The Changing Menu 1400-1900

Maggie Black looks at the cultural history of three February menus, based as much on show as the cooking.

Over the centuries it is not only the foods eaten which has changed but its serving and presentation has also evolved.

Three menus for February meals from different periods demonstrate the changing approach. Since the only coherently recorded meals of earliest times were feasts, detailed for the accountants, I have chosen 2 formal meals to match my first one as nearly as possible.

This meal was a royal banquet given after Henry IV’s second marriage, to Joan of Navarre on February 7th, 1404. It had three separate parts, a ‘flesshe’ dinner, a ‘fysshe’ one, and a third, lighter meal, labelled as completing the trinity. Each meal consisted of 3 courses, with anything from 6 to 16 dishes in each. At least 2 pastry dishes and 2 sweet ones were included in each dinner, each course ending wit a sotelte (subtlety).

The February dinner, although neither a feast nor royal, was equally designed for fashionable wealthy diners. The London Tavern was one of London’s smartest eating-places in the 17880 when John Farley, the Chef de Cuisine , created the meal for his best-seller book for private cooks. It consists of 2 courses of 10 dishes each and is simpler and shorter than most formal menus of his day, which might contain 25 dishes in a course.

The third dinner stands between the first and second in status, being a banquet of the Stationers’ Company given at the Mansion House by the then Lord Mayor, Sir Francis Wyatt, on February 3rd, 1880. This dinner has 7 courses with a choice of 3 to 7 dishes in each, plus (probably) a dessert course.

Two features of the foods served at all these meals stand out. First, Western man has not changed his concept of party fare over the centuries: richer fish and shelklfish, roast joints, poultry and patries predominate in all the menus, and creamy sweets were as popular in 1404 as today.  Second, preserved or imported rarities have always had snob value regardless of their flavour. All the menus included them: fattyt, fishy porpoise in 1404, asparagus (in winter!) in 1792, and turtle soup in 1880.

Another point to note is that party dishes have always been made for display, usually by sculpting or using bright dyes. The elaborately moulded medieval ‘sotelties’ of sugar or marchpane were deliberately designed to impress, and all medieval party dishes were highly coloured, often striped or chequered. The colour, shape and decoration of Georgian and Victorian dishes were even more carefully chosen for their display value.

In the multi-grade society of medieval England, dishes, like men, had a clearly defined pecking order, and were placed on the long tables appropriately, above or below the ornate salt-cellar and ‘banner of degrees’, which displayed the host’s status.

The arrangement of the food on the tables was also calculated to make it look a lavish display – even in the pies at the humble men’s ‘board’ only contain offals. Since many dishes were sloppy, spoon-fed or greasy, the tables were inevitably messy until the grand sweep-up and spreading of clean cloths at the end of each course; so, at the lowly tables, a half-eaten dish could be left in place until then, without mattering much, to keep the tables looking fully spread.

By 1790, the grading of foods had changes. Partly, this was because dishes had become more distinctly different and varied in a society which could draw on the products of the Americas and the East, including sugar. Also, agricultural improvements at home had brought larger meat joints and birds, more vegetables and dairy food s to many more English tables. Imported novelties and some rarities still had snob value; elaborately presented, rich dressing with butter or cream gave it to other, often quite humble, foods. But quality counted more, and more people demanded it.

The basic meal plan remained, however, almost unchanged. The food was still served in 2 or 3 courses, the last being the lightest, with a separate dessert afterwards, and many of the dishes in a course were still served together as nearly as possible.

It was also just as important as in the past to have a lavish display on the table; but at an upper- or middle-class meal it was equally essential that it should look an elegant, artistic whole throughout each course – which meant making the dishes convenient to serve and easy to remove when messy or empty.

