Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam
by Patricia Crone
- Meccan Trade and the Rise of Islam
Patricia Crone - Basil Blackwell, 1987 – vii + 300pp - £27.50
No scholar in recent years has done more to challenge old orthodoxies, both Muslim and Western, about the emergence of Islam in seventh-century Arabia than Patricia Crone. In 1977 she published with Michael Cook, Hagarism: the Making of the Islamic World, which argued on the basis of contemporary non-Muslim sources hitherto ignored, that there was a very intimate link between the earliest form of Islam and Jewish Messianism. It was, as the authors cheerfully admitted, 'a book written by infidels for infidels' and with 'what from any Muslim perspective must appear an inordinate regard for the testimony of infidel sources'. I know of no Muslim who accepted the thesis, which is hardly surprising, while if you mention it to western scholars of Islam they tend to look embarrassed, as though not quite sure what to do about it.
In this book Crone returns to the same territory, Spurred, she says, by her sceptical Oxford pupils, she sets out to re-examine the widely accepted understanding of the economic and social context in which Muhammad's prophecies were made. In the process, by questioning every assumption and every interpretation of evidence, she demolishes the understanding of the context in which Islam appeared that has been carefully, or sometimes not so carefully, built up by western scholars over the past one hundred years. She then goes on to suggest new directions in which research might move, directions which would lead to fresh support for the thesis of Hagarism.
The widely accepted argument about the rise of Islam was constructed on the early economic histories of Lammens and achieved its most persuasive expression in the works of Montgomery Watt (Muhammad at Mecca, Muhammad at Medina, The Cambridge History of Islam etc... ). It went thus: the rapid growth of trade in Mecca in the late sixth and early seventh centuries was the ultimate cause of the rise of Islam. In this period Mecca gained control of the trade from Arabia to the north and the transit trades, to a large extent in spices, from India and Ethiopia to the Mediterranean region. The consequence was the development of mercantile capitalism in a society in which attitudes derived from a nomadic economy were still strong. Greedy merchants came to focus only on making themselves rich, and neglected the poor amongst their clansmen for whom tribal collectivist values dictated they should care. Muhammad's prophecy was a warning against greed and a command to respect the welfare of the community; the rich were reminded that God was greater than they were and sat in judgement over them. The ideological revolution called Islam was the result of a major economic, social and political crisis.
Crone demonstrates, first that Meccans were not middlemen in some long-distance transit trade, and second that they did not control any trade route in Arabia. What trade there was in the region was local trade, conducted overwhelmingly with Arabs and generated by Arab needs, and is impossible to reconstruct. Moreover, the modern site of Mecca, which was not then a place of pilgrimage, which may not have been a sanctuary, which was barren and had only a small fertile hinterland, and which was a long way from significant trading partners, was probably not the site of Muhammad's Mecca. Indeed, much of the evidence, though not all, would make much more sense if Mecca were relocated in northwest Arabia.
Two questions remain. The first is, if Crone is right, how did so many scholars get it so wrong for so long? Why is it, as she neatly puts it, that hers must be 'a book in which little has been learnt and much unlearnt'? It is in part because too much reliance has been placed on the products of the early Islamic oral tradition, and she illustrates what damage can be done to it by new written evidence; it is in part because too much reliance has been placed on the exegetical literature surrounding the Quran, which testifies to what exegetes chose to believe rather than to what they remembered; it is in part too because of poor scholarship, of the wilfully blind following those who had never seen.
The second question is, if Crone is right, how now should we explain the rise of Islam? The context, she suggests, should be found in the growth of Byzantine and Persian power, The new factor in sixth- and seventh-century Arabia was the spread of Persian colonies throughout eastern Arabia and into the Yemen, and the spread of Byzantine influence from the Syrian desert, where there were client kings, to the Yemen, where their Ethiopian allies ruled until they were ousted by the Persians. What Muhammad offered was a programme of Arab state formation which would enable them to resist imperialism from the north; if the Arabs abandoned their individual tribal gods and shares in his Quranic monotheism they would be able to move as one against the outsider. Moreover, the version of monotheism he adopted was the Jewish one because, like many colonial peoples in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, he sought anti-establishment ideas from within the imperial society on which to base his resistance. It was to be Jewish monotheism that he chose because as a 'northwest Arabian' it was Byzantine Christian imperialism of which he was most conscious, while of course these Jewish ideas were readily available to him in the Jewish-Arab symbiosis of his 'northwest Arabian' Mecca. Thus the thesis of Hagarism joins forces with that of Meccan Trade and the rise of Islam.
This is a brilliant book. Providing Crone has interpreted her sources reasonably, and only the consensus of historians of early Islam can offer judgement here, she has produced one of the great scholarly demolition jobs of all time. It is, of course, a landmark in the subject. It is, furthermore, a grippingly provocative read. Teachers of the subject will love it because it gives them so much to talk about; students will do so because of the excitement it brings, because page by page we see a buccaneering scholar putting to the sword assumptions cherished by Westerners for 100 years and by Muslims for 1,300 years or more. This said, there is a chance that its argument might by marginally more acceptable to Muslims than that of Hagarism. To the extent that it makes Muhammad a leader of a protest against imperialism, to the extent that it makes Islam from its foundation a political religion, and only to this extent, it is an argument which could find favour with Muslim fundamentalists today.
- Francis Robinson is author of Atlas of the Islamic World since 1500 (Phaidon, 1982)