'A Universal Place of Study'
Three hundred years ago the seal was set for an educational establishment in Virginia that has since exercised a powerful cultural and social influence in North America. J.E. Morpurgo looks at the life and times of the College of William and Mary.
Three hundred years ago, on February 8th, 1693, William III and Queen Mary set their names to a document which signalled royal approval for the plan to establish 'a place of universal study' in the colony of Virginia.
The College of William and Mary has every right to honour its royal charter but there is reason to insist that the ceremony at Hampton Court was but the culmination of a long sequence of seminal episodes and that by celebrating 1993 as its tercentenary the college not only surrenders to Harvard its proper place as first in the order of precedence of American universities but also – and to far greater consequence – excises from its record eight decades of brave endeavour and frustrated achievement which continued to have resonance in the mores and development of William and Mary through all the years of the eighteenth century and on into the first quarter of the nineteenth.
The pioneers of English colonisation in America recognised that their settlements could not achieve permanence unless they provided the means for educating succeeding generations. The Jamestown Plantation was not yet two years old when its inhabitants began to plan a school, and by 1616 – less than a decade after the Sarah Constant dropped anchor at the mouth of the James and still three years before, far to the north, the Pilgrim Fathers disembarked from the Mayflower – the little colony was brisk with talk of a far more grandiose project: Virginia was to have its own university.
The colony was sparsely populated, its economy fragile, and it lacked the military capacity to meet and defeat a concerted assault by Virginia's Indians, but the colonists (and their mentors in England) knew that they had behind them the wealth, the influence and the well-tried organisational skills of the Virginia Company of London, they were confident that they could win support from James I and from the established church, and they suspected that by judicious use of casuistry they could turn to their own advantage even the ever-present Indian menace.
There were set-backs but for seven years the project went forward much as its originators had hoped and had dared to predict. Land was set aside for the university at Henrico, a new settlement some 80 miles up-river from Jamestown. To construct its first buildings the company sent out from England a team of labourers under the supervision of one of its own liverymen, George Thorpe, a man much admired for his energy and enthusiasm. In London the company set up a committee charged with responsibility for the university and a sub-committee of experts briefed to devise its curriculum.
The king played his part, as was the custom of the Stuarts, in a fashion which ensured that the price of his graciousness would not be born by the Royal Treasury. In 1617 he commanded all the parishes in England to take up collections for Virginian education 'four severall tymes in these two years next coming'.
The king and his subjects on both sides of the Atlantic saw it as their God-given responsibility to convert the Indians to Christianity. James I, his advisers, the company and the colonists were also convinced that conversion was synonymous with pacification, that they could compensate for the inadequacy of the colony's defences 'by rescuing from darkness those Infidels and Savages' and could 'bring them to... civility and good government'. In all probability the king and his advisers were also sensible to that quirk in the nature of Englishmen which favours benevolence directed to remote purposes above charity intended for use at home. Thus James made it clear that, though the proceeds of 'the Royal Collection' must be devoted to the 'erecting of... Schooles for the education of the children of those Barbarians', he allowed into the text of his instructions to the two arch- bishops one conveniently ambiguous phrase which opened the way for the colonists to subvert part of the funds raised in England from schools for the Indians to the education of their own boys. The money collected must be used to support the 'work in hand' in Virginia.
Two years later when Sir George Yeardley came to the colony as governor he carried with him a document which made the escape-clause blatant. The cause of Indian education still predominated but now the proceeds of English philanthropy could be devoted to 'other godly purposes'. For the colonists no purpose was more godly than the education of their own young. Already in 1617, all involved on both sides of the Atlantic – with the possible exception of the parishioners who dropped their coins into offertory-plates – were well aware that, though the 'work in hand' did envisage a grammar-school for Indians, it also included a grammar school for settlers' boys at Charles City and, again at Henrico, two colleges – one for Indians, one for settlers – to which, as their numbers increased, the colonists planned to add new colleges, all for their own boys, to form in time a collegiate university after the Oxford and Cambridge pattern.
Many well-wishers in England paid heed to the king's exhortation to 'zealous men' to add their own contribution to the sum of the Royal Collection – not a few of them dedicating their benefactions openly to the college for whites. By the end of 1621 the university had a plush endowment, land, some buildings, a substantial library – and a set of Communion-plate. On July 2nd, 1622, the Virginia Company elected the Reverend Patrick Copland Rector of the University of Henrico.
