Villebois-Mareuil and the Boers
The most distinguished of the three thousand foreign volunteers who fought against Britain during the Boer War, writes Roy Macnab, was a brilliantly gifted French soldier.
In September 1899 the young Attorney-General of the South African Republic, Jan Christiaan Smuts, believing that war between his country and Britain had become inevitable, drew up a remarkable memorandum in which he set out what he considered the most important steps to be taken if the Boers were to profit from the delay that would attend a build-up of British forces in South Africa.
Among these was to obtain in Europe the services of a military expert of high rank ‘not to have command here but to give advice which could be of the greatest value to our armies.
This is specially necessary because our people have until now been used to fighting in small numbers by means of commandos, and in the struggle that we are approaching it will be essential to fight in thousands.’
While Smuts was putting on paper his ideas to meet the military crisis that had arisen as the Boers and the British prepared to fight, in Europe that same September France was going through a military crisis of its own.
This was not a threat from outside but from within, for France was in a state of near-revolution and the honour of the army was at stake. All eyes were settled on the school room at Rennes, where an army court-martial was in progress.
A Jewish officer, Captain Alfred Dreyfus, who had already spent five years in prison on Devil’s Island, convicted of having betrayed military information to a foreign power, was being given a new trial as a result of strong public feeling that the army had condemned an innocent man.
Immediately the trial ended (Dreyfus was again found guilty but almost immediately pardoned), one of those who had been present as an observer, a distinguished, retired French officer, who had not only tried to influence his cousin, Commandant Breon, a member of the court, but had had an angry scene with a German journalist in the courtyard, returned to Paris in a mood of despair for the state of his country and for one of its institutions that he held sacred, the army.
This officer was Colonel the Comte de Villebois-Mareuil, whose brilliant record as an active soldier was matched by the reputation his military books had won him as a strategist.
Moreover, his other writing, notably his novels, showed him to be not only an intellectual with a highly satirical pen but also a romantic who saw his country and the profession of arms in terms of medieval chivalry.
Returning to Paris from Rennes, Villebois wrote a letter to Dr Willem Leyds, the Boer Minister to France, who was away in Brussels.
‘The tension in the diplomatic relations between the South African Republic and England could lead to a declaration of war’, he told Leyds. ‘In the event of this happening I have the honour to ask to serve the cause of your country in offering it my sword.
‘I left the French Army four years ago at the age of forty-seven as I was about to become a General because I found that France’s international policies were harming increasingly the vitality of the army, but I have left behind me there some reminders of myself which will prove in favour of my request should you wish to consult them.’
He then went on to refer to a conversation he had had with Johan Pierson, the Boer Consul-General in Paris, who felt that the conditions of war in the Transvaal could benefit a little from European tactical combinations and that the value of the man took the place there of ideas.
‘Nevertheless,’ insisted Villebois, ‘these exist and all the essentials of supply, of fortifications, of the field of battle could use the expertise of a staff officer.’
Villebois-Mareuil, it seemed, was speaking the language of Smuts that September. If the Boers wanted him, he told Leyds, he was ready to leave at once. Then he went to Biarritz, where he had taken a house for the summer for his only child, the sixteen-year-old Simone, whose mother had died six years before.
Here he waited, not idly, but busy on his new book on guerrilla warfare and in touch with the electors of Oran who were supporting his candidature for the Senate elections due in the following January.
The Anglo-Boer War broke out on October 11th, 1899, and within forty-eight hours de Villebois had received Leyds’ reply; he was to proceed with his mission to the Transvaal and on arrival present his papers to the State Secretary, Reitz.
Leyds then informed Pretoria that Villebois was coming, for the Colonel, as good as his word, made immediate preparations to sail from Marseilles for Lourenço Marques. On the eve of his departure from Biarritz, he dined at the home of his English friend, the historian J.E.C. Bodley1.
‘He talked’, said Bodley later, ‘of a mysterious mission which had been offered him... No one here had the faintest suspicion of the adventure he was starting and even his nearest relations were not in the secret.’
This was the sequence of events that brought to South Africa the most distinguished of some 3,000 foreign volunteers from Europe and America who fought for the Boers. Ete was appointed their General and commanded the International Brigade.
He was not a mercenary since the foreigners, like the burghers, were not paid. Nor did the Boers recruit them. Pretoria’s instructions to Leyds were clear; there was no objection to the foreigners coming, but they did so at their own expense and own risk.
