School Segregation in the USA

Mark Rathbone puts the famous 1954 school segregation case, Brown v. Board of Education, into historical context.

Any student of civil rights in the USA knows about Brown v. Board of Education, the 1954 Supreme Court case which outlawed racial segregation in schools. The United States Constitution put the Supreme Court at the head of the judicial branch of government: ‘The judicial Power of the United States shall be vested in one Supreme Court and in such inferior Courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish.’ Its purpose is to determine whether particular laws passed by Congress or by State legislatures, or decisions made by the executive branch, are in accordance with the Constitution or not. Ever since the case Marbury v. Madison in 1803, the Court has had the power to ‘strike down’ laws which it decides are unconstitutional.

Originating in 1950, the Brown case was brought by Oliver Brown, an African-American from Topeka, Kansas, with the help of the Legal Defence Fund of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP). Brown’s seven-year-old daughter Linda had to walk through a railway marshalling yard and cross a busy main road to catch a bus to the all-black Monroe School on the other side of the city, instead of attending the whites-only Sumner School a few blocks from her home. The famous 1896 Supreme Court case Plessy v. Ferguson concerned separate compartments in railway carriages, but the Court’s opinion left no doubt that the constitutionality of the provision of ‘separate but equal’ facilities for different races had more general application. It specifically described ‘the establishment of separate schools for white and colored children’ as ‘a valid exercise of the legislative power’ and led to the spread of ‘Jim Crow’ laws. Named after a stereotypical black music-hall character, these laws enforced racial segregation in all walks of life, including schools, across the southern United States. In practice, though, the facilities were separate but often far from equal, and segregation was used to keep African Americans in a subservient position.

Fifty-eight years later, however, the unanimous ruling of Chief Justice Earl Warren’s Supreme Court declared segregation in education to be unconstitutional, overturning the Plessy judgement. But Brown (actually, one of five cases which the Supreme Court combined) was neither the first nor the last such case: the issue had first been ruled upon in an American court more than a century earlier and the Supreme Court is still hearing school segregation cases in the twenty- first century. This article looks at the history of segregation in education and asks how and why the issue has been, and continues to be, at the centre of the struggle for civil rights in the USA.

Roberts v. City of Boston

As early as 1849, the Massachusetts Supreme Court had heard Roberts v. City of Boston, in which African American parents, led by Sarah Roberts, challenged the legality of Boston’s racially segregated schools. They lost, but they had placed the issue on the political agenda and six years later the state legislature ordered the integration of Massachusetts schools, the first state in the Union to do so. But over a century later, few states in the South had followed Massachusetts’ example.

Furthermore, it was not only African Americans who suffered from segregation. Soon after the Plessy ruling, the San Francisco School Board established a segregated primary school for Chinese children, including those who were American-born, later also applying the segregation policy to Japanese children, reflecting a tendency to lump together all those of Asian origin. ‘Our children,’ declared the School Board in 1905, ‘should not be placed in any position where their youthful impressions may be affected by association with pupils of the Mongolian race.’

This statement reveals the reality behind the ‘separate, but equal’ veneer: ‘our children’ meant white children, and they were to be protected, as from a plague, from contact with other races: much the same rationale applied whether, as in this case, they were Asian Americans or, more numerously, African Americans. Interestingly, the San Francisco School Board reversed this action under pressure from President Theodore Roosevelt, a rare example from that era of a President intervening to protect the civil rights of a racial minority.

LULAC

In some parts of the United States, it was Hispanics who were forced to attend separate schools. This term refers to people of Latin American, Spanish or Portuguese ancestry, sometimes also called Latinos. This highly diverse group included not only recent immigrants from Mexico and other central or south American countries, but also the descendants of Spanish settlers extending back many generations. Some of the first antisegregation lawsuits concerned this ethnic group. The League of United Latin American Citizens (LULAC) was formed in May 1929 to fight for the civil rights of Hispanics, and some of its earliest campaigns were against school segregation. In 1931, LULAC brought the first lawsuit against segregated ‘Mexican Schools’ in Texas, Salvatierra v. Del Rio Independent School District. The 1946 case, Mendez v. Westminster, brought an end to segregation of Hispanic children in California’s schools, while two years later Delgado v. Bastrop Independent School District similarly outlawed the segregation of Mexican American children in Texas. Although the NAACP grabbed the headlines with the Brown case, LULAC had led the way, winning cases in state courts for eight years before Brown.

Another front in the struggle against segregation in education concerned universities. As early as 1938, in Gaines v. Canada, the Supreme Court ruled that Missouri’s practice of sending African Americans to a law school in another state could not satisfy its obligation to provide equal facilities. Predating Brown by 16 years, this was one of the first major cases involving a federal court overruling state authorities in racial matters.

