Women and Revolution under Alexander II
Henry Kamen describes the apotheosis of emancipated Russian womanhood.
One of the most astonishing features of revolutionary life in nineteenth-century Russia was the important part played by women in political agitation. While few of them attained any international prominence, at home they attained a notoriety that is often forgotten by students of history.
This notoriety consisted, above all, in the fact that it was the women, even more than the men, who were at the core of the terrorist movement that played so large a part in the history of Russian Populism.
The fact that women should take part in revolutionary movements meant that they had attained a high degree of emancipation and were free of the standard conventions binding them to hearth and home. More often than not, they would be those who had received a good education and were sophisticated enough to look at the world independently. Inevitably, it was the upper classes that tended to produce such women.
The numerous reputable girls’ high schools, of which the Smolny Institute in Petersburg was the best known and the most fashionable, represented the acceptable ideal of female education, which advanced rapidly after the reforms of the 1850’s. In 1856 the Minister of Public Instruction, Norov, issued a memoir in which he advocated wider female education at all levels and among all classes.
In 1858 new rules for the expansion of girls’ schools were issued. But little progress was made in university education. Although women were now free to attend informal lectures and classes at the universities, and although a majority of universities favoured granting formal membership to women, there was strong official opposition, particularly from the University of Moscow, and in 1861 the government decided against women. In 1863 a University Statute definitely forbade women to attend lectures.
From this time begins the great movement abroad of young women students who found that higher education and careers at home were denied them because of their sex. The majority of them went to Zurich and opened up what was to be a flourishing colony of emigre students. Meanwhile, at home some measure of thaw was in progress, and from 1869 onwards universities such as Petersburg began to give Public Courses open to both sexes.
This effectively overcame the restrictions of 1863, but did not meet all the demands of a radical young generation that called for greater freedom in thought and action. To such young people the universities were still centres of reaction, and students continued to go abroad.
The possibilities open to women in university education had been demonstrated for the first time by Nadezhda Suslova, who had been the first woman to graduate as a doctor in medicine and surgery in 1867—not, however, in Russia, but abroad in Zurich. It was her example that pointed the way ahead for the young Vera Figner, later to become a leader of the Populist movement, but at the time a student at the Rodionovsky Institute in Kazan province.
Disappointed by the kind of education offered in Russia, she and her sister Lydia enrolled at the University of Zurich in 1872. It was in Zurich that young Russian radicals found the free atmosphere and the possibility of meeting exiled Russian liberals that made the city into a centre of revolutionary agitation.
Bakunin, the anarchist leader, and Tkachev, the exiled Social Revolutionary, were among those who exercised some influence on eager students looking for a solution to the evils besetting their native land.
The growth of the Russian colony at Zurich reflected far more than just the interest of radicals. It was the direct result of the break-up of the student movement which had caused so much trouble to the Tsarist police in 1861-1863. By 1863 official repression had done its work, and the more fiery spirits in the universities were either in exile or had fled abroad.
The time had come for a change in the tactics of the opposition. The poet and revolutionary Ogarev chose this moment to write an article (dated January 1862) in the clandestine paper Kolokol (The Bell), edited from abroad by Herzen.
The article was entitled “The Universities are Closing,” but the message was not one of regret. Instead, Ogarev cried, “Do not go to the universities. Let them close! University youth spread throughout Russia will act as a unifying agent between the various classes. To become a free man it is essential to go to the people.”
This call to defiance found a ready hearing among the sons and daughters of the educated classes of Petersburg. From now on the aim was to “go to the people,” a slogan that gave birth to the Populist movements in Russia. But an education was still necessary and for that one had to go abroad.
Zurich, therefore, became the training ground for a whole new generation of Russian revolutionaries who supplied the initiative from abroad when this had petered out within Russia. In the free air of Switzerland they could search for possible solutions to the state of their homeland. What was surprising was the large number of women students at Zurich.
