Holbein Court Painter of the Reformation
Andrew Pettegree charts Hans Holbein’s path from Germany to England and points to the ironies of his reputation as a great Protestant painter.
Hans Holbein, who was born 500 years ago this year, was one of the great painters of the northern Renaissance. Born and raised in Augsburg, he achieved lasting fame in England, as the leading artist at the court of Henry VIII. Holbein’s paintings of the king, his wives and courtiers, provide some of the most famous images of the age, and enshrined his place in the trinity of the great German artists of the Reformation: Dürer, Holbein, and Cranach. Yet there is a certain irony in celebrating Holbein as a great Protestant painter. Holbein’s career was closely interwoven with the events of the Reformation. He was patronised by some of its leading figures, and produced some fine examples of the new Protestant art. But personally he viewed Protestantism with some distaste, not least for its adverse effect on the artistic traditions in which he had been raised.
Hans Holbein came from a family of artists. His father, Hans Holbein the elder, was an accomplished painter of religious paintings who had made a distinguished career in the German city of Augsburg. His altarpiece for the city’s Moritzkirche was one of the most important paintings recently commissioned by the city fathers. Holbein’s two sons, Hans and Ambrosius (also a talented painter, though he would die tragically young), would have received their early training in their father’s workshop, before in 1514 the two boys moved together from Augsburg to Basle. For young men eager to make their way in the world this was a shrewd choice. In the early decades of the sixteenth century Basle was one of the greatest cities of Europe, and certainly one of its most cultivated and cultured. Strategically placed on the crossroads of Europe’s major trade routes, the city and its university were already famous through their association with Erasmus and the other leaders of the new intellectual movement of humanism.
Most importantly, Basle was also one of Europe’s leading centres of book production, and it is quite possibly this which attracted the young artists to the city. In this period the new science of book publishing offered rich opportunities for the graphic arts, but it was only the richest and best established publishing houses which had the capital to embark on prestige projects which required elaborate illustrated title-pages, borders, and text illustrations.
In Basle, Holbein quickly made his name as one of the finest exponents of the new arts of the design of woodcuts and engravings. Among his work during this period was a superb series of illustrations for bibles and Old Testaments published in 1522, 1524 and 1526, the years when the awakening interest in the new evangelical teachings of Martin Luther produced an almost insatiable demand for vernacular scripture. Holbein’s designs had no particular confessional slant: he also provided the designs for illustrations of conventional devotional literature. But he used these years to cultivate contacts among Basle’s ruling élite, particularly the humanist milieu which would provide some of the most outspoken exponents of religious change. His first portraits were of members of this artistic and civic set, pictures which testify both to his growing skill as a portrait painter, and to his established position in the city’s artistic hierarchy.
In 1526 this prosperous and precociously successful career was rudely disturbed by contemporary political events. By this time the shockwaves unleashed by Luther’s criticisms of the church hierarchy were making their effects known all over the German-speaking world, and even as cultivated a metropolis as Basle was not immune to their impact. At the heart of Protestantism was a call for a return to the primitive simplicity of the original Gospel message. The new evangelical preachers vehemently denounced anything in the old church that detracted from this, and some of the most violent criticism was reserved for the religious images and artwork, which in the old church, they believed, had become almost an alternative focus of religious devotion. In towns which adopted the evangelical agenda, the abolition of the mass was often accompanied by the wholesale destruction of religious art; even magnificent pieces, such as the Augsburg altarpiece recently created by Holbein’s father. For artists such as Holbein the potential consequences were obvious. It was not just that the demand for religious paintings was greatly diminished: the whole purpose of their vocation seemed to be under question.
As the Reformation gathered pace in Basle, Holbein decided the time had come to try his fortunes elsewhere. His passport to new opportunities was provided by his humanist friends and Holbein left Basle with letters of recommendations to friends in Antwerp and England from no less a figure than Desiderius Erasmus. ‘The arts are freezing here’, wrote Erasmus to Pieter Gilles in Antwerp; so ‘he [Holbein] is on his way to England to pick up some angels’. (The angel was an English gold coin; the pun on the Latin for English, Angli was typical Erasmus.)
Once again Holbein had chosen well. In England, he was immediately assured of the patronage and friendship of Thomas More, Erasmus’ familiar friend, and at this point at the height of his powers and influence. More provided Holbein with two of his most important early commissions: a group portrait of the extended More family, now sadly lost and known only from later copies and a preparatory sketch, and the wonderful, haunting portrait of More himself, now in the Frick Collection of New York. Holbein captured exactly the painful ambiguity of the intellectual in office: the man of letters as statesman, the powerful lines of his heavy chain of office contrasting vividly with the thoughtful, slightly troubled features; even at More’s moment of glory Holbein seems to anticipate the painful choices which would bring Thomas to his destruction. It remains the defining, perhaps unduly flattering, image of More; for Holbein it was a triumphant advertisement of his mastery of the techniques of Renaissance portraiture, previously almost unknown in England.
