The French Police in the 19th Century

The framework for the police of nineteenth century France, argues Clive Emsley, emerged out of the reorganisation of the Revolution and the reforms of Napoleon.

In 1896 Ré Waldock-Rousseau, a successful barrister and future President of the Third Republic, wrote an introduction to a book on the Paris Police. 'Ils veillent pour que nous travaillions ' – 'they watch so that we may work' – he declared. The same sentiments might be expressed about the English police of the period, especially by an historian or politician, or anyone else who, wittingly or not, perceives them in the same way as the police historian Sir Charles Reith – the thin blue line which saved society from 'uncontrollable crime and mob violence.' Yet even though men looked across the English Channel in both directions for ideas during the nineteenth century, the structure of the French and English police forces developed in vastly different ways.

While it is possible to locate the origins of the French police in the Middle Ages, or even earlier, the framework for the police of nineteenth-century France emerged out of the reorganisations of the Revolution and Napoleon. A large police bureaucracy was established for Paris under the Prefect of Police. From his headquarters in the Rue Jerusalem, the Imperial Prefect's central administration of some one hundred and fifty men supervised everything from crime to the supply of markets, and from fires to passports. From a separate office at 6, Petite Rue Sainte-Anne, Francois Vidocq, a former convict and police informer directed a criminal investigation division principally composed of former convicts like himself. When the office was established in 1811 Vidocq had four subordinates; at the time of his first resignation in 1827 there were twenty-eight. Each of the forty-eight quartiers of the city was supervised by a commissaire de police responsible to the Prefect, but with a considerable degree of autonomy in his district. In addition, there were a dozen officiers de paix patrolling the city and some one hundred and fifty inspecteurs who were often drawn from the ranks of police spies and informers – the supposedly ubiquitous mouchards .

Other urban areas were less well policed. The larger towns had commissaires appointed by the Minister of the Interior from a list presented by the departmental Prefect. Even though he was appointed by the central government the commissaire was paid by the locality in which he served, and careful selection did not always secure the best of men: Louis Rouaix was removed from Massat (Ariêtres chosen by the local administration from ex-soldiers. The roads of provincial France were patrolled by the gendarmerie , a military body responsible to the Minister of War and split up into brigades of five or six men; though sometimes brutal and often unpopular the gendarmes provided a consistent, if sparse, police supervision of the whole country.

The literate, urban public of France during the Restoration and the July Monarchy were fascinated by crime and les classes dangereuses – the phrase coined by H.A. Fregier during these years. Yet few argued strongly for reforms in the system of police as a means of checking the criminal and/or dangerous classes. One of the most popular novels of the 1840s, Eugères de Paris , suggested in its opening paragraphs that the police had criminal elements well under control:

A tapis-franc, in the slang of the murderers and thieves of Paris, means a smoking-house or inn of the very lowest class... liberated galley-slaves, tricksters, robbers, and assassins congregate there. If a crime has been committed, the police casts its net in this receptacle of filth, and almost always the guilty one is caught.

Bras Rouge, a tavern keeper involved in so much of the villainy in the novel, turns out to be a police informer. Vidocq himself was transformed into the terrifying Vautrin and appears in several volumes of Balzac's Comédie humaine . Some men had their suspicions about the practice of setting thieves to catch thieves, even though the system appeared efficient, but the principal concern expressed about the police was their political involvement, Louis Canler, a veteran of Napoleon's armies, joined the Paris police in 1B20; in his memoirs he looked back on the Restoration period as a time when 'the money authorised for municipal policing and detective work was largely swallowed up by the expenses of the numerous political agents'. The liberal critic of the July Monarchy of Louis Phillipe, Leon Faucher, visited England in the early 1840s. He praised the new Metropolitan Police of London for not spending their time pursuing liberals like himself, but as to the overall organisation of London policing, he could assert with Gallic pride that it was following the French lead. The Metropolitan Police were part of 'the spirit of centralisation' which was a 'recent import and purely French.'

The one significant change to French policing before the Revolution of 1848 was the creation of the sergents de ville in Paris in I829, coincidentally the same year as the Metropolitan Police took to the streets of London. The sergents , recruited largely from old soldiers, were established as part of an attempt by the then Prefect of Police, Louis Debelleyme, to restore confidence in the police which had recently appeared to be an agent of political repression. The sergents were the first civil police in the city to wear a uniform; this was introduced to indicate to the citizen where he could turn for help, to emphasise the ever-present surveillance of the Prefect, and also to ensure that the policeman himself did not shirk his duty and disappear when trouble threatened or when he fancied a drink. But while the Metropolitan Police were established at over three thousand strong, there were under a hundred sergents in Paris in 1829 and by the end of the July Monarchy in 1848 there were still less than 350 of them.

