History Tomorrow

Michael Lee questions the use of using political historical sources.

How many modern historians nowadays consider that they should regularly purchase HMSO publications, especially parliamentary papers?

I am aware of a change in my own habits of buying for my personal working library, and wonder how many others have made a similar adjustment. I no longer try to keep a selection of papers from government sources, or to put it more accurately, I no longer pay regular visits to the government bookshop and buy items from my taxable income. Yet I cannot help feeling a sense of regret. Is that stupid? Should not one accept the signs of the times?

A mark of good training in modern British history used to be knowing one's way around the records of Parliament. Any scholar worth his or her salt quickly learnt what could be derived from the Journals and what from Hansard; and the beginning of many investigations was a trawl through the relevant Command papers and the reports of committees of inquiry. It seemed important to know at an early stage what was available from the archive office of the clerk of Parliaments, what could be seen at the Public Record Office, and what could still be purchased from the HMSO. When I was a research student there were still back copies of old Command papers at a very reasonable price. Just as medievalists learnt about the forms of administration from the 'shape of the archive', so modernists could discover the character of the issues at stake from the information made available to Parliament.

Of course there were certain assumptions behind this kind of approach to historical training. The history it produced had at least two characteristic features. First, it looked as if the basis of all history was making the Crown accountable to Parliament. Parliamentary sources were seen as the record of what the executive had been compelled to disgorge. Perhaps there was also a sense that Parliament defined the public sphere. Second, history written from parliamentary sources tended to be an interpretation of the 'conscience of the nation'. It was assumed that knowing what moved the minds of backbenchers in the Commons was appreciating the substance of politics. It may well have been true that writing history from these sources was feeding the sense of progress and reform. The evidence given to nineteenth-century select committees was the source of 'blue book history'. These inquiries took the reader down below the level of Parliament to what was happening on the ground. Even local historians began with parliamentary sources.

In the middle of the 1950s I used to make a point of buying the principal White Papers, the reports of the main Royal Commissions, the reports of Select Committees that dealt with an important question of policy, and the reports of major departmental inquiries. I still have on my shelves, for example, all the major inquiries into education, from Crowther in 1959 to Plowden in 1967. I was particularly anxious to acquire any inquiry which attempted to survey the past. I also bought the daily Hansard of any debate which seemed to me at the time particularly interesting.

But these personal purchasing habits fell away during the 1970s. Part of the change was just due to economic stringency. I began to jib at the HMSO pricing policy. When the Treasury succeeded in getting the prices of government publications raised to what were considered proper profitable levels, I just felt I could not afford to pay out so much simply to be 'well informed' and to have easy access to major reports. But I also detected a change in the 'quality press'; it became more and more likely that The Times and The Guardian would fail to print the proper parliamentary reference at the end of their treatment of the document being discussed. One could no longer jot down a Command paper number for future reference. To buy the document sometimes called for a bit of personal research before going to the HMSO.

These personal difficulties of course simply reflected what was happening in political life itself. Some would say that the management of information by the Executive turned away from Parliament as its main priority and began to be largely a matter of briefing the media. The art of timing the release of information seemed more subtly developed.

I found myself occasionally resorting to a kind of subterfuge in order to acquire something which I thought I could not afford to buy. Talking to clerks of select committees could lead to complementary copies of reports; going to press conferences might give an opportunity for a free copy. It was even possible to cultivate a friendly MP and acquire material being used by research assistants. But all these methods are very costly in time. In practice I began to acquire only those publications that were immediately relevant to my teaching or research. Events seemed to conspire against an individual scholar keeping a selection of government publications in a private library for general reference.

I am still not quite reconciled to this transformation. The pricing policy of HMSO still niggles a bit against my desire to have important sources to hand. The cost per page of the reports of the Select Committee on Defence which I brought recently varied from seven to twelve pence. I have adjusted to paying twelve pence a page for a scholarly book of limited appeal; I still jib at paying that amount for reports which have pages of lists of witnesses, etc.

I have concluded that I have to move with the times and accept that the only informed opinion is organised opinion. We are not a nation of thinking people with private libraries! The problem could not even be solved by the book society formula. I cannot quite envisage yet another set of offers from Swindon which give monthly selections of the best White Papers! Short of standing for Parliament itself each individual has to create his own network to acquire such information as seems important.