'Picture Shows': The Early British Film Industry in Walthamstow
The unlikely setting of the East London suburb of Walthamstow was a centre for the infant British cinema industry at the turn of the century. Margaret O'Brien and Julia Holland chart its course, aided by interviews with and recollections of local people, many of whom were involved as 'extras' in the early silent films.
The first public picture film show in Britain was in 1896, when the Lumiere Brothers projected their strips of film at Regent Street Polytechnic, The novel impact of this event was the life-like projection and the size of the screen. As The Times reported in 1896:
The spectator no longer gazes through a narrow aperture at the changing pictures but has them presented to him full size on a large screen.
Experimentation with the movie camera was taking place in Europe and America during the 1890s. Early-film makers in Britain tended to be travelling showmen, exhibiting their films at fairgrounds, music halls and 'penny-gaffs' (shop shows). Theatres devoted specifically to film were rare. Most films before 1910 were one-reelers, that is 1,000 feet of film running for fifteen minutes or less, and presented as part of a package of entertainment. Very few of these early films survive. Film was treated as if it were cloth - a commodity to be bought and sold at a price so much a foot. A second-hand market arose and both copies and negatives literally wore out. At first any movement on screen thrilled audiences; trains stopping at a station, men demolishing a wall. Narrative films soon developed and films were sold as types or genres. Short comedies, based on simple visual gags were standard products, as were short dramas which often had strong moral messages - for example against the evils of drink.
Most films people watched before 1914 were foreign films - American, French and Italian - but there was a burgeoning British film industry. Successful pioneers formed their own production companies and studios. Walthamstow, on the borders between Essex and London, was one of the first centres of the new film Industry.
By 1914, most towns in Britain had their own purpose-built cinemas. According to Gregory Tomkin (Showtime in Walthamstow) there were ten in Walthamstow, each catering for audiences of several hundred, the largest being the Carlton Cinema built in 1913 with seating for 1,450. In attempting to create a more sophisticated image the new picture palaces were both sumptuous and respectable. The Walthamstow Times in 1913 described the entrance of the Carlton as being:
Richly carpeted having oak panelled walls and antique lanterns for illumination ... with each new cinema opened in Walthamstow a fresh set of adjectives becomes necessary in order to describe adequately its beauty and luxury.
The programme on offer in these cinemas tended to be a package of different sorts of film entertainment. The Victoria Hall, the first full-time cinema in Walthamstow, opened in August 1907 and Miathew Raymond the owner offered this programme:
Scenes of an entire trip from Southampton to the Cape of South Africa, the Rival Sisters, Wild animals in Haspburg, Lightning Sketches, Scenes of the Thor Tragedy, Bobbies Birthday Football, the Nurses Strike and Perseverance Rewarded.
In music-hall style there were also songs with choruses projected on the screen.
By 1911 there was a children's matinee at the Victoria Hall on Saturdays. Film makers quickly realised the potential of a children's market, and American film companies, in particular, developed the serial. Cheap to produce and to hire, serials such as the Perils of Pauline (1914) attracted children to Saturday matinee shows which, at a penny or tuppence, were cheap enough for most working-class children to go regularly.
The films were only part of the entertainment: The picture on the screen would darken and smoke would come out of the projectionist box. There was only one projector. Everything would stop till he cleaned the machinery' (Ted Harrison). Despite making fun of the projectionist's mistakes Ted Harrison recalls that some of the glamour surrounding films was invested in the projectionist himself, and to children it seemed a high status job. All performances were accompanied by music, usually a lady playing the piano. Occasionally a small orchestra would be provided; a contributor to the Walthamstow Guardian in June 1930 remembers Matt Raymond at the Victoria Hall and the excellent little orchestra with very short red jackets. During one Saturday matinee at St. James Electric Cinema, the film was forgotten when the band's platform collapsed. 'It came away from the wall, the music stopped. Everybody laughed' (Mrs Cluny).
Cinema managers were aware of the need to establish control over the large numbers of highly excited children. 'We were not allowed to go in gangs. Big beefy blokes kept order inside and if you swore you could be thrown out... it you spat orange pips you had to be careful to move around or they'd come after you' (Ted Harrison).