The Revolution of 1848 saw a remarkable experiment in the policing of Paris. The agents of Louis-Philippe's last Prefect, and the Prefect himself, disappeared from the streets and their offices while Marc Caussidiétat in December 1851.

Major reforms came in the early 1850s. Again the most significant change was in Paris where, in 1854, Napoleon III had the police increased and reorganised along the lines of London's Metropolitan Police. Observers throughout Europe and the United States were impressed by the London force, particularly by the way in which it had handled the crowds flocking to the Great Exhibition of 1851. Napoleon III was planning his own Exhibition. Furthermore the creation of a large, patrolling, preventive police, accountable and identifiable like the Metropolitan Police with numbers publicly displayed on their collars, was one way for the Emperor to show to the property owners of Paris that he cared for their security and their rights.

Some provincial commissaires had acquired more responsibility during the Second Republic. When Prefects distrusted the political reliability of some Mayors, they turned to the commissaire for information, and occasionally gave him powers to act outside the district to which he was appointed. Thus, by the time of the 1851 coup d'état the number of provincial commissaires was almost doubled from 1,000 to 1,745; others were appointed to supervise the railways and the frontiers. Better pay and better conditions were offered in an attempt to attract better men, since in the words of commissaire David of Lyon, writing in 1850, some of his fellows sought 'to hide their incompetence behind a mask of pride mixed with self-importance and pedantry' while others were 'coarse louts who only seemed to have studied the language of the market (les halles )'. While these reforms may have had a beneficial effect, complaints about certain commissaires suggest that the change was not as great as may have been hoped.

The turbulent city of Lyons, scene of the great workers' risings of 1831 and 1834, was given a police force on Parisian lines, but the rank and file policemen in other urban areas remained the responsibility of their municipality. No other state police system was established in a city until 1908 when Marseilles got a police force modelled on Lyons'. There were proposals to reform the gardes champêtres and even to brigade them like the gendarmerie , but these came to nothing. Indeed it is remarkable that the Second Empire, which has been described as a police state and which is generally regarded as having been much more centralised than its island neighbour, never established a central inspectorate of police like the British government and, probably for fear of alienating support from the regime, often permitted localities, who did not wish to pay for new commissaires , to block their appointments. This situation continued, indeed worsened, under the Third Republic; in 1906 when, by law there should have been 1,005 commissaires in the provincial towns of more than 5,000 inhabitants, there were only 664.

Attempts during the Second Empire to bring the police under tighter state supervision left a legacy of suspicion that equated a unitary police system with tyranny. Napoleon III experimented with several methods of supervising his 'police state'; first, like his uncle Napoleon Bonaparte, with a Minister of Police. This Ministry was disbanded in 1853 having created considerable interdepartmental friction. Eventually, in 1859, the Paris Prefect of Police was given overall supervision of national police policy. The dé , until Georges Clemenceau took up its cause in the decade before the First World War, was that he remained a General without an army.

Reformed or not, the kind of men attracted to the different police corps remained largely the same throughout the nineteenth century. The gendarmerie , responsible to the Minister of War, were regular soldiers; many of the rank and file appear to have volunteered for the corps as a way of returning to their department of origin and continuing their chosen military profession. The gendarme 's life may have been hard, he may have been unpopular with many in the community where he served; yet the life of most peasants was probably much harder. Former soldiers predominated among the sergents de ville ; after 1870 they were known as gardiens de la paix publique , but as Waldeck-Rousseau noted in the preface quoted above, they continued to be 'chosen in the ranks of the army from among the best and most irreproachable.' The commissaires also were often former soldiers – Jean-Baptiste Perrot was born in 1797, fought at Waterloo, rose to the rank of Captain leaving the army in 1843 and serving as a commissaire until his death in 1868; Gaston de Fourlet, born in 1840, was appointed as one of the commissaires speciales on the railways in I870: in his application he emphasised both his own military service and the military tradition of his family. Eight out of thirteen commissaires serving in Ariege and six out of nine in Vendee between 1800 and 1830 for whom we have dossiers, had served in some military capacity. Forty out of the sixty-nine men who served as commissaires in Var under the Second Empire were former soldiers.

In France the divisions under the term 'police' are more fully elaborated than in England. La police administrative deals with 'preventative' police actions, while la police judiciare deals with 'repressive' activities. Since 'repression' involves the amassing of evidence and the prosecution of law breakers, some of the personnel of la police judiciare would be more readily categorised in England as members of the legal profession. But administrative policing covers a wide area, including la police municipale , which broadly covers the day-to-day supervision of traffic flow, the prevention of crime and street nuisance, and la police géral . The latter is a wide category by which the government and its agents preserve the security of the state.

