The Keelmen of Tyneside
From the fourteenth century until the building of the railways, writes D.J. Rowe, the Newcastle keelmen were indispensable and pugnacious carriers between collieries and sea-going ships.
Although coal was mined in this country in Roman times, the continuous history of the industry really dates from the fourteenth century. From that time onwards, there were several coal-fields in production, but the Tyneside coal-field had the advantage over many of the others in the availability of water transport—which was considerably cheaper than land transport—to markets beyond the region.
The major centre demanding coal, which had no local supply, was London, with its lime-kilns and other manufactories, especially after the sixteenth century when a growing shortage of charcoal increased the need for coal.
There was, therefore, a considerable market for the coals of Tyneside. For the coastal journey the coal was transported in colliers, which were too large to navigate the River Tyne, and so the coal was brought from stocks on the river banks down to the colliers waiting at Shields in barges, locally called ‘keels’.
These were oval in shape, some forty feet long by sixteen or twenty in width, and carried twenty-one tons at a load. They had a single mast on which a sail was hoisted if the wind was in a favourable direction; but otherwise they were propelled by a single oar forward, worked by two keelmen and a boy called the ‘pee-dee’, while a third keelman steered the boat with another oar at the stem.
The earliest mention of keels on the Tyne is in 1330, when a keel of wool was taken from Newcastle to Wardeley,1 but soon after this keels were being used in the service of the Priors of Tin-mouth and the Bishop of Durham to move coal from their Tyneside collieries.
At this time the coal trade was mainly local, it would seem, since in 1366, when the clerk of works wished to purchase 600 tons of coal, during the construction of Windsor Castle, he had not only to hire the colliers for the sea journey, but also to hire keelmen, to bring the coal down the Tyne to the waiting colliers.2
That the export of coal from the Tyne was becoming more regular is suggested by the fact that in 1384, Richard II appointed commissioners to measure the keels, and in 1421 an Act provided that all keels should be measured by the King’s Commissioners. Thereafter the practice of selling coals by the keel-load continued until the nineteenth century.
Before 1516 little is known of the history of the keelmen, but they are then mentioned in a decree of Star Chamber as the craft and fraternity of keelmen in Newcastle upon Tyne and on subsequent occasions are described as an independent society. They held a position of some independence between producers and purchasers of coal, but towards the end of the sixteenth century complete control of the coal trade came into the hands of the Company of Hostmen, while the keelmen declined into the position of servants to the hostmen, employed on an annual bond.
Originally the hostmen had entertained visiting merchants and provided them with supplies, especially of coal for which there was no trading guild; but gradually the hostmen came to specialize in coal and by a charter of 1600 obtained the exclusive right to trade in coal on Tyneside.
From a few score keelmen in the late sixteenth century, when the output of the Northumberland and Durham coalfield amounted to only about 65,000 tons, the number had increased to some 1,600 by the early eighteenth century when the output had risen to one and a half million tons.3 A large part of this increase in the number of keelmen was made up by immigrants from beyond Tyneside, chiefly from Scotland.
Many of these men returned to their families during the winter months, when the output of coal was reduced, and this tended to break up the old craft fellowship of the keelmen, as did their decline in social status to servants of the hostmen. Nevertheless, the keelmen remained a very active body of workmen, always ready to act to protect their interests, as their turbulent industrial history shows. There is an entry in Gateshead parish books in 1671: ‘Paide for powder and match when the keelemen mutinyed 2s.’
Apart from industrial disputes, the keelmen came into conflict with their employers over the organization of their society. Early in the seventeenth century the keelmen had endeavoured to obtain a company charter, but this was prevented by the opposition of the hostmen.
Thereafter, the keelmen forsook such organization and endeavoured to form their own charitable society. This was necessary because of the lack of employment in the winter months, and also because the large number of Scottish keelmen were unable to obtain a settlement in Newcastle and were not, therefore, entitled to parochial relief.
