Great Lovers, Leaders, Statesmen

Simon Sebag Montefiore imagines dinner with Catherine the Great, Prince Potemkin and Stalin.

During the hot summer of 1934, while Josef Stalin was holidaying at his mansion in Sochi by the Black Sea, he ruminated on Russia’s great statesmen as he designed a historical textbook to educate a new Soviet generation. When it came to Catherine the Great, he held up a finger and declared: ‘What was the genius of Catherine the Great? Her greatness lay in the choice of Prince Potemkin and other such talented officials to run the State.’ Yet Stalin did not promote Catherine and Potemkin in his textbook. They were too aristocratic and enlightened for his vision of the Russian State: he preferred the ruthless power of Ivan the Terrible and Peter the Great.

Stalin understood that Catherine and Potemkin’s noble decadence and flam­boyant style were not only diametrically different from his Bolshevik austerity but their vision of the individual and state were utterly different too.

If Stalin visited more mur­der and misery on the Rus­sian people than any other monarch since Genghis Khan, Catherine and Potem­kin were probably the most humane and generous rulers Russia has ever enjoyed. I should go further: while Stalin is a fascinating subject for the historian and I have enjoyed every moment of my research on the Red Tsar, he was also a dark, strange and terrible man. On the other hand, one could not imagine more charming, funny and delight­ful companions than Catherine and Potemkin. Their relationship, which I lived through thousands of their letters, some sexual, some amorous, some political, is not only History’s greatest romance in the tradition of Antony and Cleopatra, but it is also the most successful political partnership of all.

Yet this unlikely threesome also had some things in common, and these are revealing about the state of Russia. I have spent ten years working on the three, reading their papers and notes until sometimes I could predict their responses. So let us imagine the three of them meeting at an imag­in­ary dinner party to discuss their view of ruling Russia. Blue-eyed and handsome, Catherine II, the German-born princess who seized the Russian throne in 1762, defeated the Ottomans and annexed Poland, and ruled triumphantly until her death in 1796, sits in the middle. On one side is her best friend, secret husband, and co-ruler, the flamboyant and brilliant Prince Potemkin. On the other is Josef Stalin, General Secretary of the Communist Party and ruler of Russia from 1924 to his death in 1953.

All three were great conver­sationalists – but Catherine and Potemkin would have been appalled by Stalin’s table manners. Political brilliance, superb intelligence and enthusiastic intel­lec­tual­ism would unite them. Never boring: even their laundry lists and doodles are inter­est­ing. All three were born politicians with the natural energy and gifts for the exercise of power.
These were among the most successful Russian imp­er­ial­ists in history. Stalin self-consciously measured himself by the tsars: when congrat­ul­ated on taking Berlin in 1945, he said; ‘But Alexander I made it to Paris.’ Nonethe­less Stalin swallowed up eastern Europe; Catherine the Crimea, south Ukraine, Caucasus and Poland. They would have compared their conquests with a certain vanity: Stalin loved to survey the map, pointing at his con­quests with his pipe, saying, ‘Not bad, not bad at all’.

All three believed in state power and military might: Stalin and Potemkin were both marshals (one a Marshal of the Soviet Union who pro­moted himself to General­issimus; the other a Field-Marshal and Grand Admiral); both oversaw expansions in their armies; Potemkin created the Black Sea Fleet, Stalin ordered the creation of a powerful new fleet after 1945. While neither were military geniuses, both re­gard­ed themselves as great commanders and would have happily discussed their victories.

Catherine and Potemkin believed in the expansion of the Empire as an Orthodox Christian mission; Stalin too saw the Russian state as the organ of his semi-religious mission to spread Marxism.

All three dreamed of Russian control of Istanbul and the Straits. Catherine and Stalin would have agreed on the danger of Poland: both subjugated the Poles, Catherine in three partitions, Stalin in his creation of a Stalinist satellite state. In this both adopted an ultra-Russian traditional suspicion of Poland – even though (or more likely, because) neither were Russian.

The only real Russian of the three, Grigory Potemkin, was more tolerant of an in­dep­endent Poland, respect­ing its ancient monarchy and institutions: he would have been pained by the crude violence of the third and last Partition. He longed to be king of Poland in his own right.
Catherine and Stalin would have reflected they had become the quintes­sen­tial Russian rulers when neither was remotely Russian: she was German and he was Georgian yet both became more Russian than the Russians. Catherine, as the wife of the hated Prussophile Emperor Peter III, became the ‘Russian’ candidate for the throne. She loved Russia and became, with Peter the Great, the most successful Russian ruler. Stalin in his turn rejected the inter­nation­alism of Marxism with his ‘Socialism in One Country’. He promoted Russians and persecuted Poles and Jews. They would have laughed at dinner for both spoke Russian with a thick foreign accent that they never lost.

Potemkin would have shared in this amusement for he was a child of the Russian-Polish borderlands, while Stalin hailed from the Rus­sian empire’s borderlands with the Persian and Otto­man empires.

While Catherine enjoyed the education of minor Ger­man royalty, both Potemkin and Stalin had semi-religious educations. While Stalin trained as a priest and only missed his final exams, Potemkin was an expert on Orthodox theology and longed to become a priest. Stalin talked about priests and the Church all his life; Potemkin’s hobby was religion; Stalin used religious imagery and catechismic lan­guage to promote Marxism; Potemkin used the same methods to consolidate his vision of the Russian state. While Catherine, a creature of the Enlightenment, was uninterested in religion, Stalin and Potemkin probably would have sung Orthodox hymns together after dinner.

