A Short History of the German Student Corporations
Elizabeth Wiskemann finds that the German students’ societies have played an unusual and a characteristic part in the history of modern Germany, and yet one which their mysterious rites and code of honour have obscured, even among their compatriots.
The earliest universities within the frontiers of the Holy Roman Empire were those of Prague, founded in 1348, of Vienna, founded in 1365, and of Heidelberg, founded in 1385; Leipzig followed in 1409. The medieval students were divided into groupings called Nationen: Franks, Saxons, Bo-Russians, according to the regions—Franconia, Saxony, Prussia—from which they came. In the early days the status of the students was ill-defined, and some of the members of each so-called nation banded together to protect themselves in societies which came to be called Lands-mannschaften; their members were apt to pick quarrels and to come to blows rather in the fashion of Tybalt and Mercutio. They also appear to have adopted customs that are known to have flourished in some of the convent schools of Saxony: new recruits were subjected to great cruelty and for an initial period treated as slaves in a manner that makes the worst days of British public school fagging sound agreeable.
In the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries various German princes took steps to suppress the Landsmannschaften, and in 1654 at Ratisbon the Imperial Diet forbad the Nationen and their practices; during the following years they were stamped out, surviving longest in Leipzig— that is, until 1682. By the beginning of the eighteenth century, however, a number of Landsmannschaften were again in existence. By this time the German universities had multiplied, that of Jena, founded in 1558, having become particularly prominent. Jena, close to Weimar, was geographically at the heart of Germany, and the University benefited by the enlightened behaviour of the rulers of Saxe-Weimar; in Jena, too, the fencing-masters, who had for long played an important part in German university towns, were dynastically supplied by the champions of the Kreussler family. Jena and Leipzig were, indeed, the two universities in this period which attracted students from all parts of Germany, and it was thus at Jena and Leipzig that the Landsmannschaften were most in evidence.
By 1770 the insults habitually exchanged by the students—calling one another “Stupid Boy” and pushing members of other groups off the pavements into the mire—had been codified into what they called their Komment (derived from comment—how one should behave) which decreed the correct response. Unruly duelling, tremendous drinking bouts in the surrounding villages and the continued maltreatment of their new recruits—since about 1720 called Füchse or foxes—made the Landsmannschaften into a great social nuisance; their lechery was notorious so that the town was terrified of gown diseases and no decent woman dared be seen with a student. The students, who were immune, like their professors, from harsh punishment, would threaten to ruin a town such as Jena by leaving it. In eighteenth-century Leipzig, on the other hand, which was fittingly called Little-Paris, the position was quite different. There, some of the university societies had intellectual aspirations; the students were mostly described either as poor hacks hanging around the publishing houses or as scented dandies with beribboned daggers. Elsewhere, the students dressed like soldiers; from about 1775 most of them began to wear their own coloured caps and sashes and to march with banners.
Among the more brutal Landsmannschaften of Jena there was one which had been founded in 1721 in a different spirit. The Mosellanische was not really a Landsmannschaft at all, for instead of uniting students from one district it united students from the Rhineland, the Palatinate, Wiirttemberg and Alsace; during the Seven Years War its members, like the young Goethe in Frankfurt, took Prussia’s side, feeling that Frederick the Great somehow stood for Germany. The Mosellanische Landsmannschaft pronounced friendship to be the principle upon which it was based, and its decisions, instead of being imposed by despotic senior officials, were made by the majority. About the middle of the eighteenth century, a masonic order called the Amicisten was founded by some Jena students; this and other masonic groups accentuated the tendency among German students to indulge in mysterious ceremonies, but, on the other hand, introduced a more humane mentality. For a time the Mosellaner and the Amicisten tended to merge; both voiced certain ethical aspirations; both bound their members to a life-long brotherhood. But by the end of the century they seem to have been engulfed both by old currents and by new ones.