Cinema as a mass form of popular culture was seen as a threat, exercising overtly and covertly a bad influence on working-class young people and directing them away from organised, healthy and uplifting pursuits. The Reverend Leggit expressed this jealous fear: 'Some of us have given very long years to the very poor population in London... The cinema has opened up another avenue which makes all our labours in that direction much more difficult' (London Public Morality Council 1930, evidence to chief censor.) A major source of evidence for the fierceness of the public debate on the influence of cinema is the 1917 National Council of Public Morals Inquiry. This Inquiry, conducted by a panel of prominent citizens, cited three main areas of concern: juvenile crime, the behaviour and attitudes of young people, and the physical effects of regular cinema going.
Magistrates had already linked cinema to crime. In 1912 in Sutton Coalfield, some boys found guilty of theft were bound over not to enter a picture theatre for twelve months. 'Cinematograph Blamed for Boy's Downfall' (newspaper headline). It was brought up at the inquiry that love of going to the cinema encouraged boys to steal and beg money for admission.
But by far the greatest concern of the Inquiry was the general moral effects of cinema. Girls, especially, were seen to be at risk, both from indelicate sexual situations on the screen and the indelicate 'atmosphere' in the auditorium, in particular, the darkness and in some cinemas, like The Queens, Waltham-stow, double courting seats in the back row. One witness to the Inquiry complained that the 'pictures give to children quite wrong ideas of life arid conduct... they make children, whose thoughts should be happy arid wholesome, familiar with ideas of death by exhibiting shooting, stabbings, and the like'. Lastly, the Inquiry considered the 'evidence' from educationalists that the cinema had a physically debilitating effect on children - poor ventilation, eye strain and abnormal excitement were all cited.
It is clear that what worried the Inquiry was the need for control for a powerful form of mass entertainment: The cinema, under wise guidance may be made a powerful influence for good; if neglected, if its abuse is unchecked its potentialities for evil are manifold.' In the context of the fierce moral debate and the fear of further state-imposed restrictions the industry had initiated its own form of censorship 1912. This resulted in the grading of films into 'A' Adult, 'U' Universal, and a list of twenty-two grounds for banning films; including the materiality of Jesus Christ, depiction of native customs in foreign lands abhorrent to British ideas, cruelty to women, and scenes disparaging public characters and institutions.
One of the early film pioneers connected with Walthamstow was E.G. Turner (1871-1961). Typical of the early showmen he was an inventor, film-maker and exhibitor. He gave up a hairdressing apprenticeship in 1896 to go into partnership, making and showing films. His was the first company to exploit the market in renting films, The Walthamstow Co. 1904, which was reorganised as Walturdaw in 1905. In 1896, for two guineas he laid on the first film show in Walthamstow at the Victoria Hall while it was still a music hall.
After that, he was regularly showing films in the High Street public baths on a Saturday afternoon. Public baths were often used for public events such as film shows and dancing and interviewees remember sitting on the floor, often watching unrelated pieces of film for the sheer excitement of the moving pictures. In an interview with a local paper in 1955 Turner claimed to have invented and shown the first talkies. He synchronised a gramophone to a film projector and called it a Cinematophone. According to Turner his budding enterprise was stopped by the 'big bosses who controlled Variety and Stage.'
As a film-maker Turner was a one-man crew. In his interview with the Walthamstow Guardian in 1961 he said: 'In those days we used to make a film in a day or so; if the weather was fine perhaps in one day. We used to pay 7/6 for our scenario and for these 200 ft films we used to pay actors perhaps 101- a day'. Turner would find his actors at Poverty Corner, York Road, near Waterloo Station, which was a haunt of out-of-work stage actors. Turner's involvement with the film industry continued until his death in 1961, although increasingly he specialised in the manufacture of film equipment, marketing his own earlier inventions - fire-proof projectors and operating boxes.
