Polite Accomplishments
Anthony Fletcher delves into the diaries of teenage girls in the Georgian and Victorian eras to explore the little-changing constraints, punishments and occasional delights of being brought up a girl in upper-class Britain before the Great War.
By the mid-nineteenth century, the governess was a familiar and essential member of upper-class households where there were daughters. The census of 1861 listed 24,770 of them living in England and Wales. The notion that an upper-class girl belonged in the home was deep-rooted: she should be educated there in preparation to rule there in adulthood, as a mother and manager of the domestic economy. She would be a hostess to local society, while her husband lived out a public role. Girls were trained in ‘accomplishments’ such as needlework, painting, singing and musical performance in order to attract a wealthy husband. ‘Improvement’ was the watchword of this peculiarly English style of upbringing: long years after leaving the nursery stretched out towards the magical moment when girls would ‘come out’; when they were officially presented at court and launched by their mothers on the London ‘season’ and provincial society. During their first seasons they were expected to catch a husband.
For the well-to-do, growing up was a wholly and pervasively gendered experience. Boys learned to rough it in boarding prep and public schools from six or seven; it was seen as crucial for them to cut the apron strings. Boys’ schools were large and deliberately institutionalized, whereas if girls ever did go to school these tended to be small, private and domestic in their style.
The arrival of a new governess was a nail-biting moment. Lucy Lyttleton, nearly fifteen, had already seen governesses, including a French Mademoiselle, come and go, when she described in her diary the arrival of Miss Smith at Hagley Hall in June 1856:
On the 5th came our new governess, a nice real comfortable English one, ladylike and pleasant-looking, she has begun us so well: our week divided into Monday and Thursday for Italian, Tuesday and Friday for French, Wednesday and Saturday for English.
In the 1860s, Georgiana Trench reported on the arrival at Cangort Park in County Offaly of Mademoiselle Maffey, who looked ‘sensible and kind’. She was taking charge of her three youngest, Louey, Isabel and Blanche: ‘I am favourably impressed on the whole for which I am thankful’, she told her eldest daughter.
Schoolroom routines were determined by the governess, and were cast in stone. Literature, history, geography and nature study were the kind of subjects that dominated the curriculum. Life at Renishaw, Georgina Sitwell (born in 1824) remembered, was ‘a perfect treadmill of learning’. Morning lessons, the afternoon walk, and more lessons, were followed by the change into best clothes for an hour downstairs with Mama. Girls might play her their latest piano piece or show her successfully completed schoolroom work. Glimpsing the adult world in ‘white-jacketed frocks with sashes’, the Sitwell girls in the 1840s, went ‘to sit at our parents’ dinner table during dessert’. They were allowed nothing themselves, because sweet things were not thought good for children, except a plain biscuit.
Edith Wall, governess at Bark Hart, Orpington, around 1900, regularly took the Howard girls for walks for nature observation. Under her supervision, they made watercolour paintings of plants they had seen and listed wild flowers and vegetables found under cultivation. Clare, the youngest of them, recalled her white cotton pinafores as ‘regulation day-time wear’. They were ‘a badge of childhood I much resented’. The freedom of the morning break roaming outside, out of the way of elder sisters quick to reprimand for drawers or a petticoat showing, was the highlight of Clare’s day, despite rules that she and sister Amy respected, like only eating half a dozen berries from the strawberry and blackcurrant patches.
Pasting was seen as inculcating care and attention to detail. Charlotte Bloomfield’s scrapbook, in the 1820s, and Louey Trench’s in the 1860s, testify to dedicated encouragement of patient and meticulous schoolroom work. Charlotte’s governess Miss Ridout clearly saw Charlotte’s scrapbook as an extended social history and geography lesson, giving her numerous drawings of English landscapes and mansions for pasting in. There are 288 items in all, including sketches by family friends. Louey’s scrapbook, heralding the advent of photography, was a veritable work of art: crests cut from envelopes and other ephemera jostle with pictures of family luminaries, household pets and Mademoiselle Maffey herself with her young charges.
This was an intensely personal kind of education, in a cloying domestic atmosphere. Many remembered a particular governess with warmth, affection and appreciation. Sophia Baker’s diary note at twelve years old, when Miss Laborde left her Hertfordshire home Bayfordbury in 1794, was a moving tribute:
She was a good governess, minded her duty very particularly and never spake but the truth, She was likewise very neat and clean both in her person and dress, was a remarkably nice workwoman and was very anxious for our going on well, walked out with us in all weathers when Mama wished us and gave us all the little comforts she could think of.