All over Germany the romantic revival first welcomed the French Revolution, then in a fine frenzy of German nationalism rebelled against the French Empire; the new patriotic enthusiasts protested loudly against the scandal of the Landsmannschaften. The reaction of the latter was a re-affirmation of their regional basis, their ritualistic procedure and their members’ obligation to respond to every challenge to a duel. In order to curb the endless duelling of the past, however, and to fulfil a more academic function it was agreed that the Landsmannschaften in each separate university should unite to form a corpus or corps. Beginning in Heidelberg in 1810, and during the next ten years, the name of Landsmannschaft was replaced by that of Corps; the heads of each corps in any one university united in what they called the Seniorenconvent which claimed to represent all the students whether they had been selected to be Corps members or not.
The claim of the Corps, which only admitted the well-born, to represent all the students at any university was rejected by the new type of German youth created by Napoleon’s defeat. The new young romantics were enthusiasts not for Saxony or Prussia but for Germany; it was for Germany that they fought when they volunteered in 1813. Some of them were disciples of Jahn, who preached and practised gymnastics for the purpose of building up physically fit patriots for the future. Others were more influenced by Fichte, who went from the University of Jena to become Rector of the new University opened in Berlin in 1811; in the Rhineland the voice of Arndt was most heard.
Just as the excesses of the Landsmannschaften had been extreme in Jena, so the reaction against them was strongest there. Inspired by the humaner traditions of the Mosellaner and by Schiller1 and Fichte, the Seniorenconvent of Jena dissolved itself six days before the battle of Waterloo and founded the Burschenschaft of Jena. A youth called Karl Horn, who had fought under Lützow2 against the French and who had presided over a Corps called the Vandalen, became its first chairman. Bursche (a lad) was the common term applied to the German student; while the Jena Burschenschaft kept the constitution and ceremonies of the Landsmannschaften or Corps, its name embodied the principle of allowing all students to be members with equal rights. From its members it demanded that, unlike the dissolute duellers of the eighteenth century, they should lead chaste, Christian and patriotic lives; they abandoned the boots, spurs and sophistication of the Corps and ostentatiously wore their hair “naturally,” that is to say, long and uncurled. They went in for gymnastics and an open-air life, and they read and debated together. The Jena Burschenschaft and its imitators were essentially Protestant and essentially political in their aims; they stood for the social equality of all Germans within a Protestant, united, democratic Germany. On October 18th, 1817, 468 Burschen, over 200 of them from Jena,4 paraded at the Wartburg in Eisenach to celebrate the fourth anniversary of the battle of Leipzig and the 300th anniversary of the nailing up of Luther’s 95 theses at Wittenberg. After many cries of “Heil” and a good deal of praying to the God of Luther, singing, gymnastics and drinking, the day ended with a bonfire into which were thrown a number of books and symbols which the Burschen condemned.5
As both Jena and Eisenach lay within the territory of the liberal Grand-Duke Karl August of Saxe-Weimar, the patron of Goethe who was his Minister of State, there was no immediate trouble after the Wartburg celebrations. A year later, at Jena, the representatives of 14 universities established the Allgemeine Deutsche Burschenschaft (thenceforward referred to as the A.D.B.), choosing for its colours the red and black with gold trimmings of the Lützow volunteers. It was the A.D.B. which made black-red-gold into the colours of the abortive German revolution of 1848, colours inherited in 1918 by the Weimar Republic and now by the Federal Republic of Western Germany.
From the beginning the A.D.B. was divided over two issues. Though it had been founded in egalitarian protest against the exclusiveness of the Corps, many of its members objected to the admission of Jewish Germans as their equals. The Burschenschaften, moreover, claimed to be inspired by new moral principles that should have condemned the whole game of insults and duels which often cost young men their lives or their limbs. In practice, however, it was only in Berlin that the Burschenschaften abandoned the duel. Elsewhere they established courts of honour through which apologies could be conveyed instead of a quarrel being fought out. But they dared not forbid duelling which was felt to be glorious and which, it has been said, was the expression of “a civilization in which the feeling of personal and professional honour was strongly developed but which lacked an authority strong enough to satisfy such feeling except by resort to arms.”6 These were still the days of Castlereagh and Canning.
