The Elizabethan Farmer

In an age of opportunity, G.E. Fussell describes how the Elizabethan farmer lived under pioneer conditions.

In four hundred years, though a Dunwich may disappear into the sea and the coastline may recede from Rye, the climate and contours of a country, except where human beings have deliberately taken a hand, suffer few material changes. During the same period, however, sweeping changes often occur both in the density of the population and in its social habits. The English people, for instance, have multiplied their numbers more than ten-fold— from four to nearly , fifty million. No longer mainly concerned with food-production, they are gathered together, for the most part, in crowded urban communities. These basic facts must be recapitulated if we are to understand the life of the Elizabethan farmer, whose circumstances were so different from our own that, until we have grasped their background, we find it hard to picture them. A population of four millions then lived on an area of some thirty-seven million acres, the total area of England and Wales. Large groupings of population were rare, London being the only sizeable city.

Across the Midlands, from the Humber and Wash to Bristol and Dorset, stretched a belt of open field arable lands which were the main centres of cultivation. Even here, there were deserts. In the East the Fens occupied some 75,000 acres; and at times the floods almost reached the boundaries of Cambridge. Lincoln Heath and Wolds were a solitude; and all over the limestone escarpment, from Lincoln to Wiltshire were downlands where wild life flourished, and the only signs of man were the lonely shepherd and his flock. North of the Trent, settlement was more scattered; and from the Peak to the Border there were as yet none of the dry stone walls of limestone that are today the most characteristic feature of the landscape. The Downs from Kent to Hampshire were haunted by great flocks of bustard, and a few sheep grazed there. Of cultivated land there was comparatively little. The coastal plain, apart from Romsey and Pevensey Marches, was a rich source of corn supply for London; but the weald of Kent and Sussex was a real wild of forest, just beginning to be cleared, largely by the activities of the iron-founders. A waste to the north almost touched the environs of London on the south bank of the Thames, covering all the familiar country from Wiltshire to the Devil’s Punch Bowl and on to Bagshot. Windsor Forest, across Ascot almost to Hungerford in Berkshire, was wild and unfrequented. Hampshire included the New Forest; Dorset, Bere Forest and Heath, Canford in the south, Cranboume Chace in the north. Farther west extended Exmoor, Dartmoor and Bodmin Moor. The most settled areas were patched with great forests, Sherwood being a well-known example. Wychwood in Oxfordshire and De la Mare. in Cheshire did not undergo reclamation until the nineteenth century. Along the Scottish border ran a broad no-man’s land that served as a bulwark against invasion, and first began to be disciplined towards the end of Queen Elizabeth’s reign.

The middle of England (as I have already noted) was the most closely settled part of the country. This was the scene of open-field arable farming, where the villages were only a few miles apart, and scattered farm-houses were rare. But here, too, life was extremely simple; and houses, constructed of whatever materials came to hand, ranged from the one-room mud and wattle hut of the labourer and husbandman to the four-roomed or larger house of the yeoman and little squire. Judged by modern standards, they were uncomfortable buildings. Sanitation scarcely existed. For although Sir John Harington had invented a water-closet and fitted one in Richmond Palace, its Royal owner apparently thought of it as a plaything rather than as a utility; and no common man would have aspired to such an installation. Water supplies were obtained from wells, streams, ponds, often collected from the rainfall. Only in favoured districts was there a good supply of drinking water. Of modern illuminants, the Elizabethans possessed none. Whale-oil was not yet used, and mineral oil not discovered. The wax candle was a luxury; the tallow candle or the rushlight, made at home, gave a feeble guttering light. In many homes firelight was reserved for the evening. As Professor Tawney has said, the Elizabethan countryman lived in frontier conditions.

Land was the prime source of wealth, and everyone was ambitious to acquire possession of some scrap, or to add some piece, however small, to what he already owned or occupied. Great landowner and small farmer alike were anxiously striving to expand their holdings; and the events of the Reformation brought them fresh opportunities. Henry VIII’s seizure and dispersal of the monastic lands created new conditions of land transfer; and by the end of the sixteenth century much was for sale in small parcels. All over the country yeoman farmers were buying it, in Lincolnshire, in Worcester, in Devon, in Sussex. The sale of Crown lands, too, placed other wide areas on the market where the land-hungry buyers were plentiful: Elizabeth sold land to the value of at least £817,359 to obtain funds for war expenses. Farmers of all classes had more money with which to buy. It is doubtful whether farming in England had ever been completely devoted to subsistence; but in the medieval period rents had been paid in kind and consumed on the spot by visiting landlords; though other corn and cattle rents had been collected and sent to a central domain, and there was always some traffic. Tudor times saw a change in attitude. The farmers began to look for profit, as well as for food and raw materials, as the reward of their efforts. They wanted to sell at a profit. Many of them were successful in doing so, since it was a time of rising prices.

