'Cultivated Capital': 19th century patronage in northern England
'Where's there's muck, there's money'...but there was also culture and patronage of the arts in nineteenth-century Manchester and Leeds. By Janet Wolff And Caroline Arscott.
'What in the world do you want with Art in Manchester'? Why can't you stick to your cotton spinning?' This remark was made by a nobleman, on being asked to lend pictures from his collection to the Art Treasures Exhibition held in Manchester in 1857. This belief in the incompatibility of culture and industry, and in the fundamental philistinism of the northern middle class, was one which was widely held, and which went back to earlier decades. A reviewer of a book of poems published in Manchester claimed to be 'absolutely astounded' by this phenomenon, saying of that city:
There is something in the very name itself which puts to flight all poetical associations. Only couple, for instance, in your mind the ideas of Manchester and Wordsworth, and see if, by any mental process, you can introduce them into any sort of union. The genius of that great man would have been absolutely clouded for ever by one week's residence in the fogs of Manchester.
Moreover, this image of the new industrial cities and of their inhabitants has persisted to the present day. Contemporary historians refer to the supposed ignorance of the industrialists and manufacturers with regard to the arts, and their tendency to buy forgeries on the assumption that they were Old Masters. Although it is well known and accepted that many of these people were important patrons of the Pre-Raphaelites in the mid- nineteenth century, Quentin Bell has recently explained this exercise in taste as one based precisely on lack of knowledge:
These painters found their market among those whom contemporaries would have considered an ignorant and philistine clientele, the 'self-made' men and manufacturers of the North... The advantage from the Pre-Raphaelite point of view, of this kind of client, was that he would have been relatively uneducated. He would have been relatively uneducated. He would not have known enough to know that for a cultivated public, Pre-Raphaelite painting was full of faults.
The stereotype of the northern businessmen and manufacturers has not progressed far from the figures of Mr Gradgrind and Mr Bounderby in Dickens' Hard Times.
However, a study of the urban middle class of Manchester and Leeds exposes this stereotype as a myth, and reveals an extensive involvement in, and understanding of, the arts on the part of bankers, merchants, manufacturers and industrialists. The Art Treasures Exhibition of 1857 in Manchester itself was an important example of this. This was the first national exhibition ever to be devoted entirely to art (though its inspiration came partly from the Great Exhibition of 1851 in London). It enjoyed royal patronage, and was held in a specially built palace at Old Trafford, Manchester. The enormous number of works shown ranged from Old Masters to contemporary paintings and photography. Over a million people visited the exhibition. The motivation behind this event, as well as its planning and organisation, came from a group of merchants and manufacturers in Manchester, and notably Thomas Fairbairn, partner in a local engineering firm. But it was not only the 'second-generation' manufacturers who were active in the cultural life of their city. Fairbairn's own father, William Fairbairn, founder of the firm and a self-made and self-taught man, had been involved in the setting up of the Mechanics' Institute in1824, was a patron of artists (for example, Benjamin Haydon), and was also involved in founding the School of Design in Manchester (the first outside London) in 1838.
The participation of industrialists, financiers and professional men in culture and the arts took numerous forms. They were always central to initiatives for exhibitions and other cultural events. They were also active patrons and supporters of local and other contemporary artists (often along with members of the gentry). And they were active in forming new cultural institutions in the cities – institutions like the Literary and Philosophical Society (1781 in Manchester; 1819 in Leeds, where it was called the Philosophical and Literary Society), the Royal Manchester Institution (1823), The Mechanics' Institutes (1824 in both cities), the Schools of Design (1838 in Manchester; 1846 in Leeds), and the public libraries. They were clearly prepared to devote their time as well as their money to such initiatives. (Edmund Potter, the Manchester calico printer, complained that he had spent almost the whole of two years of his life organising the Art Treasures Exhibition.) In addition, the middle classes (in this case including professionals and others, as well as the 'high bourgeoisie' of commercial and industrial entrepreneurs) provided the basis for cultural and musical life in the two cities. In Manchester it was their support which kept going the Gentlemen's Concerts, and which brought Charles Hallé to that city in 1848; the calico printer, Hermann Leo, was instrumental in this. In Leeds, as well as supporting subscription concerts, bourgeois families began a society for musical soirees in 1848, in which music was played and enjoyed in members' homes. There is no doubt, then, that the cultural life of the middle class was lively and sophisticated. It is worth looking in a little' more detail at the specific activities of these people in the visual arts in the first half of the nineteenth century.
