Looking for a Laureate: The Difficulties of Three Prime Ministers
Peter Stansky & William Abrahams describe how, after Tennyson’s death, the problem of finding a new Poet Laureate perturbed successive British governments.
The death of Tennyson in October 1892, in his eighty-third year, deprived England not only of a Poet Laureate, but of a long-established National Monument—next to the Queen herself, he had come to represent in the public consciousness the embodiment of Victorianism, a poet “who held the proud honour of never uttering one single line which an English mother would once wish unwritten or an English girl unread.”
There was a magnificent state funeral in Westminster Abbey; outside, broadsheets of “Crossing the Bar” were sold and recited. Then the search for a successor was begun. “It is sad, but inevitable,” wrote Sir Algernon West, Gladstone’s chief secretary, “that on the death of a great man, the first thought that arises is, who is to fill, or try to fill, his place?”
The appointment of the Poet Laureate was a prerogative of the Queen, who would act upon the advice of her Prime Minister. Considering the abundance of poets from whom a choice might be made, it should not have been difficult to advise her. Yet the problem of finding a Laureate remained to irritate, harass, and challenge three successive Prime Ministers—William Gladstone, Lord Rosebery, and the Marquess of Salisbury—and it was not until December 1895 that the appointment was finally made.
Tennyson had died in the early hours of October 6th, 1892. Later that day a report of his death, in circumstantial detail, was brought to the Queen at Balmoral. The elderly Victoria, who shared the taste of her age for a memorable deathbed, wrote in her Journal:
“Heard that dear old Lord Tennyson had breathed his last, a great national loss. He was a great poet, and his ideas were ever grand, noble, and elevating. He was very loyal, and always very kind and sympathizing to me, quite remarkably so. What beautiful lines he wrote for my darling Albert and for my children! ...He died with his hand on his Shakespeare and the moon shining full into the window and over him. A worthy end to such a remarkable man. He died at his place in Surrey.”
The Queen grieved; Gladstone, the Prime Minister, grieved; the great mass of readers, who had found in Tennyson’s poetry an expression of their own deepest needs and concerns, grieved. Even those less responsive to his message regarded the death as an historic occasion.
A representative figure of the younger literary generation, Richard LeGal-lienne, recalled it as perhaps the most impressive event of his first years in London. To him “it touched the imagination as giving dramatic emphasis to the passing of the old Victorian order of which he [Tennyson] had been the spiritual and intellectual spokesman, one might even say prophet.”
The late Laureate had flourished for so long—more than four decades—that he and the office were now thought of as indivisible. Some believed that the post, having been filled so splendidly, and, as it were, so finally, should be abolished; others proposed it be made hereditary and pass, along with the peerage, to Hallam, the new Lord Tennyson.
Quite evidently there was a confusion here between the death of a poet and the death of poetry, and it provoked Sir Edmund Gosse to remark acidly, “The excitement about Tennyson’s death has been far too universal to be sincere.” Gosse objected to the assumption that among the survivors there was no one worthy to hold the office.
“Our living poets,” he declared in a burst of uncritical generosity, “present a variety and amplitude of talent, a fulness in tone, an accomplishment in art, such as few other generations in England, and still fewer elsewhere, have been in a position to exult in.” The note of exaggeration is unmistakable; nevertheless, Gosse was restoring perspective where it was badly needed.
Hardly anyone remembered that Tennyson’s own advent to the post forty-three years earlier had been fortuitous. The moral was clear: one does not become a National Monument overnight. In 1850, at Wordsworth’s death, the Laureateship was offered to the elderly Samuel Rogers, who refused it, and then to the elderly Thomas Moore, who also refused it; whereupon it was offered to the youngish Tennyson, who accepted it. It is worth remarking, in view of the later aura that surrounded him, that the choice was not received with unanimous enthusiasm.
Indeed, there was a curious foreshadowing of the sentiments of 1892. The cry went up that Wordsworth’s death had created such a void that the office should be abolished rather than be entrusted to a poet of lesser stature. But Tennyson, a few months earlier, had published In Memoriam’, it was spoken highly of by Prince Albert; on November 5th, the Queen made her choice. The process by which a poet would be transformed into a Monument was begun.
One consequence of Tennyson’s having followed Wordsworth in the office was the new, perhaps arguable, doctrine that it should be held only by major poets. Tennyson and Wordsworth were indisputably major; some faint distinction still attaches to Robert Southey, who was Wordsworth’s predecessor.