In 1699, the keelmen ‘unanimously Agreed among themselves to sequester and set apart some small proportion of their dues or wages to be a publick fund or Bank for the Reliefe of themselves, their Widows and Children and also aged Skippers’.4
The keelmen requested the stewards of the Hostmen’s Company to be trustees of the fund and their employers to deduct four-pence, per keel per tide—journey to Shields and back—from the men’s wages, towards the fund. So successful was this organization that by 1701 the keelmen had built a charitable hospital for their sick and aged at a cost of over £2,000 to the fund.
The innate distrust between masters and men, however, soon brought about the collapse of the charity. The keelmen complained that the managers ‘wasted and embezzled’ the funds, and they tried to obtain a charter of incorporation to run the charity themselves. This was opposed by the hostmen, and neither masters nor men gained control of the fund, which was wound up in 1712 when the hostmen ceased deducting contributions from the wages of the keelmen.
The pressure of distress, especially during the winters, led to several further charitable organizations, but these proved unsatisfactory until a number of keelmen started a friendly society in 1730. It lasted for over half a century but was of limited use in that it had only some two hundred members who provided insufficient funds to run the Charity and keep the hospital in repair.
To improve this situation, both hostmen and keelmen made several attempts to obtain an Act forming a Charity to which all the keelmen would subscribe. While the dispute remained, that the keelmen wanted to control their own Charity, while the hostmen wished ‘the Government of the Charity (to) be lodged in the hands of Gentlemen of Rank and Fortune’, nothing was done, although the House of Commons approved the need to form a Charity.
Distress eventually forced the keelmen to compromise and agree to the formation of a Charity whose funds should be managed by Guardians chosen from the magistrates and hostmen of Newcastle; and in 1787 an Act obtained for this purpose authorized the Guardians to levy a sum of eightpence per tide on the wages of the crew of each keel.
The Charity, thus re-established, continued until 1872, when an Act abolishing levies made by Charitable corporations was passed and thereafter Newcastle corporation took over the hospital building of 1701, which still stands on City Road, Newcastle.
A major reason for the division between the keelmen and their employers over control of the Charity was an industrial one. In one of their petitions to Parliament the keelmen expressed their fears that if the hostmen controlled the Charity they ‘will be able to put what price they please upon the coals, load and refuse to load what ships they please, and by the same undue preferences, both at Newcastle and at the markets, which they formerly practised, bring the coal trade to the same degree of a monopoly which it was in before’.5
Similarly the hostmen feared that the keelmen would use control of the Charity to further their industrial disputes by giving strike pay from its funds. There is little doubt that the fears of both sides were justified. The hostmen limited the supply of coal in order to force up its price and in so doing damaged the economic position of the keelmen.
The latter, if they did not form an actual trade union, used concerted action both in their attempts to obtain control of their own Charity and during their numerous strikes, and they deserve to be placed alongside the wool-combers and tailors as the trades in which modern trade unions have their roots.
Together with the determined action, through petitions to various monarchs and Parliament, with which they endeavoured to gain control of their Charity, the main example of the effective combination achieved by the keelmen lies in the industrial action they undertook to maintain and improve their economic position.
After the strike of 1671, there were further major strikes of which evidence exists in 1708, 1710, 1719, 1738, 1740, 1749, 1750, 1771, 17945 1803, 1809, 1819 and 1822. Almost without fail, the same grievances against their employers occur from strike to strike; especially at the end of the eighteenth century when the keelmen were beginning to lose their economic power as new methods of loading coal into colliers were adopted.
In 1708 and 1710 the major complaint leading to the strikes was that the coal-owners were limiting the amount of coal sold and the keelmen were, therefore, suffering from want of employment. As a result of the latter strike, the keelmen obtained a fixed scale of wages according to the distance they had to transport the coal.