All three were intellectuals who spent much of their free time reading: each left great libraries of books in Russian, English and French. If one takes all the Russian leaders from Peter the Great to Putin today, the best read were undoubtedly Catherine the Great and Stalin.

Both ruled in a personal way, usually by writing notes to their subordinates, often as marginalia on letters. But they each appreciated the challenge of ruling vast Russia. The imperial lovers were convinced that auto­cracy was the only way to lead Russia; Stalin was convinced that only the Dictatorship of the Proletariat in his own person could achieve Russian greatness and the victory of international Marxism. They would ironically have agreed on tsardom too: Stalin said that ‘the Russian people need a tsar’ and used the imagery of a Red Tsar.

All three reflected how hard it was to get Russians to obey their orders. Catherine said that while she was the autocrat, in practice her ‘auto­cracy’ meant consulting her subjects, getting them to agree to her proposals and only then ordering them to obey her. In old age, Stalin mused that, after all his Terrors, the provinces still ignored his orders whenever they could.
So far during our imagin­ary dinner, the three have agreed on many things. While Catherine would not have enjoyed Stalin’s menu of Georgian dishes, Potemkin, who adored peasant and exotic spicy foods, would have loved it. Though the eighteenth-century couple often drank French or Hungarian Tokai wines, they would have hap­pily quaffed Stalin’s Georgian wines too.

They might even have admired a few examples of mutual ruthlessness: Stalin would have appreciated Cath­erine’s overthrow of her inept husband in 1762. He would have gleefully understood that the fallen Emperor had to be killed – even though Catherine knew history would never forgive her. She was ruthless also with the other pretenders to her throne. Stalin under­stood: he had cheerfully advised Tito to res­tore King Peter of Yugoslavia ‘because you could always stick a dagger in his back later’.

Yet now the dinner party would begin to fall apart: Stalin would have been amazed by the generosity of spirit shown by Catherine and Potemkin who repeatedly forgave plots against them­selves that would have pro­voked savage reprisals from the Georgian tyrant.

Catherine and Potemkin would have been disgusted by the random bloodletting even of the early days of Lenin’s rule. They would have been appalled by the des­truction of the class sys­tem itself. They were be­lievers in nobility yet they were flexible and merito­cratic: both constantly pro­moted talented individuals without back-grounds. Yet unlike Stalin, they believed in the individual and gloried in eccentricity and flamboyance: they were children of the Enlightenment who longed to improve the lot of their citizens. Stalin disdained such ideas as bourgeois indul­gences: he was a fanatical believer in dialectical mater­ialism, the progressive march of history towards a Utopia, whatever the human cost.

 Catherine and Potemkin loathed the French Revol­ution. Indeed the only real repression in their joint reign took place as a reaction to it. Potemkin died before the height of the Jacobin Terror, but Catherine regarded Robespierre as akin to the devil on earth. Stalin studied – indeed admired – the Terror, wanted to emulate it and saw himself as a Russian Robespierre.
The Empress and her Prince would have been utterly repelled by Stalin’s callous war on the peasantry, his man-made famine of 1932-33, and his obsessional vindictive slaughter of the Great Terror of 1937. This would have been beyond their compre­hension.

Stalin on the other hand would have praised the giant peasant rebellion of Puga­chev of 1773-74 that he would have regarded as a precursor to Bolshevism. It almost brought down Catherine but with Potemkin’s help, she suppressed it. When it came to Pugachev’s execution, she insisted it be done mercifully. Stalin would have mocked her mercy.

The Prince and the Emp­ress were not always success­ful but their intentions were as decent and humane as those of any Russian ruler up to the present. So by this point of the dinner, the atmos­phere would have turned nasty – and probably rather personal. Stalin would have de­nounced the extravagance of the imperial couple as a vivid illustration of the corruption of monarchy and aristocracy: both Catherine and Potem­kin built many palaces. Yet Stalin may have found more in common with them than one might expect – he had at least twenty mansions con­stantly ready for his use and some he never even visited.

When it came to the sex life of Catherine and Potemkin, Stalin would have sniggered drunkenly with his priapic-sadist henchman Beria, but been embarrassed by their brazen debauchery and amazed at their libertinism.

Stalin was promis­cuous as a young man when he was surprisingly good-looking. Yet after the death of his first wife in 1907 and the suicide of his second in 1932, he became highly suspicious of political women firstly, sexually confident women secondly and intelligent women thirdly. He regarded women as potential spies, security hazards that he could not afford. He became jea­lous of the happy marriages of his henchmen. So he would have been bewildered by Catherine and Potemkin: they were both uninhibited, earthy and sensual. Potem­kin was wildly promiscuous; Catherine, no nymphomaniac in fact, had only twelve lovers that we know about but she was a serial monogamist who was usually in love with her favourite of the moment. But Catherine and Potemkin fell passionately in love; they shared power and probably married in a secret ceremony. When their affair threatened to consume them both, they evolved a unique open mar­riage in which she enjoyed a series of young male lovers and he a string of beautiful mistresses. Yet they never stopped loving each other and remained husband and wife and partners in power – co-rulers of Russia until Potemkin’s death in 1791. Stalin would have been shocked by the sexual licence, threatened by Catherine’s intelligence, and above all amazed at their mutual trust. He found he could never trust anyone.

So if at the start of the occasion, the three might have believed they shared many things in the state of Russia, by the end of the evening, they would have been mortal enemies. Dinner would not have ended well.

Simon Sebag Montefiore
 
Young Stalin by Simon Sebag Montefiore is newly published by Weidenfeld & Nicolson. Both Catherine the Great & Potemkin and Stalin:The Court of the Red Tsar are published by Phoenix in paperback.