Mission to Burma 1855
British missions to the Chinese Court had already run into many grievous difficulties. When a mission was despatched to Burma, writes Mildred Archer, they found their problems no less irksome.
In the late eighteenth, and much of the nineteenth century, the British were faced with an intractable problem. It was how to deal with Far Eastern courts. Lord Macartney’s and Lord Amherst’s embassies to China had brought home to them the difficulty of making contact with the Chinese. Major Phayre’s embassy to Burma in 1855 showed that it was equally difficult to make contact with other Eastern peoples.
The Burmese, like the Chinese, were living in isolation, with no idea of the changes that were taking place around them in India and South-East Asia. The Burmese King, the Lord of the Golden Palace, saw himself as the centre of the universe—a world that consisted in fact of Bengal, Assam, China, Tibet, Siam and the sea. The Burmese were a proud and confident people and during the second half of the eighteenth century they had been successfully extending their boundaries.
At last, when they pushed towards Assam and Bengal, they came into conflict with the British. These frontier troubles led to the First Burmese War of 1824-26, which forced Burma to cede territory to Britain in the Arakan and Tenasserim. The Burmese agreed to trade with the British and to admit a British Resident at Amarapura. But the treaty did not lead to understanding and the next twenty-five years were a period of constant friction between the two peoples.
Burma was in a state of confusion. First under the mentally unstable King Tharrawaddy and then under the tyrannical Pagan Min, the central government gradually broke down. The British Residency was withdrawn in 1840 and, after that date, there were continual complaints by the British of their ill-treatment in Rangoon. Matters came to a head in 1851 when anti-British feeling showed itself in the extortion of money by the Governor of Pegu from the masters of two British barques in Rangoon on trumped-up charges of murder and embezzlement. Both men on their return to Calcutta laid complaints before the Supreme Government. It was a petty affair, but the Governor-General, Dalhousie, knowing how Burmese-British relations were deteriorating did not wish to overlook small indignities, for he knew their aim was to degrade the British.
As he put it, “The Government of India could never, consistently with its own safety, permit itself to stand for a single day in an attitude of inferiority towards a native power, and least of all towards the Court of Ava.” He knew reparations would be rejected, so he backed his demands with force. In a letter to the King, he demanded compensation but sent it through the Deputy Commander-in-Chief of the East India Company’s naval forces, Commodore Lambert, in H.M.S. Fox accompanied by two Company warships.
Although the Government of Burma promised redress, negotiations were complicated and Lambert considered that his deputation had been insulted by the Governor of Pegu. He at once blockaded the port and attacked Burmese shipping. The Burmese naturally fired from their stockade. The “combustible Commodore” replied with a broadside and sank Burmese warships in the harbour. He then sailed back to Calcutta. Dalhousie lamented this high-handed action by Lambert, but could see no way out except to threaten war.
He did not want it, and sincerely hoped that an ultimatum would lead to some new approach from the Burmese. But no move was made, the ultimatum expired on April 1st, 1852, and a British expeditionary force sailed into Rangoon harbour. Rangoon, Martaban and Bassein harbours were soon captured and the British troops established themselves there for the rains.
Still no sign came from the Burmese, and there seemed no other course open to the British but to advance to a line north of Prome and annex the whole province of Pegu. This course had many advantages; it would demonstrate British power, provide a tenable frontier and render the Court of Ava militarily harmless.
The province of Pegu, with its immense natural resources, held out rich trading possibilities. The Home Government at this time was putting pressure on Dalhousie to occupy the capital of Amarapura and to humiliate the King by dictating a peace treaty. Dalhousie was most reluctant to do this, and did not wish to press on beyond Prome. During November and December the province of Pegu was occupied, on December 20th its annexation was proclaimed and Major Phayre was appointed Commissioner.
Meanwhile, complicated political events in Burma itself were helping Dalhousie. Mindon, the half-brother of the King, Pagan Min, and leader of the peace party, was suddenly put on the throne. He at once released the Europeans who had been imprisoned during the war and sent two of them, the Italian priests Father Domingo Tarolly and Father Abbona, to act for him with the British. To their surprise, they found the British encamped fifty miles north of Prome. Phayre, having found Prome unsuitable as a headquarters for troops, had pushed on and occupied a further slice of territory.
