The Sea-Otter and History

Across the Pacific, writes C.M. Yonge, from northern Japan to the Californian coastline, the relentless hunt for the sea-otter’s precious fur had international consequences.

On October 18th, 1867, the Stars and Stripes were hoisted over the previously Russian Town of Sitka; ‘Seward’s Folly’, as it was widely regarded by his countrymen, had received the bare approval of the Senate of the United States, and Alaska, with its immeasurable resources, had been purchased from the Imperial Russian Government for the sum of $7,200,000.

It was eventually, on January 3rd, 1959, to become a State of the Union. Why, one may reasonably ask, was this vast but sparsely inhabited and inhospitable land ever colonized by a Russia separated from the Pacific by the endless expanse of a largely unexplored and unsettled Siberia? What was the lure that attracted, in many cases to their death, hunters and traders first to the Aleutian Islands and then to Alaska and down the coast, briefly as far as California?

To find the answer we must move back in time to St Petersburg at the end of the reign of Peter the Great. Among his last acts was to order Fleet-Captain Bering, a Dane in the service of Russia, to take an expedition to Kamchatka and from there, ‘in as much as its end is not known’, to explore North Pacific coast and discover whether this joined America. Peter had been dead a week when Bering left, his instructions received from Catherine I.

Five years later he was back and reporting, now to the Empress Anne, that he had reached 67°18' without finding any connexion with America. He had actually sailed through the Strait that now bears his name; but his proof was not generally accepted. Perhaps it did not satisfy even him; he had not so much as seen America, and to settle the matter he proposed a second Kamchatka Expedition.

This was swollen by the Russian Admiralty into an impossibly extensive survey covering the Arctic as well as the coasts and islands of both sides of the North Pacific, while the Imperial Academy of Science, a creation of Peter the Great, drew up an elaborate programme involving appointment of scientific staff. Here the most significant figure was to be that of Georg Wilhelm Steller, an intensely ambitious German naturalist educated at the University of Halle, and come to Russia to seek his scientific fortune.

The first section of an expedition that eventually comprised some 1000 members, set off on the interminable 6000 miles journey across Siberia in 1733; others, including Steller, not leaving until five years later. The vast distances travelled, the great numbers involved with the extremes of climate encountered and the primitive modes of transport, to say nothing of the vast programme of exploration, unite to make this possibly the greatest geographical enterprise ever planned.

With arrival at Okhotsk on the Pacific coast, timber had to be felled initially for housing the hundreds of men involved, and then for the construction of vessels thought capable of surviving in these northern seas. It is not surprising that, although an expedition to Japan took place in 1738, it was not until September 1740, nearly eight years after its inception in St Petersburg, that the American Expedition under Bering set sail. The newly built St Peter and St Paul, each some eighty feet long, with two provision ships, then crossed the Sea of Okhotsk to Kamchatka there to spend the winter in the deep shelter of Avatcha Bay in the improvised harbour of Petropavlovsk.

In the spring preparation for the crucial voyage began as soon as the ice melted, although it was not until June that the two vessels departed. After initial search for non-existent land to the south-east, they turned northward, almost immediately to lose contact, and we continue with the St Peter, carrying Bering and Steller. Water was desperately low when, on July 16th, the lifting clouds revealed the impressive majesty of, in the translated words of the log, ‘high, snow-covered mountains among them a high volcano N by W’. Alaska, with the later-named Mount St Elias, had been discovered.

Water-barrels were now replenished; but the first observations on Alaskan soil by Steller were soon cut short by Bering, his long task completed, worn out and anxious to return to the shelter of Petropavlovsk. Against contrary winds and through continuous fog, the St Peter made slow westward progress; landings were made on several of the Aleutian Islands and their people encountered. Meanwhile scurvy broke out, eventually causing the death of almost half the company, including Bering.

