Octavia Hill and the Influence of Dickens
In housing management and the preservation of the countryside, writes Alan S. Watts, Octavia Hill was a Victorian pioneer.
Among public-spirited Victorian women, Octavia Hill (1838-1912) was pre-eminent.
She was the pioneer of housing management, became the adviser of politicians and ecclesiastical commissioners, and devoted the final years of her life to helping preserve the countryside for her fellow countrymen.
Her biographers rightly stress her great debt to John Ruskin, who not only enabled her to begin her housing work by providing the necessary capital, but compelled her to confront the fact (which she tried to avoid) that her talent for art was mediocre, while her personality and many-sided abilities made her uniquely qualified for work among the poor.
Undoubtedly, Ruskin’s friendship and outpouring of ideas made a tremendous impression upon her; but it is clear that Dickens also played an important part in shaping her basic thoughts on the work she was to do.
To trace this influence we must first consider the friendship between Dickens and Octavia’s grandfather, Dr Thomas Southwood Smith (1788-1861). This began when Dickens was writing Nicholas Nickleby which first came out in monthly parts during 1838, the year of Octavia’s birth.
It was an important friendship for both men. Dickens learned a lot from the doctor, and in the novelist, Southwood Smith gained a powerful ally in his fight for better sanitation.
Octavia’s grandfather is today almost forgotten but he was a scientific life-saver comparable with Sir Alexander Fleming of our own generation. He had begun his career training for the Baptist ministry, although after a year serious doubts led him to become a Unitarian.
He found employment with a Bristol manufacturer whose daughter he married. Two children were born to them, Caroline, the elder, being destined to become Octavia’s mother.
Then, when Southwood Smith was twenty-four, his wife died. Heartbroken, and believing all his undertakings in England to be doomed to misfortune, the young man abandoned his employment and went to Edinburgh to start life anew by studying medicine.
After qualifying, he came to London where he rapidly established himself. He built up a flourishing practice and gained appointments as physician to the London Fever Hospital, the Eastern Dispensary, and the Jews’ Hospital in Whitechapel. He also lectured on anatomy.
But perhaps his most important work at this time was with his pen. His contributions to the early numbers of Mill’s ‘Westminster Review’ attracted considerable attention, and his article on ‘Contagion and Sanitary Laws’, together with a treatise he wrote on this subject in 1830, led to his nomination to the commission of inquiry into the causes of fever in London.
The Report on the Sanitary Conditions among the Labouring Classes in London, for which he was largely responsible, appeared in 1838. Its graphic accounts of the way people managed to exist in such neglected districts at Bethnal Green and Whitechapel made a great impression on the comfortable inhabitants of the wealthier districts.
They shocked Dickens too, which is revealing, for, as an observant journalist, he was by no means unaware of what London was like. He therefore made a point not only of getting to know the doctor personally, but of going to see these degraded places at first hand.
In 1842 appeared another report, largely from the doctor’s pen - the first report of the Children’s Employment Commission - to be followed by a second a year later. Just how deeply Dickens was stirred by these disclosures can be judged from a note he sent to Southwood Smith on March 6th, 1843.
‘I am so perfectly stricken down by the blue book you have sent me, that I think (as soon as I have done my month’s work) of writing and bringing out a very cheap pamphlet called “An Appeal to the People of England on Behalf of the Poor Man’s Child”.’
The pamphlet was never written, but the doctor was delighted to find the country’s most popular novelist fighting at his side. A Christmas Carol and The Chimes were both designed to strike ‘a great blow for the poor’, and later a whole group of Southwood Smith’s ideas were expounded in Bleak House.
Its descriptions of slum rookeries (Tom-All-Alone’s), of festering graveyards and polluted water supplies, of the dangers to all sections of the community from fever bred in the filth of mean streets, make Bleak House very much Southwood Smith’s novel.
Its very title suggests an insanitary dwelling. Its hero is a doctor working in a slum district. It opens in a fog - which Southwood Smith and, later, his granddaughter were hopeful of abolishing.
It was probably under Southwood Smith’s influence that Dickens began to attend Mr Tagart’s Unitarian chapel where for some years he rented a pew.