The farmers were also responsible for a good deal of piecemeal enclosure. This much-condemned practice was not always initiated by the great landlords, or carried out for the purpose of increasing sheep-runs. Many ordinary yeoman were glad to exchange one open-field strip for another, in order to have two or more adjoining strips, so as to form a compact block that could be fenced. The yeomen, wrote Miss Campbell, were everywhere active and important agents in the enclosure movement. They were the men whom Harrison described so proudly as having

“a certain preheminence and more estimation than labourers ... commonlie live wealthilie, keepe good houses and travell to get riches. They are also for the most part farmers to gentlemen ... and with grasing, frequenting of markets, and keeping of servantes ... do come to great wealth, insomuch that manie of them are able and doe buie the lands of un-thriftie gentlemen ...”

Some of them were able to send their sons to the university or the inns of court, and so made them gentlemen; and often enough their increasing wealth and spreading acres made their descendants fit to bear that title. Those whose efforts were unsuccessful sank to the level of labourers. Though opportunities were plentiful, it was an age in which it was as easy to fail as to succeed. Farmers who were so enterprising in acquiring land might have been expected to have been equally enterprising in improving their methods. But, indeed, they had little chance of doing so. Methods differed widely in various parts of the country; communications were difficult; and the farmers of one area knew nothing of the practice of their contemporaries at the other end of the country. Textbooks were few, and their writers’ knowledge often confined to a restricted area. Equally few were specialist books. By the close of the century there were four: Scott on Hops, and Mascall on Cattle, Fruit Trees, and Poultry; while Poultry was also the subject of a book translated from the French of Choyselat. But most Elizabethan farmers pursued their way undisturbed by academic advice.

In many places, the demesne farm had been cut out of the open fields and enclosed; and sporadic enclosure was gradually breaking the traditional form of the open field arable. Throughout the midland belt, however, open arable field cultivation was to continue almost undisturbed until another century and a half had elapsed; and R. E. Prothero’s classic description of this type of farming cannot be improved upon:

“Out of a bare treeless expanse rose the cluster of bare, mud-built reed thatched cottages which formed the village. Round it lay a few small enclosures of permanent pasture held in private occupation and highly prized. Sometimes a similar but larger piece of pasture was reserved for the stinted use of the commoners... . The permanent meadows ... lay in the lowest part of the land—if possible, along the banks of the stream... . Beyond the meadows lay the arable land and the rough pasture...  Instead of hedges, narrow, unploughed, bush-grown strips or balks of turf marked the lines of division between the three great fields and their component parts. These fields were usually cultivated on a three-course, more rarely on a two course, sometimes on a four-course system. [Evidence of the last is, I fear, very difficult to find.]

Every year one field lay fallow; one was under wheat and rye, the other [in a threefield village] under barley, oats, vetches, beans or peas. A third of each man’s holding lay in each of the three fields ..., [We now know that this was not invariably so and that often the holding was quite unequally distributed between the fields.] From seed-time to harvest the arable land was held in separate occupation, fenced and guarded against trespassers by the village hayward, and from seedtime till the blade showed above the soil, was protected from pigeons and crows by the crow-keeper [armed with bow and arrows]. On Lammas Day [August 12th] ten days later than now—common rights recommenced; and when once the fences were cleared and the crops removed, the livestock of the village, tended by the common neat-herd, shepherd and swineherd, grazed over the land from harvest to seed-time. Beyond the three arable fields lay the cow and sheep downs ... bounded by acres of long heath, brown furze, or toothed briars, sharp furzes, pricking goss and thorns, which fringed the edges of the woodlands.”