As direct patrons of art, the bourgeoisie had a most important part to play. We have already referred to the particular case of the support of some members of this group for the Pre-Raphaelites; it is generally agreed that this willingness to take risks with new (and so far unpopular) work was crucial to the fortunes of that particular group of painters. But the buying practices of the industrialists and men of commerce were far more wide- ranging than is usually assumed. William Hardman, a prosperous dry- salter in Manchester, had a major collection of art at the turn of the century, including, reportedly, works by Titian, Canaletto, Veronese, Ruisdael, Rembrandt, Wilson, Wright and Fuseli. Edward Loyd, a partner in a Manchester banking firm, had a collection specialising particularly in Dutch art (Cuyp, Hobbema, Ruisdael, Steen, de Hooch). Other local collectors had begun to patronise contemporary artists. Henry McConnel, partner in a Manchester cotton mill, owned several Turners and also works by lesser-known English artists, including local ones. Samuel and Thomas Ashton, of a Manchester family of cotton manufacturers, included in their collection works by Constable, Turner, Collins, Holman Hunt, Egg and Leighton. Leeds manufacturers were equally involved in building picture collections. Several of them loaned pictures for the three Polytechnic Exhibitions of 1839, 1843 and 1845.
A common way of buying paintings was to purchase them from the walls of the Royal Academy or from some exhibiting society. But painters would also take their prospective buyers into account in their work. It was also common for direct commissions to be agreed. Thomas Plint, a Leeds stock- broker, was an enthusiastic patron of the artist, William Mulready. He also commissioned Ford Madox Brown's now famous painting, Work (1852-65).
The commission for this painting provides an unusually clear example of the buyer specifying to the artist how he wanted the work done. (This practice, which was usual in earlier centuries, when patrons might specify how much gold or ultramarine paint the artist should use, or even how the painting should look and what it should contain, had retreated, as a conception developed of the artist as 'genius', expressing him- or herself in the work.) Having seen the preliminary sketches for Work, Plint wrote to the artist, asking him to 'change one of the four fashionable young ladies into a quiet, earnest, holy-looking one, with a book or two and tracts', adding 'I want this put in, for I am much interested in this work myself, and know those who are'. The artist complied with this request, even modelling the 'holy-looking' lady on Plint's own wife. The two figures on the right of the painting represent Thomas Carlyle and F.D. Maurice; Plint's request here had been for representations of Carlyle and Charles Kingsley. This case, though an unusual one, does draw our attention to the fact that the meaning of paintings is likely to be related in some (no doubt complex) way to the patron's values and ideas.
Another interesting example of patronage is the case of the commission of William Holman Hunt's The Awakening Conscience (see front cover) by Thomas Fairbairn, the Manchester industrialist mentioned earlier in connection with the 1857 Exhibition. In 1853, Fairbairn approached Hunt with the general offer of a commission; this eventually became a commission for this particular work, begun in 1853. Before Fairbairn took possession of the painting, Hunt exhibited it at the Royal Academy Exhibition of 1854, where it attracted adverse criticism. Two years later, Fairbairn asked Hunt to repaint the expression on the face of the young woman, as he found it too painful to live with.
Again, what is interesting about this commission is the relationship between patron, artist and work itself. Fairbairn's interest in the painting makes sense when we understand more about his social and economic position, and his views about politics and family life. He was one of Manchester's leading industrialists, and had emerged as a spokesman for a particular group of large engineering firms who had taken on and beaten the engineering trade union in a dispute in 1852-53. His social position in Manchester was enhanced by the fact that he had spent eight years living in London, where manners and habits were more advanced than in the provinces, and by the fact that he had married a southerner in Greenwich. He had already started collecting pictures, and owned genre scenes, allegorical works and a number of family portraits by modern British artists. He was a respectable public figure and a family man, who used the notion of the purifying effects of the home and of a wife's influence in letters he wrote to The Times, attacking the striking engineering workers. His commission of The Awakening Conscience' can be seen as consistent with the position and views that he held. It was a painting of a man visiting his kept mistress. He is playing a tune at the piano, with the woman sitting on his knee. The picture shows the moment when the woman suddenly realises the sinfulness of her situation. The scene is the opposite of a virtuous home, and as such it may have appealed to Thomas Fairbairn; the graphic depiction of one extreme reinforced the importance of its opposite – of wholesome domesticity and of the virtuous married woman.