Villebois’s intervention in the Boer-British confrontation had no direct connexion with either side.
It was a calculated involvement which had much to do with the kind of man he had become by September 1899, by which time he had confused his personal frustrations and problems of his own personality with the national problems of France in the unhappy, closing days of the century and had become a controversial figure.
His presence in South Africa, therefore, provided a link between the Anglo-Boer struggle and the internal struggle in France, whose most revolutionary elements became the most active supporters of the Pro-Boer committees.
As Bodley was to point out, Villebois hoped to use his role in the South African War to change the political situation at home and advance his own political career.
The man who in due course was to be hailed as one of France’s crusading knights had an appropriate background for membership of that con-frerie that included Lafayette, Rochambeau and Fabvier.
Georges Henri Anne-Marie Victor, twentieth Comte de Villebois-Mareuil, was born in 1847 at Nantes, where a dramatic statue commemorates him in the Place de la Bourse.
Another memorial, a simple plaque in the church wall at Mareuil, marked ‘Mareuil-Bouvines-Transvaal’, is a reminder of how this distinguished family of la vieille France began and ended-in arms against England.
In 1214 a grateful King of France rewarded Hugo Mareuil for his part in the Battle of Bouvines with the lands of Villebois and the title of Comte de Villebois-Mareuil. The death of his descendant in South Africa, also in battle against England, brought the line to an end after nearly seven centuries.
The young Villebois was nourished on the heroic and romantic legends of his native Vendee, where many still dreamed of a Bourbon restoration, among them his father, a friend of the Duchesse de Berri, the Pretender’s insurrectionary mother. He grew up at Montaigu with one ambition, to be a soldier in the spirit of the old France that had disappeared with the monarchy.
It was, however, into the army of the Emperor that he went, via St Cyr; and after service in Indo-China, he managed, by paying his own passage, to return to France in time to fight in the last battle of Napoleon’s III’s war with Prussia. At Blois on January 18th, 1871, though badly wounded, he performed gallantly, was decorated in the field with the légion d’honneur and promoted captain.
Under the Third Republic, Villebois, like his friend the future Marshal Lyautey, emerged as one of France’s new soldier-intellectuals. Product of the Ecole de Guerre, he studied the Russian army in the Balkans and wrote a book about it.
In Tunisia, he was cited once more for bravery and when General Ferron succeeded the controversial General Boulanger as War Minister he appointed Villebois as his personal aide.
By 1892, on taking command of the 67th Regiment, he had become France’s youngest colonel, ‘a remarkable corps commander’, according to his official dossier, ‘who should reach the highest ranks in the army’.
The death of his young wife, however, a year or so later marked a dramatic change in his life. She was Paula Estrangin, first cousin of Edmond Rostand, and through her Villebois, the soldier-writer, became a major influence on the young author of Cyrano de Bergerac. With Paula’s death, Villebois seemed to lose his equilibrium.
Thereafter his reactions to events seemed often exaggerated, his judgements ill-considered. In his grief he looked at France and found it no longer resembled his own ideal conception of it. He blamed the politicians; the political system itself was rotten.
Soon he convinced himself that the army too was becoming infected.
And when the Foreign Legion, of which he had been given command in Algeria in 1895, was sent on active service to deal with trouble in Madagascar but under another colonel, he decided that he himself had become a victim, a belief that the news that he was to become a General in a provincial garrison did nothing to dispel.
He asked to be placed upon the Reserve and early in 1896 departed into civilian life.
The next four years were filled with literary, journalistic and political activity. Three novels, as well as numerous military and political studies, appeared.
He lectured widely and organized thousands of ex-conscripts into the union des sociétés regimentaires, addressing its 5,000 delegates at the Sorbonne in June 1898, but resigning when the Government, fearing the latent power of so many organized ex-soldiers, stepped in to control it.
His sense of persecution was further increased when the Government refused permission to Commandant Marchand, hero of Fashoda, to share a public platform with him.
With other writers, notably Maurice Barrès and Georges Maurras, he then founded Action Française, which, long after his death, achieved considerable notoriety as a royalist, extreme right-wing movement which only disappeared in 1944, with Vichy France.