Since the Wartburg celebration Metternich and most of the German authorities had regarded the Burschenschaften as dangerous revolutionaries—which was, in fact, what they aspired to be. An extremist group in Giessen was largely responsible for the murder of Kotzebue by a theological student from Jena in 1819, and with the Karlsbad Decrees six months later the Burschenschaften were officially suppressed: in Prussia the Decrees were severely enforced, but in Weimar and parts of South Germany they remained for some time a dead letter.7 The general effect was to put back the Corps into the ascendant; it was they, who stood for the old order of things, and it was from their ranks that the various German governments tended to enrol their officials. In the ’twenties and ’thirties of the nineteenth century the Burschenschaften often adopted Corps names in order to divert the attention of the police;8 what with this, their frequent anti-Semitism and their constant duelling, by about 1840 there was little to distinguish Burschenschafter from Corps men; student life was by now just as it had been in the pre-Napoleonic days. Indeed, the bloody duelling which went on in the Hirschgasse in Heidelberg became a European scandal, and English visitors in particular were said to be horrified by what they saw there.
The accession of Frederick William IV to the Prussian throne in 1840 contributed to a notable change of atmosphere. The aged Arndt, who had been appointed to the University of Bonn at its foundation on October 18th, 1818, but had then been removed as a revolutionary nationalist, was brought back, and Professor Dahlmann, a younger nationalist, was appointed to Bonn in 1842. As 1848 approached the early spirit of the Burschenschaften was renewed; their members helped to man the barricades in Berlin, as in Vienna, during the street fights in March of that year. A student Parliament assembled at Eisenach later in the spring and sent its plans for students to elect professors, and for all the universities to became national German institutions, to the all-German Assembly which met in the Paulskirche in Frankfurt in May. Arndt and Jahn, too old by now to play much part, were elected to the Frankfurt Parliament, and Dahlmann was one of its leading spirits. By mid-July disillusionment had set in; it seemed already as if the Paulskirche Assembly would achieve nothing concrete, and the political tide turned. A Corps leader called von Klinggraeff, a chief of the Heidelberg Vandalen, called together a Corps congress at Jena for July 15th to unite the Corps of all Germany. At last, in 1855, the Corps leaders of eleven universities combined to form a central committee; it was called the Kosener Senioren-Convents-Verband because it was founded at Kosen, and it became the dominant authority among the students until it merged into a larger body in 1921. In the ’fifties the Corps more than ever set the tone.
The attraction of the Corps for the newly arrived student was not alone that of traditional prestige and swashbuckling heroics, which made it important to record your duelling defeats by the scars on your face—a unique instance of pride taken in defeat. No, the Corps took the place, for the German student, of a college at Oxford or Cambridge. For he arrived in Jena or Heidelberg—if neither were his home —as an isolated, inexperienced youth with no potential loyalties other than those inspired by the Corps or Burschenschaft. He needed something all the more because he would probably move to another University each year. Now the Corps, although they had often preserved local names and usages, formed a network of related bodies over most of Germany; when a student transferred himself from Leipzig to Gottingen, he would be directed by his Corps in Leipzig to one which was associated with it in Gottingen; from the time of the Kosener union it was only a matter of notifying one’s move.
The Burschenschaften had all along tried to be national as well as nationalistic organizations, with their Germanen or Arminen or Teutonen at each major university. In the reaction of the ’fifties and earlier ’sixties they perforce abandoned politics and fell back, as they had thirty years before, into being merely newer rivals to the Corps with which a crop of insults was exchanged. After heated arguments as to whether the Burschenschaften had a duelling relationship9 with the Corps, it was usually decided that they had and a fencing duel took place; occasionally the opposite decision was made when those concerned would probably fight, instead, with pistols. The Corps men mocked the Burschenschafter as no duellers, of course, and also as back-to-nature boys who in this period, for instance, despised the “unnatural luxury” of travelling by train. Besides, the Burschenschafter were just a little too intellectual, given to debating10 the inner meaning of black-red-gold and similar themes. When the young Treitschke began his studies at Bonn in 1851 11 he joined the Franconia Burschen-schaft. He preferred this to a Corps because the Burschenschaften stood for the union of all the students including the “Camels” or “Finches,” i.e., the many who belonged to no group at all. But for all the talk of union, mergers ended in splits and quarrels, and disunion continued to prevail.