A confused period followed, with negotiations between the British and Mindon. The latter could not believe that the British would not withdraw if offered an indemnity, nor could his dignity possibly permit the signing away of any part of his kingdom. And so the status quo continued, each side looking uneasily at the other with hostilities likely to break out at any moment.
As official diplomatic relations had now broken down, it was essential to have some informal contact between the two governments which could provide the British with information. The ideal person for this was found in Thomas Spears, a Scottish trader married to a Burmese wife in Amarapura. In 1853 Phayre persuaded the Government to appoint him unofficial news-writer and he showed himself unusually well-informed on Burmese affairs, extremely reliable and abounding in good sense.
He was an old friend of R. S. Edwards, who had been clerk to the Resident back in 1830 to 1839. He was trusted by the King and used by him to convey messages to the British. It was largely through his handling of affairs that the inflammable situation was kept under control and peace preserved in spite of no formal treaty.
The peaceful relationship was strengthened by two embassies which Spears helped to negotiate. Towards the end of 1854, Mindon intimated that he would like to send an embassy to the Governor-General at Calcutta, and Dalhousie intimated that it should be followed up with a return British Mission to Amarapura. This was arranged and Burmese envoys with eighty followers set off for Calcutta.
A small incident, recalling Lord Macartney’s embassy to Pekin, almost marred the visit. Phayre discovered that the envoy was taking a letter, the wording of which implied that the impending British Mission was that of an inferior gift-bearer to a superior. Phayre, with his excellent knowledge of the language, detected this phrase and the mission was held up until a more suitable formula was substituted.
Eventually, the visit proved a great success. The Burmese were treated with warm hospitality and attention and they thoroughly enjoyed themselves and their introduction to Western ways. They were particularly interested in photography (“sun-pictures”), which had recently reached India. On the day of their departure, however, the envoys requested the return of Pegu and Dalhousie firmly refused it.
In 1855 a British Mission paid a return visit to the Court of Ava. It was headed by Major Phayre, with, among others, Henry Yule as secretary, R. S. Edwards as attache and interpreter, Professor Oldham as geologist and Colesworthy Grant, a professional artist from Calcutta, as draughtsman. His drawings, maHp throughout the course of the Embassy, are in the India Office Library in London. Together with a privately printed book of explanatory notes, they provide a background to the whole Mission and vividly bring it to life.
They show the countryside through which the Mission passed on its way to and from Amarapura. Its members set out from Rangoon on August 1st and Grant depicts the new town that the British had laid out after the war. In the foreground is a military store go-down and in the distance “the capacious and healthy barracks for the British troops” and a pagoda converted into a signal tower. Another pagoda “is now the centre obelisk to a square, with its diverging roads, as dry, smooth and orderly as Charing Cross, or the Place de la Concorde.”
Then we see the Mission steaming up the Irrawaddy—the Embassy staff on the steamer Bentinck and the flat Sutlege, and the escort of a company of H.M. 84th Regiment, with fifteen Irregular cavalry and twenty-five seamen on the steamer Nerbudda and the flat Panlang. The boats chugged along the wide smooth river between lush banks covered in tall elephant grass and jungle. They passed Henzada and Myanaung and numerous thatched villages clustering by the water-side among palms and banana trees, the white and gold spires of the temples rising from the trees. Gradually the banks became more broken, and Prome was reached with its gilded pagoda crowning a hill.
This wooded hill reminded the artist of England. “Tempting foot-paths thread the ascent, and penetrate the depths, and the whole is rendered European in its pictorial aspect by innumerable boulders or fragments of rock, studding the shore beneath; whilst the Electric Telegraph wire above it seemed yet further to cheat the imagination into visions of Devon or Derbyshire.” At Kama great monsters guarding the temple entrance reared above the houses. At Thayetmyo the Embassy saw the thatched Library or Assembly Room of the little British cantonment—the headquarters of the British Frontier brigade.
Soon the frontier, marked by two white pillars, was passed. At Minhla, just past the border, the Mission found a deputation waiting for them, sent by the Court of Ava. It consisted of Mr. Makertich Mines, the Armenian Governor of Malun, and the various ministers who had been to Calcutta the previous winter. Together they proceeded towards the capital.