The mechanical resources in the hands of the Elizabethan farmers were limited to the plough, the harrow, and a miscellaneous array of hand tools. A few may have possessed a roller. The farmers of different counties favoured their own special design of plough; but that in most general use all over the Midlands was undoubtedly the heavy implement, the beam of which rested in a high gallows running on two wheels. This implement was vigorously condemned by Arthur Young two hundred years later, when he found it still in use, as it had probably been for a thousand years when the Elizabethan team of half a dozen or more oxen made heavy work of hauling it. In the lighter soils of Norfolk and the limited area of Lincoln then cultivated, a small two-wheel plough was favoured. A farmer required only a pair of horses to haul it; and he could both drive and guide it himself. It was praised by Barnaby Googe, a gentleman of Lincoln, and found great favour in the eyes of Arthur Young who regarded it as a new improvement. On the rich vale lands of Somerset, the farmers found that they must use a plough with a long beam, because it required heavy leverage to keep it at an even depth in the soil. The contours of Kent and Devon alike had caused the farmers in those counties to design one-way ploughs, of which that of Kent is much the better known. No doubt other designs, or variations upon the same theme, were used by farmers elsewhere. Some of them must have been very useful and easy to work. Others must have made a very poor job of it; and, where they failed, the farmer and his man broke up the roughly furrowed soil with a kind of mallet called a clodding beetle or mel. Harrows were made of wood, with iron or ash teeth. Some used a thorn bush, weighted with a log to harrow in the seed. Such was the Elizabethan farmer’s equipment, together with a rough waggon or cart, perhaps a sled for bringing home the hay or com harvest.

With this rudimentary apparatus, arable farming all over the kingdom was conducted in much the same way. The seed-bed was prepared by giving it three ploughings at intervals during the fallow year, or in autumn, early in the new year, and again in spring if the ground was being made ready for spring com after harvesting winter com. The seed might be harrowed in. All the rest was manual work. The seed was sown broadcast by hand. The growing crops were weeded by hand. Grass and grain were cut with the scythe and the sickle. The hay was made, loaded and driven home to be stacked manually. The corn was tied into sheaves, and shocks made by women who followed the man with the sickle. Whether his holding consisted of widely scattered strips in one of the old-established open-field villages, or it comprised enclosed fields of one sort or another, the farmer made his seed-bed and performed his other tasks with the help of similar methods.

It has been estimated that not more than a quarter of the surface of the kingdom was cultivated in the reign of Queen Elizabeth the First. But everywhere onslaughts were being made upon the wastes and forests; and in some parts of the country old-established custom tended to increase enclosure. In parts of Devon, for example, it was customary to allow the cultivation of part of the waste for a period of years. During that time it was usually enclosed with dry stone walls; and, though it was let fall down to grass again when the oats usually grown upon it began to yield little or nothing, the fact that it had once been enclosed would perhaps make it easier to renew the fence, and at last to maintain it permanently. Something of the same kind was common in Staffordshire and in the north. The settlement of Rossendale, for example, was greatly extended at this time, and there were encroachments in the Peak of Derbyshire that had to be regularized later. No doubt similar activity was taking place elsewhere. Thus, in Sussex and Kent, farmers were extending the area of cultivation and enclosing the small fields that are so familiar a feature of the Weald, a proceeding that inspired Gervase Markham to write his pamphlet The Inrichment of the Weald of Kent in 1636. The sea-coast farms of Sussex exported corn to London. Romney Marsh was a feeding ground for sheep, and the fruit trees and hops of Kent were already of some renown. Far to the west, hops were grown in Worcestershire and had even spread to Cornwall. In the last county, too, “raison trees” (possibly currants) were cultivated by William Carnew of Bokelly near Rowton on the Moor.

All over the country, from Cornwall to Kent, in Essex and Suffolk, in Worcestershire and Hereford, Elizabethan farmers had been quick to take up hop-growing. Such opportunities for development, however, were exceptional. The Elizabethan’s range of field crops was much more limited than that of the modern farmer. He knew nothing of turnips, swedes or mangolds for stock feeding. He had not heard of sugar-beet. He grew no potatoes. He had no “seeds” hay, or artificial grass as it came to be called. Of clover and rye-grass ley he had no conception: When he laid land down to grass, he either let it fall down or contented himself with scattering a few handfuls of the mixed weed and grass seed collected on the floor of the hay loft. All four cereals, wheat, rye, barley and oats, had long been cultivated in Europe, either separately or in mixtures like maslin, wheat and rye; dredge, barley and oats; or bullimong, oats, peas and vetches. Besides the cereals only various sorts of codware— peas, beans and vetches—were grown. A few farmers grew buckwheat or “French wheat,” as it was sometimes named. These crops alone had to suffice for the food of man or beast.

In some parts of the country, moreover, wheat-growing was impossible. The crop was unknown, for instance, in Lancashire until the beginning of the eighteenth century. Here and further north oats were the mainstay of human diet, and bere barley was used for beer. Often oats were malted and preserved with wormwood. Fifty years later, bean and pea meal was being mixed into the bread that Henry Best provided for his servants; and he himself was eating maslin, though he used wheat flour for pies. Oats, too, were commonly grown in Wales, and a great deal of rye in the Marcher Counties and the Midlands. It was proverbial wisdom for the farmer to sell wheat and buy rye where conditions permitted him to grow the more, valuable cereal. All over the south-west, barley-bannocks and barley-bread was eaten, as well as a good many far more luscious dainties such as saffron cakes, Cornish pasties and Devonshire cream. The usual diet was composed of the crops commonly grown.

