Edmund Gosse and the Victorian Nude
Jason Edwards takes a fresh look at attitudes to the nude in Victorian art, to coincide with Tate Britain's major exhibition on the subject opening this month.
In his 1907 memoir, Father and Son, the influential art critic and litterateur Edmund Gosse (1849-1928) recalled his Victorian childhood in Marychurch, Devonshire, during the 1850s and 1860s among the Plymouth Brethren. Although Gosse recognised that his family home was probably the 'most cultivated household in the parish', he could not recall seeing a single nude figure until he was thirteen. Then, his step-mother brought a 'gaudy gift-book ... containing a few steel engravings of statues'. These 'attracted him violently'.
With little accompanying information to go on, Gosse was initially somewhat baffled by what he saw. He therefore asked his father, the renowned natural theologian, P.H. Gosse, about the sculptures one morning over breakfast. His pater's response was 'direct and disconcerting'. He said that the Greek statues were the 'shadows cast by the vices of the heathen, and reflected their infamous lives'. It was for such things as these, Gosse senior warned,
... That God poured down brimstone and fire on the Cities of the Plain, and there is nothing in the legends of these gods, or rather devils, that it is not better for a Christian not to know. As he said these words, P.H. Gosse's face 'blazed white with Puritan fury', and Edmund thought that his father must have 'himself escaped with horror from some Hellenic hippodrome'.
Recalling this anecdote, Gosse pointedly locates his father's violent sermon in the family's 'garish breakfast room'. In so doing, he questions from the outset his father's taste and authority to legislate over matters aesthetic or erotic. Gosse junior also describes how his own growing fondness for Greek nudes ensured that his 'father's prestige ... considerably lessened' in his mind. Outwardly, he may have 'bowed to' his father's condemnation of the nude, but increasingly he 'did not accept' it. Instead, he believed that his own feelings were natural, and his father's perverse.
If Gosse's attitude to the nude might strike us today as admirably modern, his liberal evaluation was almost entirely exceptional among his own contemporaries. For example, he regarded as 'hysterical' the actions of one Susan Flood, the daughter of a local shoemaker and one of his youthful peers, who smashed with her parasol one of the plaster-casts of antique figures on display at the Great Exhibition because her 'sense of decency had been so grievously affronted'. However, Gosse noted that the rest of his community felt 'a great deal of sympathy' towards Susan, praising her actions as 'a triumph', and her conduct as 'magnificent'.
Later in his account Gosse recalled how, after attending a religious meeting in Susan's honour, he retreated to a particularly symbolic space: a secluded 'asylum' in his family garden, in the midst of a mass of 'snake-like boughs'. There was, he observed with a pleasing irony, 'something, surely, quaint and pathetic in the figure of a little Plymouth Brother sitting in that advanced year of grace, weeping bitterly for indignities done to Hermes and Aphrodite'. But despite the hints of original sin in Gosse's description of the serpentine vines, and his ambivalent use of the word 'asylum' - pointed in an age where those who did not conform to the bourgeois idea of sexual morality were diagnosed as morally, if not criminally, insane and risked being institutionalised - Gosse did not suffer for long. Instead, he turned for consolation to 'a great block of pompous verse' from a religious volume, and fell asleep.
At first glance, Gosse's recollections suggest a familiar image of the nineteenth century, as a repressed age fundamentally anxious about eroticism, and consequently unable to cope with the nude. The period is notorious for its many public scandals involving representations of the naked human form. For example, at the International Exhibition at South Kensington in 1862, there was public outcry at the display of John Gibson's 'Tinted Venus', a polychromed classical nude with henna-- coloured hair, flushed skin and red lips, deemed too realistic and suggestive. A decade or so later, in 1873, a similar storm in a moral teacup brewed around Edward BurneJones's 'Phyllis and Demophoon', when it was shown briefly at the Old Water Colour Society before being quickly withdrawn on the grounds of Demophoon's full-frontal nudity and because Phyllis was so clearly a portrait of Burne-Jones's then lover, Maria Zambaco.
However, if the Victorian era is notorious for its prudery, by the end of the period the nude had become one of the principal staples of the gallery-goer's diet. If, at the beginning, there was no real English tradition of nude painting beyond the mostly marginalised, old Masterish work of William Etty (whose home was Victorian York, rather than Aesthetic Chelsea or South Kensington), by the end of the period nude figures were appearing in all genres and styles of art, from PreRaphaelitism and Aestheticism through High Classicism to the more avant-garde French influences of the New English Art Club, founded in 1886.
