Ballads of a Nation

Christopher Harvie examines Scottish cultural identity since the Act of Union, and argues that writers and intellectuals have been the real keepers of the national flame.

At the beginning of the 1997 general election campaign in Scotland, the Scottish National Party’s delegates were told to ‘play down the kilted image’. This surprised no one. The same advice was given seventy years earlier to the infant National Party of Scotland by its president, ‘Don Roberto’ Cunninghame-Graham. This was odd counsel coming from perhaps the most flamboyant MP ever -- laird, essayist, gaucho cowboy, and socialist veteran of the Bloody Sunday riots in Trafalgar Square in 1887. But Don Roberto’s career and views emphasised the gulf between the popular image of the country and the ideas and ambitions of Scottish political activists.
‘Streitbar [quarrelsome]und intellektuell’ was how a German commentator, Reiner Luyken of the newspaper Die Zeit in 1992, described the writers, thinkers and artists who kept Scottish national identity alive through the three hundred years of union. It is perhaps apt that the world’s first purpose-built poetry library preceded the parliament building at Edinburgh’s Holyrood. The intellectuals’ collective shift from cultural to political nationalism in the twentieth century underlies the success of Europe’s most legalistic autonomy movement, with a ‘civic’ ethos far removed from the simplicities of ethnic nationalism.
But what about Braveheart --- the kilted image pur sang? Not a few observers have actually attributed SNP success to ‘the Braveheart factor’ put in play by Mel Gibson’s Hollywood version of the medieval wars of independence. All Scottish parties clambered onto the William Wallace bandwaggon, as they had done in the Unionist 1860s when a spiky monument was raised above the site of his greatest victory at Stirling. In 1996 it was the Conservative Secretary of State for Scotland, Michael Forsyth, who undid Edward I’s work by repatriating the Stone of Scone from Westminster Abbey to Edinburgh Castle. His MPs were wiped out in Scotland a few months later.

To continue reading this article you will need to purchase access to the online archive.

Buy Online Access  Buy Print & Archive Subscription

If you have already purchased access, or are a print & archive subscriber, please ensure you are logged in.

Please email if you have any problems.



Get Miscellanies, our free weekly long read, in your inbox every week