Between 1864 and 1870 German student life, its centripetal tendencies until now confused by its particularisms, was dominated by the compelling theme of Bismarck’s three wars against Denmark, against Austria, and against France. So much German victory made the students even readier than their parents to forget their more liberal aspirations and to accept all that Bismarck imposed. In the ’forties and ’fifties Catholic student corporations had been founded, an important one called the Aenania in Munich in 1851. But these groups had kept cautiously quiet until a big Catholic meeting at Frankfurt in 1863 was addressed by Count Hertling in no uncertain terms. The other student bodies had long prided themselves as the enemies of clericalism: now they welcomed Bismarck’s quarrel with the Catholics in the ’seventies.
The wars had seemed to show that military prowess was more rewarding than civilian virtue, and the officer class had gained a new prestige; this prestige embraced the higher officialdom of Prussia from which the rulers of the new Empire were predominantly recruited. The Corps had long been the breeding-ground for many of these people. Moreover, since 1870 and before, many university Professors and students who were nothing to do with the Corps had become reserve officers, and thus the universities in the Hohenzollern Empire were far more closely identified with the ruling class dian hitherto. The rapid development of an industrial working-class with Social-Democratic leaders, upon whom Bismarck declared legislative war towards the end of the ’seventies, seemed to complete the division of the Germans into a ruling class and one which was ruled. The Prussian Government12 instructed the Kuratoren, its special representatives at the universities, to watch sharply lest any Socialistic or radical grouping of students should form; indeed the position in the ’eighties was comparable with that in the ’twenties and ’thirties after the Karlsbad Decrees, with the fundamental difference that the students had forgotten their Volksgemeinschaft ideas, their belief in a national community irrespective of class, and the Kuratoren found nothing to suppress. The apotheosis of power which Bismarck’s policy had brought in fact spelt the end of the old Burschenschaft conception, and black, red and gold disappeared from the ’sixties until the Hohenzollern collapse in 1918. The black-white-red of the new imperial flag expressed the triumph of force in the Empire of 1871.
In 1868 the Landsmannschaften reappeared; they were no longer regional but hotly nationalistic, and in the following years, like many other organizations, they based their badges upon the black-white-red tricolour. The new Landsmannschaften, though duellers, were anti-aristocratic, that is to say hostile to the Corps; in the early twentieth century their membership appears to have exceeded that of any other national students’ corporation.
Since Luther’s day, and before, outbursts of German nationalistic fervour had been coupled with outbursts of anti-Semitism. With the retrograde course steered by Bismarck from 1879 the patriots of Germany began to discover that the Jews had succeeded in making themselves dangerously influential. (It was true that since Jews were excluded from the ruling class they were pushed into the openings provided by banking and journalism.) Professors like Treitschke and Lagarde led the outcry, while Mommsen opposed them. Among the students, anti-Semitism became strong and led to the foundation of the Verein deutscher Studenten in 1880, a patriotic union which excluded Jews. Both the Verein deutscher Studenten and an inter-University committee (Deputierten-Convent) set up at Eisenach by representatives of the Burschenschaften struggled to unite, at any rate, the non-Corps students on a national basis during the ’eighties, but although all the students, except for a few liberal outcasts who kept to themselves, were united in glorifying the new Empire in which they lived, the squabbles between them seemed to multiply. The old Burschenschaft clubs which had grown up to unite all students against indiscriminate duelling could not be prevented from duelling among themselves, and different corporations constantly sent one another to Coventry. At last, between 1912 and 1914, an agreement was worked out at Marburg between them all: it was too late for it to be tried out before the outbreak of the First World War.
