Haldane and Asquith

William Verity describes how Haldane and Asquith were close political friends and colleagues from 1882 until Haldane was abruptly dropped from office in 1915.

Herbert Henry Asquith and Richard Burdon Haldane were old political allies and friends. But they were very different kinds of men: Asquith intensely ambitious and rather pragmatic; Haldane obsessed with the practical incarnation of the most visionary ideals.

While Asquith was Prime Minister, the time came when he felt forced to deal his old friend a terrible blow by abandoning him to the most vicious attacks as a traitor. The following is the story of their relationship.

Haldane and Asquith were, with Edward Grey, members of a political trio. Asquith and Haldane had met in 1882, when both were briefless barristers, and the friendship was cemented a little later when Haldane spent a long illness at the Asquiths’ house in Keats Grove, Hampstead.

Grey had joined the group not long afterwards. Haldane and Asquith gave annual dinners at the Blue Posts Inn, off Cork St., from 1888 to 1892, at which it was the practice to invite four prominent politicians and four other guests who were distinguished in other ways.

The three shared what was then called an ‘Imperialistic’ outlook—that is to say, they favoured enlightened policies of imperial administration rather than an easy acquiescence in demands for independence. Their imperialism allied them with Rosebery and opposed them to Campbell-Bannerman’s moderate policy towards the Boers in 1901.

Rosebery lost their support when, contrary to the agreed party line, he came out strongly against Home Rule for Ireland in a speech at Bodmin during the delicate pre-election period of 1905. The trio combined their imperialism with a preoccupation with social reform; and it was this, in their early years in the House of Commons, that tended to mark them off as a distinct group within the Liberal Party.

Of the three, Haldane was the least favourably regarded by the bulk of the Liberals and especially by Sir William Harcourt, who ran the parliamentary party when Gladstone became increasingly preoccupied by Ireland. In his autobiography, Haldane neatly describes how the members of his group were regarded:

‘Asquith’s splendid gift of speech recommended him to Sir William Harcourt and the other official leaders. Moreover he had fewer views of his own than most of us. But his judgment was wise and his gifts in debate made him popular with the older men...

Grey they found more difficult. He had a most attractive personality and embodied the best traditions of the Whigs. But he was advanced in his views and of a very independent mind.

The Whips could not count on him as they could on Asquith... I myself was not so popular with the leaders or the Whips. I was not only independent but I was rather impulsive, and had the reputation of persuading my friends to take courses which they might not have taken apart from me. I was looked on by the official group as an intriguer.’

Asquith was the natural leader of the group. Haldane gave him his political start in life by introducing him to the constituency of East Fife in the general election of 1886. This was adjacent to Haldane’s own, East Lothian, which he had won in the previous year.

But thereafter it was Asquith who made all the running as the bright young hopeful of the Liberal party. In 1892, at the age of thirty-nine, he was appointed Home Secretary by Gladstone.

Asquith had never been seriously interested in the bar: it was a stepping-stone to Government; nothing more. When he foresaw his appointment he wrote to his friend Mrs. Horner:

‘When I was a boy I used to think that to get into the Cabinet before one was 40 was, for an Englishman who had to start on the level of the crowd, the highest height of achievement. I shall not be 40 until September so the odds are (between you and me) that I shall have the chance, at any rate, of bringing off this dream of young ambition.’

Haldane wrote of him:

‘From the beginning he meant to be Prime Minister, sooner or later.’

It was not so much the substance of what he could achieve in politics that attracted Asquith as the eminence of the highest positions and the ability to exercise his capabilities. Two months after entering office he wrote again to Mrs. Horner:

‘Do you remember the Theban, somewhere in Herodotus, who says... that of all human troubles the most hateful is to feel that you have the capacity for power and yet you have no field to exercise it.

That was for years my case and no one who has not been through it can know the chilly, paralysing, deadening depression of hope deferred and energy wasted and vitality run to seed. I sometimes think it is the most tragic thing in life.’

Asquith was not so much interested in the job he could do as Home Secretary as in the fact that it gave him a seat in the Cabinet before the age of forty. His achievements in office bore witness to this attitude. He dealt deftly with departmental problems and ferociously with arguments in the House; but only as they came up, without applying himself to far-reaching reforms.

Haldane by contrast was never interested in office for its own sake. Edmund Gosse’s diary gives a fair account of the kind of motivation that led Haldane to accept Cabinet rank when it was his turn to be offered it:

‘Grey saw Haldane and they agreed to stand or fall together... Grey said he would not give up his country life, thought office life such a bore, had no confidence in the Radical Rump, etc. Then said perhaps he might have gone to the Colonies.

