Writing University History for Aberdeen's Quincentenary
Jennifer Carter takes a look back on the history of the university of Aberdeen.
Universities are among the Western World's oldest institutions with continuous histories. Only the Roman Catholic church, the law courts of certain European countries, some army regiments, and a few town and craft corporations can claim similar longevity. What is interesting today is the way in which the history of these old institutions, the universities, is being written. University history has moved away from the once-dominant tradition of recording the stories of particular institutions and praising, famous forebearers, and instead tries to interpret the history of universities in its modest context – social, economic, political, intellectual and cultural. It is often a collaborative enterprise, and it frequently uses computer technology – though as one practitioner admits, it may do so with a 'mixture of enthusiasm, experimentation, scepticism and bewilderment'.
Examples of contemporary university history include the large-scale project on the history' of European Universities under the auspices of the Standing Conference of Rectors, Presidents and Vice-Chancellors of the European Universities (CRE). In Britain the history of the University of Oxford is an outstanding example, as is the research currently going forward towards a 'holistic history' of the University of Birmingham. A comparable American effort has begun at the University of California in Berkeley. This multi-dimensional approach is seen too in the leading journal in the field of university history: History of Universities, launched in 1981.
The University of Aberdeen is one of the select hand of European universities which can trace a continuous history for 500 years, since its foundation on February 10th 1495. There are eighty-one European universities which were founded before 1500, but many of them have significant gaps in their histories, when war or plague or political change interrupted their existence. Conscious that we were dealing with an unusually long institutional life, historians at the University of Aberdeen embarked ten years ago on a Quincentenary History Project, designed to honour the quincentenary in 1995, but also to make a positive contribution to the new type of university history. Our experience may be of general interest.
Almost the first decision we made was not to produce a single stout commemorative volume – or two or four – in 1995. Instead we decided to commission a series of short studies, each dealing with a particular episode in this university's history which needed exploration or reinterpretation, and raised issues which might allow comparison with the histories of other universities. One advantage of this approach is that each author has been free to tackle a topic without strict reference to the approaches taken or the ground covered by others: all have learned from each other's work, but have not been constrained by a heavy editorial agenda At the time of writing, nine short histories have appeared, in a series called Quincentennial Studies in the History of the University of Aberdeen; by 1996 we hope to have another six in place.
The books produced so far have included aspects of university history not commonly studied. For example, R.D. Anderson, The Student Community at Aberdeen 1860-1939 (1989), which launched our series, dealt with the neglected subject of corporate student life, including its manifestations in clubs and societies, sports, and political action, and how this activity affected the university as a whole. Lindy Moore, in Bajanellas and Semilinas (1991), wrote what is still one of the few substantial accounts of British women's higher education outside Oxbridge, and the only such account of Scottish students. J.D. Hargreaves' Academe und Empire (1994) studies the overseas connections of Aberdeen University and their influence both on the university and on the countries to which its graduates went, in a depth not attempted for any other university except Oxford. Books which revise and reinterpret more familiar themes include David Stevenson's King's College Aberdeen, 1560-1641 (1990) which decodes one of the most complex and obscure phases in the history of King's College as it responded to the Reformation and the tangled politics of the earlier seventeenth century, and shows how different was the experience of this early- modern Scottish university from that of Oxford or Cambridge. Roger L Emerson, Professors, Patronage and Politics (1992) and Paul B. Wood, 'The Aberdeen Enlightenment: The Arts Curriculum in the Eighteenth Century (1993), take new looks at the more familiar topic of the Enlightenment. I.G.C. Hutchison's The University and The State: the Case of Aberdeen 1860-1963 (1993) treats a central subject in university history but in such a way as to modify many commonly-held assumptions about university-state relations.
It is noticeable that several of the titles cited deal with events of the last century-and-a-half. That this is so is due mainly to the chance order of research and publication, and that balance is being redressed as the series progresses. But it is also needful for historians to address the issues of the recent past. Previous generations of university historians often dealt in loving detail with an institution's foundation and early years, and then passed most sketchily over everything thereafter. Near- contemporary history carries certain risks. We have sought to avoid judgements about living people, but inevitably some of our work has disappointed those who look on their own or their fathers’ university days in a rosy glow of comfortable reminiscence.
How successfully the series as a whole will realise its intentions is for others to judge during the next few years. Already we are conscious of gaps, where lack of evidence or lack of an appropriate author has meant that a theme could not be covered, though it has been our policy to commission authors from outside Aberdeen, as well as members of our own staff. Predictably perhaps, our decision to publish a number of small books instead of one fat one has created a demand for a single volume in 1995, and this has now taken the form of a short, lavishly- illustrated history, which drawn on the work of the series: it is entitled Crown and Gown and is written by Jennifer J. Carter and Colin A. McLaren.
