Television's Luddites
Taylor Downing, producer of a dramatised documentary about the Luddite disturbances in Regency England, talks about the making of the current-affairs-style programme, and the 'then and now' parallels about resistance of skilled workers to the introduction of new technology.
In the year 1812 the county of Yorkshire was torn apart by a series of disturbances in which groups of skilled workers came together in a secret organisation dedicated to smashing the new machines being introduced into the woollen industry. So serious did the situation become that the history of this period has been described by J.L. and B. Hammond as a 'history of civil war'. One historian (Philip Ziegler) has written that 'Great Britain in the spring of 1812 was as near to violent class warfare and revolution as at any moment of its history'.
The workers at the centre of the dispute were called croppers. They were skilled men who trimmed or shaved the woollen cloth after it had been woven and fulled. The skills of these men acquired after several years of apprenticeship lay in neatly cutting off the nap of the cloth, using giant iron shears that weighed up to 60lbs. It was known that in cropping or dressing a piece of cloth well they could double the value of the material. The croppers were highly paid workers, the aristocrats of the labour market, and the leading figure of the dispute, George Mellor, was reported to have been paid 25s. a week, equivalent to several hundred pounds a week today, and to have 100 pounds in savings. When a crude machine was invented on which an unskilled man and a boy could do in a day what it took a skilled cropper a week to perform, the croppers rose in revolt.
The disturbances came against a background of war abroad and poverty at home. The country had been engaged in war with Napoleon for nearly twenty years. Bonaparte's Berlin Decrees and the massively unpopular Orders in Council had virtually put an end to trade between Britain and Europe and America, trade on which the economy of manufacturing areas like Yorkshire had become increasingly reliant. The value of woollen exports had dropped from 12 million pounds to barely more than 1 million pounds a year. Furthermore, a series of bad harvests had forced up the price of grain to level; it never reached again all century. At a time when many families in the north spent an average of twopence ha'penny a day on food the cost of a loaf had risen to 1s. 8d. The distress that this caused was intense and the poor relief system was put under immense strain as one scene in the film illustrates.
For several months through the early part of 1812 the Yorkshire countryside nightly echoed to the sound of marching feet as bands of Luddites marched to attack the mills. An evocative and exciting account of hearing the sound of men trampling through the night is found in Charlotte Bronte's Shirley. The procedure for the Luddite attack at each mill was the same. They would ritually smash into pieces the new cropping frames, the machines at the centre of the dispute, sometimes in the presence of the petrified mill owner. Rarely was anything else damaged and other machines and property were usually left untouched.
The terrified authorities saw in these attacks the threat of potential revolution. The Huddersfield magistrate, Joseph Radcliffe, was determined to take a strong line and made extensive use of spies and informers to gain information from the closed ranks of the working communities, whence the Luddites came. Some of the mill owners began to defend their property and one of the most resolute of the owners, William Cartwright (the original for the character of Robert Monre in Bronte's Shirley), stayed up each night with a small posse of defenders after blockading his mill. His defences included giant spikes struck into barrels and 'carbuoys of vitriol' ready to pour on any attackers who might penetrate his outer defences.
On the night of April 11th, soon after midnight, about 200 men led by George Mellor attacked Cartwrights' mill at Rawfolds. For virtually the first time they found that one of their targets was well defended. The attack was repulsed and the Luddites were forced to retreat leaving two men dying of their wounds behind them. With the defeat at Rawfolds the tide gradually began to turn against the Luddites. William Horsfall was another of the local mill owners who was known for his outspoken views against the Luddites. He was reported as having sworn that he would ride ‘up to his saddle girths in Luddite blood'. On April 28th he was assassinated as he rode home from market. This turned popular feeling against the Luddites – smashing machines in the dead of night was one thing, but killing a defenceless man in cold blood was something else.
The area was swamped with spies and informers and a reward of 2,000 pounds (a fortune then) was offered for information that would lead to convictions. Eventually Radcliffe extracted a confession from one of the Luddites – whether the man Benjamin Walker 'grassed' on his friends or whether he cracked under interrogation is not clear from the available documents. Whatever was the truth of the matter, Walker had been held for questioning for four days before he gave the authorities the names and the information they wanted. This evidence from Walker was enough to lead to a series of arrests of the Luddite ringleaders who were brought before a special judicial commission at York Castle in January 1813. Twenty-four men were found guilty, some for the assassination of Horsfall, some for administering illegal oaths which had been made a capital offence, and some for smashing machines. Seventeen men were executed, fourteen in one session. The others were transported for seven years. Luddism was broken. As new machines were introduced the number of skilled croppers in the Leeds area dropped from over 1,700 to barely a handful in five years and the craft of cropping became obsolete. Skilled croppers were to be found as 'bailiffs, water-carriers, scavengers or selling oranges, cakes, tapes and laces, gingerbread, blacking, etc.'.