The Burschenschaften, it has been seen, had originally been founded with the political aim of a united and liberal Germany. Now that liberalism had gone by the wall, they had hauled down that flag and claimed to be nonpolitical. But their nationalism became increasingly extravagant. They were nearly all gross-deutsch, that is they desired to incorporate in Germany not only the Germans of Austria and Switzerland but also such “Nordic races” as the Dutch and the Flemings and perhaps the Scandinavians. In 1848 and again in the ’sixties the Burschenschaften had collected money for a German fleet against Denmark. In the ’nineties the students enthusiastically supported the new Pan-German movement which demanded a German state to contain all those who spoke German or Germanic derivations. And in 1899 the A.D.B. for two years actually joined the Navy League which demanded an expanded German Navy to challenge the naval supremacy of Britain. While after 1890 the Corps sided with the Emperor, 13 the other student organizations demonstrated in favour of the Chancellor he had dismissed. This did not mean that they accepted Bismarck’s “Little Germany” without Austria as a final solution of the German Question, but simply that they honoured what he had achieved. In 1897 tension between the nationslities in Austria reached a climax, and the German and Czech students in Prague came to blows. This created huge excitement in Germany, and after this Austrian and Bohemian-German students— as well as Swiss ones—were brought into the student unions of the German Empire. In 1904 there was a fresh climax in Austria over the demand for an Italian University, and German and Italian-speaking students fought one another in Innsbruck after which there were student demonstrations in most of the Universities of both Germany and Italy. In the meantime the Pan-Germans, including their student following, had displayed frenzied sympathy with the Boers, whom they claimed as blood-brothers, against the British; anti-British feeling was particularly strong in the German Universities in the years leading up to the war of 1914.
Inside Germany the older student societies during this period busied themselves with opposition to the Catholic student Verbindungen; the older corporations objected to the Catholics for the traditional reasons, but also because the Catholic societies fought no duels on principle, though they adopted the rest of the student ritual, wearing the so-called colours, sashes and caps and full eighteenth-century costume on specially festive occasions. The regular meeting of a Corps or other student body involved sitting round a table either at some inn, or later in club-houses, and drinking large quantities of beer by order of the student presiding. (A booklet called the Allgemeine deutscher Bier-Komment and compiled in 1899 described the rites then practised by virtually all student bodies regardless of the differences between the Corps and the others.) The orders and the songs which accompanied the drinking were often in Latin. Altogether the paradox of the ever more nationalistic and racially anti-Latin German students and their rites performed in dog-Latin and French was a curious one, but the Corps in particular insisted upon the French C at the beginning of their name and upon the use of words like Convent, Kommers and Couleur.14
In the early years of this century one of the most usual ways of provoking a duel was to accuse one’s prospective victim of staring at one —the formula was an aggressive “Sie haben mich fixiert.”15 The duel—called Mensur because of the measuring out of the ground— was a formalized affair with doctors at hand; it was important not to flinch while one’s wound was sewn up. After the duel extra drinking-bouts usually took place; indeed, the drinking after the shock of a wound was often worse in its effects than the wound itself.
In the eighteenth century only the Mosellaner had thought in terms of a life-long link between their members. This idea was later revived, and steadily gained ground in the second half of the nineteenth century. The Alte Herren, as the former members of any student body were called, not only increased at a great rate in proportion to the active members but also exerted a growing influence upon student life: this was more than ever true after the foundation of the Verband alter Corpsstudenten in 1888. The Alte Herren provided funds and club-houses, of course, but above all, since they held the most important posts in the bureaucracy, they provided careers by recommending to their colleagues well-scarred and politically reliable youths from their old Verbindungen.
The student organizations were bitterly disliked by the working-classes, partly because they were a public nuisance in many University towns, but chiefly because they were felt to be the cadets of the ruling caste and intentionally provocative towards the lower classes. After the First World War, the German student bodies quickly revived, only to be suppressed by Hitler as the scions of the old ruling class. Those who regard the present tone of West German life as pre-eminently a reversion to that of about 1910 point to the recent revival of former student traditions.16 And those who regret the restoration of duelling do so partly because it typifies the restoration of a Hohenzollern state of mind. The most obvious difference between 1910 and 1954 in non-Communist Germany is perhaps that anticlericalism among students or others is no longer openly expressed.