More was a grateful and generous patron. It was he who provided Holbein with the crucial introductions to the king, that enabled him to be taken on as one of the Henry’s salaried court painters. Initially, Holbein’s work as court painter was far from glamorous. The king had employed him largely to work on the new decorative schemes with which Henry was adorning his many newly constructed palaces. But proximity to the great, in however humble a capacity, was what counted in sixteenth-century society, and it took little time for Holbein’s exceptional gifts as a portrait painter to be widely known around the court. Soon he was once again in demand.
At this point in the sixteenth century the native English artistic tradition lagged far behind the continent. The artistic lessons of the Renaissance were yet to leave their mark on the few native painters who attempted the new art of portraiture, and the English court eyed the portraits produced at the more sophisticated Continental courts with frank envy. The only alternative was to send to the Continent for more accomplished practitioners. As Sir Thomas Elyot, a leading English scholar and author, put it in 1531: ‘We are constrained, if we will have anything well painted, carved, or embroidered, to abandon our own countrymen and resort to strangers.’
It soon became obvious that even among these immigrant artists, Holbein was an exceptional talent. The painter quickly established an extended clientele among the statesmen, courtiers and adventurers who flocked to Henry’s court. His uncanny ability to capture the personality of an individual sitter make his portraits some of the most lifelike and believable images of the sixteenth century. At Henry’s court he was in a class of his own.
This was, of course, a talent which had to be used with discretion. Henry’s court was a brutal place, where the struggle for the king’s favour was fought with little mercy. Many of those who sat for Holbein were ruthless adventurers hardened by the cynical politics of the day. The revealing drawings Holbein made in preparation for his portraits often capture something of this hardness in his sitters, but the drawings were intended for Holbein’s eyes only, and the final portrait created a far more noble and flattering image. The full extent of Holbein’s artistry is revealed only if one places the two side by side, as one can for instance with his portrait of the courtier Simon George. The portrait drawing, which survives in a superb collection of almost one hundred similar preparatory sketches in the Royal Collection at Windsor, does not mask the brutal ambition of a young man on the make; the finished oil painting, on the other hand (all the sitter would see) was a masterpiece of studied elegance.
With his most important patron, the king himself, Holbein would risk no liberties. Henry employed Holbein both for conventional portraits and for more ambitious projects, such as the group portrait of the king with his parents and third wife, Jane Seymour, intended to proclaim and celebrate the new stability of the Tudor dynasty after the long awaited birth of a male heir, the future Edward VI. For this monumental painting (again sadly lost), Holbein was able to draw on the design he had accomplished for another of his ‘political’ paintings, the famous full length portrait of the two French ambassadors, recently cleaned and restored by the National Gallery. Modern scholarship reveals this as one of the most subtle and innovative of all Holbein’s English paintings, a design full of emblematic symbolism which perfectly evoked the intricate, understated world of European court diplomacy.
The French embassy took place at a critical moment in English politics as Henry VIII, desperate for approval of his divorce and re-marriage to Anne Boleyn, sought to assure the continuing friendship of France’s king to counter-balance the assured hostility of the Emperor Charles V, the nephew of the spurned wife, Katherine of Aragon. None of this tension is revealed in the inscrutable features of Holbein’s sitters, though the critical importance of the mission is suggested by the decision to portray the ambassadors full length, a privilege otherwise reserved for patrons of royal rank.
The portrait is at once monumental and enigmatic, the impassive dignity of the ambassadors contrasting with the youthfulness of their faces, as the two men pose in rather uncomfortable formality around a table crammed with astronomical instruments and other impedimenta. At first sight these objects seem quite irrelevant to their mission, but to the educated eye all convey a subtle coded message. The astronomical instruments, the broken string on the lute on the lower table, the Lutheran hymn book, all hint at a world out of joint and the perils of the religious disunity which would surely follow from Henry’s new religious and matrimonial policies.
This was a form of emblematic representation with which Holbein was entirely comfortable from his long training in the polite humanist world of Basle, but in the turbulent world of English politics such elegant understatement was already increasingly irrelevant. In his later years in England Holbein was obliged to create images much more overtly partisan in character. His new patron, the Vicegerent in Spirituals, Thomas Cromwell, had now emerged as one of the leading figures in the increasingly confident evangelical party, and Holbein played his part in the new evangelical propaganda. Indeed it was for Cromwell that Holbein produced one of his most remarkable original designs, the title page for Coverdale’s new English translation of the Bible.