But if one excepts Ben Jonson, the first official Laureate, and Dryden, who also held the post in the seventeenth century, it is fair to say that, in the two hundred years between Jonson and Southey, mediocrity prevailed. There had been a succession of forgotten poets, political hacks, and minor scribblers—but the significant fact is, mediocrity could do very nicely in the post.
In exchange for a yearly stipend of seventy-two pounds and a butt of sack, the Laureate was to provide occasional verses: an ode for a royal wedding or birthday, a monody for a royal funeral, suitably patriotic stanzas for a state celebration or crisis. Genius was not a requisite, and in the end made no difference. From all the Laureates’ endeavours to please, Wordsworth’s and Tennyson’s included, not one really first-rate poem has ever been forthcoming.
Mediocrity, however, was not a solution likely to appeal to Gladstone, the first Prime Minister to face the problem created by Tennyson’s death. In 1892 he was eighty-three years old, an exact contemporary of Tennyson, and like him, something of a National Monument. During his long life in politics, bis actions had been governed by a probity that made itself felt equally in his private and public character.
Like Tennyson’s King Arthur and the late Prince Albert, Gladstone was the personification of Victorian virtues, and it was unthinkable for him to approach a problem with other than high seriousness. Believing as he did that the greatest care must be exercised in the bestowal of patronage, it was inevitable that he would conduct his search for a Laureate with unwavering scrupulosity.
Tennyson’s death came at an inconvenient time for the Prime Minister. After six years of Tory rule, the Liberals had been voted into office in August 1892, with the small majority of forty. Gladstone, Prime Minister for a fourth time, was dedicated to attempting yet again to get through a Home Rule Bill for Ireland, and thoughts of this mission were uppermost in his mind.
Meanwhile, he had to form a Cabinet and, immediately after its formation, cope with a dispute over imperial policy among its members which jeopardized the future of his administration. In addition, he had to contend with a host of lesser problems: how to obey the Queen’s wish that Henry Labouchere be kept out of the Cabinet while at the same time maintaining the constitutional doctrine that the Monarch has no opinions; how to save the estate of his deceased friend and colleague, Earl Granville, from bankruptcy; and now, in October 1892, how to select a new, suitable Poet Laureate.
It is necessary to emphasize the changing poetic situation at this period. A short time earlier, the poetry of the great Victorians had seemed unalterable, timeless in its achievements, enduring in its attitudes. Now, one by one the shapers of the tradition were vanishing from the scene. Tennyson’s was the third death of a major poet in less than five years: Matthew Arnold had died in 1888, Browning in 1889. In all three, though most conspicuously in Tennyson, there had been a fusion of public and private voice. Their poetry reflected in greater or lesser degree the spiritual concerns of the age. It had come to be taken for granted that the public voice was an integral part of the poetic character.
Thus, Tennyson explained that in In Memoriam the “I” was meant to stand not only for “the author speaking of himself, but the voice of the human race.” Significantly, this attempt to unite the private and public voice of the poet occurred at the very time that the conflict between religion and science was at its most disruptive. Somehow a reconciliation was to be effected: the private voice would express doubt, the public voice assurance; and the two together, the sensibility of the era.
But in spite of the assertions of the great poets, the conflict deepened; there was a corresponding, ever more marked, split in sensibility; the private voice dominated. The younger poets coming to prominence at the end of the Tennyson era—the decadents of the Yellow Book, the aesthetes of the ’nineties—had no desire to be Tennysonian. Their belief in art for art’s sake led them to opposite notions of what poetry ought to be—not “grand, noble, and elevating,” but a “beautiful” private performance. It was unlikely that the Prime Minister would find among them the Laureate he was looking for.
Yet there were still two great, aging poets of the Victorian heyday who, at first glance, seemed logical candidates for the post, William Morris and Algernon Charles Swinburne. But would they prove equal to the Prime Minister’s rigorous standards? “Wordsworth and Tennyson,” Gladstone wrote, “have made the place great. They also have made it extremely clean.” He was determined that the new appointment should continue this tradition of cleanliness and greatness. Considerably more than literary excellence was in question here; it soon became evident that the two obvious candidates were not what was wanted.
Morris was disqualified by his politics. He was an ardent and unrepentant Socialist. Besides, he had let it be known to Gladstone through an intermediary that he would not accept the post if it were offered to him. Morris’s attitude was lightly mocking. A few days after Tennyson’s death he wrote to a friend: “What a set of ninnies the papers are about the Laureateship, treating it with such absurd solemnity. Bet you it is offered to Swinburne. Bet you he takes it.”