Copland was an Aberdonian, a graduate of Marischal College and an Anglican priest. He had travelled to the East, he was a scholar. He had served on the university's curriculum committee, his piety was such that he was accorded a saint by his contemporaries, but sanctity had not inhibited his astute dealings in London's commercial markets, nor had it prevented him from weaving a skein of useful friendships with powerful, if often ungodly, Englishmen.
Copland busied himself with increasing Henrico's endowment and with casting about for suitable professorial colleagues. Before he could take passage for Virginia however, the king deprived him of his principal source of influence and the university of its English power-base. James mistrusted the City of London and resented the over-weening power which the Virginia Company exercised in the affairs of this new and potentially profitable American empire. In May 1624 he dissolved it.
Copland was dismayed but saw no reason to give up his post. Though he never came closer to Virginia than Bermuda for the next twenty years – until he defected from Anglicanism – he continued to style himself rector of the university and persisted with his task of winning support for Henrico. Once, but only once, he offered to resign, but only on the condition that his friend Nicholas Ferrar of Little Gidding would go to Henrico as rector in his place – 'and if he do I will never foresake him but will wait upon him in that glorious work'.
The colonists were also disheartened by the dissolution of the Virginia Company, but they did not abandon their ambitions and for many years gave firm expression to their conviction that their university existed de jure by including its representative in the colony's Assembly.
England at war with itself had neither money nor interest to spare for a shadowy institution somewhere out on the edge of empire. The Protectorate looked with disfavour on a colony notorious for its devotion to the crown and to the Church of England. The Lord Protector, a loyal son of Cambridge, directed such little encouragement as his regime was prepared to give to education in America towards the stolidly Puritan newcomer, Harvard College, in that other Cambridge in Massachusetts.
The Restoration revived Virginia's optimism; well-placed intermediaries begged the king to confirm royal patronage for Henrico. Charles II was gracious – and did nothing.
Paradoxically it was the advent of a Catholic monarch which presented Virginia with allies and its university with sponsors more potent than ever the Virginia Company had been. Faced with James II's determination to undermine the influence of the Church of England, the Lords Spiritual sought to bolster even the most distant outposts of Anglicanism. Most of the other American colonies were, to the bishops, suspect; the New England colonies for their Nonconformity, Pennsylvania for its Quakerdom, Maryland for its adherence to Rome. Only Virginia had proved its loyalty to the Church of England.
Shrewdly, the Virginians relegated Indian education from its primacy among their proclaimed objectives for their university and replaced it with a proposal which had been tentatively advanced in the years when Puritanism was dominant in England: they would establish within the university a seminary for Virginia-born aspirants to Anglican holy orders.
Well before James II was hustled out of England the bishops had their plenipotentiary in Virginia, and resident at Henrico. Like Copland before him, James Blair was an Aberdonian, a graduate of Marischal College and an Anglican priest who had moved to London in search of preferment. Like Copland he was adept in acquiring influential friends, in Blair's case most of them members of the Episcopal Bench.
It was one of these friends, Henry Compton, Bishop of London, who sent Blair to Henrico and who, within months of his arrival, promoted him to be his commissary in Virginia, at that time and for a century thereafter the most powerful appointment open to a cleric in America.
In a short time Blair had ready for presentation to the first-ever assembly of American clergy an outline of his proposals for education in Virginia. Then for a year, with the enthusiastic collaboration of Governor Francis Nicholson, Blair enlarged and refined his scheme. They set to paper every detail of administration and organisation, even the salary to be paid to each member of the staff. Only the location intended for the college was left deliberately vague.
When the prefatory work was completed it was still necessary to pilot the proposals through several committees, through the House of Burgeses, and through the council. Not even the most fractious of Virginia's customarily fractious leaders ventured more than a quibble over minutiae as counter to a proposal advanced by the formidable combination of governor and commissary, but even so it was not until the summer of 1691 that Blair left for England to seek the decisive support of his episcopal friends and to present a petition to the king and queen.
Blair arrived in London armed with well-nigh unlimited authority to act as he thought fit, but soon discovered that a commission signed by the government, the secretary and the speaker of Virginia's House of Burgesses was no defence against the dilatoriness of the English Establishment.