This design clearly draws inspiration from one of the most original pictorial designs of the new Protestant movement: the New and Old Covenant of Lucas Cranach, a pictorial representation of the core Lutheran doctrine of Justification by Faith. But here in Holbein’s rendition the theme is restated and stripped of much of its polemical intent. Panels of scenes of the Old and New Testament are (as with Cranach’s design) ranged along the left- and right-hand borders, but the original central panel of Man’s redemption is replaced by an imposing representation of Henry VIII handing the vernacular scriptures to his assembled prelates and councillors. Nothing could more perfectly have captured the constraints which governed the reception of Continental evangelism in Henry’s kingdom.
Subtle and pragmatic, Holbein seemed to have the perfect temperament to prosper in the maelstrom in Henry’s court. On occasions, however, the painter’s artistry could bring his patrons into unanticipated difficulties. In 1539 the king was in search of a new wife, and Holbein was sent off to the Continent to take the portrait of the potential brides. Two of his pictures from this expedition survive; the full length painting of Christina of Denmark, now in the National Gallery in London, and his miniature of the successful candidate, Anne of Cleves. It is often asserted that Henry was only persuaded to marry Anne by seeing Holbein’s flattering portrait, though there were also pressing diplomatic reasons for such a match. Whatever the reason, when Henry finally laid eyes on his new bride he conceived an instant aversion to her, which spelled the end of both the marriage and its architect, Thomas Cromwell.
Holbein, the painter, again emerged unscathed from this debacle, and it is interesting that whereas authors and printers often fell victim to the confessional politics of the age, painters were seldom held accountable for the ideological content of their work. In this respect, contemporaries seem to have taken a pragmatic view of the artist’s role: his task was to do his patron’s bidding, without his own personal convictions forming an important part of the equation. This is not to say that artists were not themselves often deeply touched by the religious issues of the day. Albrecht Dürer was a late but apparently sincere convert to the doctrines of the Reformation, and the role of Lucas Cranach as the court artist of Luther’s Wittenberg was crucial to the creation of the first memorable visual images of Protestantism. Cranach, at least, was an enthusiastic and committed supporter of Luther’s movement, and a close personal friend of the reformer. Hans Holbein, on the other hand, while he cleverly accommodated his output to the changing demands for art in Protestant centres, does not seem to have been deeply touched by its religious messages.
Something of this is evident in Holbein’s conduct of his own affairs in his last years. Although after 1528 Holbein spent almost all of the remainder of his life in England, he never became an English citizen, preferring to keep open the option of a return to Basle. At one point he made to the Basle Council an undertaking to return within two years, if the Council would in the meantime pay for the upkeep of his wife and children, who had remained in the city. Sadly, this seems to have been a bargain he never intended to keep. When Holbein died of the plague in London in 1544, he left behind debts and two illegitimate children, fathered during his English years.
This sorry tale is in many ways typical of the inconsistencies of this turbulent and morally ambiguous age. Artists like Holbein brought forth many noble works of art: in his case not only portraits but the splendid book illustrations and title-pages like that of the Coverdale Bible. But they could often do this without a deep level of intellectual commitment. Rather they were reacting as professional artists to a changing market. The restriction of opportunities for religious art and commissions for new church altarpieces made it vitally necessary to explore new avenues and opportunities. Nor should men like Holbein be too lightly condemned. For it is to their ingenuity and initiative that we owe the essentially new secular art forms of the modern era – portrait, landscape, and the Dutch genre paintings of everyday life – that emerged as the pictorial arts became emancipated from their medieval dependence on the church. And this, despite its initial destructiveness, is one of the central artistic legacies of the Reformation.
For Further Reading:
The Holbein anniversary has strangely not inspired the expected rush of new studies. Derek Wilson, Hans Holbein. Portrait of an Unknown Man (Phoenix, 1996) is the most accessible; Oskar Bätschmann and Pascal Grenier, Hans Holbein (Reaktion, 1997) the most scholarly. Helen Langdon, Holbein (Phaedon Colour Library, 1973) is still reliable. Susan Foister, Ashok Roy and Martin Wyld, Holbein’s Ambassadors (National Gallery/Yale, 1997) is the splendidly informative catalogue of the National Gallery exhibition. For the wider context, David Howarth, Images of Rule. Art and Politics in the English Renaissance, 1485-1649 (Macmillan, 1997); Lorne Campbell, Renaissance Portraits (Yale, 1990); Carl Christiansen, Art and the Reformation in Germany (Athens, Ohio, 1979).
- Andrew Pettegree is Professor of Modern History in the University of St Andrews, and Director of the St Andrews Reformation Studies Institute.