The increasing popularity of the nude was partly due to influence from above, since that paragon of virtue, Queen Victoria was a keen patron of works representing naked flesh. In addition, it would have been foolish for artists to ignore the potential aesthetic use of the nude as a subject at a time when most forms of artistic training, at least for men, involved prolonged study of both nude sculpture and the life model. At the Royal Academy, male students spent literally years drawing from plaster casts of famous antique and Renaissance figures, initially working with fragments of torsos, hands, feet and heads. This was followed by a prolonged period drawing more or less entire sculpted figures, before finally progressing to the life model, which was nevertheless always to be drawn with neo-classical ideals in mind. Even at the more progressive Slade School, students, here daringly of both genders, were still trained almost exclusively in drawing from the life model's nude body.
However, if the nude was not just to be found in art schools and galleries. The Victorian period is also significant for the extent to which it employed modern industrial processes to bring nudity to a potentially ever wider audience, through photography, mass-cast statuettes, popular illustrations, advertising imagery and stereoscopic and cinematic representations. Indeed, many of these new-fangled media and genres were particularly troubling to moral guardians precisely because of the way in which they removed the nude from the polite context of the gallery, bringing it instead into the velvety darkness of the back row of the cinema, or into the comparative privacy of the Victorian parlour or boudoir. Thus, the cult of the statuette was the subject of heated debate among cultural critics in late Victorian Britain because of the way in which its small scale, tactile appeal, and affordable price enabled viewers to take naked figures both into their hands and also into their bedrooms.
It was not, however, just mass-produced, modern nudes that were increasingly in the news in the later Victorian period. The genuine antique nudes being unearthed at various archaeological sites across the Mediterranean were also widely written about in the Victorian periodical presses. The wealth of pornographic wall-paintings and objets excavated at Pompeii, for example, may quickly have gone back underground into a private museum, but others exhumed at Olympia became veritable cultural icons, representing the epitome of a conversely healthy interest in the nude body. Thus, while on his American lecture tour of 1882, Oscar Wilde (1854-1900) combined his aestheticism with athleticism, by donating a plaster cast of the 'Hermes of Praxiteles' to the gym at Harvard, to inspire the student gymnasts in their endeavours towards crafting the body beautiful. The scholar of the Renaissance, Walter Pater (1839-94), also reminded modern readers of the ancient practice of placing nude statues in the bedrooms of couples trying to conceive children, on the presumption that more beautiful children would be inspired as a result. In addition, a nude plaster cast of the worldfamous body-builder, Eugene Sandow, was commissioned in 1901 for display at the British Museum, as a paradigm of the healthy body beautiful. Sandow himself appeared in his stage shows and adverts for his many body-building products either bronzed or covered in white powder and wearing just a fig-leaf in honour of the antique works he modelled himself after. His was just the kind of body that inspired Max Nordau, the Paris-based proponent of the notion that Westerners were becoming degenerate, to argue that his readers should chose reproductive partners who resembled classical statues, so as to improve the health of the race.
However, if the Victorian nude was the apogee of high Victorian culture, and an example for aesthetes, weight-lifters, newly-weds and bodybuilders everywhere, it was also repeatedly accused of affronting public decency. Particularly toward the end of the century, the nude came under increasing censure because of the way in which it addressed the thorny topic of sexuality. Two categories were, and still are, particularly sensational: photographs of young Victorian girls, and paintings and photographs of bathing boys. Indeed, so anxious were certain commentators to define the correct relationship with the nude that Tygmalionism', one of the most common themes of Victorian nude painting and sculpture because of the peculiarly intense encounter between artists and their models, was classified and theorised by Havelock Ellis in his groundbreaking Studies in the Psychology of Sex (1897-1928), alongside homosexuality, exhibitionism, erotic zoophilia, and various other so-called perversions.