Then Haldane, who had made up his mind, answered that sacrifices must be made for public uses, that he too had things to give up, such as £25,000 a year at the Bar, and leisure for his great University schemes.

Then he said we too must come in and we must choose the very hardest jobs which are going. In this Government there are two places of paramount importance, where it is all kicks and no ha’pence. These are the War Office and the Foreign Office.

If you will take the F.O., I will take the War Office. Grey at last consented, and then, in the dusk, so that none of the pressmen saw him, Haldane went down in person to C.B. (Campbell-Bannerman).’

Haldane’s attitude towards political preferment was rooted in beliefs he acquired while at the University of Edinburgh. In his Autobiography he wrote:

‘It was the De Rerum Natura of Lucretius that fascinated me most, when I heard Sellar (the University Professor of Latin) lecturing on it. It is more than fifty years since I listened while he declaimed to us his favourite passages. The lines at the beginning of the Second Book still remain in my memory, and I often repeat them to myself when alone:

“But sweeter far to dwell remote, aloof

In some high mansion, built on Wisdom’s hill:

Thence watch the errant crowd go to and fro,

Matching their wits, striving for precedence,

Toiling and moiling, hurrying night and day,

To rise to fortune and possess the world.”

That was his creed, and it has ever since I heard him been mine also. I think that I have in the main followed Leonardo da Vinci in the faith that it is even better to know than to be.’

About 1894 Haldane, who must by now have begun to feel a little on the shelf politically, wrote in a letter to a friend:

‘Political success is not to be an admired Minister surrounded by a devoted group of adherents.

It is to have a belief that is true and leads others to follow it.’

His interest in politics sprang out of his philosophical and literary inspiration, represented by Hegel and Goethe respectively.

Hegel instilled into him a love of orderliness and rationality—hence the famous dialogue: ‘What kind of army do you envisage, Mr. Haldane?’

‘An Hegelian army’; Goethe a fascination with the German way of doing things, in particular their system of higher education, which was at that time the most advanced in the world. He was not interested in political power unless it gave him the chance to organize, to rationalize and to reform.

Throughout their political careers, up to the time of the Coalition Government of 1915, Haldane and Asquith remained close colleagues and allies. They stood together most notably on Free Trade, which they championed, and over policy for the conduct of the Boer War in which, though not falling into jingoism, they both favoured a less lenient policy towards the Boers than did Campbell-Bannerman.

Later, when Asquith became Prime Minister in 1908, Haldane was his most consistently loyal supporter. Yet around their mid-thirties, in the early 1890’s, towards the end of the period of Blue Posts dinners, their friendship cooled a little and there occurred a slight parting of the ways.

Haldane described his relationship with Asquith in the 1880’s thus:

‘We sat by each other at dinner at Lincoln’s Inn, and after that a great friendship arose between us... He and I used to dine together once or twice a week, and we saw each other almost every day... We used to go abroad together at Easter.

We went on one occasion to Paris, our companion so far being Alfred, afterwards Lord Milner. Asquith and I then proceeded alone to Monte Carlo, Pisa, and Florence. On another occasion we two made a tour in Ireland.’

But by 1913-14, Haldane and Asquith were seeing very little of each other. In his Asquith, Roy Jenkins writes:

‘Asquith’s other contemporary in the Cabinet (besides Grey and Crewe)—and his oldest friend of the lot—was Haldane. But during these immediate pre-war years social relations with him were slight.

Throughout 1913 and the first seven months of 1914 there is no record of Haldane visiting the Wharf (Asquith’s Oxford home) or attending any meal in Downing St., or securing (or even attempting to secure) Asquith for a meal at his own house in Queen Anne’s Gate—only four doors away from the much visited Montagu residence. And on May 13th, 1914, Asquith wrote:

“Tonight we are giving a wedding dinner (20th anniversary) mostly to old habitues of Cavendish Square in its earliest days. Haldane (who had been best man at the wedding) excused himself on account of the death of a step-brother who had just passed away in the Shetlands at the ripe age of 80!”’

What had happened in between the two quotations above to their friendship and familiarity? A vital clue is provided by the passage in Haldane’s autobiography in which he very significantly links an account of the qualities of Asquith’s first wife, Helen, with her husband’s seriousness of political outlook:

‘Asquith lived in these days at Hampstead with his first wife and their children. Hers was a beautiful and simple spirit. Among my letters is one which he wrote to me on her death, a letter which shows how fully he was aware of the fineness of her quality.