The dishes were therefore designed for particular places in the table arrangement, and to some extent a set order of service. Soups, drunk first while still hot, were placed at the ends, so that the tureens could easily be removed when empties. In old designs for table settings we often see the legend Soup Remov’d for Fish – the start of our modern menu system. Large, fairly solid dishes which would not drip were generally placed in the centre of the table or around a decorative centrepiece if there was one. Flatter and sauce-covered dishes were placed at the sides and corners where they were easily reached. Side dishes, relishes and sauces might be placed between the centre dishes and outer ring.

By 1880, the most obvious change was the introduction of the serving system still, at that time, called Dîner à la Russe – which consisted of serving each type of dish in turn, ready to eat, in s set order. The system got the name because the idea of using it for the whole meal had been introduced in Paris by the Russian ambassador in 1810 although it had begun to come in much earlier as we have seen, to keep the table soigné by replacing finished or cooled half-eaten dishes. In 1773, such a dish had been properly christened in Dr Johnson’s dictionary as a ‘Remove – a dish to be changed while the rest of the course remains.’

The Russian ambassador may have got his idea partly from eating in French restaurants. The huge social changes which had dispossessed the French aristocracy during the Revolution had destroyed their great households and the jobs of their highly-trained chefs – who promptly went ‘freelance’ and established eating-houses of a new, sophisticated type. To serve the old-style 2 course meal with, say 10 haute-cuisine dishes in each course served together, was quite impractical in a restaurant, so the ‘remove’ system had been extended too all types of dishes, first at these public eating-places, but soon, too, at private functions.

The 1880 menu reflects on other great 19th century social development, the growth in size and power of affluent, mercantile-minded middle classes. They demonstrated their affluence by having even more lavish, elaborately styles meals than their predecessors, both at public and private parties, and – unlike their predecessors – described their variety in detail in their menus.

Nor was this all, as a glance at any picture of a Victorian dinner table shows. Mrs Beeton’s ‘Dinner table for Ten Persons’ in the 1880 edition of her books carries no less than 5 large stemmed epergnes bearing fruits and vases of flowers as well as 4 sweetmeat dishes and the place settings. Other pictures show swathed garlands of flowers draped around the table as well. One wonders how the diners, especially those in crinolines, managed to sit down, let alone reach their plates! The medieval banquet might have its salt-cellar, and (inedible) peacock in plumage and fantastical machpane subtleties, the Georgian dinner-party its ornate table centrepiece and desserts covered in spun-sugar ‘golden web’. But for massive ostentation in menu and setting alike, the Victorian party meal beat anything that had gone before.

Further Reading

  • Two Fifteenth Century Cookbooks , original series ninety-one Early English Text Society ed. Thomas Austen (1888)
  • John Farley, The London Art of Cookery and House Keeper's Complete Assistant , principal cook at the London Tavern (1792)
  • Elizabeth Raffald, The Experienced English Housekeeper (1782, facsimile edition, E. and W. Books, 1970)
  • Jonathan Swift (ed) Herbert Davis, Directions to Servants Etc. 1733-1742 ( Blackwell, 1973)

John Farley’s Scollop’d Oysters

For Four helpings:
About 30 small oysters fresh or canned; 6-7 oz cooked fresh haddock; salt and pepper; 1 oz soft buttered breadcrumbs; 2 dessertspoons chopped parsley (modern addition); 1 dessertspoon finely chopped spring onion (modern addition); 2 oz chilled butter

Drain the oysters, reserving the liquor. Beard them in fresh. Flake or mash the fish and season lightly. Mix the buttered crumbs with the parsley and onion. Flake the butter. Use a scrap of butter to grease 4 scallop shells. Put 2 of the larger oysters into each shell, cover with the white fish, then with breadcrumbs. Sprinkle with about half the butter flakes. Divide the remaining oysters between the shells, the repeat the other layers, ending with the butter flakes. Pour some of the reserved liquor into each shell. Bake at 375° F/ 190° C / Gas 5 for 10-15 minutes until well heated through. Place briefly under medium grilling heat to brown the tops if required.