The French Ministerial Bureaucracy 1770-1850
Revolution and Red Tape by Clive H. Church
English historians often cast envious eyes at the plentiful administrative documentation which the French state amassed from the Middle Ages onwards, and which supplies splendid raw materials for their French counterparts. Surely these mountains of red tape constitute a monument to the precocious bureaucratisation of French government? Not so, argues Clive Church in this pioneering study: we must differentiate between bureaucracy and administration. The latter long predates 1789; the former was only really brought into being during the Revolutionary decade. The Revolutionary Government in 1793 and 1794 considerably expanded the size of the administration – at the height of the Terror more than 250,000 individuals held government posts. Then that much-maligned regime, the Directory, critically altered the nature of red tape, introducing a set of administrative procedures and organisational structures which were to usher France into the modern age. The new system was sufficiently close to Max Weber's 'ideal-type' bureaucracy, Dr Church maintains – 'a formal establishment of professional administrators organised on rational lines to carry out the wishes of a superior political will' – to merit the title bureaucracy.
The freshness of Dr Church's research comes over clearly in the number of times he is obliged to repeat a litany on the lines of 'no-serious-studies-have-yet-been-under- taken-on...'. It seems almost churlish to ask for more. Yet it must be admitted that although the administrative labyrinth is explored with great thoroughness and insight, the bureaucracy fails to come alive. This is a book about '-isations' rather than individuals, and although the author endeavours to flesh out his subjects with information on their social background, the bureaucrats remain – fittingly enough no doubt – a pretty faceless bunch. Moreover, so determined is he to view the bureaucracy sub specie Weberi – the Thermidorian regime, for example, is chided for not hastening fast enough along the royal route mapped out by King Max – that the wider social context of the new bureaucracy remains rather hazy. Did the growth of bureaucracy stimulate anti-Parisian feeling for example? And how do French developments compare against those in other contemporary states such as Great Britain and Prussia?
What a pity, finally, that greater bureaucratic efficiency has not gone into the production of this book. The very first and Iast quotations in French contain typographical or grammatical errors, and they typify the slipshod standard of the text throughout. It would be charitable to conclude that Dr Church's bureaucrats were bad spellers or that a dyslexic gremlin had been let loose in the works of the Clarendon Press. At all events, the catalogue of errors mars enjoyment of a serious contribution to an important topic.
Colin Jones
Revolution and Red Tape: The French Ministerial Bureaucracy 1770-1850
Clarendon Press: Oxford University Press, 1981; 437pp.