Certainly it was the interest aroused by these reports that led him some years later to advise Miss Burdett Coutts of the urgent need for improved working-class tenements, and in 1851 to tell the Metropolitan Sanitary Association that ‘even Education and Religion can do nothing where they are most needed until the way is paved to do their ministrations by Cleanliness and Decency.’
In addition, when the doctor needed funds for his Sanatorium in Marylebone, Dickens put on a production of Ben Jonson’s ‘Every Man in His Humour’ with himself, Forster, Mark Lemon, and Douglas Jerrold taking the principal parts.
Octavia’s sister, Gertrude, then aged eight, was living with her grandfather at that time, and in later life recalled having been present at one of the performances and seeing the play from a side box.
Whether Octavia herself ever met Dickens is not known. She was, however, brought up against the family background of concern about social conditions, and as a small girl was often at her grandfather’s house where, at one time or another, he entertained most of the leading figures in the cause of sanitary reform - such men as Chadwick, Kay-Shuttleworth, and Lord Shaftesbury.
We know Dickens also dined with Southwood Smith and that the doctor attended some of Dickens’s celebratory Greenwich dinners. So it is quite likely that Octavia saw Dickens at her grandfather’s. People - such as Browning - who met the little Hill girls were greatly impressed by their uninhibited ways and intelligent talk.
Octavia’s mother, Caroline Southwood Smith, had herself at quite an early age achieved national fame as an educationalist. When a governess, she had taken a deep interest in educational theory, particularly in the teaching of infants.
Her articles on this latter subject first brought her to the attention of James Hill, a prosperous corn merchant in Wisbech, who had founded one of the first infant schools in the country.
James was then a widower with six children, and he persuaded Caroline to come to Wisbech to teach them. Soon she married him, and bore him another five daughters, of whom Octavia was the third.
Although James was an energetic, public-spirited man, his business failed in the serious financial crisis of 1840. A few years later he suffered a physical and mental breakdown from which he never recovered.
Caroline then brought her young charges to Finchley, not far from Southwood Smith’s house at Highgate.
When Octavia was thirteen, Caroline was appointed secretary to the newly-founded Ladies’ Co-operative Guild, which necessitated a move to London.
No doubt, her father’s influence was useful in obtaining this appointment, but it seems possible that Dickens also had a hand in it.
At any rate, the upper floor of the house in Russell Place, Fitzroy Square, where the Guild established its headquarters was occupied at that time by the wife of Richard Hengist Horne whom Dickens had engaged as assistant editor of ‘Household Words’.
Horne was about to embark for Australia as Dickens’s special correspondent in company with William Howitt, Southwood Smith’s next-door neighbour and also a contributor to Dickens’s magazine.
The Ladies’ Co-operative Guild came to Mrs Hill’s assistance at a critical time. It also gave Octavia her start in life. She was only thirteen, and anxious to become an artist. She began by learning the craft of painting glass, which she decorated with designs in bright pre-Raphaelite colours.
Subsequently the glass was ‘consolidated’ by a sort of cement which rendered it strong enough to form small tables, cabinets, and what-nots. It was this work on ‘consolidated glass’ that led to her first meeting with Ruskin.
But the painting was soon supplemented by another job, and this - appropriately for the granddaughter of Southwood Smith - was connected with the employment of children. After a year or two she wrote an article about it which was accepted by Dickens for ‘Household Words’.
This was no mean achievement for a girl with no journalistic experience, ‘Household Words’ being a leading magazine to which only one submission in eighty was successful. But her article - entitled ‘Ragged Robin’ - was well-written, and, more important perhaps, it dealt with a subject close to Dickens’s heart.
It described her experiences as supervisor of a group of child toymakers recruited from a ragged school. Her duties included buying the raw materials, training the children how to make doll’s furniture, and seeing that each finished article was of the requisite standard.
Because each little girl was paid according to her individual output, Octavia had to keep detailed accounts and render periodic statements to the Guild auditors.
But she was not concerned with production only. Young as she was, she was very anxious to enrich the children’s lives. She had no inhibitions about social class and no false modesty; she saw she was vastly better endowed and educated than her charges, and made it her duty to try to redress the balance.