Sweatt v. Painter

In two 1950 cases, the Supreme Court returned to the issue, ruling in Sweatt v. Painter that Heman Sweatt’s education at a separate law school for African Americans in Texas was not equal to that provided at the state’s law school for whites. In the second case, determined on the same day, the Court ruled in that George McLaurin, an African American teacher seeking a doctorate in education, had been discriminated against by Oklahoma University. He had been reluctantly admitted to the university, but was not allowed to sit with the rest of the students during lectures, suffering the humiliation of being made to sit by himself in an alcove to one side of the hall.

The Brown case then, momentous though it was, did not come out of the blue, but followed several similar cases involving either higher education or Hispanics. Why then was Brown regarded as such a major breakthrough? First, at that time African Americans were both more numerous and more widespread than Hispanics or Asian Americans, so a case involving them was bound to have greater implications. Secondly, while the proportion of Americans who progressed to higher education was relatively small in the 1950s, every child went to school, so every family in America was potentially affected by Brown.

But Brown did not end the issue. Chief Justice Earl Warren softened the blow for Southern whites by announcing that, although the Court had ruled on the principle of segregation, it would return to the case to decide how states should implement the ruling. But the Court’s 1955 judgement, popularly known as Brown II, which ruled that desegregation in schools must take place with ‘all deliberate speed’, was merely the beginning of a lengthy period in which many southern states sought to avoid desegregation.

NAAWP

The proposed desegregation of the High School in Milford, Delaware in September 1954 led Bryant Bowles to form the so-called National Association for the Advancement of White People. Named obviously in response to the NAACP, it was never in reality a national organisation, being confined to Delaware and a few surrounding states. At a meeting attended by some 2,000 people, Bowles held up his three-year-old daughter and said, ‘Do you think I’ll ever let my little girl go to school with Negroes? I certainly will not!’ Desegregation in Milford was postponed until 1962, and the last all-black school in Delaware did not close until 1970.

In Indianola, Mississippi in July 1954, the first White Citizens’ Council was formed, also to resist desegregation. By 1957, there were White Citizens’ Councils throughout Mississippi, Alabama and other southern states, with a combined membership of around 250,000. Their main tactic was economic intimidation and their recruitment of bank managers, doctors and insurance brokers gave them the means to make it effective. African Americans who tried to send their children to ‘white’ schools found they could not get mortgages or other forms of credit, and medical care and insurance were refused.

The White Citizens’ Councils cultivated an outward appearance of respectability, avoiding the ranting, rabble-rousing tone of the NAAWP and the sinister white robes and burning crosses of the Ku Klux Klan. But their resistance to desegregation could nevertheless be accompanied by violence; John Kasper, executive secretary of a Citizens’ Council in Tennessee, was twice jailed for violent campaigns against the admission of African Americans to schools in Clinton and Nashville.

This was not exceptional. In 1960, the admission of six-year-old African American Ruby Bridges to an all-white school prompted a rabid speech from Leander Perez to a large meeting of the New Orleans White Citizens’ Council. As a result, whites rioted and attacked African Americans on the streets. Ruby herself was threatened with poisoning and was so frightened that for a whole term she dare not eat her packed lunches. Some white parents withdrew their children from Ruby’s class.

Little Rock, Arkansas

The most notorious incident in the school desegregation campaign came in 1957 when a white mob prevented the admission of nine African American students to Central High School in Little Rock, Arkansas, with the encouragement of Governor Orville Faubus. President Eisenhower sent a thousand paratroopers from the 101st Airborne to protect the nine students and to restore order. The ordering of troops into a Southern state to assist African Americans for the first time since 1877 brought back memories of Reconstruction, the period of rebuilding after the American Civil War, when the former Confederate states in the South were occupied by federal forces and a series of civil rights measures were passed by Congress.

Opposition to desegregation was encouraged by Southern political leaders. The Southern Manifesto, published in March 1956, referred to Brown II as ‘this decision which is contrary to the Constitution’, and accused the Supreme Court of ‘a clear abuse of judicial power’. Its principal promoter was Senator Strom Thurmond, a southern Democrat and segregationist, who was to go on to become the longest serving Senator in US history, finally standing down in 2002, aged 100. Thurmond had run for President in 1948 against Harry Truman as a ‘Dixiecrat’ candidate, winning four states. He was elected Senator for South Carolina in 1954 and was the leading light behind the Southern Manifesto, persuading 19 of the 22 Senators for southern states and 77 of the 105 southern Representatives to sign it.

The authority of such a large proportion of their elected representatives certainly stiffened the resistance of southern states to the Supreme Court’s order to desegregate. As historian James T. Patterson put it in his 2001 study of the Brown case, ‘Easily the most effective resistance of southern whites came at state level, in laws and constitutional amendments aimed at evading compliance with Brown.’ State legislatures were able to put legal obstacles in the way of desegregation. For example, Georgia made it a felony for any state official to spend public funds on desegregated schools; Mississippi and Louisiana made it illegal for children to attend racially mixed schools. When federal courts ordered a school to desegregate, a common strategy was for the state to close the school and authorise state-supported tuition grants for the white students to attend private schools.

