Mental Illness: A Curse and a Blessing

Jerome Carson and Elizabeth Wakely explore the mental illnesses suffered by some famous historical figures and consider the impact on their lives and achievements.

Photograph of Abraham Lincoln with his son Tad (Thomas), who died aged 18 in 1871Every schoolchild has, or should have, heard of Winston Churchill, Florence Nightingale, Charles Darwin and Abraham Lincoln, but how many people know that they suffered from mental illness? In 2009 Tony Blair’s former communications director, Alastair Campbell, and the writer Nigel Jones wrote a short paper for the Time to Change anti-stigma campaign entitled, ‘A World Without: The Fantastic Five’. They argued that, if Churchill, Nightingale, Darwin, Lincoln and Marie Curie had been alive today, the stigma and discrimination that exists towards the mentally ill would have prevented them achieving what they did and that as a consequence the world would have been a different and a poorer place. But it may also be that, despite some hindrances and setbacks, the mental suffering experienced by Lincoln, Darwin, Nightingale and Churchill actually facilitated and contributed to many of their successes and achievements. Such a theory of a creative malady is well known in its application to those in the creative arts but less so for those in other disciplines and in public life.

Want the full article and website archive access?

Subscribe now

Already a member? Log in now


Sign up for our free weekly newsletter


3 issues for £5


Subscribe Today