In many ways Swinburne did seem the inevitable selection. Conferring with Gladstone, the Queen is reputed to have said, “I am told that Mr. Swinburne is the best poet in my dominions.” But this was more a question than a statement: it was unlikely she had read a line of his verse. The Prime Minister had, however, and knew that Swinburne was impossible. His most famous books, the Poems and Ballads of 1866 and Songs Before Sunrise of 1871, contained offensively republican and scandalously erotic poems. Again and again the poet had presented himself as a pagan, a sensualist, and a devotee of what the French like to refer to as “le vice anglais”—i.e., a taste for the whip.
In addition, despite his republicanism, Swinburne had attacked Gladstone over the Home Rule issue, in The Times of July 1st, 1886.
No; the lust of life, the thirst for work and days with work to do in,
Drove and drives him down the road of splendid shame;
All is well, if o’er the monument recording England’s ruin,
Time shall read, inscribed in triumph, Gladstone’s name.
Gladstone would not have allowed a political disagreement to keep him from appointing Swinburne, particularly as he was so admired in important circles. The Prince of Wales favoured him, and so did Arthur Balfour, who, although Salisbury’s nephew and a leading Tory, was also of a literary disposition and a philosopher, and esteemed by Gladstone.
But there was an unbridgeable gulf between Swinburne’s “lilies and languors of vice,” and Tennyson’s “My strength is as the strength of ten, Because my heart is pure.” True, Swinburne’s character was now irreproachable and he was carefully watched over by his friend Theodore Watts-Dunton in a villa in suburban Putney.
Swinburne could turn out verses such as the late “Etude Realiste” (which, despite its French tide, was a tribute to a baby’s feet, hands, and eyes) that any English mother might safely allow her daughter to read. But his past held against him: Gladstone told Lord Acton that his Poems and Ballads were so “bad and horrible” that they removed him from consideration.
In the first few days after Tennyson’s death, however, the Prime Minister seems seriously to have considered Swinburne. He agreed with prevailing literary opinion that this was the man best qualified, and one can imagine that he re-read his poems. On October 10th, he wrote to the Queen that he was “most sensible of the difficulties attending the new appointment... where one man so greatly excels in power, and seems to be barred by other causes. Mr. Gladstone will take special care to submit to Your Majesty no hasty recommendation.” But three days later he wrote to the Queen that Swinburne would not do, without being specific about his reasons.
“Mr. Gladstone deeply regrets the gravity of the cause which seems to disqualify Mr. Swinburne for the office.” A week later he amplified his remarks in a letter to the Queen’s secretary, Sir Henry Ponsonby. “On account of Swinburne’s pre-eminence as a poet, I have been making a very careful examination of his case. I fear he is absolutely impossible... It is a sad pity; I have always been deeply impressed by his genius.”
At the same time he was examining Swinburne and deciding against him, Gladstone was turning his gaze in an unexpected, rather strange direction—toward the surviving master of Victorian prose, John Ruskin. Although Ruskin had written verse—enough to make up a sizeable volume in his Collected Works—he was celebrated as a critic of art and society; not even his warmest admirers would have put him forward as a poet. But he had received scant recognition from the State.
Arthur Acland, a member of Gladstone’s Cabinet, had attempted previously, but without success, to obtain a knighthood for him, as the great man believed himself neglected. Gladstone, too, was an admirer of his, in spite of their political differences; perhaps he felt that now he might make amends for the long official neglect. There was the difficulty, however, that Ruskin suffered from “brain fever.”
Spencer Lyttelton, one of Gladstone’s secretaries, thought the very idea itself was mad, because Ruskin was “seventy-three, nearly out of his mind, and never wrote a poem anyone ever read.” But the Prime Minister was undaunted; he had inquiries made about Ruskin’s health, and even broached the name to the Queen. In the letter of October 13th in which he finally dismissed Swinburne from consideration, he pointed out that Ruskin “has published a volume of poems” and would “have been considered by Lord Tennyson as being, like and still more than Carlyle, a poet in prose.”
Increasingly taken with the notion, and apparently undisturbed by the prospect of a Poet-in-prose Laureate, Gladstone touted it about in letters to his friends. But the reports of Ruskin’s health were discouraging; the painter Burne-Jones told Gladstone flatly that any work or excitement brought on a recurrence of his madness. There was no choice but to abandon the notion.
