Camille Desmoulins, Revolutionary Orator, 1760-94
For a few years an impoverished barrister became one of the most effective orators and journalists of the French Revolution, writes John Hartcup.
The studious and childlike nature of Camille Desmoulins blossomed into revolutionary vigour on the day that he called the mob to arms in the gardens of the Palais Royal. Only then did his talents as a writer and rabble-rouser emerge. Up to this time he was miserably poor. What could be less promising than a barrister without a brief, a writer without a public, a tub-thumper with an impediment in his speech?
He was given a battery of names: Lucie-Simplice-Camille-Benoît Desmoulins. He was born at Guise in the province of Picardy on March 2nd, 1760, his father being Jean-Benoist-Nicolas Desmoulins, a lawyer practising in that town. At the age of ten he entered the College Louis-le-Grand. It was not long before his masters recognized in him a love for the classics that was to influence his political life so strongly and endue his writings with the learning of the ancients to whom he so constantly turned for parallels. At this college he began a life-long friendship with Maximilien Robespierre, which was to end so tragically. At twenty-four, following his father’s wish, he studied law and qualified as a barrister at the Grand Chambre de Parlement. But, finding insufficient work in Paris, he returned to his home town where he was also called to the bar. There he was equally unsuccessful.
Due to the imminent bankruptcy of the state finances, Louis XVI, in 1789, had recourse to the States General, which had not been convened for 175 years. Camille, together with his father and two cousins de Viefville, put up for nomination as delegates, one of which would be chosen to represent Guise in Paris. In this Camille also failed, one of the cousins de Viefville being elected. His disappointment was in no way lessened when he learned that his former college friend, Robespierre, had been chosen for Arras.
Camille now returned to Paris. He was without money and many are the pathetic letters he wrote to his father at this time. If he will not send him money, will he send him a bed, some sheets, some shirts, anything to alleviate his wretched existence? At the age of thirty we find him writing to his father: ‘All my life I have only wished for a house which I could call my own, but ever since I left Guise and renounced the paternal roof you have considered an inn to be sufficient shelter.’ This time, however, M. Desmoulins softened his heart and sent his son enough money to rent a room in the rue du Théâtre-Français, now the rue de l’Odéon. M. Desmoulins had shown his disapproval long enough. His son was now married to Lucile Duplessis - an excuse to show more leniency.
The procession of the Three Estates to Versailles took place on May 5th, 1789. It is described by Camille as one of the best days of his life. Writing to his father the day after, ‘The Duke of Orleans and Count Mirabeau’, he says, ‘in the dress of the Third Estate were conspicuous. Mirabeau wore a sword at his side. Our deputies held their heads high! And with reason, they had caput intra nubes.’
As yet only a spectator, Camille was passionately longing to make his way in the world. He wrote an Ode aux Etats Généraux; but this did not bring him the instant fame which he sought. On coming to power, Mirabeau startled the journalistic world by championing the liberty of the Press. He enlisted Camille to write for his paper, the Journal des Etats Généraux, which, however, died a quick death. Published on May 2nd, it was banned by royal decree on May 6th.
Events now moved swiftly. A royal sitting, fixed for May 22nd, at which the King was to make a speech before the National Assembly, was postponed and the deputies were refused admittance to the hall of the Menus-Plaisirs. Finally, the vicar of the church of Saint-Louis gave them shelter; and there the clergy allied itself with the Third Estate. The court was now in a panic, and the royal sitting could not be further delayed.
‘Versailles,’ wrote Camille, ‘was inundated with people who had come to witness the sitting. The Archbishop of Paris and the Garde-des-Sceaux were booed. Old Despremenil was nearly assaulted; and the Abbé Maury was rescued from the fury of the crowd only through the energy of a priest who lifted him up bodily and threw him into the carriage of the Archbishop of Arles.’ Further on we read that ‘all Paris is in combustion. The Palais Royal is as full as an egg. The Duke of Orleans is acclaimed everywhere with enthusiasm, while, when the King passes, nobody utters a word.’ The sitting was to end with Mirabeau’s famous reply to the Marquis de Dreux-Brézé, grand-master of ceremonies: ‘Go tell your master that we are here by the power of the people and we shall not be driven out save by the power of the bayonet.’ The assembly adopted Mirabeau’s resolution that deputies were inviolable. The Third Estate had obtained the legislative power.