In the years before the First World War, more film production companies were formed and films became longer. It was in this period of expansion that the Walthamstow film companies were established. These included: the Cunard; the Precision; the Broadwest; and the British and Colonial. The early 'producer' was likely to appear in films, to be able to operate the camera, and often performed the function of stage manager as well. Walter West, head of the Broadwest Studio, talking about a film in Pictures & Picturegoer (1925) describes early film-making:
The plot for my initial production was conceived in a little back office; by candlelight - because my last: shilling had long been put in the gas metre. Next day I secured the money (a few hundred pounds) for my first production, and started, with the help of several enthusiastic friends to produce, what was to be a 'winner'. I, as producer-scenario-writer-electrician-set-designer, leading part in the film, whilst the carpenters, office boy and secretary of the small company were also featured in this marvellous movie. The film took ten days to make, was a two-reeler, and sold at a big profit.
The Stage Manager or director, as he came to be called, was the man with the megaphone mainly concerned with keeping actors and extras within the frame of the camera's vision.
In Movies: Haw they are made and worked, Frank Talbot describes the job of a stage manager in 1912:
As a rule the camera is brought within a few feet of the picture, in order that the actors may be photographed as large as possible. On the floor on either side battens are laid to indicate the limits within which actors and actresses must move. Beyond these confines was to vanish from the scene, and the stage manager may he heard over the whirr of the camera shouting peremptorily to one or other of the company to keep in the picture...
The early studio productions operated with all kinds of restrictions, for example filming was mostly done in the summer because of the need for light. A man would be posted at the studio door to shout when the sun was emerging from the clouds.
Other features of Walthamstow's urban development made it ideal as a centre for the film industry. The Great Eastern Railway expanded to Walthamstow in the 1870s and 1880s and provided a good, cheap link to central London. Industrial and housing development took place around St. James Station and Highams Park Station. This was important as many film actors were borrowed from the theatre and needed to return to the West End each evening.
Industry in Walthamstow remained small, and protected by the River Lea and the marshes. The air and light of the area was reasonably pure and clean, making it suitable for filming. Walthamstow did not suffer the smogs of Central London.
Walthamstow was also surrounded by ideal locations for filming. Perhaps the most famous and most used was Epping Forest. The following extract horn Pictures and Picturegoer (February 1919) describes location shooting there with Broadwest's star, Violet Hopson:
I arrived at the Broadwest Studios in the nick of time. Violet Hopson, the versatile and popular leading lady of this enterprising British concern, had just finished 'making up' and, attired in tweeds, brogues and a distinctive 'Hopson' hat, was ready to board a big yellow Daimler car.
She extended to me a warm invitation to 'come too', and so I was fortunate enough to see this world-famous star at work on a scene for a forthcoming Broadwest film, 'In the Gloaming'.
We sped along the snow-laden roads for miles, then, approaching the glorious precincts of Epping Forest, a pretty spot was decided upon after much consultation between the camera-man and Mr West, who produces all the films in which Miss Hopson appears, and the company set to work to rehearse the scene. The biggest part of an hour was spent in recording... it is this consistent attention to detail, that has brought the standard of Broadwest films up to the level of the very best of the market.
The Walthamstow film companies as much as possible filmed outside, using local people and buildings. The cobbled yard of the local milk depot was a favourite for stagecoach adventures. Sensational local news events were often reconstructed on film. Precision Films, Walthamstow, made a filmed reconstruction of the dramatic murder of PC Tyler in Tottenham in 1908: two Russians stole a payroll from the local rubber factory and in their getaway shot the local policeman; in the subsequent chase across the Lea Marshes to Chingford both men wereshot. The events were filmworthy because of the association of Russians with the Anarchist scare at that time.
Many Walthamstow people were used as extras. Miss Anning recalls how film people would go into local pubs to recruit extras. She mentions the Duke's Head which is close to the site of the Wood Street Studio. Jim Hill and friends went along to the Wood Street studio after hearing a rumour at school. About thirty children were needed for a crowd scene. They were told to 'wave about - go mad'. They were filmed in the studio garden with one camera and a tripod: the director was shouting instructions through a megaphone. They were paid 'a marvellous sixpence and a bottle of pop - I'll never forget that.' Miss Arming's father was a guard on the Chingford railway when 'the film people arrived at the station and wanted to film a sequence along the platform. I think the film was supposed to be in Scarborough, my Dad was working that day and they asked him to walk down the platform and find the man who was poisoned.'
