It is natural to generalize about the West Indian islands, in 1776 as today, as if they were a single place. They were, and are, very diverse. The Bermudas, in particular, do not fit easily into any pattern that holds of the rest. They are a number of small islands 500 miles to the east of North Carolina, covering some twenty square miles. The largest, Great Bermuda, or Main Island, is fourteen miles by one; north-east of it and forming a semi-circle round Castle Harbour are the rest of the group, including St George’s.
This port could accommodate a large fleet and was the only Bermuda port authorised under the Navigation Acts; to it, therefore, all shipping had - in law- to go; it was in St George’s real estate that local men of property invested when they could. The islands, known frequently in North America at the time as the Summer, or more accurately the Somers Islands, acquired the name of Bermuda from the shipwreck of Juan Bermudez, a Spaniard on a voyage from Spain to Cuba who was cast up there.
The first settlement was begun by Sir George Somers in 1609, but in 1612 they had been granted to an off-shoot of the Virginia Company and some sixty people, under Henry More, were settled. They cultivated tobacco, but the tobacco industry gradually declined in the eighteenth century. In 1774 the population of the Bermudas was estimated by Governor Bruere at 10,655, almost equally divided between whites and blacks.1 They lived by sloop-building - many American privateers were Bermuda-built - by smuggling and privateering, and by trading openly and, after 1776, shamelessly with the mainland colonies.2
The situation in the Bermudas in 1776 was a specially involved one. Their geographical location and their poverty prevented their becoming a major refugee centre for Loyalists as did the Bahamas. In population they were small, and the equal division between whites and blacks was unusual - in Jamaica the ratio of black to white was ten to one. If they had their own Black risings - as in 1761 - these were much less serious; and there was indeed a dependence of black on white and white on black very different from that in Jamaica.
Governor Bruere found it ‘a kind of paradise by nature, but without art, cultivation or agriculture, and with little regulation or order’. But he was soon to add references to ‘the supineness and indolence of the inhabitants’. Agriculture on the Bermudas consisted almost exclusively of subsistence farming; meat and even fish were usually scarce; and pilfering was a major industry. They had the great asset of the cedar tree, out of which they constructed a hardy sea-going sloop for use in the carrying trade. In the years of war prosperity up to 1763 they were building thirty-five sloops a year.
They built up a triangular trade; salt from the Turks and Caicos Islands and from Tortuga and logwood to Britain, cloth and hardware to the mainland colonies, and provisions for themselves, a trade employing 1,000.3 The largest shipper on the islands was Jennings, Tucker & Co, who traded regularly to London and the mainland, and the two families were dominant politically and socially. Since the islands were well endowed with creeks, inlets and harbours, smuggling was rife and difficult to check. So indeed were wrecking and salvaging - the Bermuda Triangle.
A contingent of regular troops, the Ninth regiment, the Royal Norfolks, had been brought in but, located in St George’s, could easily be evaded and had to be removed in 1768 to cope with the situation in North America. The two detachments in Bermuda and the Bahamas were recalled to St Augustine where the regiment was. From that point on, the sole defence of the island was left in the hands of the local militia.
The Association, devised by the first Continental Congress in 1774, threatened the Bermudas severely, and they faced starvation. A delegation led by Colonel Henry Tucker visited Philadelphia in 1775 to ask that the islands be allowed to be supplied with necessities from them. Colonel Tucker’s was a difficult though, for many of his contemporaries, not an unusual role. His eldest son was a Bermuda councillor and had served three years before he married Frances, the Governor’s daughter.
His second son was a physician in South Carolina. His third, once clerk of the Bermuda Council, was studying medicine at Edinburgh. His fourth, St George, was studying law at William and Mary, and was a strong patriot in inclination; so much so that his anxious father- pleading economy- brought him back.
It was indeed the Tucker family that helped to remove the powder at St George’s and ship it to Charleston and Philadelphia in August 1775, to the Governor’s indignation and alarm. As a result, the Continental Congress on November 22nd, 1775, after spending a whole day in the Committee of the Whole discussing the island’s needs, agreed:
That the Inhabitants of the Island of Bermuda appear friendly to the cause of America, and ought to be supplied with... the produce of these colonies... necessary for their subsistence and home consumption.
The Congress voted that they should be permitted to import from the colonies annually 72,000 bushels of Indian corn, 2,000 barrels of bread or flour, 1,000 barrels of beef or pork, 2,100 bushels of peas or beans, and 300 tierces of rice. This was to be an annual supply, to be allocated among various colonies.