Camille was in Versailles when, on July 12th, it was rumoured that the King had dismissed Necker, appointing as his new finance minister the Baron de Breteuil. With a journalist’s nose for news, he was the first to inform Paris. There, jumping on a table in the gardens of the Palais Royal, he harangued a vast crowd with the words:
‘To arms! to arms! Take all of you green cockades,the colour of hope! Citizens, there is not a moment to be lost: M. Necker is dismissed. This recalls to patriots the tocsin of a Saint Bartholomew. This evening all the German and Swiss battalions will come fiom the Champ-de-Mars to assassinate us. There remains only one resource, to take up arms and adopt cockades by which we may know each other.’
It was then necessary to decide on a cockade. Should it be green, the colour of hope, or the blue of Cincinnatus, the colour of liberty in America? Camille tore a leaf from a tree, and the crowd followed his example. Green had become the rallying sign of liberty. It was now nearly four o’clock in the afternoon. The crowd, which had steadily grown, became menacing. Camille, applauded on all sides, was dragged off the table and carried shoulder-high through the gardens. He had become their leader.
For the next few days he was to be the idol of Paris. Meanwhile, M. de Flesselles, mayor of Paris, was assassinated for refusing to distribute arms, and the Bastille fell. Louis now went down to the assembly and for the first time allied himself with it. He had made his peace; he must now reconcile Paris. Of the King’s entry into Paris Camille writes: ‘Louis XVI, without guards, surrounded by 250,000 of the Paris militia, was to recognize his errors and humble the pride of a great throne before the majesty of the French people.’
Camille now published a pamphlet entitled La France Libre which, throughout, evoked a spirit of unbounded optimism:
‘Listen, from one end of France to the other, Paris and Lyons, Rouen and Bordeaux, Calais and Marseilles, the same cry is heard. How I thank you, O heaven, that I was born at the end of the century! Each day patriotism spreads like a fire fanned by a strong wind. Youth becomes exultant. For the first time old men do not regret the past; they even blush at the thought of it.’
From Philippe le Bel to Louis XV, he showers abuse on French monarchs. They were all either debasers of the coinage, greedy, murderers, or slothful. Failing this, weak, or imbeciles like Charles V, Louis XIV was a bad parent, a faithless friend, selfish; a vindictive, cruel and crafty prince, a persecutor jealous to the point of madness, with only admiration for himself. He saw no further than his own ends, thinking that all belonged to him, including the lives of his subjects and their wives.
The Discours de la Lanterne aux Parisiens is even more scathing than La France Libre. In it Camille styles himself custodian of a lantern which then hung above a grocer’s shop where the rue de la Vannerie, now extinct, entered the Place de Grève. In fact, it was not a lantern but an iron horizontal from which a lamp - or corpse - could be suspended. The lantern became famous; it served as a gibbet for the first victim of the revolution. It was here that the body of Flesselles was hoisted for exhibition.
Commenting on the events of the night of August 4th when the Constituent Assembly, for so the National Assembly now called itself, abolished feudal privileges, Camille said: ‘It was not on Easter-eve but on the night of August 4th that France was delivered from the Egyptian Servitude.’ He continued with a denunciation of those who benefited from the old order of things. ‘What a disastrous night it must have been for the gentlemen-ushers, for the secretaries and under-secretaries, for the valets de chambre, the lawyers, the King’s servants; for the bloodsuckers of the State, the financiers, the courtiers, the cardinals, bishops, abbots and priors.’ After the publication of the Discours de la Lanterne, he recognized that the writing of pamphlets was not enough to keep in the public eye. The first number of his journal, Les Revolutions de France et de Brabant, appeared on November 28th, 1789.