At the beginning, however, it was little more than an effort by a group of patriots towards national regeneration at a time when France, humiliated abroad at Fashoda, was bitterly divided against itself at home over the Dreyfus affair.
By the end of 1899, a year of crisis in France as in South Africa, Villebois had transferred himself from one crisis area to the other.
A French colonel’s spectacular success on behalf of the small Boer nation against the mighty British Empire would, he argued, not only restore France’s tarnished glory but give him the personal authority and political following that a national hero might command.
It would also, incidentally, be a way out of a difficult personal situation. He had formed a liaison in Paris with a well-known married woman, Madame Hochon, the artist daughter and collaborator of Hector Lefuel, architect attached to the Louvre, and had been warned that the affair could affect his Senate prospects.
Travelling under an assumed name, and with his sword concealed beneath his dinner-jacket, Villebois sailed for the South African War, once more, as in 1870 from Saigon, paying his own passage. It was a close-run thing.
The French vessel Gironde had to run the gauntlet of the Royal Navy trying to prevent munitions reaching the Boers through the Mozambique Channel, as it now does oil destined for Rhodesia. Challenged by H.M. S. Magicienne, the Gironde escaped under a smoke-screen and reached Lourenço Marques, a feat it failed to repeat when later the cruiser stopped her with gunfire and boarded her. By that time, however, its distinguished passenger was already in Pretoria.
Here, despite the French Government’s neutrality, its consul in Pretoria, Aubert, presented Villebois to Reitz and later he met Kruger himself. He was told to regard himself as a guest of the state while acting as military counsellor to the Commandant-General Joubert in Natal.
The French colonel reached the Natal front on the same day as the British Commander-in-Chief, Sir Redvers Buller, newly out from Britain, and conferred with General Louis Botha at Colenso on the eve of the latter’s great victory of December 15th, when Buller was repulsed in his attempt to march on Ladysmith, which, like Mafeking and Kimberley, was under Boer siege.
Then he carried out a number of reconnaissances, often in close proximity to the British, and a complete disregard for danger soon earned Die Franse Kolonel, as the Boers called him, unable to pronounce his name, a legendary reputation. His counsel was always received with approbation but, to his chagrin, never acted on.
His unheeded warning at Ladysmith led to the destruction of guns by British raiders; his plan for capturing Ladysmith was, he claimed, ‘massacred’ by Joubert in the abortive attack of January 6th in which he himself had taken part, riding with a Boer commando.
Meanwhile, Press reports somewhat ironically were blaming British reverses on the presence of a French strategist. The Boer commanders, however, ‘with the one exception of General Botha, who continually visits his positions and understands the importance of observations made to him’, seemed incapable in Villebois’ words of applying his advice, though as Botha told the war correspondent Marcel Hutin, the Colonel ‘sees British movements eighteen days before they happen’.
Frustrated by Joubert’s lack of aggressive spirit, he obtained permission to join General Cronje on the western front, which he believed would become the main war theatre, now that Lord Roberts had assumed supreme command.
Once more, however, it was a story of frustration. His plan for the capture of Kimberley, accepted on February 3rd by the war council, was particularly important to him because it was to be largely a French affair.
One of the Long Toms, the French 16 in. guns, mounted by the French ordnance expert Captain Leon, would bombard Kimberley which would then be stormed by Villebois himself leading a group of French volunteers.
The prize would be the capture of the besieged Cecil Rhodes himself. ‘History will add a fresh flower to the glory of France’, he wrote in his diary. ‘To take Kimberley and see the face of the Napoleon of the Cape... I look forward to Saturday.’
Again and again, however, the Boers postponed the attack, until it was too late. Lord Roberts launched his great offensive across the Orange Free State and General French relieved Kimberley.
Villebois, rejoining Cronje on the Modder, urged him to retreat in echelon to avoid being cut off, but the Boer General, refusing to abandon his waggons, moved at their pace, was surrounded and captured at Paardeberg, a fate Villebois, forty-eight hours in the saddle, narrowly avoided, escaping to join Generals de Wet and de la Rey in rearguard actions, ‘occupying positions that I disapproved of’.
By mid-March the war situation in the Free State had changed radically. Bloemfontein had fallen and the Boers were in disarray. Villebois urged guerrilla tactics, and abandoning his role as a staff officer, prepared to become a partisan.