London Society came, however, to have a great attraction for him, and he grew by degrees diverted from the sterner outlook on life which he and I for long shared. In his earlier political days he was a very serious person.

I remember once passing along the Horse Guards with him. He touched my arm and pointed to the figure of John Bright walking in front of us. “There,” he said, “is the only man in public life who has risen to eminence without being corrupted by London Society.”’

Helen Asquith died in 1891 of typhoid, a year before her husband became Home Secretary. Her preference had always been for the quiet family life and she was not ambitious for her husband. But she was to be succeeded in 1894 as Asquith’s wife by Margot Tennant, a socialite if ever there was one, a great huntswoman and hub of the celebrated Saturday-to-Monday set, The Souls.

Margot’s speciality was the carefully placed insult. She bought furs at John Lewis’s where one of the salesmen was the present Foreign Secretary, George Brown. He has said of her:

‘Quite the rudest woman I have ever met in my life. No one to touch her. Away out on her own in the class of calculated incivility.’

Asquith knew Margot Tennant during his first marriage and they met at social gatherings which he attended without his wife. Margot Asquith described how she met Helen in her autobiography:

‘I found out from something he (Asquith) said to me that he was married and lived at Hampstead and that his days were divided between I, Paper Buildings (Asquith’s law offices) and the House of Commons...

When I discovered that he was married, I asked him to bring his wife to dinner, which he did, and directly I saw her I said: “I do hope, Mrs. Asquith, you have not minded your husband dining here without you, but I rather gathered Hampstead was too far away for him to get back to you from the House of Commons.

You must always let me know and come with him whenever it suits you.”’

In a later conversation with Helen:

‘She told me she did not think that she would ever care for the sort of society that I loved, and was happier in the circle of her home and family. When I said that she had married a man who was certain to attain the highest political distinction, she replied that that was not what she coveted for him. I wondered if my ambition for the success of her husband, and other men, was wrong.’

Clearly, Asquith’s first and second wives must have been completely different in the influence they had on him: the first towards the seriousness that Haldane admired and the second towards the corruption of London Society which he feared.

This explains why Haldane regarded a diversion from the sterner outlook on life as contrary to the influence of Asquith’s first wife. He was best man at Asquith’s wedding with Margot in 1894, but it is likely that he was already by then seeing less of Asquith socially.

At the same time, Haldane was becoming more intensely serious in his thinking, both political and philosophical, and more deeply immersed in work. In 1890 he wrote to his mother:

‘Life is rather a racket, but it is good to be busy. I had a night of it last night. Left Court at 1 pm, when I had spoken for two hours. Read a brief and prepared my speech and addressed 3,000 people at Bradford, 7.30 pm Caught the 9.45 train, read two briefs with the aid of a candle.

Reached my chambers at 3.30 am to find an earnest intimation that I must read a brief which had been sent down to meet me. Got up at 7.30, read the brief, and was in court at 9.45 am and was on my feet at 10.30 to deliver an elaborate argument. Not a bit tired, only hustled a little!’

In the same year he was writing to Mrs. Humphry Ward:

‘I am writing a short review of Schopenhauer’s Aphorisms and reading The Ring and the Book and so I have begun this letter with a whole screed of philosophy. I do not apologize for it, for I know how much this point of view has meant to yourself in other regions. It seems to pervade everything. Even politics have become for me penetrated with it.’

Haldane’s increased seriousness and renewed interest in philosophy and in hard work can be traced to the rejection of him by his fiancée. In March 1890, when he was thirty-four, he became engaged to Miss Valentine Munro Fergusson; but, quite inexplicably, towards the end of April, she broke it off. Haldane described the effect on him in his Autobiography.

‘My grief was overwhelming, for I had a strong sense of the irrevocableness of the decision. The shock upset me. I could find relief only in constant work, and for long not much even in that. Sleep, when it came, was the only deliverance from black depression. But there was no moment in which I either blamed her or pitied myself.’

In the autumn of the following year he wrote in a letter to an aunt:

‘Old feelings surge up now, feelings which I had suppressed but could not destroy.’

I have already described Haldane’s attitude towards political ideas—how they sprang from philosophical and literary sources, and that for him it was the substance of changes achieved in politics that counted, not the eminence of political office. His experience with Miss Fergusson intensified that attitude.