In this condition, midway between the end of the Aleutian chain and Kamchatka, the high but desolately treeless Commander Islands were encountered. Caught in a sudden storm, the vessel was wrecked and, on the island to be named after him, Bering and many others died. The remainder only just survived, living in pits covered with canvas in the frozen soil. The leadership now devolved on the resolute shoulders of Waxall, a Swede who eight months later brought the survivors, described as looking like the wild beasts whose skins they wore, back to Petropavlovsk in a reconstructed St Peter. He reported to St Petersburg in 1749, sixteen years after he had left.

Our concern now is with Steller who rose above the surrounding misery on Bering Island to describe the impressive fauna of seals, sea-lions, sea-otters and, above all, of the gigantic Rytina stelleri or Steller’s sea-cow which survives only in his words. This sirenian, greater relative of the still surviving dugong and manatees, was up to thirty feet long, weighing some three tons. Herds of these almost unbelievable beasts are described by Steller as feeding on the rich meadows of brown seaweed or kelp that covered the rocks in the surrounding shallow water.

Every few minutes they would raise the snout above water to draw breath with a noise like the snort of a horse. Fearless, they were also defenceless; but their size made capture difficult for the enfeebled men who eventually secured one with an iron hook. This capture was their salvation. Its flesh was highly palatable, totally unlike that of the sea-bears (fur seals), seals, and sea-otters on which, with that of a stranded whale, they had previously fed. One sea-cow fed fifty men for two weeks, in the end giving them strength to survive and to rebuild the St Peter.

Confined to Bering and neighbouring Copper Island, the sea-cow was already on the way to extinction, but would have survived much longer than the thirty years that still remained to it, had it not occurred in company with the sea-otter. This, most valuable of fur-bearing animals, distantly related to the freshwater otter, is also a creature of the kelp, living in the shelter of its long fronds but feeding on the bottom-living mussels, sea-urchins, abalones and crabs.

It brings these to the surface where, lying on its back, it breaks them open on stones carried up for that very purpose. Monogamous and deeply devoted to their young, these are the most endearing of marine mammals. They occur (or did occur) throughout the range of the great kelp weeds from the Kuril Islands north of Japan to the Commander Islands, along the Aleutian Chain and then down the coast from Alaska to southern California. The value of the fur was early known to the Japanese; and it was hunted by bow and arrow off the Kuril Islands by the primitive Ainu people from northern Japan, the furs being sold at high prices to Chinese mandarins.

Steller describes them as covering the shores of Bering Island in droves; with no experience of man, they persisted in coming towards the camp fires until hundreds had been killed. Their value known, the narrow confines of the reconstructed St Peter were packed with pelts, their eventual sale to the Chinese offsetting a significant proportion of the costs of the expedition.

News of this wealth of furs fell on perfectly attuned ears. The original penetration of Siberia, from crossing of the Urals in 1579 to the first sight of the Pacific sixty years later, had been in pursuit of fur-bearing animals, sable, ermine and bear, just as similar quests for furs coming from Canada and the United States were to open up the American northwest. In Siberia furs were sought by enterprising hard-living promyshlenniki (translated as free-lance hunters) and a highly profitable trade had developed with China. The prospect of trading with the still more valuable sea-otter fur was irresistibly attractive.

Such was the immediate reaction of a sergeant of Cossacks, Emelian Basov, at Petropavlovsk when the survivors from Bering Island arrived in the summer of 1742. Financed by a trader, with a party of promyshlenniki he built a large flat-bottomed boat and in the following summer sailed to Bering Island to spend the winter collecting the furs of sea-otters, seals and blue fox. Year after year this continued, and the profits for one year alone were around 200,000 roubles.

Food came largely from the defenceless sea-cows, which would have starved had they left the kelp, if they had not first been devoured by killer whales unable to reach them when in shallow water. But Steller was not to survive them; dying obscurely in the middle of Siberia on his way back to St Petersburg and fame.

The search for sea-otters extended ever further along the Aleutian chain, and the native Aleuts were ruthlessly exploited. These almost aquatic people hunted in usually two-man canoes or baidarkas, made of drift-wood and whalebone (their islands were treeless), with stretched sea-lion skins, semi-transparent like oiled paper.