The state of France at this time was, financially speaking, analogous to our own present economic predicament. The French government was bedevilled by a shortage of money; and, when all the sources of wealth had been drained, the only resort was inflation. Meanwhile, the court sat on golden chairs, throned in the clouds. Further it could do nothing.
Always volatile, Camille now painted a wholly erroneous picture of the situation. He would have us believe that France was approaching a second Golden Age. His inconsistency was that of a weathercock, changing direction according to the prevailing opinion of the hour. He attacked his friends and enemies alike; but the next minute he praised them and applauded their actions. He talked about ‘that animal the King’, and maliciously taunted the Queen by claiming that her only authority was ‘the power of procreation’. He did not mean half what he said, but wrote to please the masses and employed vulgar humour to amuse them. As a writer he had achieved such immense popularity he must hold his place. So he descended to the lowest and most loathsome devices to attract an audience. In No. 29 of Les Revolutions de France et de Brabant he was forced to apologize to M. de Crillon for having called him a ‘doubtful citizen’. It was a matter of this or payment of 100,000 livres damages. The honest Bailly was compromised, and Lafayette did not escape suspicion.
It is just at this period that his friendship with Mirabeau began to wane. He received no invitation to write on his friend’s new paper, Le Courrier de Provence. The two men no longer shared the same opinions; and, as a result, Camille was obliged to leave Versailles where he had been the guest of Mirabeau and partaken of his cellar and table. But back in Paris he was soon to marry Lucile, a little blonde-haired girl of twenty, and set up house in the rue du Theatre-Français.
The following year, 1790, as a result of Camille’s repeated attacks, Mirabeau at last openly censured this ‘audacious journalist’. Camille, he declared, must be denounced in public; he must hear for himself, from the Assembly, what people thought of him, and speak in his own defence for the libels published in his newspaper. Mirabeau had, until recently, been Camille’s friend and, therefore, limited himself to a verbal vindication of his honour; but M. Malouet, who had been continuously libelled, was determined to see justice done and drew up a list of complaints, which he submitted to the criminal magistrates at the Chatelet. He went so far as to ask that Camille be certified insane.
On August 2nd, when Camille was present in the Assembly, Malouet rose and with great simplicity said, ‘If Camille Desmoulins is innocent let him justify himself. If he is culpable I shall be his accuser and the accuser of all those who may stand in his defence. Let him vindicate himself if he dares! Camille was unprepared, and jumping to his feet could only say ‘Yes, I dare’. But an ominous silence followed. He fumbled for words, stuttered something inaudible and quickly left the hall. This retreat could have been disastrous, had not Robespierre eloquently defended him and so prevented his almost certain arrest.
The year 1790 was now drawing to an end. Its close was to herald the happiest time of Camille’s life. When he had been miserably poor living in Paris, the Luxembourg Gardens had seen the growth of his early friendship with Lucile, daughter of a rich, middle-class official in the Ministry of Finance. For a long time M. Duplessis had refused his consent to the marriage; but now he relented, and on December 11th Camille wrote to his father: ‘Today I find myself at the height of my expectations. I have had to wait a long time for happiness, but it has arrived at last and I am as happy as any mortal can be. Charming Lucile, of whom I have spoken so often and whom I have loved for eight years, has accepted my hand and her parents have given their consent.’ But Camille’s father’s consent was likewise not immediately forthcoming, and it was not until M. Duplessis had written explaining the position that he gave his approval of the marriage.
Camille’s views on religion were well known; but Roman Catholicism was still sufficiently strong for permission for a church marriage to require a declaration of faith. He was not put off by what he considered a mere formality. After all, when the marriage ceremony had taken place, he could deny everything. Was he not to show his contempt for Papism in his last newspaper, Le Vieux Cordelier: ‘We devour God’s teaching as we would swallow an oyster!’?
The wedding took place on December 29th at the church of Saint-Sulpice. As witnesses Camille had chosen Robespierre, Brissot, Pethion and Mercier. They each held a pole supporting the canopy under which Camille and Lucile stood before the altar. Who would have thought that in the space of four years these friends would turn against each other? Robespierre was to send Camille and his wife to the guillotine; Brissot was to fall through Camille’s pamphlet, Brissot Unmasked; Pethion to commit suicide to escape being sentenced to death by the Revolutionary Tribunal.
