Pasquale Paoli: Hero of Corsica
In the year 1765 Dr. Johnson’s future biographer set out on his journey to Corsica.
Two hundred years ago James Boswell was setting out on the journey that would produce his wholly delightful, but now strangely neglected, travel book An Account of Corsica.
His main object in making this expedition, which all his friends had warned him would probably be dangerous and certainly uncomfortable, was to meet General Filipino Pasquale Paoli, the patriot leader who had then nearly liberated his native island from the corrupt rule of the Genoese.
Unfriendly critics, who like to ascribe ignoble motives to almost everything that Boswell did, describe his plan as yet another piece of tuft-hunting. Boswell had secured the friendship of Samuel Johnson; he had visited and corresponded with Voltaire and Rousseau.
Why not add the famous General to his visiting list? Human motives are usually mixed; but I believe there was more goodness and generosity of spirit in Boswell’s desire to see and talk with the General than there was of social snobbery.
Boswell, we know, longed for a father figure whom he could admire and venerate. He had already found one in Johnson; but Paoli came a close second.
Paoli, at the time, was one of the most talked-of men in Europe. Everyone, the supporters of dynastic monarchies as well as liberal thinkers such as Rousseau, agreed that the Genoese rule was detestable, and admired both Paoli’s struggle for freedom and the reforms he was bringing about in his own country.
After his exile to London, even the Empress Catherine of Russia sent him a letter of condolence. Yet today, if it had not been for Boswell, few, apart from historians and, of course, his fellow-islanders, would recollect the General’s name.
Boswell, however, has secured his immortality—not only by writing his travel-book (which has still not so many readers as it deserves) but by referring to him again and again in his magnum opus, his Life of Johnson.
During the first period of exile in London, Paoli won the admiration of Johnson. Historically speaking, he was, without a doubt, one of the most important members of the whole of the Johnsonian circle.
There is no biography in English of this great Catholic Liberal patriot—a Christian Garibaldi, as Mr. D. B. Wyndham Lewis has well said of him. Biographies in Italian and French are nearly all pedestrian productions written in the nineteenth century.
I have always found this particularly strange, and had often resolved that one day I would fill the gap. 1965 provided my opportunity.
Earlier, I had published The Highland Jaunt, the story of how I had ridden with a companion round the Western Highlands and had visited the Hebrides, which Boswell and Johnson had themselves visited in their famous tour.
The anniversary of Boswell’s Corsican journey encouraged me to give the subject a somewhat similar treatment—to retrace Boswell’s footsteps on the island and study Paoli against his native background.
Pasquale Paoli was born in the fine little mountain town of Morosaglia in Corsica on April 5th, 1725, where his father, Giacinto Paoli, was an elderly Corsican patriot.
When, in 1739, the Genoese had crushed the latest revolt with especial severity, Giacinto took Pasquale with him to Naples, leaving his remarkable elder son, Clemens Paoli, to carry on guerrilla warfare.
It was a retreat pour mieux sauter. The old man had his son educated at what was then one of the greatest Italian schools of humanistic studies. Pasquale was a keen student; and Gregorovius goes so far as to say that the youth emerged from the University “as one of the greatest and most practical of those humanistic philosophers of the eighteenth century”.1
Had the young man stayed on the peninsula of Italy, his future would have been assured. But, inspired by memories of his native country and by his father’s declarations that a time would come when Corsica would need his help, he turned from studies to military affairs and saw active service as an ensign in the Royal Regiment of Famese.
His fame and achievements had reached the ears of the Corsicans; in 1755 they appealed to him to return and become their leader. He agreed. It says much for the impression Paoli’s personality must have made that, when he was just short of thirty, they at once appointed him their sole General.
Paoh was a brave man and a competent soldier, though no military genius. But he soon succeeded in driving the Genoese out of the entire island, except for a few fortified coastal towns; and this was largely because he knew how to impose discipline on the passionately patriotic, but unruly Corsican fighters, and because they trusted him implicitly.
More remarkable than these military achievements were Paoli’s statesman-like reforms. Having expelled their oppressors, the Corsicans, he believed, must demonstrate that they were a civilised community.
First, he attacked the terrible tradition of the Vendetta. The Genoese had tacitly encouraged the endless Corsican blood-feuds.
In two years of their rule, before Paoli’s arrival, no less than seventeen hundred Corsicans, had fallen by assassination; while the Genoese Judges allowed their assassins to go unpunished.