All the time country boats with great ballooning white sails glided up and down the river “like a flight of colossal butterflies skimming the water.” At Myingun Burmese warships sped along beside the English boats. Here they saw an enormous temple bell and explored the pagoda with its colossal ruined monsters guarding the approach. At Yenan-gyaung the country changed—it became barren and rocky, with scraggy shrubs and precipitous banks. Here were the oil wells that were later to become famous. The Embassy watched the oil extracted in earthenware pots with a rough windlass, then loaded on to bullock carts.
The name of the place, they found, meant “Fetid Water Creek.” On they went to the ancient city of Pagan, where they marvelled at the innumerable temples scattered over a sterile plain. By the river, raised high on terraces, was the white Pumpkin Pagoda, and the triple-roofed wooden monasteries of the priests. “The marvels of the ancient city of Pagan, with its ten miles of ruins, eight centuries old, had long been the subject of conversation and anxious curiosity to the members of the Mission—and their realization rather exceeded than fell short of expectation.”
As Yule wrote, “The whole might pass for a scene in another planet, so fantastic and unearthly was the architecture.” They next passed the bare but busy town of Myingyan where a theatre and puppet house were attracting great crowds. Vegetation began again, and they saw Kyauk Talaung with its temples.
At last they reached Amarapura, that lovely city with gold and white spires set at the foot of “majestic hills, which were clad in purple and gold, a world of ethereal and ever varying tints, that were repeated from sky and land upon the glassy surface of the quiet river.” ... “All this,” concludes Colesworthy Grant, “produced a picture altogether which no member of the Mission who witnessed it will readily forget. Nothing on the Rhine could be compared to it.”
In the distance were the former capitals of Ava and Sagain with their ruined temples and palaces. The city of Amarapura was approached across a great lake spanned by a long wooden bridge, crowded with the gaily clad Burmese. They looked like beds of huge flowers in red, green, blue and yellow. The distant spires appeared to rise straight out of the water.
A delightful residency had been built for the Mission on the eastern edge of the lake. It was made of teak, bamboo and matting and carpeted with felt rugs. “The principal of these rooms, upwards of seventy feet in length, and furnished with dining table, punkah and chairs, was tastefully decorated, at either end, with large artificial trees, springing from Chinese vases, loaded with artificial but edible and renewable fruit; whilst the verandah in front was furnished with four large silver water jallahs, and, below, two others, of gigantic proportions, each furnished with ladles of the same costly material, and all realizing an appearance of semi-barbarous pomp, and rustic elegance.”
Mat barracks for the European soldiers were provided, and the Union Jack flew from a bamboo near the entrance. We see the compound busy with blue-jackets and red-coated soldiers, with horses hobbled in the shade of the trees. An opera house, with regular shows, was nearby, and everything was done to entertain the Mission. The King supplied English bread for them, while every day sweet-meats were prepared under the supervision of a princess, a cousin of the King.
From this base the Mission visited the moated city with its crenellated pink walls. Inside lay the King’s Palace with its golden spire and rich carving. They marvelled at the Audience Chamber with its colonnaded hall, “its choir and transepts,” and they admired “the mosaic glitter, the laborious arabesque-like carvings, and ingenious and jewelled tracery of the Throne.” “The first impression created upon the mind,” says Grant, “is that such a fabric must have been reared like coral reefs, or by some order of beings with hands infinitely less than human and patience as infinitely more than Burman.”
They were naturally fascinated by “Lord White Elephant” whose palace was situated near the King’s. He lived in a triple-roofed building, the inside painted and gilt. The White Elephant was about sixty years old when the Mission saw him and he died soon after their visit. He looked jaded and sickly although he still had a mischievous eye and an uncertain temper. He was a cream colour and about ten feet high.
He was “right royally caparisoned in bands of crimson cloth or velvet and gold, studded with large bosses of gold, blazing with jewels of every kind and size. His ears were decorated with large silver tassels, and over his head he wore an ordinary cloth of gold...” He was brought out of his palace for the Embassy to see, but not before eight golden umbrellas had been spread to protect him from the sun.