On March 17th, summoned to the big war council at Kroonstad attended by both Boer Presidents with some thirty senior officers and officials of the republics, he made a memorable entry into the chamber, when the two Presidents and Joubert stood up and Kruger bade the Colonel sit beside him.
For the French soldier it was a reception that did much to make up for the months of frustration; his role had been clarified. He had been made a Boer General with command of all the foreigners who would now operate as a single International Brigade.
In taking over the foreigners, Villebois was probably doing the Boers a service. Joubert had earlier telegraphed Pretoria from Natal:
‘Things are being made impossible for me here mainly by the volunteer corps of Irish, Russian, Dutch, French etc.
A lot of them are being sent here unfamiliar with our language and customs, unfamiliar and unsuitable for our way of making war.’
To this and other complaints about equipping them, Smuts replied:
‘We are doing our best here to equip the foreign corps and I trust you will do your best in this.’
Prince Louis d’Orleans et Braganze, cousin of the French Pretender, who passed among the Boers as ‘Louis Merey’, was probably right when he observed:
‘Most of the burghers had little sympathy for these foreign auxiliaries arriving with the air of saviours when most of them were considered as intruders.’
By March 1900 there were between two and three thousand foreigners with the Boers, organized mainly in national units, serving on all fronts, German, French, Hollander, Scandinavian and Italian corps, Russian and American scouts, two ‘brigades’ of Irish nationalists.
Le Figaro, in Paris, described the vivid impression made by the Russians in Pretoria:
‘The town is full of foreigners, arrivals of January 25th, 1900. First of all, the Russian ambulance, white blouse and green belts, Colonel Gourko, the military attaché sent by the Tsar, iron-grey uniform, white helmet... one sees on the big square in Pretoria a Cossack lieutenant, black cape with red lining, boots and headgear of astrakan.
That headwear of fur under our sun makes an impression! A little curved Tartar sword dangles at his legs.’
Each group had its colourful individuals. The Russians counted the giant Prince Bagration, later killed by the Bolsheviks, the liberal Alexander Gutchov, 1917 revolutionary and War Minister, and Colonel Maximov, an agent of Russian military intelligence.2
The Germans, who early in the war lost their adjutant, Graf von Zeppelin, who had died attacking the Gordon Highlanders with his whip when his ammunition ran out, were later led by Fritz Brail, an international anarchist who had been the central figure in the Chelsea Explosions case at the Old Bailey in 1896.
Colonel John Blake, an Irish-American West Pointer, led the first Irish brigade whose major was John McBride, later executed by a firing squad in Dublin after the Easter Rising of 1916.
The nephew of Pope Leo XIII, Lt Count Pecci, was with the Italians and among the Hollanders was Cor van Gogh, who, while a British prisoner, later committed suicide like his painter brother.
Perhaps the most unusual of the volunteers (in the South African context since he was a man of colour) was the Algerian Ben Nasser who, taking the oath of allegiance to the republics as all the foreigners did, became a Boer citizen, and in due course a British prisoner in Ceylon.
To bring together such widely different elements as Russian Cossacks, Texan cowboys and Irish rebels would have been a formidable task even for a former commander of the French Foreign Legion.
Only one thing, Villebois decided, could unify them under his standard, and rally the despondent Boers, and that was a personal action d’éclat, a spectacular raid against the enemy led by the General himself.
Leaving Maximov in charge at Kroonstad, Villebois set off on March 24th with the Brigade’s first operational detachment, a flying column of 100 composed of a French section led by Comte de Breda and in eluding Bagration, a Hollander section, and 25 Boers under the English burgher, Walter Coleman.
His aim was to blow up the railway south of Kimberley, thus breaking British communication with the Cape.
On the morning of April 5th, 1900, Villebois’s hideout behind a kopjie five miles south of Boshof was betrayed to Lord Methuen, who had arrived in the town with the 10th Division. Methuen himself led out a strong force, including artillery, to attack Villebois, who, completely encircled, refused to surrender and maintained his resistance for four hours.
Then, in the words of the British war correspondent C. E. Hands, ‘they went to the final attack, making jubilant hunting noises, Eric Smith, the one-armed Colonel of the Bucks, leading his men and waving his helmet to the accompaniment of whoops.’