The Bishop of London was unwell and when, after several postponements, at last he received his commissary, he offered only an old soldier's advice: to approach the throne 'by the proper channels'. Other bishops were in their dioceses or off in Flanders with William; those he managed to see, being no longer so concerned for the affairs of a distant colony as they had been when their church was threatened by James II, expressed enthusiasm for the college – and passed Blair on to some other grandee.
Blair spent months roaming the corridors of power and at last, on the introduction of another Scot from Marischal College, the historian Gilbert Burnet, Bishop of Salisbury, he was granted an audience by the queen. Mary, a devout Anglican, took up Blair's cause with the king, who like his bishop, favoured Virginia principally because he questioned the loyalty of his other American colonies. The college had its charter.
The charter imposed upon the college as its first responsibility the creation of 'a perpetual College of Divinity', but as a seminary William and Mary was never as successful as its founders had intended. Through most of the eighteenth century there was no bishop in America. Not many young Virginians felt the call to priesthood so undeniable that they were ready to accept the expense and the dangers of travelling to England for ordination. Of those who did go, 'some died at sea and some were taken up by pirates', some found irresistible the delights of London, others remained to cure English souls. A few returned to the colony, several of whom took up teaching posts at the college. One, James Madison (name- sake of his cousin, the President of the United States) became President of William and Mary and eventually Virginia's first bishop.
The charter was less specific about Indian education but those responsible for the future of the college followed the example of their predecessors and continued to use their intention to civilise their savage neighbours as a useful persuader to English philanthropy. Reward for their persistence came immediately and lavishly. Robert Boyle had died in 1691 leaving the bulk of his considerable fortune to be used 'to the advantage of Christian education'. Blair, again supported by Burnet, persuaded the executor of 'the Sceptical Chymist' that nothing could be more advantageous to Christian education than the establishment of an Indian School at William and Mary. The executor bought an estate in the North of England and dedicated the larger part of its income to the college. William and Mary built a school for Indians and called the building Brafferton for the Yorkshire estate.
It is possible, and even likely, that a few Indian boys were educated in Brafferton but only one, Baubee, appears in its register and he was admitted when there was no longer a master of the Indian School and long after Boyle funds had been diverted to other uses. Even so, after the Revolution, when the college impudently sued the British Government in an English court for the restitution of the right to income from the bequest, it founded its case in no small part on the good it had done the Indians.
The course which 'Their Majesties' Royall Colledge' was to follow had in fact been determined before the charter was signed, even before Blair took passage for England, when Blair and Nicholson decided to establish their college at Middle Plantation, the location chosen to be Virginia's new capital, Williamsburg. Its prime and inescapable objective was to serve as forcing-ground for the leadership of America's largest and most powerful colony.
Work on William and Mary's first building began in 1695. Much later, the building came to be known as the Wren Building, and since the Second World War, as if to compensate for the sparseness of evidence to support the claim that it was designed by the genius who built St Paul's Cathedral, the college has made the attribution unmistakable by renaming it the Sir Christopher Wren Building. For dignity and elegance it is worthy of Wren but more likely it was designed by someone well-versed in the works of England's greatest architect.
However, it was not the design but the site chosen for the building which made evident the role that Blair and Nicholson intended for the college. It was set at one end of the broad boulevard (to this day Duke of Gloucester Street) which Nicholson devised to be the axis of Virginia's capital with, from its front, as though to signal to the students the way that they must go in their adult years, an uninterrupted view of the seat of Government, the Capitol almost a mile away at the other end. Even when, later in Blair's fifty-year presidency, William and Mary built to either side of the College Building, Brafferton and the President's House, still it left open the fourth, the streetward, side which, had it been filled, would have completed a quadrangle after the Oxford and Cambridge pattern.
Within the walls of the college young Virginians were schooled in the manner then thought appropriate to preparation of leaders of a nation – Greek, Latin, Philosophy, Literature and a little Mathematics – and for a century and more the names entered in the college register – many of them the names of Virginia's planter-aristocracy – appeared again in the minutes of the council and the House of Burgesses and, as the names of judges and advocates, in the records of Virginia's courts.
