Katherine Grey: Heir to Elizabeth

According to the will of Henry VIII, it was the younger sister of the ill-fated Lady Jane Grey who would follow Elizabeth I to the throne of England. Yet few now know of the short, passionate and dangerous life of Katherine Grey, writes Leanda de Lisle.

Imagine you are 18. Your home is lost, your sister and father executed, but you have survived the reign of Mary Tudor to emerge as Queen Elizabeth’s heir and rival. In November 1558 such was the position of Lady Katherine Grey, sister of Jane, the Nine Days Queen. But Katherine’s dramatic life has been all but erased from national memory, along with one of the great love stories of English history.

To recover Katherine’s remarkable story, we must return to the dying months of the reign of Queen Mary, in the summer of 1558. Katherine was living in the royal household as a Maid of the Privy Chamber. An influenza outbreak was killing thousands across the country and a number of the queen’s ladies fell ill. When her friend Jane Seymour, niece and namesake of Henry VIII’s third wife, developed a fever, Katherine was permitted briefly to nurse her at the country house of Jane’s mother, Anne, Duchess of Somerset. Jane’s 19-year-old brother, ‘Ned’ Seymour, Earl of Hertford, was also there and, during that summer, a romance developed.

Hertford’s mother warned him that his attraction to Katherine was potentially dangerous. Queen Mary was ill and any match between Ned Hertford and Kath-erine posed a threat to her successor, Elizabeth. Under the will of Katherine’s great-uncle, Henry VIII, backed by statute, Katherine followed Elizabeth in line to the throne. This is not, of course, how history remembers it. Mary Queen of Scots is the cousin we recall as Elizabeth’s heir. But Henry VIII had excluded from the succession the entire Stuart line of his elder sister, Margaret of Scotland, and in their stead placed the heirs of his younger sister, Mary Rose Tudor, Katherine’s grandmother.

If Henry’s will and the 1536 statute that supported it had not existed, Mary Queen of Scots would have had the superior right to Elizabeth. As the illegitimate daughter of Henry’s annulled marriage to Anne Boleyn, Elizabeth had no claim to the throne under the traditional rules of primogeniture. Logically, to accept Elizabeth’s right to become queen was also to accept Katherine’s right in line of succession. And that right would be strengthened by marriage. It was possible even that England’s Protestant supporters would prefer a married Katherine to a virgin Elizabeth. Indeed, they had form in this regard.

Five years earlier, Henry VIII’s son, the Protestant Edward VI, had cut his half-sisters Mary and Elizabeth out of his will and bequeathed his throne instead to Katherine’s elder sister, Lady Jane Grey. Many Protestants backed his decision, principally because Mary was a Catholic, but also because the Tudor sisters were unmarried, while Jane Grey had a husband: Guildford Dudley, fourth son of John Dudley, Duke of Northumberland. (Katherine was married on the same day as Lady Jane to Henry Herbert, son of the Earl of Pembroke, but the marriage was unconsummated and Pembroke, soon keen to distance his family from the imperilled Greys, later had the marriage annulled.)

Protestants in particular were dismayed by the prospect of female rule, which ran against traditional notions of hierarchy and (some argued) biblical teaching. But a married queen at least offered the possibility of a male heir. To whom a queen was married was also of crucial importance.

Edward VI had expressed the fear that his half-sisters might marry foreigners and England thereby become part of a foreign empire. What he did not take into account was the hatred and envy the Dudleys inspired. Mary Tudor, supported by many ordinary people, had overthrown Lady Jane Grey on July 19th, 1553, a mere nine days after she was proclaimed queen in London. But this success was of little comfort to Elizabeth in the summer of 1558 as Mary’s health rapidly declined. Hatred of the Dudleys had helped Mary’s cause immeasurably, yet Elizabeth was in love with Lady Jane’s brother-in-law, Lord Robert Dudley. To complicate matters further he was a married man.