The nineteenth century was thus not the crowning moment of bourgeois repression, as many have argued. Instead, it was a period in which there was an almost epidemic discussion and radical exploration of sexual mores through the exhibition and discussion of the nude. Despite this, in traditional scholarship, the nude in British Victorian art, in contrast with its supposedly more sexy French equivalents, has been seen as prudish, woefully academic and unavant-garde. As Lynda Nead has argued, the general theoretical framework for considering the Victorian nude has also tended, in the wake of the 'astonishingly extended' critical valuation of Kenneth Clark's 1956 text, The Nude, to presume the pairing of the female nude with the heterosexual male connoisseur or patron as universally valid for all times and in all places. Discussions of the Victorian nude have therefore tended to reduce a relationship of infinite potential variety between represented body and spectator, of both genders and various sexualities, to a stereotypical scene of oppressive male heterosexual desire. Thus, feminist critics in the 1970s and early 1980s, inspired by Laura Mulvey's ground-breaking work on cinematic spectatorship, tended to presume that the genre was a means of endorsing male political and sexual superiority and power, and demeaning women and their sexuality by reducing them to the passive role of fetishised objects of men's erotic attention.
In recent years much has changed. Contemporary Marxist and feminist social historians of art have been concerned with the way in which issues of class and race relate to the history of the Victorian nude. For example, as David Peters Corbett has argued, the late-Victorian group of painters such as Walter Sicket and Wilson Steer, who emerged as the Camden Town group, challenged the traditional classical form of the nude as it appeared in a mythological or antique context, with unblemished skin and perfect musculature. Sickert did so in works like 'La Hollandaise' by painting with savagely rough brushstrokes insistently working-class bodies in sordid and distinctively English and urban surroundings.
Joy Kasson has also pointed to the importance of race in relation to the Victorian nude, and in particular the debate over abolition, in Hiram Powers' 'The Greek Slave'(1844). This statue eroticised and spiritualised all forms of bondage, and traded on the pathos elicited by abolitionists, but visually displaced black slaves with the image of a more acceptable white woman - a strategy of displacement brought to the fore in a Punch cartoon from 1851, 'The Virginian Slave, Intended as a Companion to Powers' 'The Greek Slave'.
Recent historians have also returned female viewers to the Victorian gallery, as depicted in images such as John Absolon's colour lithograph 'View of "The Greek Slave" by Hiram Powers', in which the audience viewing the statue at the Great Exhibition include women and children, and a little girl in the bottom right-hand corner, who looks back daringly at the sculpture. Feminist scholars have also recently brought to light new documents regarding women's experiences as models, and have recovered previously neglected nudes produced by female artists. For example, Jan Marsh has researched the experience of models and female artists within the Rossetti circle, and she and Pamela Gerrish Nunn have challenged the idea that Victorian women artists did not paint the nude, as evidenced by Evelyn de Morgan's Dawn (Aurora Tri umphans)' of 1886 and her `The Worship of Mammon' of c.1909. More recently still, Alison Smith has raised the question of homoeroticism around the Victorian nude, demonstrating that whereas northern, middle-class male industrialists tended to be the patrons of the Pre-Raphaelite female nude, there was a distinct audience for male, and particularly adolescent and boy, nude studies, such as Frederick Walkers' 'The Bathers', within the homosexual subcultures of lateVictorian London and Oxford.
It is precisely into this homoerotic context that Edmund Gosse's 1907 recollections of his valiant struggles with his father on the issue of the nude seems to fit. By 1907, of course, Gosse was a successful writer and pillar of the establishment, and his wryly affectionate memoirs of his Victorian childhood inspired an entire generation. Gosse had not, however, always been such a mainstream figure. Indeed, in his youth, as well as his childhood, he was not afraid of being in the cultural avant-garde. His wife, Agatha, was an agnostic politically radical and bicycle-riding 'New Woman', and Gosse himself had been one of the principal promoters of the risque cult of the statuette in late Victorian Britain. Gosse had also engaged, in the closing decades of the nineteenth century, in an intensely homoerotic relationship with the late Victorian academic sculptor, Hamo Thornycroft; an encounter inspiring the catty description of Gosse as a closeted 'hamosexual' by Lytton Strachey.
It is clear that this experience had a strong impact on the way in which Gosse retrospectively sought to characterise his childhood, and also on the value he placed on the illustrated sculpted nude bodies he encountered. Gosse's adolescent challenge to his father's early Victorian prudery was not simply in the name of his passionate desire to behold the female nude per se, but rather the sculpted classical nude body of either gender. According to his own account, Gosse was equally attracted to Aphrodite and to Hermes; to 'Venus in her undulations' and to 'Apollo with his proud gesture'; to the 'kirtled skirt of Diana' and to Jupiter voluminously bearded'.
