Which Road to the Past?

G.R. Elton and R.W. Fogel intervene in the vital current debate of historians: are there two separate species of history, scientific and traditional?

Although seeking historical truth may not be as clear-cut a journey as Dorothy's trek to Oz, a fork in the road has emerged that has historians – and those who read history – barking as noisily as the mindful Toto. For where once the 'historical method' implied a rigorous investigation of the documents and the application of an open, subjective mind to reconstruct the past, a new approach has undermined the notion that history was an art that could not be reduced to scientific analysis. Born of the computer age, this new 'scientific' history, with its practitioners often referred to as cliometricians , seeks both to reduce the human error involved in rediscovering the past from historical documents, and to subject such evidence to statistical analysis on a par with the social sciences.

Whether Clio, the Greek Muse of history, is pleased with her new offspring or loath of it may reach resolution in a new book by two proponents of these apparent 'schools' of history. Both scholars are leading representatives of their modi operandi , and both have laid down path-breaking interpretations of their subjects of study, leaving controversy and new methodology in their wake. It is therefore an event unto itself that two such professors of history should pause for a moment to meet at the fork in the road and debate the roads to the past.

The title of the book, quite appropriately, is Which Road to the Past? Two Views of History (Yale University Press, 1983). Its authors are G.R. Elton, Regius Professor of Modem History at Cambridge University; and Robert W. Fogel, Charles R. Walgreen Professor of American Institutions at the University of Chicago. It would not be an overstatement to say that both are well-known, respected historians who have contributed greatly to our knowledge of the past. How they reached their pre-eminence explains the very roads they have followed, and what their 'meeting' in this book portends for the future of historical study.

G.R. Elton's contributions to the field of Tudor history began with his 1953 book, Tudor Revolution in Government . The very title suggested that the author was painting a new picture of history, and it turned out to be a carefully documented landscape showing how wrong our thinking had been about Henry VIII's reign, or the previous reign of Henry VII. Where Henry VII had been viewed as the progenitor of a 'new monarchy' which set the scene for the modem state, Elton's picture showed a continuation of medieval England into the 1530s. In that decade, Thomas Cromwell, Henry VIII's principal minister, began to construct the modem state – a revolution in government.

The anticipated volley of reply and retort usually following a sweeping revision in history was slow to materialise, largely because of Elton's methodology. He had analysed innumerable documents to support his thesis, and argued it so convincingly that any detractors would. have to roll up their trousers, hold their breaths, and plunge into the sea of documentation Elton had so masterfully sailed through without mishap.

When the scholarly report was finally heard, it came predictably from the two areas dealt heavy blows by Elton: the Elizabethan period (for was not that the beginning of the modern state?), and the late medieval period (for was not that...?). The arguments sought to show that Elton was either too soon or too late in his assessment of the bureaucratic reality of the modem state. Moreover, there was some suspicion about the 'discovery' of Thomas Cromwell as the chief architect of this Tudor revolution, and the seemingly docile, almost semi-comatose behaviour of Henry VIII through it all. Was Thomas Cromwell behind the Henrician revolution in government, or was it G.R. Elton behind the Cromwellian revolution?

Elton was undaunted and unconvinced by the criticism, which he answered with the cool efficiency of master Cromwell. Further, there was more work to be done to explain this intriguing view of Tudor history. To the key question, if a modem bureaucracy was in the works, how was it planned and implemented? Elton answered with his book Reform and Renewal , showing Cromwell's careful state planning. To explain the important problem of enforcement, Elton replied with Policy and Police . Along with a large body of scholarly articles and papers, Elton had restructured and redefined the long-held images of the Tudor state, and forced historians – young and old – to reassess their thinking and their prejudices. Perhaps most important, his meticulous use of historical records established an unwritten creed that thoroughness, care, and a disciplined understanding of the documents was to become the standard for reconstructing the past. G.R. Elton is now the symbol of that standard.

Robert Fogel's splash on the blotter of historical research carne two decades after Elton's momentous book with the publication of Time on the Cross in 1974. Although an accomplished economic historian before this work, Time on the Cross gained international attention – and notoriety – both for its subject and its methodology. Simply put, where once the institution of American slavery was viewed as a stagnant economic aberration peopled with lazy, promiscuous blacks and cruel, sadistic slaveowners, Fogel and his co-author, Stanley Engerman, proffered an entirely different picture. The economic system of slavery, they said, was not only profitable but more efficient than the free farms of the North. Slaves were well-fed, tenacious workers, and as Victorian in moral outlook as their white owners.

