The Noble Lady and the Player

In the early eighteenth century, writes Robert Halsband, the marriage of an aristocratic young widow and a Drury Lane singer caused violent surprise among her friends.

In the Autumn of 1738 a most unusual scandal agitated London’s beau monde. Lady Henrietta Herbert had ‘furnished the tea-tables here with fresh tattle for this last fortnight’, wrote Lady Mary Wortley Montagu to a friend travelling abroad. The young widowed Lady Harriet (as she was usually called), daughter of Earl Walde-grave, had asked a priest to marry her to John Beard, ‘who sings in the farces at Drury-lane’.

A friend of the young widow had appealed to Lady Mary, and had been advised that, ‘since the lady was capable of such amours, I did not doubt if this was broke off she would bestow her person and fortune on some hackney-coachman or chairman; and that I really saw no method of saving her from ruin, and her family from dishonour, but by poisoning her; and offered to be at the expence of the arsenic, and even to administer it with my own hands’, if she were invited to drink tea that evening.

Whether the marriage had actually taken place was not known; her friends conjectured that Lady Harriet’s lover might have been intimidated by her brother, an ensign in the Footguards. What Mr. Waldegrave told his sister was noted by the pious Lord Egmont in his diary: ‘that her lover had the pox, and that she would be disappointed of the only thing she married him for, which was her lust; for that he would continue to lie every night with the player that brought them together, and give her no solace. But there is no prudence below the girdle.’

Although her relations had no reason to be amazed at her constitution, Lady Mary remarked, they were ‘violently surprized at the mixture of devotion that forces her to have recourse to the church in her necessities; which has not been the road taken by the matrons of her family’. Her great-grandmother, to be sure, had been Arabella Churchill, mistress of James II. And when the daughter of that union, the first Lady Waldegrave, was a widow, living at the exiled court at Saint-Germain, she had been ordered into a convent by her father because she refused to name the man whose child she was about to bear.

A liaison between a noble lady and a player, sanctified or not by marriage vows, was unprecedented. In the past, of course, peers had kept stage-women as their mistresses. It was far more subversive for an aristocratic widow to give herself and her jointure to a player, whose social position was that of a vagabond.

Born in 1717, Lady Harriet was the only daughter of the 1st Earl Waldegrave. Her mother, daughter of a baronet, had died when the girl was only two; and she was then reared by her Stuart grandmother, and educated in all the elegant accomplishments customary for a girl of her social class.

At her death in 1730, the Dowager Lady Waldegrave left debts to spinet, dancing, and writing masters, and a bequest of £1,000 in stock to be held in trust for the girl. Within a week Lady Harriet, accompanied by a maid and a steward, left for Paris to await the arrival of her father from Vienna. Her two brothers were at Eton.

Lord Waldegrave had succeeded in removing his family’s Jacobite taint, in part by renouncing Roman Catholicism the year his wife died; and he was subsequently awarded a succession of posts at Court. He was about to take up the appointment, which lasted ten years, of Ambassador to France.

As a diplomatist, in the opinion of William Coxe, he ‘conducted himself in his embassies with consummate address... Though a man of pleasure, he pursued business, when business was necessary, with indefatigable diligence’. He could not have found much time to spend with his daughter.

When Lady Harriet returned to England, she lived with her maternal grandparents, Sir John and Lady Webb. Before long she was ready for the marriage market. In the autumn of 1733, when she was sixteen, her grandmother was approached by an emissary of the Marquess of Powis to ask whether a treaty of marriage could be negotiated for his younger son, Lord Edward Herbert. This Welsh family had a rather questionable past—Lord Powis, a Tory and a Roman Catholic, had been imprisoned and exiled for Jacobitism and then pardoned in 1722; but Lady Harriet’s family made no objection to them on this score.

‘Lady Hareout knowes littel of this Affare,’ Lady Webb wrote to the girl’s father, ‘and whether She will Like a Man of his adge I Know not.’ The suitor’s age, Lord Waldegrave estimated, was at least forty-five. Another disadvantage was that the suitor’s elder brother, Lord Montgomery, might marry and beget an heir. Still, the family was so prosperous, Lady Webb assured the girl’s father, that Lord Powis could provide a marriage settlement of £20,000 and settle an annuity on his son.