For the academic year 1872-3, when Vera Figner began her studies there, one hundred and forty Russian women enrolled in the course. Figner speaks of the existence of a discussion group among the Russian students, called the Frichi Circle, after the great house in which most of the members lived. The twelve members of the Circle were all women.
They discussed “the development of socialist ideas, from Thomas More to later times; political economy; popular movements and revolutions; familiarity with the state of working-class questions in the west; study of English trade unions, history of the International, and so on.”
The Tsarist government, however, grew alarmed at the great number of Russian women who attended courses at Zurich, and in May 1873 it issued an order threatening to exclude students from all official occupations in Russia unless they left the University. One of the principal reasons given for this order was that Russian women at Zurich had been practising “free love” and so giving offence to the local population.
The threat, whatever its motives, was too serious to be ignored, and the student body began to split up, several members going back to Russia and others going to other foreign universities to study, since the order applied only to Zurich.
Even after this, a small core of women was left behind. The Russian colony at Zurich never entirely disappeared and was supplemented from time to time by exiles who found it safer to plan revolution from abroad. It was a group of these who in 1875 founded the central body of the Pan-Russian Social Revolutionary Organization, based on an alliance between Russian and Caucasian revolutionaries and devoted to working-class agitation within Russia.
At one of their first meetings, writes a Caucasian delegate, they were surprised to see half a dozen young girls turn up. “All these girls were simply and smartly dressed, and against our will they attracted our attention. Some were so shy that they lowered their eyes... Certainly at least half of these girls had never crossed the threshold of the so-called world.” Yet these were women who were all to play a central part in the new organization.
One of them was Lydia Figner, whose sister Vera was at that moment in Berne with at least two other prominent women revolutionaries. In Russia, at the same time, girls were drifting into the revolutionary movement because it was the only one to offer education with a purpose.
Katerina Breshkovskaya, who was later to appear as one of the defendants in the Trial of the 193, reports that “as early as 1873 a community was formed in Kiev by the ‘youth belonging to the intelligentsia.’ These were students and girls who were studying courses in midwifery. There were no other courses for women in Kiev at that time.”
The organization founded by the Pan-Russian group consisted within Russia of about a score of people who dedicated themselves to propaganda among the workers, using as their mouthpiece a short-lived (1875-6) newspaper called the Rabotnik (Worker) which existed only so long as the agitational groups existed. In this work a fundamental part was played by women propagandists who had made their first incursions into revolutionary life at Zurich.
A contemporary records how one of these, Beta Kaminskaya, “took advantage of every possible pretext to start discussion with the workers.
If she saw a young man holding the book which his employer had given him and which contained the rule concerning the workers’ duties, Kaminskaya read it aloud to him, explaining the meaning of each rule and showing the workers how each one of these articles was harmful to them and advantageous only to the employer. She spoke to them of the lives of workers in the West, of their solidarity and their struggle against exploitation.”
But all this good work fell to the ground when in April 1875 the police rounded up the agitators in Moscow and totally destroyed what remained of the organization. The Rabotnik, the first working-class newspaper printed in Russia, ceased to exist in 1876. The whole group disintegrated. In 1877 the leading figures in it were put on trial at what became known as the Trial of the Fifty, so named from the number of accused.
Once again it was a woman, Sofia Bardina, one of the Zurich circle, who dominated proceedings. Her defence speech proclaimed the ideals of a whole generation of revolutionaries.
“If the ideal society of which we dream could be brought into being without any violent revolution, we would be happy in the depths of our souls. I only think that in certain circumstances violent revolution is an inevitable evil... We want to destroy privileges, the division of men into classes, into those who possess land and those who do not. We do not want to destroy the individuals who make up these classes.”
Such moderate sentiments were of little avail. She was sentenced to ten years’ hard labour and then banished to Siberia. Later she escaped abroad, but the years of prison had broken her spirit and she committed suicide in 1883.