Nineteenth-century governments believed that the maintenance of the security of the state enabled them to take measures of 'legitimate defence'. Sergents de ville and later gardiens de la paix publique were principally concerned with municipal policing, though of course, events could often involve them with judicial policing. Their instructions read much like those given to the Metropolitan Police of London. The gardes champêtres had similar concerns; but their dependence on the local notables of the municipality who appointed them, led often to a very partisan administration of justice. The commissaire 's role was less clear cut. Was his first responsibility to the community in which he lived, and which paid his salary, or was his prime responsibility to the State which appointed him? The bulk of the advice proffered under government auspices, especially during the Second Empire when a Journal des Commissaires de Police was begun, emphasised that while he should never antagonise the community, and always behave in a responsible and impartial manner, the commissaire 's first responsibility was to the state. 'Never, absolutely never, have a confidence in the locality... because of what he is, the commissaire of police has no real friends. For honourable though he may be, the very nature of our public office engenders distrust.' Individual commissaires responded to this advice in different ways, but the pay, even after the reforms of the 1850s, was never good enough to attract sufficient of those paragons whom different regimes sought for the post.

Circumstances probably made the commissaire more the agent of an alien state than he may have wished, however. The variety of local patois made it quite likely that, on his appointment at least, the commissaire would have difficulty in conversing with the local population. In 1846 the novelist Gustave Flaubert, touring Brittany, found at least one commissaire who had to use a gamekeeper as an interpreter. Thirty years later a commissaire in Gers conceded, 'It's true that I have great difficulty in understanding the local speech.' Gendarmes could have the same problem – one reason why the gendarme serving in his native district was so valuable. Local men, however, could present other difficulties. When peasant columns assembled in southern France to oppose the coup d'érale of Aix complained that the gens du pays among the gendarmerie of Basses-Alpes had remained 'inactive'. Reports of this type, however, were rare and in general the gendarmes could be relied upon to do their duty.

Mid-nineteenth century reformers of the French police looked to London for their model; at the same time, it was possible for them to argue that this model owed something to the idea of centralisation as practised in France. However centralisation, particularly in the aftermath of Napoleon III's 'police state', was something that many Frenchmen were as wary of as were many nineteenth-century Englishmen. Some of the police reformers in England hoped for a more centralised system than that which emerged and Sir Edwin Chadwick, the principal architect of the Royal Commission Report on a Constabulary Force, leaned heavily on the French legal codes in his work on preventive policing. But Chadwick was cautious enough to leave references to France out of the Royal Commission's report of 1839. Tories of the old school were united with Chartists and Radicals in abhorring the military style gendarmerie and the political nature of policing in France. The English government was equally squeamish, especially when, during the late 1850s and early 1860s, Chief Constables began proposing military training so that their policemen could be used as an auxiliary force to support the army in case of invasion. What the bulk of rank and file English policemen, a significant number of whom had served in the army or possibly in the paramilitary Royal Irish Constabulary, believed about militarisation is impossible to assess, but, after the first Fenian outrages of 1867, a correspondence began in the Police Service Advertiser urging that the English police be armed. Most of the policemen who wrote advocating such a move pointed to the Royal Irish Constabulary; but one policeman at least, perhaps as one professional admiring another group of professionals singled out the French gendarmerie .

It was established in 1791 and from that time to the present it has been maintained alike by Monarchical and Republican Governments. The fact alone speaks powerful in its favour; for if the members of that force were the instruments of oppression under a Monarchical Government, surely a Republican would, on coming to power, disband the whole force at once. Instead, however, of its being considered dangerous to the liberty of the people, the force has the confidence alike of the government and of the people. Here again is another exemplification that an armed police is not a dangerous one.

Public confidence in the nineteenth- century French police varied among different social groups, and with different occasions; it had little to do with either armament or the military nature of the police. Few objected when the police arrested an individual who was universally condemned as a 'criminal' – a brutal murderer or a child molester. But liberals and radicals cared little for policemen when they found themselves the objects of la police géral ; and while peasant folktales often concluded with evil brigands being decapitated or burned alive by gendarmes , the gendarme and the commissaire continued to be viewed with suspicion by peasants as representatives of an alien, interfering power.

Notes on Further Reading

Patricia O'Brien, 'The Revolutionary Police of 1848' in Roger Price (Editor) Revolution and Reaction: 1848 and the Second French Republic , (Croom Helm, London, 1975); Howard C. Payne, The Police State of Louis Napoleon Bonaparte 1851-1860 (University of Washington Press, Seattle, 1966); Philip John Stead, The Police of Paris (Staples Press, London, 1957). 

  • Clive Emsley is a lecturer in history at the Open University. His Policing and its Context: Comparisons and Parallels, 1750-1870 will be published shortly by Macmillan.