In mid-May, formalities having been concluded, the happy suitor dutifully thanked Lord Waldegrave ‘with a delight and satisfaction beyond the Power of expression’ and promised: ‘the Study of my life shall be to make Lady Harriot as happy as my station will allow’. A month later, Lord Waldegrave wrote testily to his agent, who had told him that Lord Edward’s father insisted on security for the dowry:

‘I am not fond enough of the match to do any extraordinary things for it, and it was meerly out of complisance to Sir John and Lady Webb that I did not declare against it.’

The reluctant father of the bride sent £100 for her wedding clothes.

‘Your Lordship’s approveing of My Marrage with Lord Edward Herbert,’ she wrote, ‘is what I hope will Make me Very happy and the Car-racter he has of good Humour Convinces me More of it’.

Three weeks later, on July 7th, 1734, she became Lady Harriet Herbert. If she expected to outlive her middle-aged husband, she could not have foreseen his dying so soon. For in November, only four months after climbing into his nuptial bed, Lord Herbert was lowered into his grave. He had died in Bath, leaving his widow an expectant mother. The following June she bore a daughter, who was christened Barbara, after Lady Webb.

The birth of a grand-daughter deeply disappointed Lord Powis; for his surviving son, Lord Montgomery, was still a bachelor. His agent advised him: ‘If you cannot soon settle Lord Montgomery, you ought to marry yourself. There are several young Catholic ladies who would be glad to contribute to keeping up so noble a family.’ Seventy years old at the time, Lord Powis could still—or so his agent thought—exert himself to keep his male line alive.

Since Lord Edward had died intestate, and both his widow and posthumous daughter were minors, they became wards of Chancery. The Powis family lawyers began to scrutinize the marriage contract, certainly not for the purpose of protecting the widow’s interest. Lord Montgomery objected to the settlement of £20,000, claiming that he had never been consulted; and his lawyers advised bringing the case to the Court of Chancery, and in the meantime paying Lady Harriet her widow’s jointure of £600 a year.

Yet he could hardly have been ignorant of a contract negotiated by his father and brother for several months; a more logical explanation is that since Lady Harriet had not produced a male heir, the Powis family hoped to reduce the generous terms that had won her. In the normal course of events, she could have remained a widow, protected by her father and brothers; or she could have remarried a man of her own social class. But she chose neither of these alternatives.

The man for whom she defied convention was John Beard. His origins are so obscure that his parentage is unknown and, although he was probably born about 1716, the exact year is uncertain. As a young boy, he was enrolled among the Children of the Chapel Royal, the choir that sang at services in St. James’s Palace and occasionally at its social functions.

At this time, the Master of the choir was the well-known musician Bernard Gates; and the boys under him received not only musical training but a moral and Christian education, and instruction in reading, writing, arithmetic, geography, history and the rudiments of Latin.

In 1732, when Gates staged a private performance of Handel’s oratorio Esther in a tavern in the Strand, Beard sang the part of the Priest of the Israelites, his first recorded appearance on a stage. The future Lord Egmont thought the performance ‘exceeding fine’.

When a choirboy’s voice changed with puberty, he left the choir; and in October 1734 the subdean of the Chapel Royal certified that Beard should therefore be ‘removed from the Service of the Chapel’. By order of the Lord Chamberlain he was given the usual present of clothes, valued at about ten pounds.

A month later, having been engaged by Handel, he made his public debut (on November 9th, 1734) at the Theatre Royal in Covent Garden as Silvius in Pastor Fido, based on the popular pastoral romance of Guarini. A splendid audience attended, including the King and two of the Princesses. Lady Elizabeth Compton wrote that Beard ‘shines in the Opera of Covent Garden & Mr Hendell is so full of his Praises that he says he will surprise the Town with his performances before the Winter is over’.