The world of ideas, which he had previously explored for its own sake, he now began to look to as something of a refuge. He ended his letter, already quoted, to Mrs. Humphry Ward in the summer of 1890:

‘When a soul has missed the goal towards which it was striving, and is still staggering, it naturally, in recovering its balance, seeks to restore the prop which it knows of old and has never found to fail.

It is more relief to me than I can express to find myself again engrossed in the old searchings, and to be able to believe that they will mean, even in a practical life where they are supposed to be remote, an amply sufficient future to me.’

His hopes for the deepest relationship were dashed, the feelings they aroused suppressed. But these hopes and feelings were also transferred to the world of ideas and their embodiment in activity where Haldane felt relatively secure. Again to Mrs. Ward:

‘After all has been said and done when the highest call has been discharged and we have done our duty to our neighbour, and are free to turn to ourselves, there is no satisfaction so deep and lasting as that which arises from a sense of concentration in real work. It gives us all our deliverance even when we are dissatisfied with what we have accomplished.’

From this period onwards, Haldane devoted himself wholeheartedly to what Gosse called his ‘great university schemes’, especially for what was to become the Imperial College of Science and Technology and the Charter for Liverpool University and to his philosophy, culminating in his Gifford lectures for 1902 which were published under the title of The Pathway to Reality.

Edmund Gosse, who constantly acted as jester to Haldane’s Lear, wrote to thank him for sending a copy of the book:

‘I want to be a philosopher,—but cheerfulness is always breaking in—you know the old story. But I can tell a philosopher when I see one, and I know, by a sort of intuition, that you are the real thing and a consecrated sage.’

As Secretary of State for War from 1906 to 1912, Haldane had a period of highly strenuous and constructive activity. Applying his special talent for first principles, he reorganized the army on the basis of the Blue-water theory.

Believing that Britain’s position as an island and her control of the sea rendered defence in depth of home territory unnecessary, he concentrated on creating an Expeditionary Force that could be mobilized at a moment’s notice to go to the help of Continental allies.

He abolished the old reserves and replaced them by the Territorial Army of which the key-note was again speedy mobilization. He invented the British General Staff, on the German model, to create and coordinate detailed plans. And in doing all this he succeeded in reducing the Army Estimates; in 1907 they were down on the previous year by £2,036,000.

By 1912 Haldane had reorganized the army to his satisfaction, and when he was offered the Lord Chancellorship in that year he was glad to take it. He had been seriously attached to the law for its own sake, not just as a stepping-stone to politics, and to be Lord Chancellor was the pinnacle of his legal ambitions.

It was the position that Asquith had tried hard to get for him in the 1906 administration and was now happy to be able to offer to him. Haldane wrote to Asquith:

‘More than six years ago you fought a hard fight for your old friend over this great office and now you have yourself bestowed it on him. My feeling I will not try to express. You know how deep it is. My mind goes back to the past, to the days when we travelled together to the Law Courts from John Street, Hampstead, days which I am not likely to forget and are very present to me now. I cannot easily write more.’

In 1914 Haldane, together with Prince Louis of Battenberg and anyone else who could be regarded as having the remotest associations with Germany came under attack, especially in the Harmsworth and Beaverbrook press. ‘Every kind of ridiculous legend about me was circulated,’ he wrote in his Autobiography.

‘I had a German wife; I was the illegitimate brother of the Kaiser; I had been in secret correspondence with the German Government; I had been aware that they intended war and had with held my knowledge of this from my colleagues; I had delayed the mobilization and despatch of the Expeditionary Force. All these and many other things were circulated.’

The best known of these accusations is that Haldane had said: ‘Germany is my spiritual home.’ In fact, he did not even make the remark, though it is hard to see what is unpatriotic about a love for Hegel and Goethe. At dinner with Mrs. Humphry Ward in April 1913, Haldane was asked about Lotze and his teaching—Haldane had studied philosophy under Lotze in between studies at Edinburgh.

He replied: ‘Yes—I consider Lotze’s classroom was my spiritual home.’ 

Professor Oncken of Heidelberg, who was at the dinner, rushed into print sixteen months later, after war had broken out, to say that he had heard Lord Haldane call Germany his spiritual home. Haldane dealt phlegmatically with the attacks on him by the press and people:

‘On one day, in response to an appeal in the Daily Express, there arrived at the House of Lords no less than 2,600 letters of protest against my supposed disloyalty to the interests of the nation. These letters were sent over to my house in sacks, and I entrusted the opening and disposal of the contents to the kitchenmaid.’