Lucy Lyttleton was grateful to Miss Smith for the history and literature she learnt. Louisa Bowater was devoted to her German governess, Agnes Lentz, between 1855 and 1860, who was keen on instruction in mythology and geography, but also gave her, she believed, her strong moral values. She visited Agnes in Hamburg in her former governess’ old age.
Deportment was taken very seriously. Elizabeth Bradshawe, born in 1798, recalled her governess Miss Cook’s insistence on kneeling upright before her for morning prayers. ‘I wonder God does not strike you dead for poking so’, she once warned Elizabeth’s sister Maria. ‘To improve our figures we were made to lie half an hour every day on boards and then to walk up and down the passage with weights on our heads’, wrote Barbara Tasburgh, born in 1815. Mary Butt, spotted with a tendency to stoop, was subjected to a back-board, strapped over the shoulders, from six to thirteen. ‘I groan under fearful inquisitory exercises’, Lucy Lyttleton wrote in 1857, ‘for the wrenching my shoulder blades into shape’. Diagnosed with weak spines in 1875, Eva and Kate Knatchbull spent an hour on the floor each day. Angela Forbes remembered sitting with straps and ‘what-nots’ on her shoulders and her feet in stocks. ‘Hold up your head, Miss’ was the constant cry which echoed through Lucy Aikin’s childhood: she recalled back-boards, iron collars and ‘a frightful kind of neck-swing in which we were suspended every morning’.
There were tales of woe from early schoolroom years, when some governesses used their discretion to punish excessively. How could we tell tales, wrote Mary Carberry, who was born in 1867, to parents who only saw a governess ‘in her charming manners’, when she brought the children to the drawing room?
They do not know how deplorably artful we are growing: how in our fear we try to propitiate her with flowers, peaches and tender enquiries after her relations.
Mary Williams recalled the strict Miss Blackburn, who around 1810, when she was stuck in her lesson ‘or showed the least sign of rebellion and temper or impatience’, shut her in a closet, ‘till I could say with a cheerful voice that I was quite good’. Throughout her adulthood, Mary Haldane was haunted by the sound of the closing door when she was put in an empty room for punishment as a child in the 1830s. Lucy Lyttleton recalled Miss Nicholson, who ‘spanked me for obstinacy when I was only dense’ and terrified her out of her wits, by walking her on the parade at Brighton ‘with my hands tied behind me’, declaring ‘it was ten to one we should meet a policeman’.
Thus Eliza Fox, daughter of a barrister brought up in Regency Chichester, was told by her Mama, at seven, that she had to ‘leave off being a tomboy’ and learn to behave ‘like a young lady.’ Educated there beside daughters of aspiring Sussex parents, Eliza attended the soirées intended to tone the manners of the boarders ‘and take away that want of ease so common in young ladies reared in a farmhouse far removed from fashionable society’. The headmistress of this establishment took care of deportment by showing off her girls in the cathedral on Sundays. She put them through their paces in the ‘Garland Dance’, ‘a wonderful display of graceful action’, performed for the benefit of the city’s fashionable social circle. Finished at a London boarding school, Eliza’s training worked like a dream. Back home to help look after younger siblings and caught one day by an early visitor sweeping the drawing room, she discussed Wordsworth’s Lyrical Ballads with poise. ‘I must say I don’t often meet with a housemaid so ladylike and intelligent’, he was heard to remark.
Elizabeth Bradshawe, born in 1798, attended a Doncaster boarding school in her teens. Masters for piano, harp, guitar, drawing, writing and flower painting visited in turn to instruct the girls. Miss Murphy, the headmistress, arrayed the girls for dancing lessons in white, ‘with primrose coloured sashes, gloves and shoes’. Elizabeth recalled her as ‘very particular about our carriage: we were to make a sweeping curtsy to those assembled before advancing.’
Decorum was the be-all-and-end-all at Mrs Devis’s school in Queen Square, London, in the 1790s: ‘every movement of the body in entering and quitting a room, in taking a seat and rising from it, was duly criticized.’ A coach was kept by the school so that girls could practise alighting from it in the correct manner.
When they returned to their home near Canterbury, Mary and Fanny Papillon, at school at Great Camden House in Kensington in 1835, told their parents they hoped ‘you will think us improved’. Their account of making their gardens, working worsted material and taking French lessons from a visiting master relates to a typical pattern of individual tasks in ‘the carved schoolroom’ there, which a contemporary lithograph well illustrates. It shows pupils dotted around the room engaged in a range of activities. There is no concept of division into classes or uniform work.