It was an end worthy of a General Custer. Villebois fired his revolver for the last time and Sergeant Patrick Campbell, husband of the celebrated actress Mrs Patrick Campbell, fell.3
Then Villebois himself was killed by a shell splinter and the fight was over. Greatly moved by his adversary’s heroism, Methuen paraded 1,500 men, together with the captured foreigners, at the Boshof cemetery where Villebois was buried with full military honours.
The Comte de Breda gave the funeral oration. ‘It was too sad for words’, Methuen wrote to Lady Methuen. Then he wrote to Villebois’s orphaned daughter and sent an officer to Paris with her father’s ring.
He also paid for a stone to be put over the grave. Replying in the House of Commons to critical questions about Methuen’s behaviour, the Secretary for War said it was a gesture from one brave man towards another.
In France, news of Villebois’s heroic death transformed him overnight into a national hero, though not without embarrassment to the French Government, whose opponents were determined to make capital out of it.
The Times reported from Paris: ‘To understand what has happened on the announcement of the death of Colonel de Ville-bois-Mareuil, it must be remembered that since General Boulanger disappeared ten years ago, the Boulangist party for such it is whatever names it assumes, has been searching for a man to take his place.’
When the Government, under pressure, gave permission for serving officers to attend the memorial service at Notre Dame to be conducted by the Archbishop of Paris, the War Minister Gallifet, speaking in Parliament, warned that officers attending the service were not to become mixed up ‘in any demonstrations that might arise’.
This was exactly what dissident elements intended should happen.
When the congregation of 10,000 came out into the streets, the appearance among them of General Mercier, a key figure in the Dreyfus prosecution, acted like a signal and young militants shouting Vive l'Armée surged forward in an effort to involve uniformed officers in their demonstration.
Mounted police moved in and there were scuffles and arrests. Then, a fierce political controversy began in the Paris Press, in which the ‘Lafayette of South Africa’, as he was called, became a pawn, each political faction claiming the hero as one of them.
In South Africa, the loss of their General was a blow from which the foreigners never recovered. Maximov assumed command, but gave it up when he failed to win the support of the various national units, which, converging on Kroonstad and finding their General was dead, resumed the fight separately. By September most of them had disbanded.
Villebois never achieved what he set out for, unless it were heroic fulfilment as a soldier. As The Times History of the War in South Africa said of him: ‘Naturally of a quixotic nature, he showed in his life and writings an almost medieval delight in the glory of the soldier’s profession.’
In France, where he was soon honoured with statues and street names in the big cities4, the Third Republic settled down to happier times while the Entente Cordiale helped to reconcile pro-Boer Frenchmen with the British Empire, of which the Boers themselves and their defeated republics became a part on May 31st, 1902.
There was, however, an echo to these events a year later. On June 4th, 1903, Edmond Rostand at the early age of thirty-five was giving his inaugural address as a member of the Académie Française.
Those present might well have imagined he was talking about the soldier-writer he had recreated for the theatre and who in turn had created his own fame, Cyrano de Bergerac. But he was not. The man he was describing was Georges de Villebois-Mareuil.
He would arrive, Rostand was saying,
‘abruptly, very spruce, with his quite incredible moustache and blue eyes. He would take me up and transport me through well-chosen landscapes, recounting fine stories of war and love.
Sometimes a word of his would have the healthy bitter tang of a bay leaf that one has bitten; the whole day through he would sparkle without trying to or be profound as by accident. He would bring me back fascinated and refreshed; without seeming to, he had taught me everything.
I still hear that charming voice...’
It was a kind of epitaph for his kinsman, but Rostand had already written, in the dying words of Cyrano himself, perhaps the most appropriate comment on Villebois-Mareuil and the Boers.
‘There is, despite you, something that I carry away... my panache.’
1 J. E. C. Bodley (1853-1925), described by Sir Denis Brogan as ‘one of the most acute foreign observers of French affairs of his time’ (The Development of Modern France 1870-1939, Rev. Ed., p. 192). Villebois had undertaken to translate Bodley’s book France.
2 His reports to the Chief of the Intelligence Committee, Russian General Staff, were published by the Soviet Government in 1940.
3 She was appearing in Mrs Jordan at the Royalty Theatre, London, that day.
4 In Britain there is a monument to Villebois’s horse on the village green of Latimer, Bucks, where it was given a military funeral in 1911. Captured at Boshof and re-named Villebois, the horse was brought to England by Lord Chesham who commanded the Yeomanry in the battle.