Grant’s pictures not only show the topographical background to the Mission, but also the different types of people it encountered. There are Karens and the Khyens of the Aracan Hills, with their tattooed faces, heavy necklaces and dark blue clothes. There are Taline ladies in their gay silk dresses with delicate powdered skin. There are the Burmese infantry with tattooed thighs, who struck Grant as “vigorous and powerfully formed men.” There are the cavalry, whose inferior ponies disappointed the Englishmen. Then there are the Manipur boatmen who rowed the great war-boats. Several albinos and a hairy woman with her child also interested the Embassy.
Some of the Burmese officials with whom the Mission came into contact are also depicted in Grant’s drawings. There is Moung-ghee, son of the famous General Bandula who had opposed the British in the First Burma War. There is the Governor of Pagan and several magistrates of towns within the British territory, wearing their gold chains of office. Portraits follow of the Chief Wungyi or Prime Minister, the Second Wungyi, as well as one of the Ambassadors who had visited Calcutta in 1854. The Chief Civil Judge and the Royal Scribe, who was in charge of the British Residency, are also included. Their signatures in Burmese script are attached to the drawings.
Various foreign employees of the Burmese government figure in the sketches—Mr. Makertich Mines, the Armenian Governor of Malun, and Mr. Antonio Camaretta, the Goan-Portuguese Collector of Customs at Amarapura. One of the Italian priests, Father Paulo Abbona, is shown, for he had the King’s confidence and was frequently used to communicate with the Mission. There is also General D’Orgoni, a French adventurer, whom Grant found very polite and helpful, but whom Spears had found a source of great anxiety.
He stands swaggering in a gold-braided red and blue uniform, one hand on the hilt of his sword. While things had been going badly for England during the Crimean War, D’Orgoni did everything he could to discredit the British. He took a mission of Burmese officials to France and suggested a Burmese alliance with the King of Sardinia. He returned again, claiming that he was arranging a timber contract with the French Minister of Marine.
Most interesting of all, perhaps, are the portraits of three British personalities important in Burmese affairs—R. S. Edwards, the dark-skinned interpreter to the Mission who had been employed by the East India Company for forty years and had a deep knowledge of Burma and South-East Asia; Thomas Spears, the unofficial news-writer, and Major Phayre himself, who was to become first Chief Commissioner when the three separate divisions of Burma were amalgamated in 1862. He was a great scholar and linguist and knew more about Burmese history, literature, religion and the people than any other official.
Unfortunately, Grant could not get permission to draw the King himself, although he took a great interest in the landscapes and wanted copies. “His refusal to sit for his Portrait did not appear to originate in any repugnance to the thing itself on his own part, but partly in deference to the prejudices of others—(‘It is not the custom,’ was an early expression of feeling in the matter, ‘to carry away the King’s face,’)—and, in the opinion of the Envoy, principally to the fear that some disrespect might be shown to, or accidentally befall the picture, which would by reflection or inference, cast a corresponding dishonour upon the original.”
The Embassy, like its predecessors in Burma and like the missions to China, met with continual difficulties about etiquette, and both Burmese and British were continually jockeying for position. The earlier missions of Symes (1795) and Crawfurd (1826) were seen by the King only after long delays and on “Beg-pardon” days when only suppliants, vassals and dependants were present. This time things were better. The King made it known that he would see the Envoy at short notice of two or three days.
But he at once wanted to know how Phayre would address him and was relieved to know that the Envoy would use the same form “as one of the King’s own ministers.” A great many negotiations took place concerning the actual procedure to be followed when the Governor-General’s letter was delivered at the Palace. Would the British assemble at the Royal Court House to watch the Procession of Princes and dignitaries and remove their shoes there? Or should they proceed to the Palace direct and remove their shoes only on reaching it? In the end the latter plan was agreed to.
Phayre had wished that the Governor-General’s letter should be carried under a canopy to the steps of the Audience Hall where members of the Royal House were allowed to carry their umbrellas, but the King sent a private message to Phayre asking him to withdraw this stipulation. Eventually the letter was carried by the Secretary seated on an elephant with the Union Jack flying above him. In front of the Secretary were the presents, including four Arab horses and an English carriage; behind them came a band, the Cavalry and Infantry of the Escort.