It was the difficulty of obtaining justice under Genoese rule, without the help of bribery, that had been largely responsible for the growth of blood feuding.
Paoli, a devout Christian as well as a statesman, at once moved against the Vendetta. He sent priests and missionaries to preach in the fields, as well as in the churches, against the sin of revengeful murder; and he himself visited remote parts of the island to reconcile contentious families. He also punished Vendetta murderers by the disgraceful sentence of hanging.
When a relation of his was found guilty of carrying on a Vendetta, he had him punished by this method. But nothing affected the veneration that the Corsicans felt for their new young General.
By the time Paoli’s first period of rule had come to an end with the French occupation of the country in 1769, the blood-feud had been all but stamped out; and that it was to return during the nineteenth century was no fault of his.
But the conquest of the Vendetta was not enough. He established a democratic Consulta at the ancient capital of Corte in the centre of the island—a Consulta where every village was represented by popular voting—founded a university at Corte, and encouraged religious and philosophic studies.
Before the French Revolution had broken out, before the doomed Polish attempt to establish a democratic constitution in 1791, Paoli had put into effect many of the liberal ideas of Rousseau, while remaining a devout Catholic.
When the Genoese, who despaired of holding the island, sold out their rights over the fortified coastal towns to Lotus XV of France, and subsequently, although they had already lost it, sold their rights over the whole island, the French army attacked in force.
At first Paoli’s forces beat them back; but eventually superior numbers and superior military discipline prevailed at the battle of Pontenovo in 1769. For the second time Paoli was driven into exile, and took refuge in London, where he attracted many friends.
King George III, who took a liking to him, according to an oral tradition I have heard in Corsica, offered him the hand in marriage of any lady of his couit. But Paoli replied that he was already married—his true wife was his native country.
Readers of Boswell’s Life of Johnson need not be reminded of the quiet, dignified impression he made. He exerted a good influence on Boswell, lent him money and prevailed upon him for a while to remain tolerably sober.
But it was a sad retirement for a man of forty-four still at the height of his intellectual powers. Then hope of a kind suddenly revived.
Reports of the French Revolution in its earlier stages must have seemed blessed tidings to the aged Paoli.
At the age of sixty-five, the French National Assembly summoned him back, first to Paris where Robespierre greeted him in flatulently pompous terms as a leader of Liberty and next sent him on to Corsica as President of the Assembly and Lieutenant-General of the Corsican National Guard.
Paoli was deeply moved; and, upon his arrival at Cap Corse, he knelt and kissed his native soil. He genuinely believed that, in the spirit of Liberty, Corsica under French suzerainty would once again become free.
In my travels through Corsica in 1965, 1 was fortunate enough to be shown a few unpublished letters from Paoli written at this time. One is especially moving.
Addressed to a forebear of the courteous old gentleman who kindly let me read it, it is dated three days before Christmas 1790, after one of the heaviest snowfalls and bitterest cold spells that Paoli could remember on Corsica.
Nevertheless, he says, the cold does not inconvenience him. In London there was seldom, if ever, cold and snow as hard as this.
But in London how humid the cold had been! He had learned during his English exile, in the cold damp air, how to huddle over a fire, even in a great city.
“Here”, he went on, “I need no such fire, no such huddling over it. I walk about in my shirt; for the pure clean air of my Corsica invigorates me. And as for warmth, the soil of my native land (la mia patria) is quite enough to keep my blood and heart warm forever.”
At first, things went well for him. He was received back among his own people with universal enthusiasm. His most ardent supporters included the young Napoleon Buonaparte, then a lively believer in Corsican independence.
“Mais”, as Canon Cristiani, the author of the most readable and informative recent pamphlet memoir of Paoli laconically remarks, “il devait trop tôt dechanter.”2
While the Revolution moved on in continental France towards the Terror of 1793, Paoli saw his dreams vanishing.
The wanton bloodshed, the persecution of religion, the rage of Revolutionary passion, all made him understand that there was to be no true liberty for Corsica if attached to such a state.
Ominous too was the obvious sympathy that the young Buonaparte—now Bonaparte—showed towards events in France. Corsica was too small to hold him. At Ajaccio, in Napoleon’s house, I saw the trap-door in his private study by which he used to escape when Paoli, his former hero, paid him an unwelcome visit.