For the immediate needs of the Bermudians, the Congress further voted that a cargo of provisions should be sent in the brig Sea Nymph, Captain Samuel Stobel. The people of Bermuda were delighted with ‘this concession’ made by the Continental Congress, unwilling though they were to bid open defiance to the power of Great Britain.
In the circumstances, Governor Bruere felt himself isolated and was doubtless confirmed in the feelings he had expressed at an earlier date, when he wrote to the Earl of Dartmouth that he could not ‘confide in any person here, at present’, as there seemed to be ‘few friends of government here’.
W. G. Kerr in his Bermuda and the American Revolution describes the situation thus:
‘Twenty sail of Bermuda vessels, nominally engaged in picking up wrecks and turtles at the Bahama banks, sold the revolting colonists ships, salt, cannon and military stores, thus keeping in supplies the American privateers who preyed on the West India trade. In fact, most American privateering ships were Bermuda-built. The salt makers at Turks Island did a lively trade, exchanging their produce for flour and grain.’
The geographical position of the Bermudas and their small population made any alternative strategy impossible. Their tacit relationship with the colonies as essentially an economic supplier - not least (once war began) of salt -and a suppliant, was occasionally interrupted by the appearance of British warships.
In November 1778, however, a British garrison of two companies arrived under the command of Major William Sutherland, reinforced in December 1779 by a further 100 men, under Lieut-Col Donkin; and from then on the colony was under British protection and control. Many of the leading figures traded openly with the enemy. After 1780 there were frequent expectations of French or Spanish invasion - and even of Bermuda becoming openly ‘rebellious’. In 1781 St George Tucker wrote to Washington:
‘The reduction of Bermuda would open again those resources for the supply of salt to the Continent, the obstruction of which has been severely felt by the inhabitants of [Virginia] in particular, who not being furnished with vessels of their own, have been obliged to depend on the fortuitous arrival of Bermudians driven hither by necessity, or allured by the advantages of our commerce, to brave even the horrors of a prison-ship, which many of them have fatally experienced.
A capitulation nearly similar to that of Grenada would ensure this end... I would presume that a fifty-gun ship and three or four frigates with some land forces would accomplish this end in no less than three days, there being no garrison in the place except about 300 invalids.’
Later, in detail, he advised that Castle Harbour and St George’s Harbour be entered, and the blow struck from within. If this proved impossible, then a force should be landed at Tucker’s Town to reduce the Castle, and another at Ferry Point to overpower the town and fortifications of St George’s.
Washington was sufficiently interested for Tucker to elaborate the plan over many pages, suggesting that the whole scheme be considered by ‘some respectable gentleman’ resident at the West End. He knew of competent pilots who were available, and who thought the time suitable for action; and, he continued, in the event of success Bermuda could remain a neutral island until the end of the war, when a disposition of it could be made in accordance with the wish of its own people and the best interests of the new United States and its allies.
A number of Virginians, some of them exotic, can clearly be identified as early refugees in Bermuda. According to Dunmore’s letter to Germain July 23rd, 1776, some of his followers were then about to sail for Great Britain, others for the West Indies, and still others for St Augustine in East Florida.
According to a letter written by one of the passengers on the same date, those on board the ship Logan were going to Glasgow, Scotland, while other vessels were bound for the English ports, London and Whitehaven, and still others for St Augustine and the island of Antigua.
Strangely enough, Staten Island, New York, which was the immediate destination of Dunmore himself and about a thousand other refugees, white and black, was not mentioned by either writer; nor was Bermuda, which was not then always distinguished from the other West Indian Islands. When St. George Tucker sailed to Virginia in 1776, he did so via Turks Island to pick up a cargo of salt.
A few Virginia families, however, clearly went to Bermuda. Among these were Samuel Farmer and his household, except his eldest son who sailed first to New York, then to the West Indies in October 1778, and a year later to Bermuda, where his father died in May, 1780.
Robert Shedden, the merchant of Portsmouth, with his wife and two children, also sailed for Bermuda accompanied or followed by Mrs Shedden’s brothers, William and Bridger Goodrich. Bridger Goodrich’s arrival in 1777 - along with the British troops - at last checked the open trade and the obviously emerging sympathy with the mainland colonies.
Bridger Goodrich is a colourful figure. Having had long connections with Bermuda and sympathy at first with the Patriots, he was converted to the royalist cause - strangely enough it seems - by Dunmore. His and his brothers’ arrival in Bermuda, soon to be followed by that of his father’s, and by a group of Scotch-Irish adventurers, transformed the island’s role.