The only other poet Gladstone seems to have considered at all seriously was William Watson. In 1892 he was thirty-four, and had gained a certain measure of prominence with poems on Wordsworth and Shelley, consciously written in the manner of those masters. Then, in a period of fifty hours, “not stopping for food or rest,” he produced an elegy on the death of Tennyson, “Lacrymae Musarum,” which impressed a large number of readers, among them the Queen and her Prime Minister. For a moment Watson became a serious canditate. But Gladstone was obsessed by the Tennysonian precedent: Watson was too young; one poem, no matter how fine, was not a major body of work. The problem seemed insoluble.
There was one poet, meanwhile, who believed the solution to be himself: he, Lewis Morris, the perfect man for Gladstone to appoint. Born in 1833, he was a voluminous poet, and had turned out poem after poem of minimal merit on every conceivable topic.
He was also an amateur politician, active for the Liberal cause in his native Wales, who had run three times for Parliament, although never successfully. In 1886, when so many in the political world had turned away from Gladstone because of his dedication to Home Rule, Morris had remained doggedly loyal. If Gladstone had regarded the Laureateship as a plum, to be offered to the poet politically closest to him, he could scarcely have done better than Lewis Morris. But he was aiming higher, indeed as high as possible; at no time was Morris under consideration.
Morris, however, for years had been regarding himself as a candidate, and in certain quarters his claim seems to have been taken seriously. The question of who would be the next Poet Laureate had arisen as early as 1888, when Tennyson had suffered a very serious illness. That year, an anonymous article, “Tennyson: and After?” appeared in the Fortnightly Review, which may well have been written by its editor, Frank Harris. Although the article surveyed the field in general, and pointed out the lack of any obvious candidate, it was devoted mostly to a biting attack on Morris, whom the writer must have considered a very serious contender:
“Mr. Lewis Morris’s works are collected in a volume carefully got up to resemble the ‘ Globe ’ edition of Lord Tennyson. Mr. Lewis Morris has celebrated of late years everything that ought to be celebrated: Jubilee, Armada tercentenary, the Queen’s visit to Wales, and Lord Tennyson’s birthday. His opinions are always and eminently respectable; his verse not infrequently so. His view of things in general is precisely that which is dear to the half-educated middle classes, a facile optimism garnished with cheap philosophical phrases, and using the most awful names and ideas of religions as the counters of sentimental platitude... Pretentious and factitious mediocrity; that is all we can find in Mr. Lewis Morris at his best.”
Poor Morris! In spite of his political loyalty and poetical facility, Gladstone did not appoint him to the office. In 1895 he received a knighthood, but that was merely a consolation prize.
While Morris believed himself to be the ideal candidate, there were numerous other lady and gentlemen poets writing in 1892 from among whom the Prime Minister might have chosen, if he had not set so exalted a standard. Gladstone himself was aware of this. A few years later, perhaps reflecting on the numbers of poets and poems thrust upon him while he had the post to bestow, he wrote:
“My experience leads me to believe that the supply of poetry, or verse assuming to be poetry, is more egregiously in excess of the demand than any other description of literature.”
Early in 1892, the Fortnightly—as though to limit the field and to make things simpler when the need should arise—had published a list of poets of distinction then writing, apart from the Laureate, and arrived at a total of seventy-two. But none of these, ranging from Swinburne down, was acceptable to Gladstone. As the Critic remarked in November 1892, “No name stands out: no one writer of verse is clearly designated as his [Tennyson’s] successor in the vacant official post.”
Fearful that if he appointed one of the seventy-two he would expose the office to “sarcasm and ridicule,” Gladstone at this point turned for advice to his friend Benjamin Jowett, the Master of Balliol College. “Don’t fill it up,” said Jowett. For the present, he suggested, let the post remain unoccupied. “Nobody expects it to be filled up.”
Since no one of Tennyson’s stature was available or suitable, better to wait until such a one arose from the ranks of young poets who had yet to prove themselves. This was a recommendation Gladstone was relieved to accept. “Well,” he said, “I shall be in no hurry.” Some years later, in 1897, when Jowett’s biography was published and this advice was made known, Lewis Morris reacted with fury: it was his opinion that Gladstone had neglected a “plain and obvious duty.”
Jowett had crystallized the Prime Minister’s view that no action need be taken. On November 4th he communicated his decision to the Queen. Two days later, James Bryce, a member of the Cabinet and at the time the Minister-in-attendance at Balmoral, prepared a memorandum for the Queen on the vexing subject. He followed Gladstone’s line—the grandeur of the office, the insignificance of the available candidates—but argued strongly against abolition.