He was more deeply upset by the actions of his oldest political associates, Grey and Asquith. Grey was a stout defender of Haldane; for instance, in a letter to Lord Derby he wrote:

‘I cannot express to you how indignant I feel about the attacks on Haldane.’

But in one crucial respect Grey let Haldane down. As Foreign Secretary he could have put a stop to all the rumours that Haldane had done less than he could to prevent the outbreak of war by publishing details of the negotiations in which Haldane had been involved. This he refused to do before it was too late. Something of Haldane’s bitterness at this is reflected in his own account:

‘If my full story could have been made public I think that the attacks would have been destroyed. But both Asquith and Grey were averse to making public the details of previous negotiations with Germany while the War was going on. I had therefore to remain unshielded, and I had no illusion as to what in the end the result was likely to be.’

The fate that he foreshadowed was exclusion from the Cabinet. He warned Asquith of this in the autumn of 1914 and offered to go quietly, but Asquith laughed him off. But a few months later Haldane’s worst fears were realized. In April and May 1915 the war was going badly. The generals were complaining about lack of shells.

Admiral Fisher as First Sea Lord and Winston Churchill as First Lord of the Admiralty were not getting on well and this, together with clumsy interventions by Kitchener, led to disaster at Gallipoli.

With Grey ill, Asquith himself was conducting the delicate negotiations with Italy that led eventually to her entry into the war on May 23rd. But on May 17th the Conservatives demanded a coalition government.

Asquith was faced, if he did not comply, with the threat of a scorching attack in the Commons on the administration of the Admiralty. Fisher at this time was on the brink of resignation and public exposure of the state of affairs at the Admiralty, when the Navy’s role was particularly crucial, could bring the Government down. It could also prevent Italy from entering the war.

The Conservatives’ conditions for entering into a coalition government were twofold: Churchill should be relieved of the Admiralty and Haldane should be dropped from the Cabinet altogether. They had, perhaps, a case against Churchill in view of the Dardanelles.

But their adamant stand about Haldane showed that they had weakly believed all the rumours circulated in the papers. Unfortunately they did reflect a feeling that was common among the Tory rank and file of the time. Grey tried to intervene on Haldane’s behalf and wrote to Asquith:

‘I think Bonar Law should be told that it is at least doubtful whether I shall stay if Haldane goes; that the injustice of the mad and malicious attacks upon Haldane in the National Review and Harmsworth Press have caused more resentment to Haldane’s friends and those who know the truth about him than any political question has ever aroused; and that now when these attacks have come to a head in this way, it is impossible not to show how one resents them.

If Bonar Law is really pressing the point, I think I had better see him and any of his friends who share his view, and tell them what I think, and how the matter stands. If you don’t object, I will write to Bonar Law and save you further trouble on this point.’

Grey saw Bonar Law, but had no success and finally did not himself resign.

The tone of Grey’s letter suggests that it was a struggle to persuade Asquith of the urgency of fighting to keep Haldane. And, in fact, much as Asquith clearly regretted dropping Haldane, there is no evidence that he fought at all hard with Bonar Law over this condition for coalition; he hardly seems even to have remonstrated about it.

His tone in letters of this time was rather one of self-pity: as he wrote to Viscount Samuel: ‘No one knows how much I have suffered. Very gladly indeed would I have gone. No one has made a greater sacrifice than I have.’

Haldane had no individual communication from Asquith at the time of his dismissal—just a circular asking for his resignation which the Cabinet received, and no reappointment.

Dismissal from the Cabinet meant being stripped naked for Haldane. The respect of his most senior colleagues and oldest friends was the last protection he had against the vicious attacks that were made on him from all sides. Churchill’s phrase ‘thrown to the wolves’ in Great Contemporaries was an apt description of what was done to Haldane. But Haldane was kind to Asquith in his account of the event:

‘I think that the Prime Minister was naturally concerned as to the necessity for this, for he and I were very old and intimate friends. So was I concerned, but mostly on his account, for I saw the first signs appearing of the movement to displace him likewise, and I was not sure that he would not have done better if he had displayed more of an iron hand in maintaining his position and that of his colleagues.’

Churchill’s description of Asquith at this time goes as follows:

‘When Lord Fisher resigned in May and the Opposition threatened controversial debate, Asquith did not hesitate to break his Cabinet up, demand the resignation of all Ministers, end the political lives of half his colleagues, throw Haldane to the wolves, leave me to bear the burden of the Dardanelles and sail on victoriously at the head of a Coalition Government. Not “all done by kindness”! Not all by rose-water! These were the convulsive struggles of a man of action and of ambition at death-grips with events.’

