“Although the Vatican Council was convoked to deal with issues of widest import, the errors and calamities of the times, the matter with which in fact it principally dealt was the Papacy; and the outcome of the Council was the settlement of long-standing controversies concerning the position and authority of the Pope in the Church.”
In this opening sentence of his great study of the First Vatican Council, Dom Cuthbert Butler points squarely to the issue dominant in the mind of the 760 or so Fathers of the Roman Church assembled in the Basilica of St. Peter’s during the fateful months of 1869-70.
From every standpoint, human or ghostly, whether one studies the history of the Council as a piece of plain historical narrative, or as the guided manifestation of the Holy Spirit working out a necessary “development of dogma” within the Church Militant, it is essential to bear this fact in mind.
The Vatican Council was primarily concerned with the definition of the Pope’s infallibility. Everything done, said or argued, every theological passion aroused or suppressed, hinged on what Dr. Ullathorne of Birmingham, that indefatigable letter-writer and most trustworthy of witnesses, termed “the question.”
Every subject debated—the rights and duties of bishops, the condemnation of liberalism and rationalism, the reform of the breviary, the revision of the catechism, the relation between Church and State—gave place to this overriding question.
To the minority of bishops who opposed the definition, the infallibility doctrine was a nightmare, threatening ruin to the souls of many and constituting a powerful hindrance to would-be converts among the Church’s “separated brethren.”
To the majority of the Fathers—above all, to Pius IX himself—infallibility was the seal and crown of the Council, an article of faith which, so Manning falsely prophesied, would “bring Protestants crowding into the Church.” The rival tensions, the truncated debates, the general lopsidedness of the Council’s agenda, can only, in the type of factual account aimed at here, be ascribed to this all-important cause—glorious to some, baleful to others.
Early in December 1864, two days before the controversial Syllabus of Errors was published, Pio Nono summoned the cardinals resident in Rome to discuss an idea that he had long had in mind. He wished, he told them, to hold an oecumenical council—the first since Trent; he asked each of them to declare their minds in writing. Of the twenty-one replies, two were against, half-a-dozen doubtful and the remainder in favour, and the Pope accordingly set up a council of four cardinals to deal with the project.
Catholic sovereigns, it was decided, should not be consulted beforehand, but the Holy See, as at the Council of Trent, “should do what was proper in their regard.” Thirty-four representative bishops were asked for their confidential opinions, and instructed to submit summaries of a possible agenda. Among them were two men who were to dominate the Council and earn themselves a common nickname as the “chief whips” of the opposing factions.
Felix Dupanloup (1802-1878), Bishop of Orleans since 1849, could fairly claim to be the most eminent French churchman of the nineteenth century. A Savoyard, born of a peasant girl who had been seduced by a tailor, he became in the words of the late Philip Spencer, “one of the noisiest, most active, most influential and hated of all the bishops in the Catholic world
...He seemed to have discovered the secret of perpetual motion. With his tall figure, big head, aquiline nose, piercing eyes and flushed complexion, he stood out like a great sinister bird in salon, committee and pulpit. A brilliant catechist, a skilful spiritual director, a triumphant educationist, he leapt from one task to another with a vitality that astonished even his enemies.
The man was a fountain of energy. He seemed to take breath only on his rare retreats. For the rest of the time he was fighting—fighting any opponent who cared to give battle, fighting with a combative ardour that often seemed disproportionate to the cause at stake.
As a young priest, Dupanloup had received the dying Talleyrand’s quizzical submission to Mother Church; as the Director of the seminary of St. Nicholas de Chardonnet, he diagnosed Renan’s spiritual malaise as a genuine loss of faith, and advised against his entering the priesthood. When the bourgeois dévôts execrated Madame Bovary, and its author faced criminal prosecution, Dupanloup pronounced the book admirable, adding: “To realize its merit to the full you ought to have had my twenty years’ experience as a provincial confessor.”
He was the leading prelatial champion of the Liberal French Catholics, the supporter of laymen like Montalembert and Falloux who advocated the Church’s coming to terms with the existing regime in France—an attitude that had already won it great concessions in the way of education and revenue.
As such Dupanloup was anathema to the Ultramontanes—or neo-Ultramontanes as they were beginning to be called—and especially to Louis Veuillot, the rabid editor of L’Univers, personal friend of Pius IX (“Caro Veuillot!” “Trés Saint-Père!”), the founder of that ferocious school of French Catholic journalism that reached its climax in the diatribes of Claudel and the Eliminations of the pre-war Action Française.