Paris in 1793 began to be aware of Paoli’s attitude. He was no longer a “Friend of Liberty”, but a treacherous old reactionary. In the British Museum Reading Room there is a copy of a pamphlet entitled “Grandes Trahisons de P. Paoli contre la liberté du Peuple.”
It is scurrilous in the Fascist or Communist style, with which we are now so familiar; the patriot hero is coarsely abused and forcibly commanded to “...off”. The grand old man did not obey.
Corsica, which almost to a man was for him, declared him the country’s Generalissimo; and continental France officially declared him a traitor and his countrymen who followed him equally traitorous.
Paoli has been blamed for the move he now made; but he made it at the suggestion of his Consulta, in the desperate hope that, with the assistance of a great naval power, Corsica might retain her threatened liberty. He offered his country to George III.
The one condition he laid down was that Corsica should remain an independent part of the British Empire, and that is should be ruled by a Viceroy. The offer was accepted; “but”, as Birkbeck Hill puts it, “by an act of incredible folly not Paoli but Sir Gilbert Elliot was made Viceroy.”3
This act of folly estranged most of the Corsicans. Some blamed England, some Paoli for making the offer. “Bref,” as Canon Christaini writes, “Pascal Paoli est devenu, si l'on peut dire, ‘une pomme discorde’ dans son propre pays.”4
Admittedly, Elliot had a difficult job; but as a member of an ancient Scottish Border family who always talked of himself as an Englishman, and who had pressed hard for the Union with Ireland, he had obviously little interest in the rights of small nations.
Elliot’s viceregal position was doomed from the start. Most Corsicans were offended; and a few, such as Pozzo di Borgo, who were jealous of every other Corsican, tried to stir up trouble by tale-bearing. Elliot relied much on Borgo.
In an unpublished letter to Dundas (later Viscount Melville), now in the National Library of Scotland, he announces that “Paoli is playing the rogue as well as the fool”.6 This I decline to believe.
The old man may merely have been behaving in a reserved and apprehensive manner. In another letter, also unpublished, Elliot writes: “I would advise you to give up Corsica as a country impossible to be governed without force, and therefore unfit to be governed by England”.6
The inevitable occurred. George III was induced to write a friendly letter to Pasquale Paoli, inviting him to England. Paoli had no choice but to accept; and in 1796 Great Britain abandoned the island, which soon became a province of the French Empire.
The body of Napoleon, who outlived Paoli, was returned eventually to rest by the banks of the Seine. Pasquale Paoli lingered on in London till 1807, where he died at the age of eighty-two.
We know little of what he said or did; for he lived in strict retirement. Gregorovius tells us that, to the last, his mind was occupied with thoughts of his native country. As a Catholic, Paoli was buried in one of the few cemeteries that in those days allowed Catholic interment; but a noble bust of him by Flaxman was set up in Westminster Abbey.
The Napoleonic tradition, strong in 19th century Corsica, was strengthened by Napoleon III.
It was not, therefore, until 1889 that a public subscription was raised in Corsica to recover Paoli’s remains for re-burial at his birthplace at Morosaglia.
When I visited his last resting place, someone had placed a wreath of flowers with a tribute to “the Father of his Counixy”. It was in the Corsican language, which is a dialect of Latin, rather than of Italian.
The Times of August 24th, 1889, contains an interesting account of the opening of Paoli’s grave at the old St. Pancras cemetery. When the tomb was opened, a leaden coffin was revealed bearing this inscription:
PASCAL DE PAOLI CORSORUM OLIM SUPREMUS
DUX ET MODERATOR NATUS DIE V APRILE
A.D. 1725
VITA FUNCTUS LONDINI
A.D. 1807
It was a refreshing experience, talking to people on the Island of Corsica who had not heard of, or were not interested in, the sad tale of Boswell’s later follies, but who remembered the name of Jacques Boswell as that of the generous-hearted young man of twenty-five, who had visited them, who had pleaded their cause, who had sent them aid, and who had been loved by their great Pasquale Paoli.
1 Wanderings in Corsica by Ferdinand Gregorovius (Constable, 1855).
2 Pascal Paoli: sa vie, son oeuvre par le Chanoine Ciistioni (A. Tomesi, Ajjaccio 1960 p. 42).
3 Boswell's Life of Johnson, edited by George Birkbeck Hill (Clarendon Press 1887 Vol. II p. 71).
4 Cristiani, p. 43.
5 Nat. l i b . of Scoüand (MS 3112 no. 46).
6 Nat. Lib. of Scotland (MS 5308 no. 603).