He bought a fine large Bermuda-built sloop which had fallen a prize to the Galataea and, having refitted her as a privateer and renamed her the Andrew Hammond, after a naval captain whom he had known in Virginia, assumed command of her himself. Her trial run yielded five prizes in quick succession, two of them Bermudian vessels laden with Indian corn for the island; and Goodrich suggested that these be given up so that he could escape the odium of preying upon his neighbours.
Nevertheless, he made it clear that, except for authorized provision ships, he had no intention of letting Bermudian vessels go unmolested to the Continent. By the end of January 1778 he had taken nine prizes, seven Americans and two Bermudians. So long as he confined his privateering to American ships, the Bermudians looked on his enterprise with equanimity.
He was, in fact, doing what the geographic position of the islands obviously suggested: they had, in the Seven Years’ War, lived by just such privateering. Several other privateers were fitted out to cruise - more acceptably - against French and Spanish shipping as well as American; their success in capturing prizes increased the number of mouths to feed and reduced Bermuda in 1780 to sore straits.
Goodrich was far from welcome. He was a brash incomer, who did too well at the islands’ expense, and imperilled their tortuous relations with the mainland. When the War was over, Colonel Henry Tucker, living in and enjoying London, reported that the Goodriches had amassed a fortune estimated at £100,000. Later, they moved to Bristol, like many other Loyalists, and, in the end, Bridger Goodrich returned to Bermuda.
But as early as 1778, local Bermuda leaders - Henry Tucker, John Harvey and George Bascome - had organized a ‘General Association’ to boycott Goodrich’s activities, and to hold no commercial dealings with privateers. When Captain Pender of the British privateer Triumph called at the west end of the island, he could get no supplies; when in 1780, however - on the advice of his Bermuda-born second-in-command, he hoisted the Stars and Stripes, fourteen or fifteen boats went out with supplies.
In fact, Goodrich defeated the boycott, and by 1780 ninety-one prizes, many French, had passed through Admiralty Court. Goodrich did well, indeed, and celebrated by marrying Elizabeth Tucker, the colonel’s niece. A tax on privateers was imposed by the local assembly. But when the Massachusetts Loyalist and former Judge of the Boston Supreme Court, William Browne, became Governor of Bermuda in 1782, replacing the vigorous Lieutenant-Governor George Bruere (G.J.’s eldest son), privateering was discouraged as likely to ‘draw the resentment of the enemy’.
Other Virginian Loyalists in Bermuda were less interesting figures. Dr Archibald Campbell of Norfolk, one of Dunmore’s partisans and a cousin of the Tuckers, did not leave Virginia until May 1776, when he sailed for Bermuda with his family in the sloop of war, Nautilus, Captain John Collins. During the War his services were in demand, notably when smallpox struck.
In 1784 he returned to Virginia to recover debts, and remained there for five years in a vain effort to secure the passage of an act authorising debt recovery. During his absence his family remained in Bermuda. He obtained from Governor William Browne a certificate testifying to his character and loyalty, and he appears later as Speaker of Assembly in the Bahamas.
Andrew Cazneau, the former Boston vice-admiralty judge, also spent some years in Bermuda after his banishment from Massachusetts. He became a councillor for his three-year stay; and in 1780, when Britain tried to take a stronger line with the Bermuda government, he was appointed admiralty judge, obviously to tighten up the operation of the prize tribunals. He was supported by his fellow Bostonian Daniel Leonard (‘Massachusettensis’) who was moved from Barbados to become attorney-general alongside him. Scotsman Robert Traill was appointed collector of customs.
The Bermudian story for these years is a fascinating one. By 1782 the scale of the War against France and Spain permitted privateering not only to flourish but to become again legitimate. In the first four months of 1782 they captured no less than thirty-four prizes and by September a further fifty-nine.
The people, wrote Traill, ‘now discover a spirit that fully convinces them they are at this period no friends to the Americans; for the fitting out of privateers in all parts of the islands in order to annoy their trade is becoming so general that there are now about eighteen sail commissioned and belonging to it’.
It was not quite unanimous. Some Bermudians - Thomas Roberts, Thomas Morgan, Ben Stiles and James Briggs-called on Washington in 1781 to invade the island, if necessary with French aid, promising popular support against British tyranny, and suggesting a capitulation on similar terms to those accorded Grenada, giving neutrality while the war lasted. J. M. Varnum said that the task would require only 500 men and three or four frigates. Talk of invasion was in the air, but Britain’s supremacy at sea by the summer of 1782 after Rodney’s victory prevented any invasion.