Between June 1791 and August 1792 the French monarchy committed irrevocable mistakes, ending with the King’s suspension and imprisonment with his family in the Temple. August 10th marks the end of the monarchy, and its collapse made Danton Minister of Justice and Camille his secretary. Camille and Lucile now went to live with Danton at the chancellery in the Place Vendome, where they delighted in the well-furnished rooms and the walls richly adorned with tapestry. Camille felt that he had become a personality just because he was lodged in the house of a minister and could afford expensive food and wine. He was still such a boy that the extravagances of life meant a great deal to him. To his father he wrote:
‘My friend Danton has become Minister of Justice by the grace of the cannon. The cause of liberty has triumphed. Here I am installed at the palace of the Maupeou and the Lamoignon.’
The Reign of Terror began with the September massacres. The people, with Danton as their leader, became the real rulers of France. Camille, like his friend Danton, was aware that the appetite of the people had to be satisfied, released, as he wrote, ‘from a tyranny dating back to the Merovingians’. September 21st, the day after Valmy, saw the opening of the National Convention. Camille had been elected deputy for Paris - not without some misgivings on the part of the electors as to whether such a brilliant satirist was fit to occupy a responsible position in the government.
He now turned his attention to the destruction of the monarchy by writing a pamphlet, printed by order of the Convention, entitled Opinion of Camille Desmoulins, Deputy of the Convention for Paris, on the Judgment of Louis XVI. It was a reply to Necker’s Reflections presented to the French Nation regarding the proposed trial of Louis XVI. As was hardly surprising, Necker’s attempted vindication of Louis fell flat; it was described by Camille as ‘the laughable attempt of an idol, itself trampled underfoot, to raise another also overthrown’.
In April 1793 the Committee of General Safety and another called the Committee of Public Welfare became the real seat of power; and, although the Convention remained, it was through these two committees that France was governed.
In May Camille published a pamphlet entitled Fragment de l'Histoire Secrète de la Révolution, but the sub-title, l'Histoire des Brissotins, came nearer the mark. It was a violent attack on the Girondists, and Brissot was singled out as an enemy of the French Republic. Shortly after its appearance the Girondists were put under arrest. Few escaped the guillotine. Meanwhile Camille himself,
Ame enfantine et mobile, et folle: oiseau de flamme,
Esprit defaune et coeur de femme,
was softening. Moderatism was to be his undoing. He committed himself by defending his friend Arthur Dillon who, when he held off the Prussians at Valmy, had assured Dumouriez of victory. Dillon had been thrown into prison, accused by the Committee of General Safety of plotting to rescue the Dauphin from the Temple and proclaim him King as Louis XVII. But, though he saved Dillon, his Histoire des Brissotins was the death-knell of the Girondists. When the jury at their trial gave a verdict of death, Camille jumped up exclaiming: ‘Oh! My God! It is my Brissot Unmasked,’ and fainted.
The struggle for complete power among the different sections of the Jacobin coalition now increased in bitterness. In the centre were the Extremists, the followers of Robespierre, St Just, Couthon, Collot d’Herbois, Barrere and Billaud-Varennes. To the Right, the Moderates, among whom were Danton, their leader, Desmoulins, Herault de Sechelles, Fabre d’Eglantine and Philippeaux. Lastly, on the Left, Hebert, Chaumette, Anacharsis Clootz, the leaders of the Paris Commune.
After the fall of the Girondists Camille remained silent, fearing lest his pen might cause him to commit further indiscretions. He was waiting for the moment to preach a more tolerant line, since he was becoming fearful for his own safety. One evening, when Danton and Camille were walking together along the Quai des Lunettes, Danton watched the last rays of the setting sun reflected in the water of the Seine. Turning to Camille, his eyes full of tears, he said: ‘Look! The Seine is running blood. Too much blood has been spilt. Take up your pen and ask for clemency; I will support you.’