For the next three years Beard sang tenor roles with Handel’s company at Covent Garden, one of the two rival opera companies, both supported by political factions. His robust tenor voice rang out in manly contrast to the brilliant Italian castrati, who were adored by the musical public and opulently rewarded by the opera managers. Many years later, Beard was eulogized by the satirist Charles Churchill as a welcome relief from the ‘vile race of Eunuchs on stage’.

He was, in fact, considered by Charles Dibdin to be the best singer of his time. Fortunately he was also a good actor. For in 1737, when both opera companies were bankrupt, and Handel left London to recover his health at Aix-la-Chapelle, Beard was engaged by the managers of the Drury Lane Theatre. He made his first appearance there on August 30th in a speaking part—that of Sir John Loverule in Charles Coffey’s ballad-opera The Devil to Pay.

A spectator at the performance noted in his diary: ‘the first night of Beard’s playing—his success great.’ The theatre managers were sufficiently encouraged two months later to cast him as Macheath, the hero of The Beggar’s Opera. Since its initial run in 1728—which was said to have made its author John Gay rich, and its producer John Rich gay—this ballad-opera had remained popular.

The part of the handsome, irresistible highwayman suited Beard so well that he continued to play it frequently for many years. He also played in the farces and pantomimes that took up an increasing part of the stage entertainments.

When Beard’s liaison with Lady Harriet Herbert became a subject of London gossip in the autumn of 1738, he was indeed a singer in the farces at Drury Lane. He was playing the parts of the Spaniard in Columbine Courtezan, Longbibb in Harlequin Restored, Poudre in Harlot’s Progress, and Mercury in The Fall of Phaeton. How could a young actor of no social position meet a young, aristocratic widow?

One conjecture is plausible. According to a petition that Beard sent many years later to the Duke of Newcastle, asking for a vacant post, since 1733 he had been ‘principally employ’d in the performance of the Birth-day and New-years Odes’. The annual celebration of the King’s official birthday always drew great crowds to Court; and it would have been easy for the two young people, approximately the same age, to meet, converse, and fall in love. Beard had an attractive personality—hearty, gay, and generous. As the hero of The Beggar's Opera, a later critic thought him too much of a gentleman—hardly a fault in polite society.

By whatever means the noble lady met the player, their match aroused the fierce disapproval of the girl’s family and friends. Monday, January 8th, 1739, was a particularly busy day for Beard. He sang the part of Jonathan in Handel’s new oratorio Saul at its public rehearsal in the King’s Theatre in the Haymarket, probably at midday; he played his popular part in the farce Columbine Courtezan at the Drury Lane Theatre in the evening; and, at a place still not known, he married Lady Harriet. He must have been aware of a startling irony in his oratorio performance that day when he was addressed by Merab with the lines:

Yet think with whom you stoop to link yourself,

How poor in fortune, and in birth how low!

The newly married couple did not go off on a honeymoon; and Beard continued to appear at Drury Lane. A week after his marriage, he played Joe in Robert Dodsley’s farce The King and the Miller of Mansfield, and, on the same evening, sang in the public performance of Saul at the nearby Haymarket. For the rest of the season he played frequently in farces, comedies, and masques; and he also sang in Handel’s stirring new oratorio Israel in Egypt. His career evidently went on as before.

For Lady Harriet, however, profound changes occurred. ‘Birde continues to sing upon the stage’, noted Lord Egmont in his diary. ‘This lady has 600 l. a year jointure, 200 l. of which is encumbered by former debts, and 200 l. she has lately sold to pay his debts. To-day [Jan. 13th, 1:739] it is said her goods have been sold.’ Evidendy Lady Harriet had been forced to mortgage her jointure because (as we know from later litigation) the Powis family had not paid it promptly.

She and Beard now settled in a house off Red Lion Square, a cheerless region north of Holborn. In April 1739, Beard was allowed for the first time the lucrative privilege of a benefit at Drury Lane, and performed in The Devil to Pay, and tickets for admission were advertised as being on sale at his house.