In making the dramatised documentary The Luddites, director Richard Broad and myself imagined we were film makers in 1812 going out with a current affairs crew to report on the disturbances in the woollen industry. We asked ourselves how would we cover such events if they were happening today? And so in our imaginary 'This Week' or 'Panorama' of l812 we dramatised some of the secret meetings of the Luddites with the men masked to prevent their identities from being known. We filmed the croppers in their workplace where they explained to us the craft of cropping and the skills involved. We filmed the manufacturers in their mills and asked them how they justified the introduction of such machinery at times as difficult as these. We witnessed attacks on mills. And, just as we would today, we interviewed prominent 'experts' of the day. Robert Owen and David Ricardo both appear in the film giving us their perspective on events. Also we interviewed the 'hard-line' Home Secretary of the time, Viscount Sidmouth, who made it clear to the cameras that the government would stop at nothing to put down these disturbances. He told us that he was willing to send more troops into Yorkshire than Wellington had at his disposal in Spain at the time during the Peninsula War.
We knew that there would be certain obvious problems with trying to recreate the look of England in the early stages of the Industrial Revolution in a convincing or realistic way. We wanted to film everything on location in Yorkshire in the area where the events took place, and we were fortunate in finding a superb mill in National Trust property at Hardcastle Craggs north of Hebden Bridge. Built as a cotton mill in 1801 the mill was just the right size for us and had an adjoining row of workers cottages that were a great bonus. Unfortunately the mill was semi-derelict and had no windows but after negotiations with the National Trust we were able to share the cost of the restoration work with them. The filming has left as a legacy a magnificent example of local industrial architecture. No examples of the central machine in the dispute, the cropping or shearing frame, had survived: it is one of the ironies of the story that after the bitter struggle over the introduction of this machine the frame soon became obsolete when an improved machine using rotary blades was invented. However, John Magson, a local craftsman who specialises in building replica machinery from the woollen industry, was able to build such a machine for us based on the drawings from a Cyclopoedia of 1818. Magson made three machines, one of which worked and two of which we smashed for the cameras. The working machine can now be seen at the Piece Hall Museum in Halifax.
Whilst the film relies upon the central 'deceit' of being reported by an imaginary film unit of the time, everything in the film is derived from historical fact. As principal sources we used the various Reports of the Parliamentary Committees who reported on the woollen industry and on the disturbances and the detailed accounts of the trial in the Leeds Mercury. We consulted several other collections of documents, including the letters to and from the local magistrate known as the Radcliffe Papers. Several histories of the woollen industry at the time provided essential background for the team, as did George Walker's delightful drawings in the Costumes of Yorkshire.
Perhaps most interesting of all, from our point of view, was the work of journalists from later in the century v ho drew on a local oral tradition in relating the Luddite story. In 1878 Frank Peel, the editor of the Heckmondwike Herald and Liversedge Weekly Courier, produced a series of articles based on research into the Luddite events and conversations over the previous years with men who had been Luddites or who were close to the Luddites. Peel's articles were later re-published in book form as The Risings of the Luddites. E.P. Thompson considers Peel's account of events as an 'important historical source', and to us it provided a direct line to some of the men and the situations which we were dramatising. Peel talks, for instance, of getting information about John Baines, the old republican and radical, who used to hold forth to the croppers at regular meetings at the Crispin Inn, Halifax (one of the sequences we have dramatised), from an old man 'who had stood as a stripling in the Luddite ranks, and had often joined in their wild defiant songs as they plied the sounding shears, [who] called himself an "old rebel"'. Another book of this period, rather more fictional in its style but still apparently derived in part from the memories of old men, is Ben o' Bills, The Luddite. This story is based on a fictional family caught up in events. The narrator is supposed to be Mellor's cousin who reluctantly gets involved with the Luddite bands.