Meanwhile, other revolutionary movements in Russia had come to the same impasse of suppression and defeat. The call to go “to the people,” which had been raised after 1861, led to the formation of the first (and unsuccessful) organization called by the name Land and Liberty (Zemlya i Volya). In inspiration it depended on the ideals propounded by Herzen’s paper Kolokol.
But after 1863 this first Land and Liberty ceased to exist, and for some time the revolutionary stage was occupied by other societies of lesser moment. The anarchist Bakunin was among those whose influence led to the formation of policies and societies with no great inspiration and little chance of success. Not until the formation of the Chaikovskists in 1869 did there come into existence a group capable of leading revolutionary agitation in Russia.
Led from the first by Nikolai Chaikovsky, who gave the movement its name, and Mark Natanson, the real leader of the group, the Chaikovskists began to attract some of the most promising revolutionaries of the period, among them Prince Peter Kropotkin.
Centred on Petersburg, the group devoted itself to propaganda above all. Here again the women played a vital part. Of the half dozen or more women who stood out in this circle the most prominent was Sofia Perovskaya.
Perovskaya was by origin from the highest social circles. Her father was a General who had at one time been Governor of St. Petersburg. Trained and brought up as the daughter of a senior bureaucrat, she soon showed that she was more interested in studying life than in pursuing social rounds. She devoted herself to serious reading and eventually joined the Chaikovsky circle. When she did so in 1870, she was still only seventeen years old.
A photograph of her taken shortly afterwards shows how this youthfulness in years was matched by her schoolgirlish features. ButPerovskayawas far from being a schoolgirl. According to Kropotkin, she was the heart and soul of the Chaikovskists. “We used to meet,” he writes in his memoirs, “in a suburb of St. Petersburg, in a small house of which Sofia Perovskaya, under the assumed name and forged passport of a labourer’s wife, was the supposed tenant...
Perovskaya was a Populist to the very bottom of her heart, and at the same time a revolutionary, a fighter of the truest steel. She had no need to embellish the workers and the peasants with imaginary virtues in order to love them and to work for them. She took them as they were and said to me once, ‘We have begun a great thing. Two generations, perhaps, will succumb in the task, and yet it must be done’.”
The “great thing” begun in favour of the workers and peasants was of paramount significance. In the first place, the emphasis placed by the Chaikovskists on working-class agitation made them the pioneers of the working-class movement in Russia. Their success may be measured by a police report of 1874 which confessed that “the propagandists have been able to sow among the workers hatred for their employers and the belief that the forces of labour are being exploited.”
In the second place, the Chaikovskists produced some of the most active leaders of the Populist movements at the end of the century, notably Natanson who in 1876 was responsible for the formation of the new Populist party Land and Liberty, so named in honour of the first one that had existed in the 1860’s.
The second Land and Liberty, which came into being because of the loss of cohesion among the Chaikovskists and the growing pressure of the Tsarist police, filled the gap left by the decline of the Social Revolutionaries. Revolutionaries now gravitated towards the new organization. Vera Figner and Dorothea Aptekman, two of the most prominent women agitators abroad, had already left Switzerland at the end of 1875 in order to help the movement at home.
Figner and another sister of hers, Eugenia, volunteered to take part in the movement “to the people” which now formed the core of Land and Liberty policy, and in 1877 they went into action in the province of Samara. The date is important for another reason.
1877 was the year of the great repression in Populist history. Of the many court trials of revolutionaries that then took place the first prominent one was the famous Trial of the Fifty in March. The great sympathy aroused in the public mind by the selfless young conspirators in the dock was enhanced by Sofia Bardina’s crowning speech. In an effort to recapture the initiative the government pushed through an even larger trial, that of the 193, which lasted from October 1877 to January 1878.
One day the Governor of St. Petersburg, General Trepov, visited the prison where the prisoners for the latter trial were kept. Angered by the behaviour of one prisoner, Emelyanov, known also as Bogolyubov, the General obtained an order to have him flogged. He was flogged so unmercifully that he went mad and died some years later. The humiliation and injustice of this flogging threw the revolutionaries into a frenzy, and retribution was planned by several agitators.