When Mary Tudor died in November 1558, one of Queen Elizabeth’s first actions was to demote Katherine from a maid of the Privy Chamber to the Presence Chamber, to which all the higher gentry had access. It sent out a clear message that those who wanted royal favour should not be too friendly with Katherine. But that summer Elizabeth was too busy pursuing her passion for Robert Dudley to notice the romance between Katherine and Hertford flourishing under her nose. The couple later remembered the royal progress of 1559, with its summer banquets and garden walks, as the time when they fell in love. It was, however, Elizabeth’s devotion to Robert Dudley that was the talk of the court.

By the summer of 1560 many believed Elizabeth’s affection for Dudley would lead to her overthrow and ambassadors and privy councillors were discussing the arrangement of a suitable future marriage for Katherine, as her heir. The Spanish hoped to see Katherine married to a Habsburg. Elizabeth’s councillors talked instead of the Earl of Arran, leader of the Scottish Protestants and the heir of Mary Queen of Scots. Katherine had, in fact, already agreed in secret to marry Hertford, a promise sealed with ‘kissing, embracing and joining their hands together’ in his sister’s private closet at Whitehall Palace. And Hertford, although young and inexperienced, was well connected and had much to recommend him. A descendant of Edward III, he was also the son of Edward VI’s uncle, the hardline Protestant, Protector Somerset. 

Only circumstantial evidence remains to suggest who knew of Katherine’s romance, but her aunt Katherine’s widower, Henry Fitzalan, Earl of Arundel, appears to have been one of them. At the time of Elizabeth’s accession Arundel had been among the queen’s suitors. Elizabeth had laughed off his attentions and he was now pursuing Hertford’s sister. If Elizabeth wouldn’t make him a king, Arundel hoped he could yet make a king’s brother-in-law if Katherine, married to Hertford, were to become queen.

The most significant figure linked to the young couple was Elizabeth’s secretary of state, Sir William Cecil, who was Katherine’s kinsman and had begun his career in the household of Hertford’s father. Cecil was among those most concerned about Elizabeth’s devotion to Robert Dudley. On September 6th, 1560 he warned the Spanish ambassador that he ‘clearly foresaw the ruin of the realm through Lord Robert’s intimacy with the Queen’. Twice Cecil commented that he wished Dudley dead. That evening, however, it was Dudley’s wife, Amy Robsart, whose corpse was found lying at the foot of a short flight of stairs in the house of a friend. The coroner’s jury, which later viewed Amy’s body, returned a verdict of death by misadventure. It suggested suicide. But there was no shortage of those willing to believe that Dudley had killed his wife. Cecil’s great fear was that Elizabeth would now marry Dudley despite this.

Fortunately, the queen soon made it plain that she understood that this was impossible.

If Cecil had encouraged Hertford and Katherine’s relationship, as some later believed he had, he now advised Hertford to pull back. Dutifully, Hertford ceased contact with Katherine and even flirted with another girl at court. But when Katherine wrote him a furious letter he feared he risked losing her if he put off their nuptials much longer. They married in December 1560 with only his sister Jane as witness. According to the transcripts of later interviews in the Tower, which describe their wedding night in intimate detail, Katherine married Ned Hertford in his bedroom at a house on the Thames. They toasted their marriage briefly but Hertford’s sister, ‘perceiving them ready to go to bed’, soon left. They made love with Katherine naked save for a fashionable headdress. They got up briefly and then went back to make love again, dashing back to court before they were missed.

Over the following months the couple met for passionate encounters in many of the queen’s palaces, as well as at Hertford’s London house. In March, Katherine’s sister-in-law, Jane Seymour, died aged only 19. That same month Katherine began to suspect (correctly) that she was pregnant but, fearful of the implications, she convinced herself she must be mistaken. With Hertford anxious to leave England on a trip to Europe, she ignored the signs of pregnancy and agreed he could go. Cecil, aware only that they were seeing each other, not that they were married, and anxious to keep them apart, explained to Katherine that Hertford leaving was for their own good. But as she reflected, Cecil’s advice had come too late.