Accustomed as they were to political discourse and to leadership in what was of all Britain's American possessions the largest and, with the possible exception of Massachusetts, the most influential, it was inevitable that when the colonies grew restive under British rule men out of William and Mary were prominent, some of them pre-eminent, in the debates which led eventually to all the thirteen colonies breaking with the crown. Reared by their families and schooled by the college in an essentially British tradition they did not look upon resistance to British hegemony in America as in any way a rejection of their British heritage. It was not they but the British themselves who had betrayed British principles by arrogantly denying to the king's American subjects the unequivocal right to parliamentary government that was enjoyed by his subjects in the British Isles. ('No taxation without representation'.) They saw them- selves as the true heirs to Cromwell, Algernon Sidney, John Locke and the instigators of the Glorious Revolution and, when it became apparent that no British Government would condone an accommodation of a kind which 150 years later under the Statute of Westminster conferred Dominion status on other British colonies, few of them hesitated before deciding to create a new nation which would perpetuate in America the principles which Britain had abandoned.
With the exception of a few words impertinently inserted by John Adams from Harvard, the Declaration of Independence, the noble finale to the pre-revolutionary debates, was in its entirety the product of the mind and pen of Thomas Jefferson, and Jefferson, though unlike most of his Virginian contemporaries more inclined to Francophilia than to Anglophilia, was never reluctant to recognise the virtues of the British tradition and always ready to acknowledge the debt that he owed to William and Mary for the grounding the college had given him in British Political Philosophy, British History and English Literature.
Debate turned bloody. When Americans fought to make permanent the independence asserted by Jefferson, and when America's leadership essayed the task of establishing a framework for the proclaimed unity of thirteen diverse states the political and legal expertise common to men from William and Mary proved vital, not only to Virginia but also to the new nation. College alumni were active, and some of them dominant, in almost every committee set up to direct the course of the war with Britain and in all the conventions which prepared and ratified the Constitution of the United States.
At times during the war the college itself was close to the scene of battle. One or another of its buildings was occupied either by the French or the British, and it was only the intervention of a politically powerful former student which frustrated the intention of the Continental Army to commandeer the whole college.
These harsh experiences did not dent William and Mary's self-assurance. All those other American institutions which hitherto had boasted names with royal associations defended themselves against suspicion of continuing anti-republican sentiment by taking for themselves new and unequivocally American names. The college saw no reason to indulge in such petty subterfuge, no cause to apologise for its past. The College of William and Mary it had been since 1695 and the College of William and Mary it would remain for all time.
During the years of battle the college was still capable of innovation, and particularly of innovation founded upon its tradition. In 1776 a group of students founded a club to discuss the political, philosophical and moral issues of the day. Although interest in such topics was symptomatic of the college's predelictions, the society was by no means esoteric; similar groups existed in every college and university in Britain and America; but to enliven their earnest meetings the William and Mary students imposed upon themselves for their society arcane rules, a secret handshake and a Greek-letter name impenetrable to all save initiates. A founding member took himself and the society to Yale and in time chapters were established in almost every important university in the United States. Phi Beta Kappa remains unique for its dedication to high academic standards but William and Mary's chapter, Alpha of Virginia had more significant consequences; it was the progenitor of all those mysterious Greek-letter fraternities which are central to American undergraduate social life – and which are incomprehensible to all who are not American.
In colonial times many William and Mary men moved on to be trained as lawyers, not a few of them without any intention to practise. Some went to London, to one of the Inns of Court; most were prepared for the profession in Williamsburg law offices. In 1779 the college established a School of Law, the first in America, with as its first professor, George Wythe, a perfervid patriot and, as also were three other William and Mary men, a signatory of the Declaration of Independence, but even so an ardent champion of the English legal system. (Like many Virginians from his day to this, Wythe was able to reconcile two seemingly irreconcilable prejudices: chauvinism and Anglophilia).
It was, however, also in 1779 that the blow was struck which heralded the decline of William and Mary. Virginia moved its capital to Richmond. William and Mary was deprived of the centrality to public life which for almost a century had fashioned its most distinctive characteristics.
The consequence was not immediate. The time-lag between student promise and adult achievement is long and for many years there were men from the college active at the forefront of state and national public life, as governors of Virginia and of new territories, as senators, as ambassadors and as jurists. One – John Marshall – became the first (and, many would say, still the greatest) Chief Justice of the United State Supreme Court, three – Jefferson, Monroe and Tyler – presidents of the United States.