They were all beaten to it by a young girl who, the day after the trial ended, mixed with the number of petitioners who habitually visited the Governor to place their grievances before him. When it came to her turn to speak to Trepov she took out a revolver and fired point-blank at him. Trepov was only slightly wounded, but his assailant was arrested. Her name was Vera Zasulich.
From the age of seventeen she had been a revolutionary. From 1869-1871 she had been in prison and was then sent into exile under surveillance in Kharkov. It was shortly after this that she undertook to assassinate Trepov.
At her trial the judge asked her what had motivated her action. Zasulich answered, “I could not bear the thought that the degradation of human personality should go unpunished.” Her trial turned out to be a manifestation of popular support for her act of protest. Surprisingly, she was tried by a jury and not by a military court.
The mass emotion aroused is illustrated clearly in the account given by the presiding judge, after the jury had been called in. “There was a deathly silence. Everyone held their breath. The foreman of the jury handed me the verdict. Against the first question stood out in firm letters: ‘No, not guilty!’
A whole whirl of thoughts about the results, the impact, the significance of these three words swam through my head as I wrote them down. I handed the verdict back to the foreman, and glanced at Zasulich... No one who was not present can imagine the outburst of noise that drowned the voice of the foreman (when he read the verdict), or the commotion which shot through the courtroom like an electric shock. Cries of uncontrolled joy, hysterical sobbing, wild applause, stamping feet, shouts of ‘Bravo! Vera! Verochka!’—all merged into a single groan and wail.”
The shock of the acquittal on March 31st, 1878, made headlines all over Europe. Zasulich was quickly spirited away by friends who feared her re-arrest. Kropotkin reports his reception of the news:
“I was in Paris when the news of the acquittal came, and had to call that day on business at the offices of several newspapers. I found the editors glowing with enthusiasm and writing forceful articles in honour of this Russian girl.”
So successfully did Zasulich disappear into hiding that abroad it was believed she had been re-arrested by the police.
The Revue des Deux Mondes broke into a lyrical article demanding her reappearance: “Before definitively resolving the Eastern Question, before committing ourselves to cross the Bosphorus again, or even before pronouncing on the treaty of San Stefano, before settling the frontiers of Bulgaria, before deciding if this new province of Russia should stop at the Balkans or extend to the Aegean: Europe must wait to know what has become of Vera Zasulich.”
In the event, she had escaped abroad to safety in Switzerland. There she drifted apart from the main trends in the revolutionary movement, and ironically became firmly opposed to the use of terroristic tactics. She was in Russia in 1879-80, but went abroad again until 1905; then she returned as an enemy of Lenin and of the Bolshevik revolution of 1917.
Despite herself, the spark lit by this girl with the flat peasant features lit the way to a new era of violence. The year of the attempt on Trepov—1878—also became the year when four attempts on crowned heads were made in Europe—two against the Kaiser, one against the King of Spain, and one against the King of Italy.
And at home Zasulich’s shot set in train further, more successful, attempts at assassination. The terrorist tradition was, of course, not new, but it had not always been approved of by the revolutionaries in Russia.
The first important terrorist act in Populist history was the shot fired on April 4th, 1866, at the Tsar Liberator, Alexander II, by Dmitri Karakozov, comrades one by one” except for Rysakov, who had informed against his fellow conspirators a young nobleman and Populist whose despair at the growing misery of the peasantry drove him to consider assassination the ideal protest as well as solution. Karakozov’s failure led to such brutal repression by the police that it eliminated terrorism as an advisable policy for the next decade.
After Zasulich, however, terrorism came into being again. In August of this same year 1878 the head of the Third Section (the secret police), General Mezentsov, was stabbed to death in the middle of St. Petersburg by two members of the newly organized Land and Liberty.
In February of the following year the Governor of Kharkov, Kropotkin, a cousin of the anarchist leader, was shot by a Jewish member of the revolutionary organization. Finally, on April 2nd, 1879, the Tsar again became the victim of an unsuccessful attempt, this time made by Alexander Solovev, an earnest and dedicated member of Land and Liberty.