What was the attitude of Lady Harriet’s family? Her father’s cousin General Charles Churchill wrote to him a month after the marriage: ‘I can easily imagine what your Good nature felt for her, little as she deserves it. But the best way is to neither talk nor think any more of it, so I shall take my leve of the subject. I am shure it is what I would do was it my Lass.’ But Lady Harriet had apparently not alienated her grandmother; for, when Lady Webb added a codicil to her will, a month after the marriage, she bequeathed £100 to each of her grandchildren including Lady Harriet.

The next season (1739-40) Beard resumed his regular roles at Drury Lane. In addition he sang in Handel’s oratorios and masques at the theatre in Lincoln’s Inn Field—Alexander's Feast, Acis and Galatea, and L'Allegro and II Penseroso. He apparently tried to earn as much as he could, playing for twenty consecutive Fridays in Rosalinda, a musical drama, at Hickford’s Concert Room. But then, instead of completing the season, he played his last performance—in Dr. Arne’s Comus—on May 1st, 1740; and during the whole of the following season he remained absent from the stage.

For some reason, Beard and Lady Harriet left England that summer, and by July were living in Lille. They may have taken Barbara, then aged six, who had lived with her great-grandmother, Lady Webb, and put her into a convent school. Not for the first time Lady Harriet tried to win her father’s forgiveness, writing to him (on July 9th) with the most abject pathos:

‘I won’t call my Selfe a troublesome Corispondant to Your Lordship because I fear my letters have never had the honour of being perus’d by you beyond the first Line: as soone as you found the authur they weer like her Condemd and thrown from you, or ellse those Vows of Duty and Affectionate Submission I think my Dear father could Never have read without feeling an Emotion in his heart in my favour, but would have sufferd his angre to have been disarmd by his Kneeling weeping Child. But I hope this will come in a Luckyer hour to your hands and find you in a Willing Moment to receive my petition, Exert the father over the Judg and forgive your Imploring Daughter.’

Her enemies had exaggerated her faults, she insisted; and all she wanted was his forgiveness. Her appeal was in vain. At the end of October, Lord Waldegrave, recalled from his post in Paris, returned to England. He died in April of the following year at his estate in Essex, suffering from dropsy and jaundice. He may have been, as an historian described him, of a ‘mild and affable demeanour’; but toward his disobedient daughter he remained to the end a stubborn and unforgiving parent.

During the next few years, although the private lives of Lady Harriet and Beard are obscure, his career on the stage is fully documented. For the season of 1741-42 he returned to play at Drury Lane Theatre, appearing in fewer plays, but singing more frequently in the interval-entertainment. In Henry Fielding’s new farce Miss Lucy in Town he acted and sang the satiric role of Signor Cantileno. Horace Walpole, an enthusiast for Italian opera and singers, complained that Beard mimicked the tenor Amorevoli ‘intolerably’.

The following season, when he sang the name-part in Handel’s Samson, Walpole again disparaged him as ‘a man with one note in his voice’. Certainly, compared to the castrati, with their fantastic agility and their bravura technique of trills, rims, roulades, and embellishments, Beard’s straightforward tenor must have seemed monotonous. To Tom Davies (famous later for introducing Boswell to Johnson) Beard excelled in recitative ‘by giving uncommon force of expression to the passions of love, grief, and resentment’—a wide enough gamut. A month later Beard was chosen by Handel to sing in the first London performance of the Messiah.

After having been at Drury Lane since 1737, Beard left it in 1743 to play under John Rich’s management at the rival patent theatre in Covent Garden, opening in two plays—as Colonel Bully in The Provok’d Wife and as Lovemore in The Lottery. He also continued to sing for Handel, in February (1744) creating the part of Jupiter in Semele. Devout listeners who were shocked by the sensuality of that secular oratorio could attend a more elevating one a few weeks later when Handel conducted Joseph and His Brethren, with Beard singing the part of Simeon.

After hearing it in rehearsal Mrs. Delany, a fervent Handelian, reported to a friend that the composer was ‘mightily out of humour about it, for Sullivan, who is to sing Joseph, is a block with a very fine voice, and Beard has no voice at all’. This could not have been Handel’s opinion, for in June he asked John Rich’s permission to engage Beard for the next season at the Haymarket.