A tradition among provincial gentry families of sending teenage girls for a period in London was well established by the early eighteenth century. Lady Elizabeth Smyth, in Somerset, sought the improvement of her daughters Betty and Astrea in 1710. They stayed with her sister-in-law in the Haymarket, attending school and working with private writing, spinet and dancing masters. ‘We desire that they may have anything that is for their good’, wrote Lady Elizabeth, ‘only desire that they may be bred humble and not too nice to live after our plain way.’ ‘They are as much improved as can be expected for the time,’ her sister-in-law reported after a few months, ‘and are the prettiest girls in the school.’ Betty and Astrea, she was confident, ‘will be very neat and genteel.’ Lady Anne Cust, in Lincolnshire, was on the same tack in the 1740s, when she placed first her Betty, then her Jenny, then her Lucy with a trusted relative, Mrs Woodcock, in London. ‘I think her improved and that she will make a genteel woman’, Lady Anne declared, welcoming Lucy home in 1746.
Leading provincial towns offered comparable, if less remarkable, educational facilities for parents seeking these courses in politeness. Mary Chorley’s father, much away on business, boarded her with her aunts, the Misses Fords, in Lancaster, where masters called to give her lessons six mornings a week. Her diary, from the age of ten to thirteen, recounts her graduation from visiting as play to practice of the real thing. On July 7th, 1776, she noted, her friends Nell and Maria came and ‘we played at visiting’; on May 1st, 1778 ‘it being my birthday I had many young ladies to drink tea with me’; on June 2nd, 1780, Mary spent a ‘delightful afternoon’ having tea and dancing with her friends at Elhill, an actual social debut inscribed in her surviving diary.
Country house parties, private balls and tennis and croquet on the lawn were essential ingredients of this new scene. The ritual of visiting cards taking account of girls in their late teens accompanying their mothers on social calls, their names printed underneath, shows how etiquette was formalizing. The conventions of ‘coming out’ became fully established: pinafores were abandoned, hair was put up, hems came down. Clare Howard, five years old, watched with awe the departure from Bark Hart of her sisters Edith and Maud for their presentation at court to Queen Victoria in July 1897.
For an upper-class mother presentation of her daughter at court was the climax of years of social training in accomplishments. Sophia Baker, presented to Queen Charlotte on February 13th, 1800, made a long diary entry that evening:
I was presented by Mama … I was dressed in white with a festoon of roses, three yellow feathers and a gold chain in my hair, a set of topaz earrings, clasp and locket, all kind presents … The Queen was very gracious and good humoured … Mama was in purple velvet.
A hectic programme of operas, assemblies and balls filled Sophia’s first London season. Suitors began to gather around the debutante: Sophia developed a particular fondness for a Mr Methicke, whom she ‘much missed’ when it came to the next Hertford Ball in the local season.
At fourteen, Lucy Lyttleton still lived a schoolroom life, cleaning out her rabbits and learning about boiling turnips outside lesson hours. Piano practice was her daily chore. For one lot of visitors to Hagley Hall she had to play her duets three times: ‘I learnt today the tiresomeness of boring people with one’s company uninvited from twelve to five.’ Her public debut came at the Queen’s Ball in April 1856, when she was not yet fifteen. She and her sisters Meriel and Lavinia were dressed alike, ‘in tarlatan frocks, trimmed with white ruches, twined round with some very pretty pink trimmings’. They wore ‘wreaths of pink roses’ in their hair. Visits to the theatre for King Lear and The Winter’s Tale in 1856 were followed by Handel’s Messiah the following year, ‘wonderfully done’.
Lucy’s coming out was very gradual. At a dinner with her widower father Lord Lyttleton in June 1858, ‘for the first time I was bowed at to leave the room… I didn’t know if I was on my head or my heels’. Still sixteen, she ordered dinner at Hagley ‘for the very first time in my life’, reflecting in her diary with the expostulation ‘Oh dear’. ‘I mean to read a good deal’, she told Catherine Galdstone, her Aunt Pussy, just before leaving the schoolroom on September 5th, 1858, her seventeenth birthday,
... then it will be nice being more au fait of everything, from hearing the talk at breakfast ... Altogether I look forward greatly to my out life.
An autumn round of country-house parties preceded the social initiation of Lucy’s 1859 London season. ‘I am exhausted with behaving properly’, she wrote after two days of the first of these at Alderley in Cheshire. ‘I enjoyed it greatly and kept clear of all scrapes’, she reasoned after a visit to cousins in North Yorkshire, where ‘for the first time in my life’ she played cards for money. Staying with the Robartes family at Lanhydrock and the Carew Poles at Antony in Cornwall was exciting, with a trip in a post-chaise to Tintagel a special highlight. But going home to Hagley for Christmas, blowing bubbles with her brothers and playing draughts, whist and backgammon, was a merciful release from social performance. The year ended with her first local ball at Stourbridge, ‘not in bed till past three, nor up next morning till eleven-thirty’. It ‘felt so dissipated’.