The proof of this revisionist pudding lay in the cliometric, or 'scientific,' approach to the surviving data of the period. With the aid of computers and graduate students, Fogel utilised the myriad lists and numbers found in records such as slave market invoices and plantation documents. Equipped with statistics and social science models, Fogel enraged traditional historians, and not a few fellow diometricians, with a view of slavery that many Americans had great difficulty recording with their inherited belief in a 'land of the free and the home of the brave.' Worse, Fogel went public with his findings; that is, he made them available in a non-technical volume. He also appeared on television and spoke to reporters of major newspapers.

Fogel's book prompted immediate reaction. The controversy appeared before the public in newspaper and television interviews by rival factions, and a three-day conference was held in the autumn of 1974 at the University of Rochester, USA, to discuss Time on the Cross . Over 100 historians, economists, and sociologists from America and abroad came to exchange academic blows and take Fogel to task over his research methods and results. One scholar said that their analysis was based on 'selective data and dubious assumptions'. Others recognised that, because of this book, it would no longer be possible to blame a ruling Southem class, dead a century and more, for all of the woes blacks share today. Fogel and Engerman parried each jab at their work skilfully, and continued to do so for the next few years in papers and articles. (Three volumes by Fogel and Engerman will soon appear detailing their findings and the entire scope of the controversy.) Their basic assumptions have weathered the storm. If cliometricians were a splinter group off the main line of historical research before 1974, they were clearly in the forefront of a debate on historical methodology after that year.

That the cause c

Before walking their separate methodological ways, the two scholars part company with certain conclusions and observations. Fogel notes the excitement cliometrics has caused, with many young historians struggling to master scientific methods for historical research. But he offers warnings regarding what the scientific historian should consider about his craft. Cliometricians have had to admit that traditional history is better suited for certain studies, painful as this admission might be. Perhaps more important, Fogel says that few generalisations cover all aspects of human behaviour, and that behavioural models must be 'place and time-specific.' He believes that while cliometricians have contributed to the elaboration of the narrative, 'Cliometrics has not made traditional history obsolete.' Finally, in the spirit of detente, Fogel allows that both schools 'supplement and enrich each other,' and that the two methodologies are neither 'mutually exclusive nor intrinsically antagonistic.' Fogel's hope for rapprochement between the two groups may yet see the day when the lion lies down with the lamb. Which group is the lion will probably never be agreed upon, but one thing is ceztain: the lamb won't get much sleep.

Elton pauses to reload and reflect on the usefulness of cliometrics. 'We are all historians,' he says, 'differing only in what questions interest us and what methods we find useful in answering them.' He agrees with Fogel that the achievements of scientific historians lie in two areas: the study of long-term trends and developments, and the investigation of broad phenomena like the economic effects of slavery or the demographics of large populations. Because of their use of quantitative data, Elton sees the scientific methodology as not very useful before the year 1700, and impossible before 1500 because of the nature of the historical record. Cliometrics, he says, can only operate by suppressing the individual in favour of the aggregate, which can prove valuable for concepts and structures, but not for 'the story of people.' Elton also warns that 'the method is so mathematical that it produces a false sense of security.' But he nonetheless accepts the new methods as valid and promising.

Both historians agree on certain fundamentals of historical research: the need for thoroughness in the search for evidence; taking precautions against subordinating details to interpretation; searching for better investigative methods. They note the popular view that each age rewrites its own history of the past because each age is conditioned by values and judgments of that age. This can be seen today with the increased interest in black history, female history, and the history of certain third-world countries. Such ideological changes, however, are not the only reasons – or the primary reasons – for rewriting history. New evidence and better methods are more likely to lead to new interpretations. How one 'does history' is at the heart of the debate.

The two roads to the past may never cross, but they will undoubtedly wind over hill and vale in close proximity to each other. The traditional historian may wonder if the cliometrician's method to his madness of counting up seemingly incongruous numbers really reflects but a madness to the method. The cliometrician may marvel at the traditional historian's preoccupation with documents relating to individuals or events that somehow allow for the construction of a government or the policies of a monarch.

When the Scarecrow pointed to one road, then another, Dorothy asked 'Are you doing that on purpose, or can't you make up your mind?' Historians have apparently made up their minds: both roads lead to the past. But unlike the hapless little girl who had to make a choice, we can follow the progress of the travellers to the past. Discoveries abound along both routes.

  • Mark R. Horowitz is an English historian and writer.