Dupanloup was no Gallican. His loyalty to the Papacy, to its spiritual and temporal powers, and his personal reverence and affection for Pio Nono, were entirely unsuspect. He was, however, the polemical leader of what came to be known, once the Council had assembled, as the “inopportunist” party—the minority of Fathers who believed that in the disturbed state of men and governments, the time was inopportune to enforce Papal Infallibility as a formal dogma.
In this he was supported by a formidable phalanx of ecclesiastics: Cardinal Mathieu, Archbishop of Besangon; Cardinal Rauscher, Primate of Austria; Mgr. Darboy, Archbishop of Paris (later to be shot by the Communards); Hefele of Rottenburg (a great scholar and the reigning expert on previous Councils of the Church), the tough-spoken Strossmayer of Bosnia, and a number of distinguished French, German, American and Hungarian bishops, all of whom believed (all too rightly, as the event proved) that the proclamation of Papal Infallibility would do untold harm in relations with their Protestant and Eastern Orthodox neighbours.
Opposed to Dupanloup and his inopportunists was the eminently opportunist Henry Edward Manning, Archbishop of Westminster (1808-1892), the brilliant ex-Anglican Archdeacon of Chichester, who had made his submission to Rome in 1851.
Much good and not a little evil has been written of Manning. He has inevitably suffered in comparison with Newman (for whom he had little sympathy), and it is only recently that we have come to realize the tremendous work he performed in furthering the “Second Spring” of Catholicism in England.
An ascetic and an autocrat, his aims and achievements—in education, social welfare and the revival of the secular clergy—over-rode his sense of personal relations. Mgr. Capel, Dr. Errington, Father Newman, the English Province of the Society of Jesus, all felt the Archbishop’s crushing hand.
A man of an almost harshly practical and positive turn of mind, he was a fierce and devoted administrator and a firm believer in the administrative virtues of the prelatial commanding officer. Abp. David Mathew has well written of him in his Catholicism in England (1936, revised 1948) that:
The atmosphere of Harrow and Balliol, then so valuable, remained with Manning throughout his life. The milieu from which his family came was not necessarily higher than that of the young Newman: but it was much more in contact with the governing class. Government in its different forms and in all its aspects appealed to him.
He had an understanding knowledge of the modes of official action, which he turned to good account in his relations with the Vatican and Whitehall and even in the London Dock Strike. His appearance in extreme old age, that transparency of texture, that asceticism were consonant with the unrivalled public position which he gained in the last years of his life...
In 1869 Manning—the only convert-Catholic present at the Council—was a youthful sixty-one and his “texture” was not so transparent. From the first he threw himself heart and soul into the cause of the Ultramontane zelantes.
“His will,” Dom Butler records, “inflexibly pursued its objects, and his mentality was such that whatever view he held he held it with whole-hearted conviction of its truth, so that to differ from him was simply to be wrong. His great powers of organization and diplomacy found an open field at the Council.”
With Manning were associated Deschamps, the courtly Archbishop of Malines, the nominal chieftain of the Infallibilists; Cardinals Senes-trey of Ratisbon and Cullen of Dublin; and, as the opportunist ranks swelled, large numbers of Italian, Spanish and Latin American Fathers, all of them inflexible champions of Papal potestas and inerrancy in matters of faith and morals.
On the fringes of the Basilica or from their respective vantage-points, a mixed bag of interested spectators—scholars, theologians, journalists, diplomatists and politicians—followed the Council’s proceedings with a friendly, a neutral or an anxious eye.
From Augsburg, the aged and eminent Döllinger, pioneer of the new science of ecclesiastical history, thundered his objurgations in the Allgemeine Zeitung, reinforced by the grave headshakings of Lord Acton, his middle-aged disciple on-the-spot, and, in his turn, reinforcing the fears and suspicions of the Bavarian Government, voiced by its Foreign Minister, von Hohenlohe.
From his chancellery in Berlin, Bismarck declared that “in spirituals full liberty would be left to the Church; but if there should be any incursion into the civil domain, it would be resisted.” Von Beust, the Austrian Foreign Minister, himself a Protestant, gave a similar warning, while in Downing Street Mr. Gladstone perused Acton’s lengthy and foreboding communications.
Manning, who deeply distrusted Acton—“such men,” he sniffed, “are all vanity; they have the inflation of German professors and the ruthless talk of undergraduates”—was later to counteract his liberal influence through the good offices of Odo Russell, the unofficial British representative at the Vatican.