Freedom of Choice Plans

Another widely adopted strategy was the approval of ‘pupil placement’ laws, which were passed in ten states. Avoiding the use of terms like ‘negro’ or ‘race’, schools were allowed to adopt so-called ‘freedom of choice plans’, which allocated students according to ‘morals, conduct, health, and personal standards of the pupil’. By this means, schools could be nominally desegregated, but still exclude black students in practice. Under Virginia’s pupil placement law, for example, school authorities considered hundreds of thousands of placements without finding one black student qualified to be placed in a white school.

These actions by state authorities may have been less newsworthy than mass protests like that at Little Rock, but they were much more effective in blocking progress on desegregation. On three occasions between 1958 and 1971, the Supreme Court returned to the issue to eliminate loopholes which allowed some southern states to evade compliance with school desegregation. In Cooper v. Aaron in 1958, the Court condemned the failure of Arkansas to desegregate schools following the 1957 Little Rock incident. In 1968, Green v. New Kent County outlawed ‘freedom of choice plans’, and the following year Alexander v. Holmes County approved mandatory desegregation of schools with immediate effect.

With all schools legally (de jure) desegregated, attention turned in the 1970s to de facto segregation, which was common in some northern cities: schools did not discriminate on racial grounds, but virtual segregation of housing areas led to schools often having overwhelmingly white or predominantly black students. It was not enough, it was argued, simply to take the negative step of removing race as a criterion for selection and hope that better race relations would follow. Proactive measures were needed to give a positive stimulus to greater racial mixing. A solution adopted in many cities was transporting students to schools across the city from where their lived, in order to achieve a better racial balance. In 1971, in Swann v. Charlotte-Mecklenburg, the Supreme Court declared this practice, known as bussing, to be constitutional.

Predictably, this was unpopular with white parents living in prosperous suburbs, whose children were forced to attend predominantly black schools in deprived inner city areas. Even in Boston, Massachusetts, where schools had been integrated since 1855, parents formed a pressure group, Restore Our Alienated Rights (ROAR), to campaign against bussing.

Debate Reignited

The fiftieth anniversary of Brown v. Board of Education in 2004 reignited debate about the case’s legacy and led to a number of revisionist books by Law professors questioning the view that desegregation had been the best means of ensuring equality of educational opportunity. In Silent Covenants, Professor Derrick Bell, Jr. argued that trying to ensure that separate schools were equal in resources and standards would have achieved better results for African Americans. Another revisionist, Professor Michael Klarman, argued in From Jim Crow to Civil Rights that Brown did more harm than good as it provoked a backlash from white southerners, and reinforced racist attitudes which had previously shown some signs of easing. According to Professor Risa Goluboff in the 2007 book, The Lost Promise of Civil Rights, NAACP lawyers would have been better advised to concentrate on economic inequality and discrimination in employment.

However, in a review of Goluboff’s book in Democracy Journal in 2007, Mary Frances Berry, a former chairwoman of the US Commission on Civil Rights, defended the legacy of Brown, arguing that if the case had not legally redefined equal protection, the subsequent triumphs of the Civil Rights movement, such as the Montgomery bus boycott, might have failed. ‘It was, in no uncertain terms, the inspirational fount for all that followed. Brown is not just a school desegregation case; it is emblematic of our national will to renounce segregation and to live up to the promises of American democracy.’

The Supreme Court also returned to the issue of school segregation in 2007, considering two cases, in Seattle, Washington and Louisville, Kentucky, where School Districts used race as a factor in admissions to ensure more integrated schools. The Court, under Chief Justice John Roberts, ruled by a 5-4 majority against the school boards, arguing that using race as a factor in allocating school places – even with the best of intentions – was a violation of the 14th Amendment’s equal protection guarantee. Berry’s interpretation of this decision was that, ‘the Robertsled Supreme Court has clearly announced that it is out of the desegregation business’.

Obama’s Inauguration

In September 2007, former President Bill Clinton went back to his home state to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the Little Rock Nine’s courageous stand for desegregation, and all nine of them were invited to Washington in January 2009 for Barack Obama’s inauguration as President of the United States. Whether it is pioneers of desegregation being feted in late middle age as symbols of past triumphs or the legality of current school admissions policies being determined by the Supreme Court, it is clear that more than half a century after the Brown case, school segregation remains a burning issue in American politics.

Issues to Debate

  • Why was the issue of segregation in schools such a major focus in the struggle for civil rights?
  • What is the difference between de jure and de facto segregation?
  • To what extent do you agree with Mary Francis Berry that Brown v. Board of Education was ‘the inspirational fount for all that followed’?
  • Why is an issue first addressed in US courts in 1855 still the subject of Supreme Court cases in the twenty-first century?