The break with Britain had no drastic consequence for the college's finances. From 1693 onwards, with the notable exception of the Boyle Bequest, much of its income had been derived from Virginian taxes, its payment authorised by the House of Burgesses. With Independence such limited authority over Virginia taxation as remained with the crown was automatically subsumed by the government of the Commonwealth of Virginia.
There were new colleges in Virginia but none threatened William and Mary's primacy until 1819 when Jefferson, being unwilling to condone the college's lingering Anglicanism, abandoned his intention to make his alma mater the state university and instead set up a new institution close to his home, Monticello in Charlottesville. William and Mary became a small, insignificant college in a sleepy country town in a state no longer pre-eminent.
When, in the heroic but tragic years between 1861 and 1865, Virginia became once again the head and the heart of a nation the consequences for the college were disastrous. Most of its students and many of its faculty went off to join the Confederate Army and again, as during the revolutionary war, the college was close to the eye of the storm of battle. Virginia sacrificed its young men, its economy and its vitality to the Southern cause. The humiliation of defeat and the long drawn out, bitter experience of reconstruction brought the college to the very brink of nemesis. For some years it was kept alive only by the presence of a handful of students and the doom-defying toll of the college bell.
It was not until the early decades of this century that any substantial effort was made to revive William and Mary's fortunes. In 1906 the College became a state institution – an act of submission that, whether by decision or by chance, William and Mary has ever since kept secret from all outside Virginia in a nation proud of its classlessness which even so assumes that private institutions are somehow socially superior to those funded out of tax-revenues. And in 1918 the college turned co-educational.
Despite these enlivening developments, William and Mary might have remained for all time just another small college, and indistinguishable from many of the same kind in all the states of the Union had it not been that in 1926 John D. Rockefeller Jr. agreed to finance the bold and formidable task of giving back to Williamsburg its eighteenth-century elegance. Not even Rockefeller money could recreate the political prestige which Williamsburg had enjoyed when it was Virginia's capital but the restoration gave to the city national and even international status. From all parts of the United States and from abroad, visitors came to town – before the Second World War in their thousands, latterly in their millions. Williamsburg became a showcase for the arts and a centre for historical studies and research. William and Mary is once again at the centre of a vibrant city, a city that is now well-suited to the role of university town. The renaissance of Williamsburg revived the college's confidence. With the city it has profited hugely from the nationwide and worldwide attention paid to the restoration and from the recommendations of admiring tourists.
William and Mary's three colonial buildings have been impeccably restored. Still in use by faculty and students and still the college as it is known to most in the world at large, they stand now as an eighteenth-century outpost to a vast modern campus.
In return for state funds William and Mary is bound to ensure that a substantial proportion of its undergraduate population is made up of Virginia residents but the college's enhanced reputation has brought in a large number of students (both undergraduate and graduate) from all parts of the United States and from many other countries, and has also encouraged benefactors (even, some of them, British) whose generosity has allowed the college a considerable measure of independence. It could not justify its high standing exclusively on its antiquity and, though there are within its province some highly prestigious elements – the National Law College and the Institute for Early American History and Culture – which are both unique to it, William and Mary can now offer almost everything that could be expected from a modern university anywhere in the world.
The college which had its origins at Henrico is now again, as its founders had always intended and as it was in the eighteenth century, 'a place of universal study' and useful to a nation.
For Further Reading: Hugh Jones edited by R.L. Morton, The Present State of Virginia. (1724) (University of Carolina Press, 1956); Dumas Malone, Jefferson the Virginian (Eyre R Spottiswoode, 1948); J.E. Morpurgo, Their Majesties' Royall Colledge: William and Mary in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries. (William and Mary, 1976); R.L. Morton, Colonial Virginia (University of N. Carolina Press, 1960); R.B. Nye and J.E. Morpurgo, Birth of the USA (Penguin, 1975); Parke Rouse, James Blair of Virginia (University of N. Carolina Press, 1971) and by the same author, Cows on the Campus (Pietz, 1973).
- J.E. Morpurgo is Emeritus Professor of American Literature at the University of Leeds. He was for many years General Editor of the Penguin History Series and Director of the William and Mary Historical Project.