Papa set the rules for Lucy’s first season: ‘two balls a week’, no waltzing (which was seen as threatening her aristocratic inviolability and chastity) and opera only when it did not include the ballet. She wrote her diary in snatched moments. Royalty was the heart of this experience. Lucy recorded her nervousness at meeting Queen Victoria when she was presented on June 7th:
The look of interest and kindliness in the dear little Queen’s face … the way she gave her hand to me to be kissed filled me with pleasure that I can’t describe and that I wasn’t prepared for … I feel as if I could do anything for her. She said to Aunt Pussy ‘you have brought your nieces’ to me with great feeling … So touching of her for no doubt she was thinking of our having no Mama to bring us.
Chronicling those months, Lucy portrayed them as a time of chaste but romantic encounters. She swooned at meeting the Comte de Paris, as the exiled King of France was called. She kept failing in her aim to dance with him but did manage to converse in her best French. ‘Low was my curtsy, most gracious was his bow’, ran her account of her introduction to the Duc d’Aumale. Her Aunt Emmy had warned her that this first season would be testing. Lucy told her on May 27th,
I quite agree with what you say about society ... only I do hope very earnestly that it may do me good in many ways – teaching one carefulness in talk, giving one opportunities to avoid silliness – and then the perpetual need of self-control.
The return to Worcestershire at the end of July was a much needed break. ‘Thank heaven’, ran her diary entry that evening, ‘we came home to the dear bright snug quietness of green summer Hagley’.
But what was the cost for these girls of a social training which constrained their bodies and their minds, channelled their energy into practising the rituals of a subordinate role? The diaries and letters of Kate Stanley, born in 1842 into a boisterous, argumentative family, are revealing in this respect. Kate quarrelled with her godmother about Jane Austen’s ‘dreadful’ novels. In her mid-teens, she discovered a certain freedom in the field. Riding her horse Silistria, she found he ‘would be in front and at one time ran with me nearly through a bush after the huntsmen’, as she told her Mama describing this first hunt. From twelve to eighteen, her vigorous intellectual life focused upon her brother Lyulph, triumphantly successful in his academic career at Eton and Oxford, with whom she corresponded incessantly.
A clever girl, at ease with a clever brother, it now dawned on Kate that society was an enormous bore. She was attending lectures at the Geological Museum, reading John Stuart Mill on Liberty, immersed in debates on Darwin’s Origin of Species in 1860, the year that she came out. ‘I do not think balls quite the perfection of amusement’, she confessed to Lyulph, ‘I think I should get tired of them and it is so much trouble to talk to silent men’. Back at Alderley, her Cheshire home, after the London season, Kate was not satisfied with tennis, card games, billiards and croquet, ‘rather amusing but not as engrossing as everybody says it is’. Wildly jealous of her brother, she nevertheless clung to him as an intellectual companion to whom she could let off steam.
The candid expression of inner feelings by Victorian girls was unusual but not unknown. ‘I wanted so much to be a boy’, wrote Gwen Raverat (1885-1957), ‘that I did not dare think about it at all, for it made me feel quite desperate that it was impossible to be one.’ Mary Haldane longed to play cricket ‘and to go out spearing with the boys and ride to hounds.’ Seeing her uncles come in from cubbing or setting out to shoot, Mary Carberry wanted ‘to be one of them, to exchange my silly frock and socks for breeches and gaiters, to have my hair cut short, to feel my face hard and rough, to throw my leg across a horse to ride and ride and ride’. She prayed ‘with all my might to be turned into a boy’, Emily Lytton (1874-1964) declared. Roaming the estate of her home, Knebworth Park in Hertfordshire, she was ‘always a hero of some kind.’ Emily lived for her fantasy life: ‘never have I known happier moments than when, sallying forth into the Park, armed with bow and arrows, I pretended to be Robin Hood, Ivanhoe or Richard Coeur de Lion’.
Further Reading
Anthony Fletcher, Growing Up in England: The Experience of Childhood 1600 – 1914 (Yale UP, 2008); Kathryn Hughes, The Victorian Governess (Hambledon, 1993); Amanda Vickery, The Gentleman’s Daughter: Women’s Lives in Georgian England (Yale UP, 1995); Christina de Bellaigue, Educating Women: Schooling and Identity in England and France 1800 –1867 (OUP, 2007)
- Anthony Fletcher is Emeritus Professor of English Social History at the University of London.