George Bascome, lawyer-turned-merchant, summed up Bermuda’s situation, though with only partial truth. Writing to St George Tucker, on March 28th, 1778, he said:
‘In the midsts of this mighty struggle for glory, dominion and liberty, poor little Bermuda has observed a strict neutrality. This perhaps you will say was the most difficult political manoeuvre that could be attempted. Be it so; God be thanked; the lives of 14,000 souls have been saved by it.’4
The recipient, himself strongly American in his sympathies, knew all too well the inaccuracy of this view. Yet if their role had been closer to that of America’s ally than of neutral, and if the Tucker family were clearly Patriot at heart, it remains that to the majority of Bermudians the ties of loyalty did hold, cushioned after 1782 by the mounting evidence of the Royal Navy’s presence and power.
Needing American supplies, it had come close to disloyalty. It was held in line by the energy and courage of George Bruere, endlessly requesting more guns and more men, but never doubting ‘the equity, honour and candour of government’, and by the unwelcome vigour of privateering Bridger Goodrich, who trusted no government and no neighbour.
The former died, of wounds and exhaustion, in 1785. Goodrich lived on in affluence. And so did the arch-compromiser Henry Tucker. Indeed by 1785 it was all as if it had been a tale for the chimney corner. Colonel Tucker returned from London to die in Bermuda in 1785. H. C. Wilkinson5 writes of it all in lyrical prose:
In the following spring the Colonel was restored to the embraces of his adoring household. He had written St George in Virginia to send, or better to bring him, a good horse, and that dutiful son, undeterred by the events of the war, hastened to do so. He brought his family with him and spent three months at the homestead in Southampton. He rode that good horse over most of the island and was entertained everywhere, and his hospitable hosts, after clearing their dining-table and toasting the king, never failed to raise their glasses for the second time to the honour of General Washington.
When the weeks were spent and St George had to sail again to Virginia, he looked back upon his holiday as the happiest period of his life, but his father felt the parting had left a chasm in his heart. The Colonel lived until April 1785, and his last days were cheered by the progress which his second son, Thomas Tudor, was making in the ‘metropolis’ of New York. This son lived to be Treasurer of the United States.
But, as Wilkinson also notes, Bermudians in fact lived at the centre of an Imperial network, and in the next generation were to treat the mercantile world and the Empire as peculiarly their own.
‘The enterprising members of the younger generation of Bermudians, however, were dubious about commerce coming to them and felt that it was their part to sally forth into the world. They went in all directions. Some of the sailors accepted Mediterranean passes to protect themselves against the Barbary pirates while on their voyages to the southern European ports.
Simultaneously, a small flotilla of sloops went to Newfoundland to fish, but found, to their chagrin, that, by the terms of the recent Treaty, they were without rights in those waters and had no alternative but to return empty to their own island... At the same time, in other fields, Anthony George Forbes was making a most creditable start in medicine and in literature at Edinburgh, and Francis, the eldest son of Dr. Forbes, was starting upon a distinguished legal career which later took him to the antipodes.
Henry St. George, the eldest son of the Honourable Henry Tucker, following his Bruere uncles, entered upon the service of the East India Company of which in time he was to become Auditor-General. Several of his brothers joined him in India. In the career of arms, meanwhile, another Forbes and two more of the Tucker boys became colonels in the Peninsular War under Wellington.’5
1 Bruere to the Earl of Dartmouth, March 29, 1774, C.O. 37 vol 36.
2 Bread and flour, overwhelmingly from the middle colonies and the Upper South, constituted, after tobacco, the major colonial commodity export, and their average annual value in the years 1768-72 was £412,000. D. Klingman, ‘The Significance of grain in the development of the tobacco colonies’ Journal of Economic History xxix 2 (June 1969) pp 268-278; J. F. Shepherd and G. M. Walton, Shipping, Maritime Trade and Economic Development of Colonial North America. CUP 1972.
3 Kerr describes it thus: ‘eighty to a hundred vessels were constantly at sea, each manned by a skeleton crew of two whites and 4 negroes. Some of the boats were owned by their captains, a good many by better-off islanders who employed the crews. In this way fully half of the able-bodied men became expert mariners. These were for the most part dwellers in either end of the island group but especially in the east from which access to the open sea is easy and direct.’ Bermuda & the American Revolution 1760-1783 (Princeton Univ. Press 1936, 1969).
4 Tucker House Papers, Williamsburg, cited by W. B. Kerr, op cit p. 130-131.
5 Henry C. Wilkinson: Bermuda in the Old Empire (OUP, 1950).