Besides a rather restricted range of crops, the Elizabethan farmer was handicapped by two other deficiencies unknown today. He had no artificial manure, and he was always short of winter fodder. For fertiliser the Elizabethan farmer had only the muck-heap and the sheep fold. Since the cattle spent most of their days at free range on the common waste, little dung was produced at home; but what there was must have been most carefully conserved. Fitzherbert advised that it should be spread on the barley ground in late April or May. “And where he hath barley this yere, sowe it with wheat or rye the next time it is falowed and so shall he mucke all his lands over at every second falowe.” This meant putting the muck on the land after the first fallow ploughing. It must first be laid out in small heaps, and then spread evenly over the surface just as a good farmer does today, or, perhaps, I should say did, before the invention of the manure-spreader. There was nothing odd about the sheep-fold. The flock grazed upon the Downs, for example, in Berkshire and Wiltshire, during the day, and was folded on the arable during the night. Sometimes the lord claimed that it must be folded upon the demesne for his own benefit, at the expense of the village farmers.

Here and there throughout the kingdom, some farmers were trying to increase their supply of manure by adding other natural substances of mixing soil. Along the sea-coast in Devon and Cornwall, sea-weed was collected and used for manure. The use of sea-sand, too, was common in coastal districts; and it was sometimes carried as far as ten miles inland. A great improvement was the re-introduction of marling—a term that covered a good deal of soil mixing. The process (which was by no means general) was to dig up some of the subsoil, and spread it on the surface. This changed and improved the soil texture, and was intended to make it more fertile. Mud from ditches, stream beds and even road scrapings were also used, the last practice being condemned by some manorial courts, if the farmer had laid straw down in dirty places to rot under the feet and wheels of passing traffic. By and large, however, the supply of manure from all these sources was very scanty.

The shortage of winter fodder, in addition to the prevalent method of keeping the animals in one herd or flock on the waste of the manor, was a major handicap from the intelligent breeder’s point of view. Selective mating was impossible; and there was nothing to prevent the poorer males becoming the fathers of degenerate offspring. Sheep were more valued than cattle, because of their wool; and a good sow was esteemed equal to a cow. A regulation made by Henry VIII forbade stallions and mares of less than a certain size to be turned out; but whether this order was obeyed is another question. It has been suggested that water meadows provided an early bite and a heavier crop of hay than the wild grass meadows; but I am doubtful whether any more than a tentative effort had yet been made to construct them. Many of the riparian meadows were, of course, subject to natural flooding; but it is unlikely that the floods were in any way controlled. When the store of hay and straw was consumed, the Elizabethan farmer was obliged to use “browse” consisting of withered leaves, bits of bark and small branches of trees and shrubs. This was no very substantial winter keep, and the animals grew gaunt and weary by the end of winter.

Appalling as these difficulties may appear to us, they did not daunt the spirit of the Elizabethan farmer. First, he knew of no other conditions. Secondly, he was encouraged by the spectacle of ambitious contemporaries everywhere rising to wealth and power. Meanwhile, the great luxury that the richer classes had begun to indulge in was not within the farmer’s reach. He had no Flemish tapestry or Dutch linen. He drank from a bowl and had but a plain table board, supported on trestles. He owned little plate. Maybe a silver salt was the pride of his wife’s heart. He slept on a bed of flax, protected by curtains of home-spun wool. His coat was of frieze or Kendal green. He owned two doublets, and rarely employed more than two servants. The acreage of the land he farmed varied widely. Already there were some very large farms; but the majority were moderate in size, often very small by modern standards. His livestock, except on the specialist sheep-farms, was limited in number, as so many of inventories made by his executors show; a cow or two, a few calves, a sow, a dozen sheep, more or less, perhaps one or two horses, was usually the sum total. With the plough and the harrow as his only implements, the area he could cultivate was limited, unless he could employ many men and had several ploughs and plough teams. Often the harvest was barely sufficient, and sometimes quite insufficient, to maintain his family. In good years, there was a surplus for sale. Yields were probably not more than half the present national average, though local yields were occasionally higher. To balance these difficulties, he had many compensations. The age he lived in was a period of opportunity; and its opportunities were being eagerly grasped. Ambition, based upon very real prospects of success, seems to have been the keynote of the Elizabethan farmer’s life.