The first number of the Viewc Cordelier appeared on December 5th, 1793. Initially, Robespierre supported Camille, for he saw in this publication an instrument to eliminate the Hebertists. But, although the paper became immensely popular, Robespierre at once felt himself compromised. This was the beginning of Camille’s downfall. Robespierre, seeing the danger he ran by allowing Camille a free hand, insisted that he submit proofs for censorship.The Vieux Cordelier was undoubtedly Camille’s masterpiece. Never before had he handled those cruel weapons of ridicule with such dexterity.
A break was inevitable. However much Robespierre might wish to see the overthrow of the Hebertist faction, he could never suffer his own name to be compromised by one such as Camille. The publication of No. 5 of the Vieux Cordelier was a volte-face. Since it appeared after a proposal, seconded by Hebert, to expel him from the Jacobins, this number was taken up with a vindication of his character, in the course of which, by denouncing the leader of the Commune, he repudiated his plea for moderation and clemency. It was the Camille of former days who now spoke.
The day the paper appeared a special meeting was held at the Jacobins where it was decided that Camille should be made to answer for his conduct. Collot d’Herbois instigated the enquiry and proposed that Camille’s vindication should be read aloud. Camille, instead of making a straightforward reply, tried to excuse himself. This, in itself, was enough to arouse suspicion. Immediately he had concluded, Robespierre rose and delivered a speech demanding that No. 4 should be burned. Camille, as once before when he had said ‘Yes, I dare!’, impetuously exclaimed: ‘To burn is not to answer.’ He had fallen into a trap, and Robespierre took him at his word. It was decided that the third and fourth numbers of the paper should be read.
Camille had always needed friends. He needed them now more than ever. With Danton’s power waning and Robespierre a declared enemy, it already seemed that the knife was about to fall. Having often known fear, he was now terrified at his indiscretion. February 15th, 1794, saw the publication of No. 6, the last of his writings to appear during his lifetime. Again he attacked Hebert, but with little conviction.
The Dantonists were steadily losing both popularity and power; yet it was in the Hebertist faction that the Convention saw their most dangerous opponents. St Just drafted a report alleging that both the Hebertists and Dantonists were in foreign pay; and that, although they represented seemingly different views, they were both striving to throw the republic into confusion. Chaumette at once asked that the report be submitted for immediate perusal. The Committee of Public Welfare had triumphed. Nobody now dared challenge its power. The arrest and execution of the Hebertists followed. Only the Moderates remained. They must also be annihilated. If the government showed leniency it might itself be accused of moderation.
On March 30th St Just delivered a speech at the Convention demanding the arrest of Danton, Desmoulins, Philippeaux and Lacroix; and the downfall of the Moderates was accepted with scarcely a murmur of dissent. The warrant of arrest was signed, and exactly a week after the fall of the Hebertists the Moderates were imprisoned in the Luxembourg.
The scene outside the Palais de Justice on the morning of April 3rd was menacing. Paris had turned out in its thousands to see ‘Justice’ done. The people had grown tired of bloodshed; and, whatever the verdict of the Tribunal, they were unwilling to see Danton and Camille summarily condemned. Against Camille there were two charges: his defence of General Dillon and his attack on the Committee of Public Welfare, when he had asked for clemency in No. 4 of the Vieux Cordelier. The trial was to last four days, and all were condemned save one, L’huillier, to show, perhaps, a semblance of impartiality.
It was a beautiful April evening when the three tumbrels conveyed the Moderates to the scaffold. Though the leaves on the trees had not yet turned the rich green of summer, Camille must have been reminded of that July afternoon when, in the gardens of the Palais Royal, he had called the people to adopt them as cockades. The sun was already setting when the victims reached the Place de la Revolution. Camille, who at his trial had declared that he was thirty-three, the age of the sans-culotte Jesus - he was, in truth, thirty-four - said on mounting the scaffold: ‘It is thus that the first apostle of liberty should perish!’ And then, ‘Oh my poor wife!’ Nine days later, she, too, met the same death.