In this account Churchill is reacting over-strongly against his own removal from the Admiralty, which he took very badly and against an excessively wan image of Asquith that had obtained. But it is equally unjust to portray Asquith as a red-blooded political butcher.

As Roy Jenkins wrote, he was the ‘last of the Romans, essentially a man of Government, a great servant of the State, rather than a tribune of the people.’ He lived in the Whig tradition; a politician who resolved problems as they arose, making his decisions in the light of a clear intellect and a fastidious ethical code.

Asquith described once how he settled a Cabinet dispute. He waited before intervening:

‘A sudden curve developed itself of which I took immediate advantage with the result that strangely enough we came to a conclusion which satisfied McKenna and Grey and also Ll.G. and Winston.’

The problems that had arisen before the war, such as the constitutional struggle with the House of Lords, vast as they had been, had all been amenable to the Asquith treatment. Campbell-Bannerman’s phrase had been, when calling for Asquith to win a point or settle a crisis, ‘Send for the sledgehammer’ and the sledgehammer had worked. But suddenly in 1915 the sledgehammer no longer worked.

The colossal upheaval of war and the corrosive personalities it threw to the fore, such as Northcliffe and Lloyd George, required force to meet force; the force of a more dynamic, visionary personality than Asquith’s.

Therefore, baffled by the power of events, Asquith gave in rather too quickly and too easily to Bonar Law. Haldane’s prognosis was right. It was only another year before Asquith was himself removed from office by a palace revolution led by Lloyd George.

When the war was over Lloyd George split the Liberal party by making no accommodation with Asquith’s supporters at the coupon election and, later, by refusing to divest himself of the bulk of his party’s money. After the election of 1922, when the revolt of the Conservative Curzon club did to Lloyd George what Lloyd George had done to Asquith, both Liberal leaders became generals without an army.

Asquith’s activities at that time are revealing. Until his death in 1928, he was constantly striving to resuscitate the Liberal Party as it had been. Though he accepted his fortune with great dignity, he was lost without a position from which to exercise leadership.

By contrast, in 1915 Haldane had his own resources to fall back upon. His much earlier, private tragedy over Miss Fergusson had made him emotionally very self-reliant.

As he had then, in 1915 he threw himself into work; for universities, as before, and now increasingly for adult education. His interests in these areas drew him closer than ever to the Webbs—he had always been one of their strongest admirers—and to the Labour Party.

In his attempt to revive the Liberal Party, Asquith in January 1922 invited Haldane to be present at a big demonstration in the Central Hall, Westminster, at which Grey was to speak. Haldane replied:

‘I need hardly tell you that, so far as individual feeling is concerned I have the fullest desire to be by your side. Intimate association in public affairs during many years, and deep regard for you personally, naturally make me wish to be with you now. But there is a question of principle which for me is one of vital importance.

My public life has for long past been bound up with the cause of Education, more than with anything else. It is now so bound up more than ever...

It was for this reason that three years ago I decided for the future to work with whatever party was most in earnest with Education in the widest sense. I came to the conclusion that whichever of the existing parties was really most in earnest about the general enlightenment of the people would in the end get their confidence.

I observed then, as I observe now, the almost complete lack of harmony between my strong conviction on this subject and the programme of official Liberalism...

In the official programme, and even in your own speeches, I can find no response about the thing I care for before any other at this moment, and regard as the key to reform generally.

That is why I am driven to seek it where I see a chance of finding it. And that is why I feel I ought not to accept an invitation which in other respects I much appreciate. For I am with you in all else.’

Asquith replied:

‘Reports of speeches in the press in these days are meagre and often untrustworthy. But for a long time past I have hardly made a speech in which I have not emphasized this point. I enclose for your information a specimen (I could easily multiply them) of what I said at Bristol less than a year ago.’

A year after this interchange, Haldane was installed as Labour’s first Lord Chancellor. His support of Labour was an important factor in the election of 1923 and his availability was decisive in enabling Ramsay MacDonald to form a Cabinet.

Would Haldane have helped Asquith had he not let him down so badly in 1915? There is no telling. But the tone of Haldane’s letters is distinctly cool and it is possible that loyalty to his old colleague would have been stronger than the pull of his educational interests if he had felt secure grounds for such loyalty.

What is certain is that Haldane, through his vision and concentration on the substance of political change, had made a complete adjustment to the post-war world while Asquith was still lost in the past.