Described as ‘possibly the finest little craft ever built by man’ (Chevigny) they were almost miraculously balanced by their occupants and propelled by two-ended paddles, while seals, sea-lions and sea-otters were killed with uncanny accuracy by spears aided by use of a throwing-stick.

Within ten years six vessels were annually making successful voyages from Okhotsk or Kamchatka, with half that number failing to return. Kodiak, the large island off Alaska, was reached in 1763. Tragedy succeeded tragedy as the Aleuts were sent for hundreds of miles through stormy seas in the continuous hunt for otter pelts, until these gentle people rose in wrath at Unalaska, destroying four vessels and killing many of their crews. But this barely affected further activities after the first European settlement was established on Kodiak Island in 1784.

Other European countries became slowly aware of this eastward extension of the Russian Empire, although they did not grasp the reasons. The Spaniards, settled no further north than Mexico but claiming the entire Pacific coast, responded by the establishment of Franciscan Missions that, along El Camino Real, was to take them to San Francisco by 1776 and still further north to Sinoma in 1783.

In London interest was centred on reports of new discoveries in the North Pacific, and that it was in the hope of finding an opening by way of the Pacific into the long sought North-West Passage that Cook sailed in the Discovery and the Resolution on his third voyage. He was to encounter sea-otters at Nootka on the west coast of the future Vancouver Island where one was drawn by his artist, Webber. Pelts must have been obtained there and later in Alaska, where he met natives and some Russians.

Passage through Bering Strait in the summer of 1778 was followed by return for the winter, and to his death, at Hawaii. Probably the major happening on the return journey after visiting Kamchatka was the stop at Canton when the sea-otter pelts, obtained by barter in the north Pacific, fetched such high prices that several crew members deserted in the hope of returning north for further profit.

In this manner the nature of the lure that had drawn the Russians to Alaska became known; and within a few years vessels from Great Britain and from New England, and later from other countries, were rounding Cape Horn and running far north for the sole purpose of bartering for sea-otter furs.

In Alaska the private companies, based on Irkutsk, that had been responsible for early operations up to the settlement on Kodiak were superseded in 1801 by the government chartered Russian-American Company that effectively governed Russian-America until 1867.

As befitted his task, the first governor, Aleksandr Baranov, described by Washington Irving as ‘a rough, rugged hard-drinking old Russian; somewhat of a soldier, somewhat of a trader; above all a boon campanion...’ was a person of tenacious vigour, the largely unfettered ruler of a vast territory, understanding in his dealings with the gentler Aleuts and relentless in those with the savage yet semi-cultured mainland Tlingits.

Under his leadership a large party moved from Kodiak south to Sitka, renamed New Archangel, in richer sea-otter waters. With firearms obtained from Americans trading in pelts, the local Indians had destroyed the settlement, killing almost all the settlers. But Baranov was back and the settlement permanently re-established. He adventured further south to found Fort Rus not far north of San Francisco. There were contacts around the mouth of the Columbia River with John Jacob Astor coming from the opposite direction in pursuit of furs; but these were broken off during the war of 1812 when British vessels dominated the north Pacific.

Very gradually the scene changes. Baranov was superseded and almost immediately died in 1819. Never during his twenty-seven years in Alaska had he more than 400 Russians under his command, with some 1,000 natives and half-castes whom he had educated and trained. Succeeding governors were no less dedicated. A real measure of religion and culture was introduced by the missionary efforts of Father Ioann Veniaminov, a native of Irkutsk attracted to the Pacific by the needs of the Aleuts, whose life he felt held so many of its attributes that he omitted the curriculum of hell from the church breviary. He studied these people and their various dialects, writing what remains the standard work upon them.