In due course Beard sang leading roles in Handel’s new oratorios—Deborah, Hercules, and Belshazzar; he also performed frequently at Covent Garden in his repertory of comedies, farces, and masques. At his benefit night (in March 1745), when members of the Royal family including the Prince and Princess of Wales attended, he again played the part of Macheath.

Meanwhile, the Powis family were again delinquent in paying Lady Harriet her jointure: by the summer of 1744 they had paid her only two thirds of what they owed. A year later, when Lord Powis died, to be succeeded by his surviving son as 3rd Marquess, Lady Harriet’s plight was even worse. In November 1745 she wrote to him twice—flattering him with his Jacobite title Duke of Powis—to ask about her marriage settlement and dowry, and about the appointment of a legal guardian for her daughter, but he did not reply.

She then wrote again, on her own behalf, begging for a loan of £100: ‘I have no resource of friends or Creditt—those by the Usage from the Duke your Father are pretty well draned; and [I] have not upon honour five pounds in the house. This is a Melancholy and true State of my Affairs.’ This time Lord Powis replied—with a refusal. Lady Harriet then sent him a long rehearsal of her complaints. The loan he had refused was, she wrote,

‘a Subsistence for myself and Child... I, my Lord, Labour under too menny debts allready to be able to raise the sum I ask’d of you on my own bond—and have no security to offer, your Father having Compeld me to the Engageing what Little plate I had. I assure you I am without Money, or without power to gitt any.’

Although reluctant to bring suit against him, she continued, she needed speedy relief because her creditors pressed her.

How, one wonders, could she have been so impoverished when Beard was fully employed at Covent Garden and elsewhere? They were probably so heavily in debt that his pay from the theatres could barely sustain them. Besides, Beard’s brothers and sisters may have been dependent on him; he supported a feeble-minded sister identified in his will as ‘Catherine Beard (an Innocent)’.

Yet, ironically, Barbara Herbert—whose moderate allowance of £150 was carefully accounted for—was heiress to a great fortune. In August 1746, Lady Harriet relinquished her guardianship; and as her nominee the Court of Chancery appointed Viscount Montagu, who was related to both families. He placed the girl in a convent in Bruges, where she remained for two years, and then brought her to live with his wife and son at Pontoise, near Paris.

By this time, owing to the death of her uncle Lord Powis in March 1748, her importance as an heiress had considerably increased. For Lord Powis’s heir was Lord Herbert of Chirbury, a distant relation; and Lord Herbert’s heirs were his brother (also unmarried) and then Barbara Herbert. Two months after inheriting the estate, Lord Herbert— born about 1703, and a Protestant and Whig— was created Earl of Powis. If he wished to keep the estate in his own family he must marry and beget an heir.

In the meantime, Lady Harriet brought suit against him in Chancery on behalf of her daughter and herself, claiming that her jointure had not been paid out of the £20,000 settlement, and that Barbara was the late Marquess’s heir. Lord Powis’s answer was succinct: he knew nothing of the settlement, and the Marquess’s will naming him heir was legally valid. The suit dragged on, unsuccessfully, for two years.

In a new dramatic turn, directly involving Barbara, her aunt Lady Mary Herbert, who lived in Paris, accused Lord Montagu, in June 1749, of having schemed to arrange a marriage between the girl and his son. She appealed to the King of France for a lettre de cachet; and, when it was granted, the girl was brought to the Convent of Port Royal, and thence to England for the Lord Chancellor to appoint a new guardian.

She was permitted during the interval to stay at Lord Montagu’s house at Cowdray. The trustees of the girl’s property, in opposing her marriage to Lord Montagu’s son, charged that Lady Harriet favoured it because she was to be paid for ‘selling her Daughter’. The new guardian, approved by Lady Harriet as well as the Powis family, was the Dowager Lady Herbert of Chirbury, a relation of Lord Powis’s.