Thus, while Acton was imploring the Prime Minister to take concerted action against the Papal claims, Russell was undermining his efforts by means of soothing dispatches to the Foreign Secretary, Lord Clarendon.
With his accustomed ruthlessness, Manning obtained from the Pope—not at all loth to accommodate his favourite champion, where the object of his heart was concerned—a dispensation from the law of secrecy governing the Council’s proceedings, so that he could communicate to Russell (himself a sympathetic Protestant) everything that took place beneath the aula.
As a result, when the crucial Infallibility debate came on in May 1870, Gladstone’s proposal for a demonstration by the united European and American governments was lost in Cabinet to Clarendon’s policy of non-intervention. As Manning was to put it in his own highly loaded account, written later;
The Prime Minister, Mr. Gladstone, supported the Bavarian proposal on the grounds and by the arguments supplied to him by Acton; but Lord Clarendon, better informed by Odo Russell, exposed one by one the fallacious statements and wilful distortions of fact. Finally, after a hot discussion, Mr. Gladstone was defeated in the Cabinet, the Bavarian proposal was rejected, and the Vatican Council was left in peace to do God’s work.
All this was still in the future. At the outset no government (except that of Russia, which refused to allow its bishops to proceed to Rome) hindered the Council in any way.
It had been decided that the Dutch Jansenist bishops should be excluded, while the case of the Anglican bishops “was decided negatively, on the ground that the validity of their orders was not recognized.”
The Pope’s letter to the Orthodox Churches “unfortunately got into the press before it was presented to the Eastern Patriarchs, with the result that the Patriarch of Constantinople returned it to the Vicar Apostolic unopened.”
Protestant bodies in Germany, France and in America issued reasoned statements of the Reformation position, and of their inability to comply with Pio Nono’s exhortations. “Thus,” writes Butler, “even before the Council were dashed the hopes of many bishops, such as Dupanloup, that it might pave the way for the Reunion of Christendom.”
After much necessary delay in the preparation of agenda (aggravated by the breaking-out of the Austro-Prussian War in 1866), the Council was formally opened at a First Public Session by Pius IX on December 8th, 1869, the Feast of the Immaculate Conception. Ullathorne described the ceremony eloquently in a letter written the following day:
When all, after the protracted winding in of procession of prelates, were seated, the scene was marvellous... you cannot easily realize the effect of those two long ranges of prelates rising in eight tiers on each side, in silver copes and pure linen mitres. There were some 600 bishops besides the cardinals ranged from the two sides of the apse, ten patriarchs in advance of them, and the abbots and generals of Orders down in front of the bishops...
The royal persons, including the King of Naples [Francis II, exiled since 1861 and living in the Farnese Palace], ex-Dukes of Tuscany and Parma, Empress of Austria [Elizabeth of Bavaria, stabbed to death by an anarchist in 1898, but at that time a beautiful and unconventional young woman of 32], etc... Outside was the dense mass of the faithful, and the sound of their voices and feet was as the sound of many murmuring waters on the seashore.
At 3 o’clock [the ceremonies had begun at 7 a.m.] the Pope had retired, and the bishops were winding their slow way out to the unvesting chapels, recognitions of old friends taking place in all directions amongst them. You saw continental prelates meeting their old school companions come from remote and strange countries, and all sorts of joys, tendernesses, and congratulations.
Another English bishop, Amherst, declared that there were some 50,000 people in the Basilica that day.
Battle over the definition of the Pope’s Infallibility was quickly and critically joined over the election of the deputation on Faith. Here Manning, who rigged the election in favour of all twenty-four of his co-opportunists (including himself, Deschamps, Senestrey, the redoubtable Mgr. Pie of Poitiers and the Archbishops of Cashel and Saragossa), played a notable and decisive part in the creation of the Council’s major dogma. Dom Butler writes severely:
After going through the proceedings of the entire Council, I have to say that this appears to me as the one serious blot on its doings. It was surely an error of judgement not to accord to a considerable and influential minority, counting among its members a number of the foremost and most justly respected bishops of the Church, some representation, some vehicle for the expression of its views on this committee.
The practical effect was that the Minority became an Opposition, exasperated by the sense that the Majority was bent on overwhelming it by mere force of numbers, without giving it a fair hearing.