“It would be a great misfortune if a post of much antiquity and dignity, adorned by not a few illustrious holders, should be suffered to expire. Great Britain is now the only country in Europe where this national recognition of poetry as the highest expression of national thought and national literary art has been preserved in an office, whose very title recalls the immortal names of Petrarch and Tasso.”
Gladstone had informed the Queen that he would continue to “weigh and sift the subject.” Bryce concluded with an assurance that soon some poet would arise who would be “evidently right” and “conspicuously worthy.” No more was heard of the problem during Gladstone’s administration.
In March 1894, Gladstone, growing deaf, blind, and dissatisfied with his colleagues in the Cabinet, resigned his office. He was succeeded as Prime Minister by Lord Rosebery. Rosebery, as a young man, is reputed to have said that his ambitions were to marry the richest woman in England, to win the Derby, and to become Prime Minister; and ultimately he achieved all three.
But it would be false to infer from this that he was a man of unswerving purpose who knew what he wanted and went after it. In fact, Rosebery’s character was marked by a kind of aristocratic indecisiveness, an inability or unwillingness to make up his mind, which gave his administration a notably inconclusive air, and which boded ill for all those poets who were waiting for one among them to be singled out.
Rosebery was a man of letters, widely read, himself the author of several books. He might be thought to have welcomed the chance to exercise his discrimination, and ultimately to dispose of the bays. But again the inference is misleading. Rosebery waited, and the public grew impatient. Many an anxious letter was written to The Times deploring this lapse of an English constitutional office.
Questions were asked in the House. In July 1894, D- A. Thomas, perhaps in the interest of his fellow Welshman, Lewis Morris, asked the Liberal leader in the House of Commons, Sir William Harcourt, to explain the delay and to indicate when the post would be filled. Harcourt answered: “This is a delicate question, and, amidst conflicting claims I must shelter myself in the decency of the learned language, and I would reply, ‘Poet a nascitur, non fit’ ...My honourable friend must remember what happened to the shepherd Paris when he had to award the apple, and the misfortunes which befell him and his partners.”
Harcourt’s lumbering attempt at comedy was seized upon by Punch. Its next number contained a full-page cartoon of the Prime Minister, dressed as Paris, refusing the apple to three leading middle-grade contenders, Lewis Morris as Juno, Sir Edwin Arnold as Venus, and Alfred Austin as Minerva.
While Rosebery remained silent, the poets themselves continued to agitate. In April 1895 the Idler solicited the opinions of twenty-one literary figures, mostly poets, as to who should be named Laureate. The majority proposed Swinburne. Oscar Wilde’s statement was characteristic:
“Mr. Swinburne is already the Poet Laureate of England. The fact that his appointment to this high post has not been degraded by official confirmation renders his position all the more unassailable. He whom all poets love is the Laureate Poet always.”
Characteristic also, and noticeably less reverent, was the statement of Bernard Shaw:
“I have hitherto formed no opinion as to the fittest person to be made Laureate, as it is no part of my business to keep a registry office to provide the court with servants, or its literary retainers with situations. However, I have no objections to consider the point for a moment, since my opinion is invited. In this country the word poet means a person who writes rhymes, no distinction being made between Homer or Shelley and the gentlemen who write commercial odes to tooth-powder and pens.
He may therefore be a person of infinitely greater dignity than a king; or he may be the sort of middle-class snob who is moved to sincere emotion, and consequently to poetic utterance, by pictures of royal weddings in the Illustrated London News, and photographs of princesses bending over the cradles of their babies; or he may be a mere handy rhymester, who will do anything he is paid for, from a penny valentine to a five act drama.
The quality of the supply varying thus widely, it is, I presume, the business of the court to get the best sort of poet its terms can command, those terms being, not a money payment but the privilege of putting up the title ‘ Poet Laureate ’ over the shop... There is, of course, always the alternative of getting the work done by a contractor, though as a Collectivist, I prefer direct employment of labor by public bodies wherever possible.”
One contributor to the Idler's symposium, Sir Edwin Arnold, suggested that the Laureate should be “The Man whom Her Majesty chooses.” Sir Edwin was not taking any chances; he was convinced that Her Majesty intended to choose him, and he did not mean to jeopardize his future by praising a rival. He believed erroneously that the Queen had wished to appoint him earlier, but that Gladstone had demurred.