In May 1719 the Tyneside keelmen joined a combination with their fellows on the river Wear to strike for considerably higher wages. There is no evidence that this strike, which brought nearly the whole trade of the Northumberland and Durham coalfield to a halt, was aimed at forcing capitulation by the coal-owners because the London market would suffer.
This may well have been behind the combination; but in mid-summer the strike would have needed to last longer than it did before London felt the pressure of demand. The strike ended when the magistrates obtained the arrest of two of the ringleaders which led to the return to work of the remaining keelmen.
Of all the strikes, that of 1740 was the only one that resulted from anything extraneous to the keelmen’s trade. During the previous winter the Tyne had frozen and interrupted the coal trade for an exceptionally long period, while in the early summer corn prices were very high and there was much distress. The keelmen struck for cheaper food and the food-rioting that had occurred in several northern towns came to a head in Newcastle on June 26th, when keelmen and pitmen marched into the town.
In the disorder that ensued, the militia fired on the crowd, killing one of the rioters, which then stormed the Guildhall leaving it a ruin and taking £1,200 from the treasury. Until the evening, when some companies of soldiers arrived, the mob, composed chiefly of keelmen, had complete control of the town.
This was not the first occasion on which keelmen’s strikes had led to the stationing of soldiers in Newcastle, and four years later four companies of soldiers had to be sent to maintain order in Sandgate, the area where most of the keelmen lived. On this occasion the keelmen had struck because they were being forced to carry more than the usual load of eight chaldrons (21 tons, 4 cwts.) in each keel, and since they were paid only for the normal load they were losing money.
The coal-owners had been forced to give overmeasure to the buyers as a means of obtaining trade during a period of price-cutting. The strike was eventually terminated by the drawing up of a contract of the keelmen’s terms of employment, in which it was stated that the maximum load per keel was eight chaldrons.
By 1750 this agreement was being openly broken by the coal-owners, and in March a body of keelmen stopped work and so intimidated their fellows that all the keelmen came out on strike for several weeks.
The magistrates offered a settlement based on the I744 agreement, but the keelmen, who wanted more favourable terms, refused this, whereon the magistrates broke the strike by sentencing a number of keelmen to the house of correction and using substitute workers protected by the military to man the keels.
From their industrial record and the heavy nature of their work, it was inevitable that the keelmen should get a name for violence and roughness of living. This was not, however, the whole of the story. They were great sportsmen, Harry Clasper, a keelman, becoming a champion sculler. That they had a pleasing turn of humour is suggested by the story of a keelman caught by a press gang.
Seeing the magistrate release one man because he was an American sailor, the keelman entered the witness box and in broad Geordie declared, ‘Aa’s a Yankee tee, hinny.’ On many occasions when in Newcastle, John Wesley preached in Sandgate and was well received by large crowds of keelmen.
Although an immediate attraction, Methodism failed to convert the keelmen from their violent ways, since there were several strikes before the turn of the century, in one of which the keelmen did considerable damage to their employers’ property.
At the turn of the eighteenth century, the keelmen were beginning to feel the effects of the industrial revolution and the story of their subsequent decline in the first half of the next century places them with such other pre-industrial workers as the wool-combers and handloom weavers. In the years before 1800, a ‘spout’, a form of chute, was coming into use for loading coal direct into the holds of the smaller colliers without the use of keels, which meant that the keelmen were losing employment.
They began to have fewer keel-loads of coal, earned less, and some of their number suffered severe distress. Decline for all keelmen was averted by the fact that colliers could not pass up the Tyne beyond Newcastle to load at collieries farther upstream because of the low arches of Newcastle bridge. The collieries above bridge had, therefore, to continue using keels despite the new inventions.
Once again the keelmen took strike action in this new struggle against their employers. In October 1809 they struck in support of their demand for higher wages, because their total earnings were reduced by the growing use of the spouts. After some weeks of the strike, the keel-men’s demands were met by considerable wage increases. This victory ensured the quiescence of the keelmen for some time, but with the trade depression after the Napoleonic Wars and the increasing depredations of the spouts into their work, the keelmen came out on strike in 1819.