Many people offered themselves as extras for the fun. Mrs Standen's mother and aunt, took part in a circus film. They had to stand inside the big top which was erected on Forest Road, and look up and scream - 'My God - she's fallen.' One lady recalls seeing the Three Musketeers wandering up Wood Street to the Broadwest Studio. To some people, film production brought a bit of glamour into the area. Louise Kable told how she and her sisters used to hang over their back garden fence to watch the stars whenever there was a garden party to celebrate a new film.
To the film maker local interest: could sometimes prove a problem. In a interview in Picture Post (date not known) Walter West describes shooting on location in London:
Street scenes always present some difficulty to the Producer, for in London, even yet the public is not used, to the sudden appearance of a movie camera. No sooner is the tripod unloaded from the motor car which has conveyed the working staff to the scene of action, then a small errand boy stops to gaze wide-eyed at the movie folk - soon he is joined by several other 'rubber necks', and before the artistes can act their scenes, a crowd of some hundreds of people has collected, including business men in top hats, ladies in costly furs, the nursemaid and the postman. Frequently these interested spectators ruin a scene, because their curiosity leads them to step in front on the camera. Not infrequently also does the crowd become so large, that the efforts of the police to disperse it prove almost hopeless - then much to the producer's annoyance, the only solution to the problem is to steal away and endeavour to set the scene in a less busy thoroughfare.
There were two main studios in Walthamstow before 1924. The British and Colonial Kinematograph Company (established in 1909 by A.H. Bloomfield and J.B. McDowell) which in 1913 moved to the site of an old roller-skating rink in Hoe Street, and the Broadwest Film Company (established in 1914 by Walter West G.T. Broad bridge). Each studio occupied a large area of about half an acre. British and Colonial was one of the major studios in London, having room for twenty sets at a time; however, sets often consisted merely of painted backcloths, sometimes rather creased in appearance. Maximum use was made of natural light - the roof was part glass, and there were sliding doors so that the cameraman could go outside to film long shots. There were thirty Westminster electric lamps above the stage. The cameramen used the large wooden box cameras made by Moy or Pathe. Nearly every part of film production was done in the studio, including film processing at Broad-west. Rushes were viewed in the property store. There was no fire-proof projector booth, which must have been a hazard to the projectionist and the film.
Walter West began making films in 1912. with a short two-reeler that took ten days to make and was sold at a big profit. For the first few years of Broad-west he continued this policy. In its early days British and Colonial made a name for itself by producing several distinctive adventure series, including five one-reelers on DickTurpin; and the famous 'Lieutenant Daring' series which created one of the first stars, the 'dashing' Percy Moran. Reviews in Bioscope stress the patriotic nature of the Lieutenant Daring series with films like Lieutenant Daring Avenges an Insult to the Union Jack. 'This is stirring naval drama which will appeal forcibly to all patriots'. Bioscope was an influential trade journal that reviewed all films released and contributed to the major moral and social debates on the cinema.
More ambitious films followed. The need to rival more sophisticated features from abroad and provide films for British audiences in the new Picture Palaces encouraged investment in longer and more expensive productions. British and Colonial started, a new tradition by making the first expensive British spectacle film in 1913, The Battle of Waterloo. It was directed by Charles Weston, was five reels long and proudly boasted '2,000 soldiers, 116 scenes, 1,000 horses, 50 cannons'. This was to be a money-spinner, and was sold to two renting companies for £5,000. Bioscope gives The Battle of Waterloo a full-page spread paying tribute to British and Colonial, pioneers of the film industry in their 'admirable courage and enterprise in attempting this big national production'.
British and Colonial also pioneered films featuring 'balloon and aeroplane thrills like Through the Clouds (August 1914). There is an account of aeroplane stunts by Cyril Taylor Smith in the Walthamstow Guardian of April 17th, 1959. Mr Smith, was a stuntman for British and Colonial. He earned £4.10 per week but would get '30 golden sovereigns' for a particularly dangerous stunt and he recalls leaping out of aeroplanes suspended from the roof in the Hoe Street studio.