Now that there was a new Prime Minister, closer to him in his views—Rosebery was attempting to lead his party from a policy of “Little Englandism” to a greater concern with the problems of Empire—Sir Edwin felt himself the logical candidate, and, in the words of the Dictionary of National Biography, “he confidently expected the reversion.”
Born in 1832, he had spent the years 1856 to 1861 in India, as Principal of the Government Sanskrit College at Poona and Fellow of the University of Bombay. This experience developed in him a passionate interest in the East, which continued through his lifetime, and which was handsomely reciprocated: he received the Order of the White Elephant from the King of Siam, and the Imperial Order of the Medjidie, Second Class, from the Sultan of Turkey. His fluent, uninspired verse was devoted chiefly to Oriental themes. His best known and most popular book was The Light of Asia, a poem of great length whose subject was Buddhism, sympathetically presented.
Arnold was also capable of turning out verse on Occidental themes. As though to prove his fitness for the Laureateship, his 1895 volume numbered among its contents “Lines Written in the Birthday Book of H.R.H. The Duchess of York,” and “Crathie Church, Written for the Royal Bazaar at Balmoral: At the Desire of H.R.H. The Princess Beatrice.” But all this poetic activity did Sir Edwin no good. Rosebery failed to notice him. Characteristically, as in politics, so in art: Rosebery could not decide, and he was driven to remark that he would as soon appoint a Court Jester as a Poet Laureate. The post remained unfilled.
In June 1895 Rosebery resigned as Prime Minister. The Liberals were not again to hold office until December 1905. There was a disastrous General Election, and the Tories came in with the Marquess of Salisbury as Prime Minister—his nephew Arthur Balfour was leader in the House of Commons, but the nephew’s refined literary taste apparently had no influence upon the uncle.
England had now been almost three years without a Laureate, and the time was approaching when a decision must be made. Salisbury had none of Gladstone’s or Rosebery’s literary scruples to complicate the task of choosing a poet, but he detested making an appointment of any sort.
He knew he had no particular skill in judging character, and he rather disliked patronage. He once remarked about the necessity of appointing new Bishops, “I declare they die to spite me.” About poetry he knew very little, and cared less. But Princess Maud of Wales and Prince Charles of Denmark were about to be married; it would be nice to have a Laureate to celebrate the event.
Salisbury included among his friends one poet, Alfred Austin, whose name had always been linked in public speculation with Lewis Morris’s and Edwin Arnold’s as the third second-rate possibility. Of an age with the other two, he was born in 1835, and had written many volumes of verse, as well as some inspirational books about his garden. The qualities of his verse are better demonstrated than described, as in the opening stanza of “Mother Song”—
White little hands!
Pink little feet!
Dimpled all over,
Sweet, sweet, sweet!
What dost thou wail for?
The unknown? the unseen?
The ills that are coming,
The joys that have been?
This, it may be argued, represents Austin at his worst; unhappily, at his best he is only slightly better.
Like Lewis Morris he was capable of composition on almost any topic; like him also he was unswerving in his political loyalties. He was a consistent, almost a fanatic supporter of the Tory party, particularly in the pages of the National Review, the journal he founded and edited. Unlike Morris, he was to be rewarded for his loyalty in the manner he felt he deserved.
At the end of December, Salisbury offered the post to Austin. On January 1st, 1896, it was announced in the New Year’s Honours. The issue that had vexed the literary and political world for three years and three months was now resolved. Gladstone, looking for a Laureate, had aimed high; Rosebery had aimed, but one cannot be certain where; Salisbury unquestionably had aimed low. The appointment was greeted with a chorus of jeers and laughter that continued for the seventeen years of Austin’s Laureateship.
Those inveterate candidates for the post, Sir Lewis Morris and Sir Edwin Arnold, now that it had been bestowed elsewhere, responded in characteristic fashion. Morris said of the appointment that it had put the clock of poetry back eighty years, but at least the only official recognition of poetry by the State had not been suppressed.
Arnold sent the new Laureate a telegram: “Accept my heartiest congratulations with which no grudge mingles, although I myself expected the appointment.” Austin remarked in his Autobiography, “I would rather be the man who would send such a telegram in such circumstances, than be incapable of sending it, yet have written the greatest of poems.”
As for Salisbury, when asked to justify himself—although it is hard to believe that he would bother—he is alleged to have said that he gave the post to Austin “for the best possible reason, because he wanted it.” Or, in other versions, because “he would enjoy it,” or “because no one else asked for it.”