Meanwhile, as we have already seen, the second Land and Liberty, resurrected in 1876, was busy with activity but unsure of its aims. In the three years from 1876 to the congress of the party held at Voronezh in 1879, no firm policy could be decided upon.
When the meeting took place at Voronezh, in the year after a series of terroristic assassinations, a strong minority devoted to terrorism had grown up within the party. Voronezh ended with a split in the movement, and the radical minority struck out on its own path, as the party of the People’s Will—Narodnaya Volya. Although Narodnaya Volya was to develop as a terroristic body, “terror for its own sake,” as Vera Figner later claimed, “was never the aim of the party.
It was a method of protection, of self-defence; it was considered a powerful weapon for agitation and used only when the aims of the party would be furthered.” Yet terrorism was an accepted principle of which there were tried exponents in the party, including a core of women, notably Maria Oshanina, “the only conscious Jacobin member” of the party, to quote Franco Venturi. Of the other women the most prominent once again was Perovskaya.
Narodnaya Volya accepted almost from the first that one of its aims was to be the assassination of the Tsar, who had betrayed the cause of freedom in Russia. Consequently, the work of the next few years centred on plots to kill Alexander II, and in nearly all of them Perovskaya played a key role. It was she who on November 19th, 1879, took part in the attempt to mine the Moscow-Kursk railway line over which Alexander was due to pass in the imperial train.
The conspirators that night let one train through by mistake and succeeded only in blowing up the train that came after it; unfortunately for them, the Tsar had been on the first one. In the spring of 1880 Perovskaya went to Odessa where she and a fellow conspirator, a man named Sablin, began to lay a mine under a street over which Alexander was due to pass on a proposed visit to the city.
The visit failed to materialize and the plans were abandoned. Narodnaya Volya, now depleted by several arrests and executions, could ill afford to make another unsuccessful venture. In December 1880 they therefore concentrated their efforts on work in St. Petersburg. It was proposed to rent a shop on Malaya Sadovaya street, along which the Tsar often passed, and to mine it according to the plan drawn up at Odessa.
On February 14th, 1881, the Tsar actually passed along Malaya Sadovaya, but although the tunnel was ready the mine had not been laid. In exasperation the Committee of Narodnaya Volya stipulated that all preparations must be completed by March 1st.
This was to be the seventh attempt, and it must be the last. If the mine failed, then four bomb-throwers were to be at hand, and if even this failed, Zhelyabov, the principal activist of the party and Perovskaya’s lover, was to fall upon the Tsar with a dagger.
Unfortunately, bad luck again frustrated their preparations. On the evening of February 27th Zhelyabov was arrested, and on the following day police visited the cheese shop at which the tunnel was being dug. The loss of their main conspirator, and the possibility of discovery, now made further delay impossible. A meeting of the Committee on the night of February 28th decided that everything must be ready by the following morning for a possible attempt.
In Zhelyabov’s absence, Perovskaya became the driving force behind the preparations. The hand-made bombs were ready by eight o’clock in the morning on March 1st, and Perovskaya gave the throwers full instructions about the positions they were to take up.
Just before one o’clock on March 1st, the Tsar left his palace in his coach. Half an hour later the coach began the return journey. But it did not come back through Malaya Sadovaya, and the efforts spent on the mine were therefore wasted. Sofia Perovskaya, however, saved the situation with her presence of mind. Deciding that the imperial coach would have to return via the Ekaterinskaya Canal, she hurried over to the bomb-throwers, assigned them new positions, and arranged to give the signal with her handkerchief.
As the Tsar’s carriage rumbled past, the first of the conspirators, Rysakov, threw his bomb. It fell short of the carriage, and instead mortally wounded a Cossack and a passing boy. Alexander stopped and got out to inspect the damage. Rysakov had been seized by some of the guards and the Tsar came up to look at him. Someone asked the Emperor if he had been hurt. “I am safe, thank God,” he replied. Rysakov said, “It is too soon to thank God.”