From the point of view of drawing up scenes and characters these accounts were especially useful to us. Peel's narration, particularly, draws not just on an oral tradition but on a secret oral tradition, a tradition driven underground by years of pursuit and persecution imposed by the Combination Acts into what E.P. Thompson calls 'the opaque society'. Some sort of underground network certainly existed between the disaffected districts with a sort of shadowy connection going back as far as Despard's conspiracy of 1802 and coming forward to the time of Oliver the Spy and the Peterloo Massacre. Peel describes meetings in early 1812 when Yorkshire croppers listen to the tales of frame- breaking from Nottinghamshire delegates. But with government spies and informers paid 'by results' it is difficult to give credence to some of the accusations of activities by French agents and of a nationally organised revolutionary council waiting in the wings to exploit the situation.
What clearly emerges is a powerful protest from a group of men who feel that they must make a stand against the spread of the factory system, against the further incursions of naked industrial capitalism. The spectre of the factory with its gross exploitation of women and children haunted these skilled working men. They saw the factory as a dark and grimy cauldron in which skills had no value and in which individual liberties were surrendered to the owners and bosses who then expected people to work, slave-like, for long hours in appalling conditions. The rhythm and pace of industrial life in Yorkshire were being transformed at this time, work was no longer performed at home to the sound of the spinning wheel and the handloom but was carried out in vast 'manufactories' to the rhythm of the time-clock and the factory whistle.
The Yorkshire Luddites were well organised as far as they needed to be in terms of arranging for sometimes hundreds of men to rendez-vous at night in secret and to carry out a co-ordinated attack on a mill. They were articulate and forceful in their protest against a system of de-skilling and industralisation that they saw as robbing them of their skills and their privileges which had been passed down for generations. They were forced underground and into violence by the rules of a society that at the time was too frightened to allow working men to meet together and to organise. In telling their story in The Luddites, we have no doubt played with the truth at times and in places perhaps distorted some of the historical characters in the interests of dramatic licence. I hope, however, that the film is true to the spirit of the tirne and that it will disabuse some people of using the word 'Luddite' in a derogatory sense to represent someone with a mindless objection to change and progress. The Luddite message was proclaimed loudly and articulately in 1812 and its echo is as relevant and as interesting in today's society as it was 170 years ago.
David Englander reviews the programme's attempt to 'put a very human face to the faceless mob'.
On Friday, 8th January, 1813, at 9am , behind the Castle at York, George Mellor, William Thorpe and Thomas Smith were executed before the eyes of a sombre and silent crowd. What brought them to the gallows? The Luddites is an attempt to re-enact and explain the sequence of events that carried these humble craftsmen from the industrial villages of the West Riding to die on the scaffold that fateful Friday morning.
The format in general works very well. The documentary-drama, organised around a clear visual narrative structure, makes for an easy identification of people and problems and gives ready access to the past in a manner that is both arresting and instructive. The facility with which the camera can present ordinary folk from times past as real flesh-and-blood people, makes me green with envy. The photography is skilful, locations well-appointed and the performers convincing. but such a programme requires more than technique. The Luddites is a subtle and perceptive account that engages our sympathies and enlarges our understanding of the social costs of the market-led process of industrialisation that occurred in this country some two hundred years ago, at a time when there were no North Sea oil revenues to cushion the resultant unemployment and minimise disruption.
Given our current preoccupation with the social costs of de-industrialisation, the relevance of a historical perspective seems almost self-evident. Or does it? Well, it all depends on the kind of history that is on offer. The kerfuffle over BBC television's drama series The Monocled Mutineer exposed in no uncertain terms the political passions excited by the 'wrong' version of the past. The BBC's offence on that occasion was to present a reading of events that exhibited the ideological character of the Great War and contested the ways in which it had been restructured and re-lived as literature and history. Extravagant claims for the historical accuracy of the production merely supplied the pretext for an outcry in press and Parliament that was primarily political in inspiration and purpose.
Thames Television have been rather more fly with their publicity. The Luddites makes no claims to historical authenticity; it is an imaginative interpretation, a form of 'faction', rather than a faithful reconstruction of events. So long as the viewer is not confused as to the status of the programme there can, I think, be no objection, to this mixture of fact and fiction. The provision of a free information pack, with facsimile documents, additional commentary and further reading, underlines the seriousness of purpose and sense of responsibility that characterises a production which, insofar as it arouses enthusiasm and interest in the study of history, is to be warmly welcomed.