Underpinning the work of the scholars who have contributed to the Quincentennial Studies series has been a considerable co-operative effort in running conferences, organising archival and bibliographical support, and creating a computerised student database. Among the several conferences held, which attracted international support and refreshed the efforts of the Aberdeen team, two of the most notable were 'Aberdeen and the Enlightenment.' (1986) and 'The University in its Urban Setting' (1993): the second of these was organised in collaboration with History of Universities. The first firmly staked a claim for Aberdeen's contribution to the Scottish Enlightenment to be more widely recognised. The second, while it included many aspects of town-gown relations, highlighted the fact that Aberdeen had two very different types of university before they were merged by Act of Parliament in 1860 to form the modern University of Aberdeen.
Situated in Old Aberdeen, which until the 1890s was a separate burgh from New Aberdeen, King's College was a typical late-medieval university, under the patronage of the pope and the local bishop, and supported also by the king of Scotland. King's adopted a collegiate lifestyle in a small burgh dominated by an episcopal cathedral. Aberdeen's second university, Marischal College, founded by George Keith, Earl Marischal of Scotland, in 1593, was typical of a newer type of European university, set up under the patronage of a locally-important nobleman and supported by the city fathers of a prosperous city, as well as receiving the approval of the king. Marischal remained for all of its separate exisience 'the town's college', drawing most of its students from New Aberdeen and the area around, and always allowing students to attend by the day. This contrast between the civic and the collegiate was of greater long- term influence on the development of Aberdeen's two universities than the obvious fact that King's was a pre- Reformation foundation, whereas Marischal was a direct product of the Reformation.
Given the survival of many manuscript lists of students attending particular classes, especially for the nineteenth century, the compilation of a computerised database to record and analyse these attendances was a high priority for the Quincentenary History Project, and so far the years 1860 to 1880 have been covered. Published lists record graduates, but there has been no previous attempt to record all students and the patterns of study they followed. It is generally known, and not only about this university, that many students simply did not graduate before the late nineteenth century because few careers demanded a university degree for entry. Some students dropped out through poverty or illness or even death before completing a course: many more attended only those particular classes which interested them. But the surprising fact is that many who completed a full course satisfactorily did not actually graduate – even some of the brightest Aberdeen students of that time, who did well in the competitive examinations for the Indian Civil Service, felt no need to be graduates. Altogether only 47 per cent of all students in these years graduated.
We hope that as a result of our work the foundation and history- of this university will be seen again as part of a European tradition, because in vital respects Scottish universities are closer to their European than to their English counterparts. But equally, the British dimension has been emphasised, especially for the period since the eighteenth century, as has the very close connection which .has existed between this university and North America since the late seventeenth century, and between this university and the British Empire and Commonwealth from the mid-nineteenth to the mid-twentieth century. Aberdeen shows clearly its distinctive reactions to the process of university reform in the nineteenth century, and demonstrates the importance of its social and geographical context in all its responses to change – whether in its modernisation of medical teaching; its accommodation of women students: or simply in the way in which it survived this century's two World Wars.
Aberdeen's experience highlights and qualifies two arguments about the nature of Scottish higher education since the eighteenth century – the question of 'democracy-' and the question of 'anglicisation'. Our experience supports the view that university education was more democratically available in this region of Scotland than it was in England. The number and proportion of students from humble backgrounds may not have been large, but many individuals did manage to get a university education here which would have been denied them elsewhere, The annual competition for entrance bursaries, at King's and Marischal and afterwards in the united university, certainly helped many poor students to obtain a university education, and grants from the Carnegie Trust in payment of fees were also significant in the inter-war period.
The curriculum changes of the late nineteenth century, bringing in Honours degrees to replace the traditional MA degree, seem less the result of any direct English influence than a response to a changing job market, and the more regulated entry to the professions, not only in Britain but also in the Empire. One theme which has come through inescapably in all our work is that of political influence over the supposedly 'autonomous' university, whether in the form of direct political interventions in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries; of eighteenth-century Whig patronage over appointments, of central. government's intervention in policy and finance in the nineteenth century; or the twentieth-century problem which has been harder for Aberdeen to manage than for many other universities – that of reconciling national and international objectives with an unusually strong regional role.
We did not set out to 'praise famous men', but we have come to appreciate the remarkable resilience of this particular institution, which in its 500-year history: has survived such traumas as the sacking of most of its staff for holding politically incorrect views in 1715, or the constant battle to keep its buildings standing and to pay its way in times of penury: from the seventeenth century to today. Bishop Elphinstone's thirty-six students and staff of 1495 have grown to a modern university of near 10,000, but the founder's original intention is as valid for the university today as it was then – to serve society and to serve the truth.