Now that the fifteen-year-old heiress—described by her mother as ‘a very good Humourd inofencive Girle’—was safely installed with her Herbert relations, the final episode of her maiden days was played out. Its outline can be seen through two long letters sent to her by her mother, who advised her to be wary of Lord Powis’s friends, but to remain on good terms with him.

‘Suppose Lord Powis should some time hence even have thoughts of Marrying you, he cannot do it without your free Consent.’ Such a solution was both simple and logical. Lady Harriet’s brother Lord Waldegrave now entered the scene. He was to accompany Lord Powis on a visit to the girl; and Lady Harriet cautioned her:

‘I judg by that that they are united—and therefore conclude twill be the best way for you not to Struggle, but to make the best composition for your self you can.’

She begged her daughter ‘that you’d make it one of your articles that your poor Momma may allways have free access to you—for I aprehend Lord Waldegrave may be for excluding me, tho I am shure Lord Powis has too Much humanity to do it.’

She was convinced that her brother was intervening only for that purpose; and she carefully instructed her daughter to insist on three conditions: ‘that your Religion shall not be any Ways Molested... that your Inclinations shall never be attempted to be forced... that you see your Mother without any restriction.’

The girl endorsed each letter with one word: ‘Mamma.’ Whatever the terms of settlements and conditions, Barbara Herbert married Lord Powis on March 30th, 1751, a girl of less than sixteen to a man of about forty-eight. It was a curious repetition, in this detail, of her mother’s first marriage.

Throughout these years of family litigation, Beard continued his career on the stage. After the season of 1747-48, his fifth at Covent Garden, he returned to Drury Lane Theatre in his usual repertory. In January 1750, as he was returning home in a sedan chair at two o’clock in the morning, he was held up and robbed—and perhaps beaten, since he was reported ill a week later. His benefit in March allowed him to recoup his losses.

The next year, when his benefit-receipts are recorded, he got £200. Yet a year later, in March 1752, when his benefit was advertised, he was living in lodgings in Russell Street, Covent Garden. This may imply that further poverty had forced him and Lady Harriet to move from Red Lion Square to a raffish slum neighbourhood. His step-daughter, now the Countess of Powis, could not have taken any notice of him.

As the 1752-53 season drew to a close, Beard played a very profitable benefit in March—with receipts of £260. On May 25th he appeared in The Shepherd's Masque, shortly before the playhouse closed for the summer. Six days later, Lady Harriet died. The cause of her death at the age of thirty-six is not known, except through the sentimental rhetoric of an obituary notice of Beard that the European Magazine published in 1791:

‘his struggles to support her in something like her former state, involved him in many difficulties; and her frequent and long illnesses (occasioned principally by grief for having embarrassed the man she loved) increased those difficulties, and she sunk under them.’

On her monument in St. Pancras Churchyard, Beard himself paid his tribute—from one ‘who, during a happy union of 14 years, tenderly loved her person, and admired her virtues’. The noble lady who married a player had indeed been noble in his eyes.

For him, as well as for Lady Harriet, their marriage may have been a mésalliance. His later career shows what he might have otherwise accomplished. In 1759 he transferred from Drury Lane to Covent Garden Theatre, where the aged John Rich was still manager and patent-holder, and married one of Rich’s four daughters. It was a prudent match. When Rich died two years later, Beard took over the management, and held it until 1767.

Increasing deafness curtailed his career as actor, singer, and manager. In July the patent for Covent Garden Theatre was sold for £60,000; and one-fifth went to him and his wife. They bought a villa at Hampton, the Thames-side village, where they had an agreeable neighbour in David Garrick. Beard lived on in pleasant retirement with his young wife until 1791, when he died and was buried in the church at Hampton.

Besides a widow (who lived until 1818) he left legacies of £3,000 and a reputation of most praiseworthy qualities: ‘unrivalled in fame and excellence... He had one of the sincerest hearts joined to the most polished manners... through life he fulfilled the relative duties of a son, brother, guardian, friend, and husband, with the most exemplary truth and tenderness.’