Tradefull Merchants: the Portrayal of the Capitalist in Literature

John McVeagh

Margot Heinemann | Published in 31 Mar 1982

This study of the portrayal of the capitalist in English literature over the past 500 years is valuable for its rich and detailed documentation (especially the fascinating unfamiliar quotations from less-known works), rather than for any new or profound cultural analysis. Questions of literary form or intended audience are largely ignored. Nevertheless it demonstrates in a thought- provoking way how over this long time-span our literature has more often than not shown hostility to capitalists and traders (by whose activities the society appears to live), though usually in favour of the life-style of landowning aristocrats and gentlemen-scholars, financed by the capitalism it criticises.

Late-medieval and early Tudor writers like Langland and More still assume an economically static society as the norm: thrusting merchants and capitalists are simply examples of the sin of avarice, as in the morality play Respublica or Marlowe's Jew of Malta in Elizabethan and Jacobean drama the clash between old and new attitudes is more complex. Dekker and Heywood, writing for the popular theatres, praise the new trading ventures and make heroes of Gresham, the great merchant, and Eyre, the master- shoemaker who rises to be Lord Mayor. Alongside this, however, runs the sharply hostile treatment of capitalists as usurers and bloodsuckers in plays by Massinger, Jonson and other city-comedy satirists. This 'anti-mercantile' comedy lasts into Restoration times, where the values of a socially elite theatre are smart and snobbish, and the merchant is seen as either knave or fool.

In the later seventeenth century, however, Dryden and Waller, though still critical, approve and exalt honourable commerce. Later Defoe both in his journalism and in Robinson Crusoe carries enthusiasm for foreign trade, exploration and useful production much further, and is indeed the most confident and optimistic of all authors about capitalist enterprise. This general approval becomes closely linked with aggressive nationalism and pride of conquest in the eighteenth century poetry of Thompson, Savage, Gay and Edward Young.

Disillusion sets in, Dr McVeagh suggests, around 1780 with the new wave of enclosures (reflected in Goldsmith's Deserted Village), the trial of Warren Hastings, and above all the rise of industrialism, which made hostility to commerce and capitalists for the first time a central theme in poetry. The revolutionary denunciations of Blake, the backward-looking romanticism of Coleridge and the more tempered regret of Wordsworth are succeeded in the next generation by Byron, Shelley and Keats all expressing strong sympathy with the workers as victims.

More open-minded on the whole issue is Walter Scott, balancing regret for a noble but violent and obsolete feudal order with a not unsympathetic image of practical Scottish businessmen (in Rob Roy or Redgauntlet) as representatives of an inescapable new world and its morality. But Scott did not have to deal with industrialisation and the huge commercial city, which so dominated the imagination of Dickens, and on a lesser scale of Mrs Gaskell and Charles Kingsley. The doubleness of Dickens's marvellously concrete vision is well brought out – approving self-made men, inventive manufacturers and philanthropists, yet seeing commercial and industrial society as increasingly barbarous and sinister, and its leaders, from Bounderby the millowner to Merdle the financier, as soulless villains. This double view is characteristic of much nineteenth-century writing on the theme: indeed the most radical hatred of capitalists is often defused by being put into the mouth of a madman (Tennyson's Maud) or a fanatic (Kingsley's Alton Locke).

For the twentieth century the field is so vast that any brief treatment is likely to seem scrappy. Conrad's novels, notably Nostromo and Heart of Darkness, are seen to explore the corrosive effects of imperialism and commerce on those who operate them; and E.M. Forster shows, pre-eminently in Howard's End, how the sensitive civilised values of English intellectuals depend economically on the work of exploiting managers and tycoons. Above all, D.H. Lawrence represents the successful capitalist (Gerald Crick in Women in Love) as the ruthless destroyer of everything vital and creative in the traditional culture.

After the 1930s, Dr McVeagh concludes, capitalists and capitalism are no longer central in literature because the social effects of a welfare economy have checked the operation of the profit drive. 'What has faded is the insecurity, the fear of being out of a job... So in literature resentment fades too against a world dominated by capitalist influence.' in a book published in 1981 this sounds decidedly old-fashioned. But if cause and literary effect are rarely as simply related as this, it does seem likely that writers may soon be producing fictional versions of the multi-nationals and their managers, who have already closed down so much of the industry built by the Rouncewells and Doyces in Dickens's time. They would be in a great tradition.

Margot Heinemann

  • Margot Heinemann is a lecturer in English at New Hall, Cambridge.

 

Tradefull Merchants - the Portrayal of the Capitalist in Literature

Routledge and Kegan Paul, 221pp.