Spanish Civil War

Paul Preston looks at the continued interest in the 1930s conflict, the subject of a new exhibition at the Imperial War Museum.

The last time that anyone did a serious count, there were over 15,000 books published about the Spanish Civil War. That was in 1968 and the counting was done by a team from Franco’s Ministry of Information. The scale of the literature then was partly a result of the fact that, since 1939, the propagandists of the victorious Caudillo had been producing, on an industrial scale, books and pamphlets interpreting the war in such a way as to justify the existence of the dictatorship. In turn, this material had stimulated counter-efforts from both defeated Republicans in exile, their foreign sympathisers and independent scholars the world over. In the thirty-three years following the publication of that official bibliography, books on the subject continued to pour out. The death of Franco himself in 1975 saw a massive boom in previously banned publications in Spain. University departments began to sponsor hitherto dangerous research. The result was a further flood of publications that has taken the total nearer to the 20,000 mark and a notable roster of television documentaries and movies.

Expectations that intense interest in the Spanish Civil War would die out have not been fulfilled. There are currently a number of feverishly active internet discussion sites on the subject and a quick search will locate nearly a thousand websites devoted entirely or in part to the conflict. Even in the US, where interest in all things European seems to be dwindling, an embittered debate was triggered recently  by the publication by Yale University Press of a set of documents about the war emanating from the Soviet archives. Edited by Ronald Radosh, Mary R. Habeck and Grigory Sevostianov, Spain Betrayed:The Soviet Union in the Spanish Civil War portrays partisans of the Republican side in the Spanish Civil War as willing or inadvertent stooges of Stalin. Its basic thesis is that the Spanish Republic at war was little more than a Soviet satellite. This revives the Cold-War view of the Spanish Republic as the first Popular Democracy, comparable to those established after the Second World War in Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia. It is an ahistorical argument that tears the conflict out of its chronological and geo-political context. Between 1936 and 1939, Soviet foreign policy was not what it was after the experience of invasion by the Third Reich and Spain was not Poland. Nevertheless, the thesis has been eagerly taken up by American rightists keen to remove the last jewel in the Communist crown – the anti-fascist struggle of the Spanish Republic – and equally enthusiastically refuted by others on the left. 

What is remarkable is the scale of the passion these discussions have aroused in the US about a Spanish conflict that, after the Second World War, Korea and Vietnam, and the wars of the Middle East and the Gulf, seems a small-scale squabble. In Spain, such a situation is more understandable. Books on the war and its aftermath regularly top the national best-seller lists. Since last April, the top-selling title in Barcelona has been a book about the Catholic Church and the Civil War by a Benedictine monk, Dom Hilari Raguer, entitled The Gunpowder and the Incense. Public launches for books on the war invariably draw a crowd. There were four alone in Madrid in the last week in September. That month, the University of Leiden in Holland hosted an international conference on the Brigades. In Britain too, interest in the Spanish Civil War remains vibrant.

That was evident last July, when a large crowd gathered at the International Brigades’ monument on London’s South Bank, for the annual commemoration of the Brigades. In his speech, the International Brigades Association President, Jack Jones, announced the creation of the International Brigades Trust to continue the work of preserving the legacy of those who went to Spain to fight fascism.

On October 17th the dwindling band of British veterans headed to Lambeth, for the launch of a larger commemoration of the war. On that day the Imperial War Museum opened probably the largest exhibition on the war ever seen in the UK. An astonishing array of posters, photographs, uniforms, weapons and other artefacts of the struggle have been gathered from all over the world in an effort to give a comprehensive vision of both sides in the war. As this exhibition shows, the Civil War inspired the greatest writers and artists of its day in a manner not repeated in any subsequent war. A vast number of items have been amassed by the Museum that bear testimony to the artistic and literary resonances of the war, both at the time and subsequently.

On October 26th, survivors from North and South America, Europe and Australasia will be going back to Madrid for a tribute to their sacrifices as ‘Volunteers for Liberty’. They will be greeted by the municipal authorities, be guests of honour at a festival, taken for a tour of the principal battlefields around Madrid, and will inaugurate another exhibition on the role of the International Brigades in the Spanish Civil War. From Madrid, they will go on south-east to Albacete, the Brigades headquarters where the volunteers were taken in 1936 for training. Scholars from Spain and elsewhere will join them from October 29th–31st for the Second International Forum on the International Brigades, organised by the University of Castilla-La Mancha, at its Albacete campus where it has established a major archive on the role of the volunteers.

Those who have the stamina will then travel north where a remarkable ceremony will take place to commemorate a little-known aspect of the greatest, and decisive, battle of the Spanish Civil War. This started on July 25th, 1937, when a Republican army of 80,000 men crossed the River Ebro in an attempt to reunite the two halves of the Republic, severed when Franco’s forces reached the Mediterranean the previous April. They broke through the Nationalist lines at great cost in casualties but Francoist reinforcements were rushed in and the Republican attackers were subjected to nearly four months of fierce artillery bombardment and sweltering heat. With fresh troops armed with new German equipment, Franco set out to annihilate the Republican army. During the battle, the Republican medical services carried out daily miracles in improvised hospitals. One of these was in a huge cave at the village of La Bisbal de Falset in Catalonia, in the region of Priorat, to the north-east of Flix. It was rediscovered by an English author, Angela Jackson, in the course of research for her book on British women in the Spanish Civil War (to be published in 2002 by Routledge). As a result of her work, a plaque will be unveiled in the cemetery at La Bisbal de Falset, in the first weekend of November, in memory of the many who died in the nearby cave hospital during the Battle of the Ebro.

All of this serves to remind us that the Spanish Civil War was a rehearsal for the Second World War. More than 40,000 men and women, workers and intellectuals, went from all over the world to join the International Brigades. They saw clearly in 1936 what others chose to ignore: that when Madrid fell, Paris and London would be next.  They felt, too, that Spanish revolution offered a way out of the harsh realities of capitalism during the great Depression. In the event, they were defeated and yet the continued fascination for the war goes on disproving the old adage that the history of wars is written by the victors. Albert Camus indicated why this would be so when he wrote ‘It was in Spain that men learned that one can be right and still be beaten, that force can vanquish spirit, that there are times when courage is not its own reward. It is this, without doubt, which explains why so many men throughout the world regard the Spanish drama as a personal tragedy.’