She used to read to them - Mary Howitt’s Steadfast Gabriel was a firm favourite - and pass on snippets of information as the opportunity arose - a chat about cobwebs and spiders, for example, when a spider was seen hanging from its thread.
She also taught her children to resist the temptation of buying such things as the ‘stout pale pudding, heavy and flabby’ on which David Copperfield had misguidedly spent his pennies.
Instead, she made them club their funds together and buy ingredients for a meal they could cook for themselves. She also insisted that mealtimes should be decorous. She made them clear one of the work-tables and spread a clean cloth, so that they could sit round like a family at home.
Ill-health prevented Octavia continuing this work beyond 1857. Nevertheless, for many years after the group had broken up, she retained her interest in the welfare of the individual members.
On the demise of the parent organization, the Ladies’ Co-operative Guild, Octavia was obliged to rely on teaching for her livelihood. She also worked as secretary to the Working Women’s College, and put in many hours copying pictures and making drawings for Ruskin.
In 1864 she began the work she is famous for. She persuaded Ruskin to purchase the property in Paradise Place which was to be the prototype of her ‘courts’, and allow her to manage it on lines that had been maturing in her mind for some years.
The state of the property when she took it over was appalling, and so was the condition of the tenants. Yet in a remarkably short time she had transformed both place and people.
She introduced habits of cleanliness, started savings clubs, taught the women to sew, found employment on maintaining the property for the men who had fallen out of work, and instilled into all her tenants a growing sense of community.
But she still considered herself to be a teacher by occupation. The housing work was not done for reward, but to realize an ideal. As she wrote later:
‘Ruskin risked upwards of £3,000 in the experiment, when not many men would have trusted that the undertaking would succeed.
And moreover, while he assured me that his money was entirely, fully, and freely given for the good of the cause, and if it was sunk, would never be regretted by him, yet he foretold that the work would spread if I could make it pay, and urged me therefore to try - a foresight and practical wisdom far beyond mine at the time.
I remember well smiling supreme amazement, and saying, “Who will ever hear or know? The important thing is to make it a good thing, realizing as far as may be, your ideal and mine.”’
‘Household Words’ was one of the channels by which people did come to hear and know. Octavia was brilliantly successful in her experiment, and she and her trainees (who included Dame Henrietta Barnett, Emma Cons, Lady Courtney and her sister, Beatrice Webb) did an immense amount to improve housing conditions.
If we are to ask where she obtained her initial ideas, we must acknowledge that most of them came from her grandfather, and many from Ruskin. But they were matured in discussions around the family fireside, where in the Victorian tradition, Mrs Hill and her daughters took it in turns to read aloud.
Here they heard not only Shakespeare and Browning, but articles from ‘Household Words’ and instalments of Dickens’s novels. It is difficult to believe that the description of Pancks and his employer, the rapacious property-owner, Casby, together with the accompanying details of bad debts, arrears of rent, and the unwillingness of landlords to do even the most necessary repairs, went unnoticed.
So, too, they must have discussed Dickens’s strictures on charity, especially his portrayal of its debilitating effect on Mr Dorrit and his daughter, Fanny, and noted in the same novel Dickens’s charming picture of the avuncular turnkey who suddenly recognized that Little Dorrit had seen nothing of the world except the inside of a debtors’ prison, and so,
‘they used to issue from the lodge on alternate Sunday afternoons with great gravity, bound for some meadows or green lanes that had been elaborately appointed in the course of the week; and there they picked grass and flowers to bring home.’
Octavia had led her toymakers out for Sunday excursions in the same way and they had returned to Fitzroy Square laden with bluebells and other country spoil.
In the spring of 1867, Dickens accepted another of Octavia’s articles. This was entitled ‘Poor Playgrounds’ and appeared in ‘All the Year Round’ on May 4th.
By this time Octavia had persuaded Ruskin to acquire a second piece of property, ‘a wretched court’, as she described it, but with the great advantage of having space for a playground at the rear. Octavia’s article dealt with the difficulties of providing even this simple amenity.
There was bitter opposition from neighbours, walls were pushed over, stones thrown at workmen. Even when the playground was completed, the children for whose use it was intended merely stood about. They had no notion of how to play, and had to be taught.