Alexander turned away and moved towards his carriage. At that moment the second conspirator, Grinevitsky, threw his bomb at the Tsar’s feet. There was a second thunderous explosion. When the smoke cleared, they found the Tsar on the ground, covered with blood and dying. Near him lay Grinevitsky, also mortally wounded. It was shortly after two o’clock. The Tsar Liberator died just over an hour later in the Winter Palace, to which his attendants had carried him.
Vera Figner, waiting for news of the attempt, heard the explosions and shared the excitement of the occasion with the other waiting conspirators.
“We all wept. The heavy nightmare which had for ten years weighed down on young Russia was at an end. The horrors of prison and exile, of violence and atrocities upon hundreds and thousands of our adherents, the blood of our martyrs—all expiated by this moment, by the blood of the Tsar. A heavy burden was lifted from our shoulders. Reaction must come to an end and give place to a new Russia.”
It only remained for the assassins to expiate their crime. In custody, Rysakov gave way under pressure and began to inform against his colleagues. The next few days witnessed the arrest of dozens of leading members of Narodnaya Volya. After the success of the assassination, Perovskaya lost all her will to continue the work, and longed to join Zhelyabov in custody. She was arrested on March 10th.
The Executive Committee in its anxiety ordered members of the organization to leave St. Petersburg and hide in the country. Vera Figner, however, was at her own request allowed to stay for a few more days. On the morning of April 3rd she left her flat and walked into streets alive with conversation about the execution of the regicides. An hour after she left, the police arrived at her flat.
That day saw the hanging of the regicides. Sofia Perovskaya, Zhelyabov, Rysakov, and two others mounted the scaffold. Zhelyabov was included because of his voluntary confession of complicity. Perovskaya embraced her comrades one by one, excluding Rysakov. Then the nooses were tightened.
“Sofia Lvovna Perovskaya,” wrote Figner later in her memoirs, “by her revolutionary activity and by her fate as the first woman to be executed for a political crime, remains one of a small number who will pass into history.” The two had first met in 1877. Perovskaya had instantly attracted Figner’s attention. “She looked like a young peasant girl with her short flaxen plait, her pale grey eyes, and her round childlike cheeks.
In her fair, attractive little face there was much that was youthful and unaffected, much that recalled a child. This childlike character of her face was preserved up to the very end, despite the tragic moments she went through during those March days.”
Another woman colleague, Katerina Breshkov-skaya, who first met Perovskaya in June 1878, recalled that “she was as pure and calm a figure as if she had stepped out of a classic drama of ancient Greece. Her young, fresh face expressed peace of mind, calm wisdom, and superiority to her surroundings. Even her smile was as serious as that of a mature man.”
With this picture in the minds of her comrades, everywhere in the revolutionary world she instantly assumed the honours of a proto-martyr. In 1883 Turgenev went so far as to publish a worse than mediocre prose poem about Perovskaya in which she was addressed as a saint.
This was the apotheosis of emancipated Russian womanhood. Beginning first with the urge to educate themselves in order to serve the people, several women had entered medicine in the footsteps of Nadezhda Suslova. Figner’s whole training, and that of many others in Zurich, had been in medicine.
Even Perovskaya had a medical diploma, which she worked for in Petersburg in 1876-7. The failure of the movement “to the people,” and of peaceful agitation, convinced such women that their work would be in vain unless greater freedom were established in Russia. As Figner was to say at her eventual trial in September 1884:
“It was not insincerity, but bitter necessity that forced me to give up my original views and set out on another path... My experience had led me to the conviction that the only way to change the existing order was through violence.”
Thus gentle and well-educated young women were driven to believe passionately in terror as the only means to achieve freedom. Scores of them received prison sentences and exile in this cause, and some ultimately gave up their lives. Very few, however, who lived long enough to see the Revolution triumph in 1917 were to reconcile themselves to it.