ms Penny Icke, Hon Secretary, RCAHMW, Plas Crug, Aberystwyth, Ceredigion, SY23 1NJ, tel: 01970 621210, Penny.Icke@rcahmw.org.uk