Far from being cultural deserts, the developing northern industrial cities contained thriving art markets and growing populations of artists, many of them, clearly, able to make a decent living through portraiture and other sales. In 1821, one source lists only six portraitists and one landscape painter in Manchester; by 1825, Baines' directory lists twenty-one professional artists. The. 1851 census lists 156 painters in the town, and the 1861 census lists 156 (in 1851 the third largest population of professional painters in England, and in 1861 the second largest after London). The art dealers, Agnews and Grundys, were thriving in Manchester by the mid-nineteenth century. In Leeds, booksellers like Thomas Fenteman and carvers and gilders, operated as art dealers in the expanding market.
There were also a number of cultural institutions, founded as part of the activities of the new middle classes engaged in forging a collective and distinct identity. The Royal Manchester Institution is a good example of this. It was initiated in 1823 by a group of artists, who wanted to ensure regular exhibition of their works, but it was soon taken over by the town's governing class, who had been approached for their patronage. The first committee, set up in October 1823, included no artists among its twenty-eight members, hut it did include several major cotton manufacturers (H.H. Birley, R.H. Greg, David Holt), various prosperous merchants, bankers, doctors and lawyers, and the President, Vice-President, Treasurer and several directors of the Manchester Chamber of Commerce. The Royal Manchester Institute continued to run art exhibitions, offered prizes (funded originally by the banker, Benjamin Heywood) and from an early date built its own collection from the works on display. (This collection formed the basis of what is now the City of Manchester Art Gallery's collection, when the premises and works of the Institution were transferred to Manchester Corporation in 1882.)
One important role for the Royal Manchester Institution was in bringing about more social cohesion among the rather disparate sections of the town's middle class, helping to bridge differences of occupation, residence, religion and even politics. It also served the purpose of enhancing the image of the town. G.W. Wood, a partner in the Philips' hat-making business, who drafted the proposal for establishing the Institution in l823, was quite explicit about this aspect:
The candid and reflecting will not deny that an exclusive interest in the pursuit of gain has a very unfavourable influence on taste and manners.
He pointed out that:
An alliance between Commerce and the Liberal Arts is at once natural and salutary... [The Arts] provide a counter- acting influence to the gross and sordid spirit, which is too often the result of an undivided attention to mercenary pursuits.
The way in which involvement in cultural institutions and activities served the crucial secondary purpose of producing a common class identity was paralleled in Leeds with regard to the three Polytechnic Exhibitions. These were large miscellaneous exhibitions, organised by voluntary committees to raise money for such projects as a new hall for the Mechanics' Institution or for the building of public baths. Each included a large art section where paintings were on show, lent by up to ninety local collectors. The exhibitions were commented on at the time as being exceptional in bringing together members of different religious and political factions of the middle classes. Tories and Liberals, Anglicans and Dissenters, who would normally have had very little contact with each other, co-operated for months on the committees. An analysis of the lists of people who loaned pictures also shows participation across the entire spectrum of middle-class Leeds.
The cultural pursuits of members of the new middle class were complex in their motivations and effects. On the one hand, as we have suggested, they served the purpose of forging a class identity across the various fragments of the bourgeoisie. In this process, too, a specifically urban bourgeois identity was contrasted with the culture, politics and life-style of the gentry – the older ruling class (although the attitude of the industrial capitalists, bankers and merchants was always an ambivalent one, combining elements of emulation of gentry ways of life with vigorous rejection of other of its aspects). On the other hand, this cultural class identity was part of the efforts of this group to clarify its relationship with the lower strata. Culture operated both to control working-class activities and to educate workers into what were perceived to be appropriate values. On the occasion of the Art Treasures Exhibition in Manchester in 1857, for example, a fund was set up to enable children from poor districts to attend, and many employers sent train-loads of their employees to visit it. The entrance fees on Saturday afternoons were reduced to sixpence to encourage working people to attend. The Polytechnic Exhibitions in Leeds were also attended by large numbers of working people, encouraged by the organisers and other members of the Leeds bourgeoisie. Employers bought tickets for their employees, and gave them the day off to attend. There was a specially reduced penny rate for children from charity schools. Here, too, we see a combination of paternalistic benevolence and social control.