Behind the Secretary followed Phayre in a tonjaun, attended by Burmese ministers on elephants. Behind them were the other officers of the Mission, each paired with a Burmese official, on elephants. Just as the procession moved off, the Chief Minister objected to the Union Jack being flown above the letter and its bearer, but Phayre refused to move unless it remained there. When the Minister again objected, Phayre threatened to return to the Residency.
When the Palace Gate was reached, the procession of the heir-apparent suddenly appeared out of a side-turning, and preceded the British Mission, thus keeping them waiting in the road. This tactic, it was thought, was designed to assert his dignity. A retinue of several hundred soldiers attended him, who then counter-marched. The Mission also had a suspicion that, like the procession in Aida, “each man as he passed out of sight circled round again, and repeated the manoeuvre, so as to double or treble the apparent numbers of the force, and to retard” the Mission’s entrance.
At last all passed off peacefully. The Mission refused to remove their shoes or prostrate themselves while approaching the Palace. They took off their shoes only at the foot of the stairs to the Hall of Audience and removed their hats only when the King entered and took a seat on the throne. When the presents were handed over, the interpreter spoke so indistinctly that Phayre could not hear what exact phrase was used and the presentation proceeded smoothly.
Four days later, however, when the Mission visited the heir-apparent and the presents were given to him, Phayre discovered that the presents were being “respectfully offered” and he felt sure that the same phrase had been used on the previous occasion at the palace. Major Phayre at once whispered to the Chief Minister that this phrase must be altered. “As there was some boggling about this,” wrote Yule, “the Envoy half-rose from his seat, and said, ‘I shall leave the Hall, unless this alteration is at once made’. The reading-official was then rebuked and told the presents were “royal presents from a King.” Beads of perspiration were noticed on the forehead of the heir-apparent as he watched this scene.
As the Mission left the Prince’s palace, the mahouts made their elephants trumpet. This caused panic among the cavalry’s horses, and the elephants taking fright, backed into the crowd. The Mission were not sure if the mahouts’ action was intended to discomfort the horsemen.
Nevertheless, the stay in Amarapura was not marred by any discourtesy. The presents were duly admired, especially the photographic apparatus and a railway model. The silver wine-cooler was unfortunately mistaken for a spittoon. Phayre had a number of pleasant interviews with the King at which they discussed Buddhist literature and the relic-caskets that had recently been excavated at the Bhilsa topes in India.
But at no point could Phayre get the King to agree to the signing of a treaty. The King expressed over and over again his wish to live at peace with the British and to exchange goods freely with them. But he would not agree to any formal document that would recognize the loss of Pegu.
The Directors of the East India Company considered the Mission a failure, but Dalhousie was well pleased and considered that “peace with Burma is to the full as secure as any written treaty could have made it.” Never before had a foreign Embassy been welcomed so warmly or treated with such courtesy and consideration. There was no doubt that a new understanding between the two countries had been created. Today it is clear that it was not mere arrogance and pride that led to the earnest discussions about etiquette that appeared so absurd at the time. King Mindon and his court felt that they must cling to their old ceremonial and ritual.
They feared that if this was infringed the whole structure of their power might collapse, and what would then follow they had no idea. Nor could King Mindon be expected to sign a treaty that would have recognized a loss of territory and cause him to lose face before his people. He could not bear to think of his name going down to posterity in the royal annals as the King who had signed away his kingdom.
The British, in fact, had come face to face with a problem that defied ready solution. In expanding over Asia, they were at a loss quite how to act. But so, too, were the Eastern peoples whom they met. The latter had no idea of the economic and military strength behind European expansion. Faced with aggressive strangers, they took shelter in an unrealistic world of their own, and pretended that the foreign devils had conformed to it.
The British on their side recognized that an impasse existed, but could not see their way round it. For the time being, amicable relations appeared to exist, but the more discerning had an uncomfortable feeling that nothing had really been achieved and that eventually concessions would have to be wrested from the Burmese by brute force. Thirty years later events were to show how well-founded these suspicions were.