Broadwest's first 'super' production was The Woman Who Did in 1915. Based on a popular novel of the same name, it was the story of a Girton girl who lived with the man she loved without marrying him. Shot partly in Milan and Perugia starring Eve Balfour and J.R. Tozer, West recalls that it was the first time a British film company had gone to Italy and no-one in the crew spoke Italian. Both Walthamstow studios took the lead in what was then the unusual venture of foreign location work. British and Colonial filmed on location in Jamaica in 1913 for Lieutenant Daring and the Dancing Girl, and F. Burlingham scaled the Alps with heavy equipment to make Tragedy in the Alps (1913).
The First World War made profound changes in the lives of British people, not the least of which was increased Government powers in all spheres of life including leisure and culture. For the first time the Government saw the potential of film for propaganda purposes, not only in neutral countries to counter German propaganda, but also to show the extent of the British war effort to audiences. Films were expected to raise morale and encourage greater efforts among the industrial workers at home. However, at the beginning of the War cameramen who went to shoot film on the Western Front faced enormous difficulties, carrying all their own equipment and having to argue their case with military men of the old school for authorisation to film. To deal with these problems, British and Colonial was one of the companies to form the Cinematograph Trade Committee in 1915. This Committee became incorporated first with the War Office and then the new Ministry of Information. The film companies agreed that any profit made through public distribution of their war footage should be given to military charities. Official War Cinematographers were appointed. One o£ these was McDowell, Managing Director of British and Colonial; he spent much of the war filming on the Western Front. Along with another cameraman, Malins, McDowell made The Battle of the Somme in 1916 which was highly successful nationwide, as described by Malins in his book How I Filmed the War:
His Majesty the King has declared the 'the public should see these pictures'; and Mr Lloyd George, after witnessing a display of the film, sent forth the following thrilling message to the nation: 'Be up and doing! See that this picture, which is in itself an epic of self-sacrifice and gallantry, reaches everyone. Herald the deeds of our brave men to the end of the earth. This is your duty.
According to the trade press, in the first two weeks of its release, Battle of the Somme raised over £30,000 and had 2,000 cinema bookings. Their reviews are ecstatic, 'No written description, no matter how facile his pen, no verbal description by the most interested participator... could hope to convey... the reality of modern warfare with the force and conviction shown in the marvellous series of pictures.'
War dramas also enjoyed a vogue; hundreds were produced. Broad-west's A Munitions Girl's Romance was typical: it derived interest not only from espionage but from its actual shots of aircraft in flight and during manufacture. The film explores the issues of the influx of women workers in the new munition factories and the partial breakdown of class barriers.
By the end of the war Broadwest was one of the most important film companies in the country. However, American competition was already making itself felt and during the post-war period studios tried several ways to keep the British market. Successful books and plays were adapted to film to encourage their audience to go to the cinema. Broadwest made a series based on the racing novels of Nat Gould. This cycle was essentially English, utilising, as it did, the world of racing with its class stereotypes and intrigue.
The American studio model of a stock company and stars was adopted by the film companies. British and Colonial even brought in American personnel to revive the studio. However British studios could not compete with the prestige and money of Hollywood. Walter West was interviewed by the Waltham Forest Guardian in 1948 about 'bit-player' Ronald Coleman. He claimed Coleman earned more in a day in Hollywood than West paid him in a week. In imitation of Hollywood, producers felt they had to create stars to sell their films. Broadwest could boast one of the most famous British stars, Violet Hopson. Her image in the films and fan magazines was carefully constructed as the genteel, retiring and dedicated actress.
By the early 1920s American films dominated world distribution. The American industry had forged ahead during the War and was able to exploit the post-war depression in Europe. Its own massive domestic market meant that films could be sold cheaply abroad, undercutting British home-produced films. Until the British film industry, protected by government legislation, began to recover in the early 1930s, American competition forced many companies to close. Among the casualties were the Walthamstow companies: Broadwest closed down in 1921 and British and Colonial in 1924.