In recalling his childhood interests in the nude in this way, Gosse's account thus suggests that, from long before the development of the distinct fin-de-siecle homosexual subculture, indeed from before the Great Exhibition of 1851, even fiercely academic nudes had the power to address a wide range of subjects, both male and female, urban and rural, rich and poor, promiscuous and chaste, with consequently diverse erotic preferences and political agendas. Thus, Gosse senior could employ the Victorian nude to bolster up Puritan family values, through coded warnings about the dangers of sodomy and, more specifically male buggery, by pointedly identifying Edmund's beloved illustrations with 'the vices of the heathen', both Greek and Biblical. I say P.H. Gosse was specifically alluding to sodomy and male buggery since he specifically identified his son's statues with Sodom and Gomorrah, `the cities of the Plain', and also with the 'infamous' practice of pederasty within Plato's circle, well known to all classically educated Victorians. In cautioning his son that the classical nude was an example of one of those things that it was better 'for a Christian not to know', Gosse senior was also employing, as Eve Sedgwick has shown, a centuries-old negative characterisation of male same- sex eroticism as 'the unspeakable'; that sin which should neither be 'named nor committed', that sin 'amongst Christians not to be named', and, most famously, as the 'love that dare not speak its name'.
Gosse's example is particularly challenging because his attraction to the nude of both genders refused to conform to more recent notions of heterosexual and homosexual identity, which, as Michel Foucault has notoriously argued, were unknown in Europe before the late nineteenth century. Before that date, Foucault suggests, the Victorians did not imagine that same-sex acts were practised by a specific kind of individual, the so-called homosexual, with an exclusive passion for members of his or her own sex. Rather, they imagined same sex eroticism within a much broader range of proscribed acts which were collected under the umbrella term of sodomy, thus placing alongside any form of sex deemed unproductive or immoral by Biblical texts, whether oral or anal, pre- or extra-marital, and sex with anything other than a reproductive partner or aim in mind. Gosse's eroticised interest in the nude of both genders does not, therefore, make him an exceptional spectator in the mid-nineteenth century, but in some senses a representative one, a typical Victorian viewer whose desire to behold the nude risked being described and even experienced in terms of ideas of sodomy.
Gosse, however, does not provide us with an alternative way of understanding sexual identity from the often risible psychoanalytic model. Rather, he retrospectively and selfconsciously diagnosed both his father and Susan Flood in a thoroughly Freudian fashion. Thus, Gosse validated his own violent attraction to the nude of both genders by diagnosing Susan Flood's rival point of view as hysterical: a standard psychoanalytic, not to mention highly misogynist, strategy though one that was not outlined by Freud and Breuer until 1896. Gosse also mirrored Freud in suggesting that his father's paranoia around the nude was the result of his own repressed homosexuality, when he observed how his father's 'violent' feelings against the statues were the mirror of his own 'violent attraction' towards them; they were a sudden recoil from something that he initially desired to see, since he had apparently escaped with only retrospective 'horror' from the 'Hellenic hippodrome'.
Yet in many ways, Gosse's account does challenge our inherited familiar notions of the Victorian encounter with the nude. As we review the Victorian nude in the gallery today, Gosse's memoirs remind us that it aroused desires, that were different to our own, were born out of different ideas, and were experienced in different ways. Father and Son also reminds us that the nineteenth century was not simply dominated by so-called family values, and that our idea of Victorian values is a nostalgic and politically motivated historical fantasy. Thus the study of the Victorian nude might provide a wide range of historically desirable and different possibilities around erotic and corporeal experience and identity, in both the nineteenth and the early twenty-first centuries. Indeed, the subject might now reemerge as an important historical, theoretical and political topic, providing a rare form of insight into that 'bodily being' (i.e. Victorian and our own corporeality) which is, in Judith Butler's phrase, 'considered to be the most real, most pressing, more undeniable', and also most historically evanescent.
We have a limited range of historical evidence regarding bodily experience, and visual evidence such as the nude in art may give insights into the various ways in which bodies can be imagined, constructed, experienced, and contextualised. To take perhaps the most controversial case, studying Victorian representations of nude children can provide a historical perspective to our difficult current debates regarding what constitutes the 'acceptable' treatment of minors.
Gosse's Father and Son, then, provides a challenge to the widely held presumption that the Victorian age was one where heterosexual nineteenth-century Pygmalions desired Galateas of their own devising. 'Exposed', the major show of Victorian nudes showing at Tate Britain this autumn, which provides evidence of - and juxtaposes - well over 150 nineteenth-century representations of the human body, recognises and should facilitate this historiographical project in a whole host of unprecedented, timely and fascinating ways.