Later, he was persuaded to move to Sitka and attempt with less success to convert the more intelligent Tlingits. He travelled to the south, visiting Fort Rus and making contact with the Spanish Franciscans with whom he conversed in Latin. He became the first Bishop of New Archangel, building a cathedral and a college for training priests. Afterwards he was to become Archbishop of Siberia and finally, when aged seventy-one, and Alaska now part of the United States, he was elected Metropolitan of Moscow.

Meanwhile, the sea-otters continued to be relentlessly pursued; even the Spaniards ceased to protect them. Both Russians from Fort Rus and Americans hunted the southern stocks of what are now regarded as a distinct race, or even as a species, living in warmer waters than their northern relatives. Sailing before the mast in 1834, Richard Henry Dana returned from a now Mexican California in a vessel carrying sea-otter pelts.

The Spaniards had been shipping their share to China in exchange for quicksilver needed in the silver mines in Mexico. Then, in 1841, Fort Rus was sold to John Sutter on whose land gold was to be discovered; and the manifest destiny of California to become a part of the United States was realized.

Inevitably the populations of otters fell, and with this the interest of Russia diminished; the Russian-American Company now required government help, although its concern for its responsibilities and the devotion of its servants never ceased. The story of the eventual sale is strange and confused.

The United States had supported Russia during the Crimean War, and a surprising relationship developed between countries with such widely different political systems. The feeling grew in Russia that these American lands were useless, and that the United States might be bound in still closer friendship were ownership to change hands.

The company’s charter was not renewed in 1861, as it had been twenty years previously; and government was carried on provisionally from year to year, although negotiations for the sale were held up during the period of the American Civil War.

In the outcome no one was satisfied; there was no willing seller to gratify a willing buyer. Only by an odd vote did the United States Senate agree to the purchase; later, the House of Representatives made endless difficulties over voting the necessary money. The Russian most responsible for the sale retired in disgrace.

Military rule was imposed under the command of an officer recently engaged in Indian warfare. It was so undisciplined that even the Cathedral was looted, and when, after ten years, the soldiers were withdrawn, Sitka was a ghost town. Control farther north, although vested in a purely commercial corporation, was exercised with far greater humanity.

This Alaska Commercial Company was primarily concerned with exploitation of the fur-seals which haul out to breed on the Pribilof Islands between Bering Strait and the Aleutians, animals over which the Russians had exercised reasonable methods of conservation. These now ceased with disastrous consequences that led eventually to an international agreement in 1911, under which sealing was controlled, while, as a minor provision, complete protection was given to whatever scattered remnants still remained of the once teeming stocks of sea-otters. The last few legally collected pelts fetched $800 each.

It remained to be seen whether protection had come in time. If reduced below a critical level, populations of such slow-breeding mammals cannot recover. Had the otter, like the sea-cow, been exterminated? Possibly it had never been in such danger in the far north, where areas were vast and not everywhere accessible to the hunters. This proved to be the case, and stocks have slowly risen so that some limited hunting was resumed in 1968.

The far more accessible southern sea-otter did appear to have been destroyed; but, when the coast road south of Big Sur was opened in 1936, a group, or ‘pod’ of some 100 otters was discovered. Since then they have steadily increased. Once totally absent in that area, they can now be observed in numbers from Steinbeck’s Cannery Row in the one-time Spanish and then Mexican capital of Monterey.

And they have brought the kelp with them because they eat the sea-urchins and the abalones that restrain the kelp by consuming the sporelings. A new balance is now being set up, not to the liking of those who collect the locally prized abalones and clams, or the sea-urchins which are exported to Japan. Here comes the clash of interests that may have to be resolved by controlling the otters.

All, indeed, is a matter of balance between plant, animal and human populations. The Russians broke into this kelp community to exterminate its uniquely large member and extend their country’s confines in pursuit of the otters. So, in the end, Alaska came to be United States’ and not Canadian territory.

That is of minor significance; but the retention of Russian America into the present century would have raised far greater problems than even Seward could have prophesied. Now only the persistance in older settlements of the Orthodox liturgy, with its onion-topped churches, remains to remind the visitor of the one-time Russian occupation of Alaska.