Butler adds that this was far from being the Pope’s own intention, and that Pius had expressly named Dupanloup as a member he would have wished to see on the committee. As for Manning, he gloried in what he and his supporters had achieved, declaring tersely that “heretics come to a Council to be heard and condemned, not to take part in formulating dogma.”
“All the cautious people,” wrote Ullathorne, “as opposed to the zelantes, feel that our Archbishop’s rooms are the centre of a determined intrigue after noting that Manning used the same ugly word “intrigue” of his opponents, Butler adds candidly “after all, ‘intrigue’ is the recognized word by which we all designate diplomatic action displeasing to us.”
The Council was now well under way, with two or three Congregations sitting every week, beginning each morning with a low mass of the Holy Spirit celebrated by an archbishop, and lasting roughly from 9 am to 1 p.m.; in all, eighty-six sittings took place between December ’69 and the prorogation of the Council in July of the following year.
Each bishop spoke in Latin, the Hungarians being especially admired for their complete and bi-lingual fluency in the language. (The influential Mgr. Pie, reproached by some Italian bishops who declared they could not understand his pronunciation, “repeated a sentence in his best Italian style, and then ‘said Gallus sum, et Gallice loquor!’”)
The procedure was elaborate and cumbersome, the acoustics poor. As they moved into the hot weather, the human element betrayed itself. The old men’s tempers grew short, and the more prolix bishops were greeted with murmurs of “satis, satis!” and “descend from the ambo!”
The Spaniards in particular were grave offenders, wearying their brethren with long and irrelevant excursions into patrology and unnecessary citations from the saints and doctors of the Church’s earlier centuries. (St. Cyprian was laid under special contribution and everyone, except for the Anglican Archbishop Benson, who wrote a monumental tome on the saint’s life, times and work, must have been rather sick of this particular theologian before the Council ended.)
By the spring of 1870, at least ten of the Fathers had died in conciliar harness and many were petitioning to return home on sick leave. As early as December, the Pope was declaring that if the Council lasted six months, he would be bankrupt: “Non so se il Papa uscirà di questo Concilio fallibile od infallibile,” declared His Holiness with plaintive wit, “ma questo è certo che sarà fallito.”
“It is an actual fact,” commented Ullathorne, retailing this bon mot, “that one of the well-off cardinals wrote to claim the Pope’s hospitality which was only intended for poor bishops, such as the struggling remote missioners.” One has a feeling that the protagonists of M. Peyrefitte’s Les Chevaliers de Malte would have been at home with certain mundane aspects of the Council.
There were, of course, livelier moments. The wag or enfant terrible of the Council was undoubtedly Mgr. Verot of Savannah, a Sulpitian and an out-and-out Gallican who was born in France and went to the States in 1830.
A bishop of tremendous pastoral zeal and goodness who “played a giant’s part in the work of reconstruction in the South after the catastrophe of the Civil War,” he was a frequent and lengthy speaker who raised alternate laughs and exasperation, and was continually rebuked by the various Presidents, receiving their strictures with great good humour.
Speaking at a Congregation considering the Church’s definition of rationalism, he declared that “instead of condemning obscure errors of German idealists, it would be more to the purpose to condemn the theory that negroes have not souls; and he proposed a canon anathematizing any who dare to assert that blacks are not of the human family.”
During a debate on the Primacy of the See of Peter, he concluded his speech by proposing a new canon, namely that, “If anyone says that the authority of the Pope in the Church is so full that he may dispose of everything by his mere whim, let him be anathema!”
At once the President (Cardinal Capalti) bounded to his feet. “We are not in a theatre to hear buffooneries,” he thundered, “but in the church of God to transact the serious business of the Church... the Rt. Rev. Father must pardon me, if carried away by zeal I have had to say this; for as often as he mounts the ambo he detains the Fathers of the Council in listening to his pleasantries.”
Contrary to rumours—largely spread by Acton and by Mozley, the correspondent of The Times, whose absurd and hair-raising dispatches were due largely to his knowing neither French nor Italian—there was only one real “scene” at the Council.
This was occasioned by Strossmayer, Bishop of Bosnia and Sirmium, the fiercest and most outspoken of the minority group, a Croat and pan-Slavist who feared infallibility would put a barrier between reunion with the Slav Orthodox communions.
During a debate defining the Church’s condemnation of Protestantism, he declared amid mounting murmurs (mostly Iberian) of “Haereticus!”, “Damnamus eum!” and “Protestor!” that “there are among Protestants many grave men who are a great help to Catholics in opposing these errors,” going on to cite Leibnitz and Guizot, “whose refutation of Renan I would like to be in the hands of all.”