They outlined a number of grievances in a petition to the coal-owners, including the perennial one of over-measure in the keels, but their major complaint was that they had ‘suffered very great Privations from want of Employment, chiefly owing to the Vend by Spout having increased so much of late’ and they requested limitations on the use of spouts. Since this was asking for control of the way the coal-owners used their private property it led to a hardening of local opinion against the keelmen.
The strike dragged on for several weeks, coinciding with the reform agitation after the Peterloo affair. Quite naturally, the local authorities feared that the strikers and reformers might join in a revolutionary movement—although there was at no time any sign of this happening— and they obtained considerable naval and military support in case of disturbances.
The only danger occurred by accident when a group of marines killed one man while firing on a mob that had gathered at Shields when the magistrates and military had escorted a number of strike-breaking keels down river. The mob attacked an inn where the Mayor of Newcastle was sheltering, supposing that he had ordered the marines to fire, and that worthy gentleman had to escape by the back exit.
His fright led to demands for further naval and military forces, but these proved unnecessary since the strike was brought to a negotiated conclusion that satisfied some of the keelmen’s demands without doing anything about the spouts.
Only three years later the keelmen again came out on strike over similar grievances to those of 1819, which suggests that the agreement of that year had proved unsatisfactory. Basically, the strike was again over the inroads which the spouts were making into the trade of those keelmen who worked for below-bridge collieries, and it is indicative of the community of feeling that existed among the keelmen that those abovebridge, who were unaffected by the spouts, remained on strike for ten weeks in support of their below-bridge colleagues.
At the end of this period the keelmen returned to work since the strike was broken by the use of substitute workers and even one of the famous Wylam ‘Dilly’ railway engines mounted on a barge to tow keels. The keelmen did not, however, give up their determination to be rid of the spouts. In January 1823, armed with legal assistance, they began an action to have the spouts removed as being an obstruction to the navigation of the river.
The action dragged on until 1830, going through numerous courts and even reaching the Lord Chief Justice, but the eventual verdict was that although causing an obstruction, the spouts increased the trade of the river and their removal was not, therefore, justified.
This decision defeated the ingenuity of the keelmen and little more is heard of them in Tyneside history, although they remained an important part of the coal trade until well into the nineteenth century. With the advent of the railways in the 1830’s, many of the above-bridge collieries stopped using keels and had their coal transported to Shields by rail; while the removal of Newcastle bridge in 1876 and the subsequent deepening of the river channel to accommodate colliers meant the end of the keelmen’s trade.
Now nothing but memory remains of the keelmen apart from a number of Tyneside folk-songs in which their exploits are recounted, the most famous of which is the Keel Row:
As I went up Sandgate, up Sandgate, up Sandgate, As I went up Sandgate, I heard a lassie sing: Weel may the keel row, the keel row, the keel row, Weel may the keel row, that maw laddie’s in.
He wears a blue bonnet, blue bonnet, blue bonnet, He wears a blue bonnet, a dimple in his chin; And weel may the keel row, the keel row, the keel row,
And weel may the keel row, that maw laddie’s in, etc.
1 W. S. Mitcalfe, ‘The History of the Keelmen and their Strike in 1822’, Archaeologia Aeliana, Fourth Series, Vol. XIV, 1937, p. 1.
2 R. L. Galloway, ‘Earliest Records of the working of Coal on the banks of the River Tyne’, Archaeologia Aeliana, New Series, Vol. VIII, 1876-9, p. 195.
3 J. U. Nef, The Rise of the British Coal Industry, Vol. 1, p. 19.
4 F. W. Dendy (Ed.), Extracts from the records of the Company of Hostmen of Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Surtees Society, CV, p. 154.
5 F. W. Dendy, op. cit., p. 176.