In general, class formation and class identity seem to be inextricably linked with cultural and artistic activities in mid-Victorian England. In relation to the visual arts, it is worth looking, finally, at one or two of the paintings themselves. Here, it is possible to interpret the ways in which the meaning of particular works, or types of work, is a central part of these processes. As we have already indicated with regard to the Plint and Fairbairn commissions, style and con- tent of the works is entirely relevant to the way in which patrons and viewers 'use' the works. 'Subject' pictures like Work and The Awakening Conscience presented their chosen topic in a particular way, but the same can be said of apparently neutral genres of painting, like portraiture and city views. When Thomas Fairbairn commissioned a family portrait from William Holman Hunt, ten years after buying The Awakening Conscience, with its theme of the sinful woman and the wicked ménage, he acquired a picture in which the opposite situation was represented.
The Children's Holiday is not just a realistic portrayal of his wife, Allison, and their five youngest children, but is a representation of a virtuous wife and a happy home. Mrs Fairbairn is shown as strong and pivotal in her proper domestic sphere. The shape of her body, tightly waisted in her gleaming silk dress, is broadened across the upper half by the fringed paisley shawl that she wears, so that she takes on the form both of the ancient oak tree above her on the right of the picture, and of the elegant tea urn on the left. The associations of the nature, permanence, strength and English virtue which carry over to her from the oak tree are tempered by the associations of culture, classical art and learning, and the taste and appreciation of fine modern workmanship, which are conveyed by the tea urn. The picture is set outside rather than inside a house, but all the more strongly are the essential features of home seen to be evident in the person of the wife and mother. The comfort and repose of the leather-upholstered armchair and the oriental carpet, and the refreshment and nourishment promised by the tea table, are attached, by the composition of the picture, to the figure of the woman. They are literally butted up against her skirts, so that they take on the character, not just of elements of her environment, but of her own self. They can then be understood as spiritual as well as physical benefits offered by the woman to her family.
In these ways, the portrait conveys a whole set of ideas about the proper role of woman, and her proper sphere of operation. Her position is seen as central and essential in the home, among her children, but nonetheless the painting indicates the presence, outside the picture, of her husband. She is submissive and obedient to a master, just as the spaniel in the picture is to its young master. In fact, the picture divides the figures into pairs: two deer, brother and little sister, elder sister and baby, boy and spaniel, and, finally, the figure of the husband outside the picture partners the wife and completes the set. In each pair, one figure is larger, and is protecting and controlling the smaller and weaker one. The portrait shows the limitations and dependence of women, as well as showing the positive virtues ascribed to women. The ideology of the family, and the social and economic relationships within the bourgeois family, are articulated very fully by this group portrait.
Similarly, a picture such as Leeds from the Meadows by Joseph Rhodes is something more than just a topographical view of a town. The picture dates from the 1820s, when Leeds was a rapidly growing industrial city, at the forefront of the development of wool- and flax-manufacturing technology. The way the city is shown in the painting is interesting at a time when industrialisation and the evils or benefits of city life were a subject of fierce controversy, and at a time when there was an economic and political struggle for influence within the city, as the traditional exercise of power by a merchant elite was disturbed. The part of the picture devoted to the city is just one narrow strip in what is otherwise a landscape showing trees, bushes, fields, a river, rows and two rustic figures. The city is, in this sense, safely contained in, and partly neutralised by, the countryside. The features of the city that occupy the skyline are not smoking chimneys, but mainly church towers and spires.
Nonetheless, the city is not completely de-industrialised in the way it is represented, because on the horizon at the right we can pick out a very large and prominent factory, and in front of it a modern bridge. The building is the four-storey main mill of the Park Mills woollen factory, owned by Benjamin Gott, and the bridge is Wellington Bridge, which he took the initiative in having built in 1818-19. The picture therefore finds a way of presenting Leeds as a city where innovation and factory production take their place without disturbing the idyllic peace of the countryside, and without disrupting the patterns of authority implied by a town, which is basically a cluster of houses round a few churches, and surrounded by fields.
The manufacturers and industrialists of the north, then, were not the 'ignorant and philistine' group Quentin Bell describes. They were very much involved in the arts, often in an extremely well-informed and sophisticated way. They were also central to most of the major cultural initiatives in industrial cities like Leeds and Manchester, whether temporary events like the Polytechnic Exhibitions in Leeds or the Art Treasures Exhibition in Manchester, or permanent institutions like the RMI or the Literary and Philosophical Societies. And, as we have suggested, the involvement of these members of the middle classes in patronage of the visual arts manifested itself in many of the paintings themselves. Occasionally this was the result of direct influence (as in the case of Plint); more generally, it is possible to read the paintings in terms of the cultural values and meanings of their prospective and actual buyers and viewers. The relationship of class, culture and art in nineteenth-century England is a complex and fascinating one, which will repay a good deal of further research.