The difficulties with the drama-documentary approach are of a different order. In its concern to present the machine-breakers as identifiable people, rather like you and me, the programme tends to lose sight of the significant differences that separate them from us. The intrusion of anachronism into the dialogue is also a problem, though perhaps a less serious one in view of its stated objects. Professional historians, for whom precision is a duty rather than a virtue, will no doubt be irritated by these avoidable lapses, but they would be wrong to allow the flaws in the production to outweigh its considerable strengths.
The Luddites is an admirable attempt to make sense of people who were misunderstood in their own lifetime as they are today. On the whole, it succeeds very well. Taylor Downing and associates have managed to penetrate the 'opaque society' and put a very human face to the faceless mob. Its weaknesses are the weaknesses of a medium that responds poorly when ideas and issues are unsupported by strong visual evidence. Alas, so much of the scholarly debate about the significance of machine-breaking in Regency England turns on the interpretation of evidence which is often intractable and not very filmic.
The Luddites appear to have covered their tracks with exceptional skill: intensive research, spread over more than one hundred years, has uncovered no genuine first-hand accounts of their activities. Why they chose to carry their secrets to the grave remains unclear. Whatever the reason or reasons, the more relaxed atmosphere of mid-Victorian Britain did not persuade them to commit their memories to print. The absence of the kind of autobiographical evidence that, in other spheres, has been so important to the development of the social history of labour, accounts for Edward Thompson's insistence upon the significance of the 'folklore' of Luddism as providing access to the shadow world of the machine breakers. Frank Peel's The Rising of the Luddites, based upon information derived from a secret oral tradition and an intimate knowledge of the disturbed districts, has been re-discovered and presented by Thompson as a work of meticulous scholarship and a major source for the study of Yorkshire Luddism. It is also a key text for Taylor Downing and Richard Broad who are unashamedly Thompsonian in perspective.
The quality of Peel's work has, however, been much disputed. Thompson himself readily concedes the inferior craftsmanship of the post-Luddite chapters. His critics insist that the earlier chapters are equally faulty. Professor Malcom Thomis, for one, cautions us against attaching undue importance to popular legend. 'Traditions', he writes, 'are often notoriously corrupted versions of the original, and traditions relating to Luddism have doubtlessly been determined by what men have chosen to remember and hand down rather than by what actually occurred at the time'. The issues between Thompson and Thomis go further and concern the connection between machine-breaking and politics. In short, was Luddism a purely industrial phenomenon or did it possess a political dimension with distinctly insurrectionist undertones'?
On this The Luddites is exceptionally good. One of its best features is the handling of the process of radicalisation with all its hesitancies and ambiguities. 'It's alright you talking about the rights of man, what about our right to work?', says William Thorpe addressing the veteran political agitator, John Baines, in an encounter at the St Crispin Inn. Mrs Bampton and her husband, too, are particularly effective in pinpointing the ways in which the destruction of trades and communities and the unsettlement of families contributed to the growth of organised resistance.
Luddism, however, was not a uniform movement. In Nottinghamshire, for example, where its non- political character is not seriously in doubt, it is the role of violence in the furtherance of industrial objects which historians find contentious. In the northern counties, by contrast, there is no denying the presence of a revolutionary element with contacts on either side of the Pennines that was active during the disturbances of 1811-12. The scope and importance of such seditious activity has, however, been questioned. Some scholars maintain that the attempt to locate Luddism within a continuous revolutionary underground, with Father O'Coigly at one extremity and Arthur Thistlewood at the other, tends to exaggerate its extent and cohesion by comparison with the expanding popular movement for Radical reform.
Are then the Luddites to be regarded as communal heroes or common criminals? Those writing in the non-Marxist tradition, who question the 'folklore' of Luddism, dismiss the account of an ‘opaque society' peopled by revolutionary heroes as so much eyewash. The Luddites, according to Malcom Thomis, were neither local heroes nor the bearers of an emergent class consciousness, but pathetic isolated wretches who, when goaded beyond endurance, resorted to archaic and negative forms of protest. I think Thomis is wrong, but I also think that his viewpoint is important and could have been better represented.
Still, it would be churlish to end on a critical note. Taylor Downing's attempt to produce a historical documentary-drama that makes good television and addresses our current concerns is successful on both counts. Whether the audience will react in quite the way he expects is another matter. In the Britain of today many viewers will have found the scaffold scenes comforting rather than appalling.