Octavia emphasized the extent of this deprivation. Not only were they completely ignorant of games and songs, but of almost everything outside the court (very much like Little Dorrit). Nevertheless, they had a morbid interest in unhealthy things, like the condition of the corpses dredged from the Regent’s Canal.
At the close of the article Octavia expounded her views on the distribution of charity, views strenuously opposed by Beatrice Webb in My Apprenticeship. Octavia wrote:
‘One principle we have had carefully to observe in all our dealings with the poor. Hold back your hand from gifts of things they expect to have to provide for themselves. Do this for two reasons.
First, that you may encourage in them foresight, energy, and self-control. Add largely to their savings, if you will; give them materials, if they will manufacture them; above all, employ them if you can.
Secondly, if you will steadily refuse to give, you will drive yourself and others to face the question, Can a man live on the wages we pay him?
Private charity may back up for a time a hollow state of things, as the system of outdoor relief in aid of wages did; it may eat out our manhood and womanhood, our self-reliance and our providence; but it cannot make brave, healthy, honourable citizens.
Let us give up the plan of screwing down on our payments for work done, until a labourer can barely subsist on his wages while all goes smoothly with him, and stepping in with our charity when we happen to be touched with the sight of want.’
It was her firm belief that the old system of outdoor relief - the Speenhamland system - had brought untold misery and ruin, and that the New Poor Law, harsh though it appeared to be, had been necessary to correct the old abuses.
On this subject it may seem she was in opposition to Dickens, but he, despite his criticism of the way the New Law was applied, did not condemn its basic theories. Indeed, in his Postscript to Our Mutual Friend he wrote:
‘I believe there has been... no law so openly violated... In the majority of shameful cases of disease and death from destitution which shock the public and disgrace the country, the illegality is quite equal to the inhumanity.’
People needed adequate wages. They also needed entertainment, and Octavia wrote in ‘Macmillan’s Magazine’, July 1869:
‘I have tried, as far as opportunity has permitted, to develop the love of beauty among my tenants. The poor of London need joy and beauty in their lives.
There is no more true and eternal law to be recognised among them than that which Mr. Dickens shows in “Hard Times” - the fact that every man has an imagination which needs development and satisfaction.
Mr. Sleary’s speech, “Peoplemutht be amoothed,Thquire,” isoften recalled to my mind in dealing with the poor.’
Perhaps Dickens seldom or never crossed Octavia’s path, but he certainly walked the route ahead of her. As the years went on, Octavia’s housing work expanded until she had the management of several large blocks of property in various parts of London.
She was active, too, in preserving open spaces. She failed to prevent Swiss Cottage Fields, the countryside in which she had played as a child, from being built over. But she was more successful with Parliament Hill, Hilly Fields, and many other spaces, large and small.
This work with the Commons Preservation Society led her into a series of undertakings of increasing difficulty. She and her friends had begun by endeavouring to raise money for the purchase of threatened land.
They went on to prepare maps of footpaths and commons, to establish where there were rights of way, and fight court-cases to re-assert ancient rights. Soon the need for a central agency to hold land became apparent.
The fact that there was no way in which a person could leave land in trust for his fellow citizens was highlighted when Mr Evelyn, descendant of the diarist, found he was unable to do so with Sayes Court.
Octavia’s closest associates in these activities were Sir Robert Hunter of the Commons Preservation Society and Canon Rawnsley, who had been very active trying to prevent Thirlmere being turned into a reservoir for Manchester.
After discussing this question of a public body to hold land it was agreed that some form of company was needed. Octavia wrote to Sir Robert: ‘A short expressive name is difficult to find for the new company.’
She wondered whether ‘Commons and Garden Trust’ would do, adding: ‘I do not know that I am right in thinking that it should be called a Trust, but it might be better than Company.’ Sir Robert evidently agreed with her, for he pencilled in the margin “? National Trust”.
Octavia Hill died in 1912, and lies in Crockham Hill churchyard. From the church one can look out across Kent, the county which both she and Dickens particularly loved. Ide Hill, Toys Hill and Mariner’s Hill, all National Trust properties, are within view.
It might be said of her to anyone standing in that churchyard: ‘If you seek her memorial, look about you.’