The assembly, records de Cesare, “was transformed into a howling, menacing mob” and “the tumult was such that the police guarding the Basilica proposed to force the doors of the hall.” Failing to be heard amid the uproar, Strossmayer said: “I attribute this to the deplorable conditions of this Council” (an immense and renewed uproar of “He is Lucifer, anathema, anathema!” and “He is another Luther, let him be cast out!”), he descended the platform.
To rehearse the steps by which the minority were driven into surrendering their opposition to the dogma of infallibility would be a wearisome recital—it is all set out at length, with each blow given and returned, in Butler’s admirable two volumes. The crucial debate—opened by Mgr. Pie (“the Minister in charge of the bill”) on May 19th, lasted fifteen days.
Deschamps of Malines crushed Rivet of Dijon, Hefele discoursed weightily on Chalcedon to the embarrassment of the majority; Freppel of Angers discoursed professionally in his best Sorbonne manner, Cardinal Guidi of Bologna made a surprise intervention on bishops being witnesses of tradition, which earned him a rebuke from the Pope; “Witnesses of tradition?” said Pius, “there’s only one; that’s me.”
Manning and Cullen spoke forcefully (the former for almost two hours), Gasser, Prince-Bishop of Brixen in the Tyrol, addressed the Fathers for two hundred and forty minutes. Transylvanian and Peruvian bishops, impressed by these and similar “magnificent orations,” waived their right to speak. The formula finally accepted was proposed on July 9th, accepted at a General Congregation on the nth, passed on the 13th and solemnly enacted five days later. It runs as follows:
The Roman Pontiff when he speaks ex cathedra, that is, when exercising the office of pastor and teacher of all Christians, he defines with his supreme apostolic authority a doctrine concerning faith and morals to be held by the universal Church, through the divine assistance promised to him in St. Peter, is possessed of that infallibility with which the divine Redeemer willed his Church to be endowed in defining doctrine concerning faith and morals: and therefore such definitions of the Roman Pontiff are irreformable of themselves [and not from the consent of the Church], (The last clause in square brackets was added on the 16th.)
On the eve of the Public Session, the minority were deeply perplexed as to what to do. Haynald, the combative Archbishop of Kalocsa (Hungary), urged that they should attend the Council “and with clear and distinct voice, in face of Pope and Europe, of kings and peoples, of the future, close this dolorous discussion with a resounding negative vote.” He carried the meeting with him, but Dupanloup, who arrived late, opposed the idea strongly: instead, he urged abstention.
“We could not vote ‘placet’,” he told his colleagues, “for nobody would believe us; we could not vote ‘non placet’ for the Catholic world would not understand us, and might be scandalized.” He prevailed, and a letter to the Holy Father was accordingly drafted. It reminded Pius of the minority’s eighty-eight “non placets,” adding that it was notorious how many bishops endorsed the same views.
The letter went on to say that since the signatories could not say “non placet” “in a cause so closely concerning your Holiness,” they had determined to be absent from the Public Session and would return therefore “without delay to our flocks, to whom, after so long an absence, the apprehensions of war and their most urgent spiritual wants render us so necessary.”
Monday, July 18th, began with rain, after a night of thunder and lightning. This time the crowd was not so overwhelming; the Roman high summer had dispersed most of the notabilities and the Infanta of Portugal was the only royalty present. For once Thomas Mozley of The Times did his profession justice:
And so the “placets” of the Fathers struggled through the storm, while the thunder pealed above and the lightning flashed in at every window and down through the dome and every smaller cupola, dividing if not absorbing the attention of the crowd...
The storm was at its height when the result of the voting was taken up to the Pope, and the darkness was so thick that a huge taper was necessarily brought and placed by his side as he read the words “Nosque, sacro approbante Concilio, ilia, ut lecta sunt, definimus et apostolica auctoritate confirmamus.”
And again the lightning flickered around the hall, and the thunder pealed. The “Te Deum” and the Benediction followed: the entire crowd fell on their knees and the Pope blessed them in those clear sweet tones distinguishable among a thousand.
The Franco-Prussian War, which broke out the day after the ceremony just described, caused the withdrawal of French troops from Rome in the following month.
Italian troops invaded the Papal territory early in September and the siege of Rome began on the 20th, the city capitulating, on the Pope’s orders, after a few hours. A month later Pius issued an Apostolic Letter “suspending the Council indefinitely, until more propitious times.”