Katherine was eight months pregnant, and on another summer progress with the court, before she confessed to Robert Dudley that she was to have Hertford’s child. She begged him to be her intercessor with the queen. He failed to mollify Elizabeth, who threw Katherine in the Tower. Recalled from Europe, Hertford was also imprisoned, arriving at the Tower on September 5th, 1561. Elizabeth suspected a plot, but had no idea who was involved. The Spanish ambassador believed Cecil was the prime mover in plotting the union and Arundel’s name was also mentioned. But the couple’s testimony revealed no evidence of anything behind their marriage, other than their own careless passion. As Elizabeth’s progress continued grimly through the eastern counties, she now also had to face the emissary of her better-known rival, Mary Queen of Scots.

The Stuart queen had recently returned from France to the kingdom of her birth. On September 8th her adviser, William Maitland of Lethington, arrived at the ancient royal castle of Hertford where Elizabeth was based, bearing Mary’s letters. Scotland had fought and lost a war with England after Mary had laid claim to Elizabeth’s crown on the grounds that she had the right of primogeniture. Mary had refused to ratify the subsequent peace treaty that demanded she now recognise Elizabeth’s claim as queen. It appears there was a price for her signature to that clause: Elizabeth should name her as heir, not Katherine Grey.

Maitland found Elizabeth ‘To all appearances … falling away … extremely thin and the colour of a corpse.’ The stress of discovering Katherine’s pregnancy had taken its toll. The messages Maitland had brought with him would now pile more pressure on her. While the letters from Mary offered sisterly affection, the rest, sent by members of the Scottish nobility, warned that the surest way to keep Scotland’s friendship was for Elizabeth to name Mary her successor. Maitland urged this last point strongly, only to have Elizabeth retort that she had expected a different message: one concerning Mary’s willingness to ratify the treaty. As the interview continued, however, what emerged was that despite their differences, Elizabeth, the  future goddess of Protestant, English nationalism, far preferred the claim of the Catholic, foreign, Mary to that of Protestant, English Katherine Grey.

Elizabeth told Maitland the succession was not a matter she wished to meddle in, in part, she hinted, because it would provoke a debate in England that would not be in Mary’s interest. And she assured him:

I here protest to you, in the presence of God, I for my part know no better [claim than the Queen of Scots] nor that I myself would prefer to her, or yet, to be plain with you, that case that might debar her from it.

It was an extraordinary statement. Elizabeth had made it quite clear that she believed Mary’s rights of succession, under the tradition of primogeniture, were more important than those decided by English statute and her father’s will.

Elizabeth understood what her father had not. By introducing Parliament into the divine process of the succession he had interfered with the notion of the divine right of a monarch to rule. Elizabeth feared that, if she did not prove Protestant enough (and she had differed with Cecil and others about how Protestant her religious settlement should be), or if she simply failed to produce a son and a male successor, Parliament, which had sealed her right, could be used to legitimise her deposition. And Katherine, with her marriage and impeccable Protestant heritage, would be her likely replacement.

Elizabeth expressed her bitterness to Maitland about Katherine and the third Grey sister, Lady Mary. ‘It is true’, she said ‘that some of them have made declaration to the world that they are more worthy of [the crown] than either [the Queen of Scots] or I, by demonstrating that they are not barren, but able to have children.’ But, Elizabeth claimed, the pregnant Katherine was unable to inherit because her father had been convicted of treason after his involvement in the 1554 revolt against Mary Tudor, which had led to his execution and that of Lady Jane Grey. It was a failed argument that had been used once before by Lady Strange, a cousin of the Greys, and it was a mark of Elizabeth’s desperation that she made it.

Maitland hoped that, if he pressed Elizabeth further, she might even name Mary Queen of Scots as her choice of heir. At his final audience, however, Elizabeth again raised the issue of the 1554 revolt. Protestant rebels, angered by Mary’s intention to marry Philip of Spain, had hoped to use Elizabeth to replace her Catholic sister. One day, Elizabeth reflected, such men might find a reason to overthrow her, either in favour of Mary Queen of Scots or Katherine. A prince could not trust even the children who were to succeed them, Elizabeth said, perhaps thinking of Katherine’s unborn child. Certainly her parting comment to Maitland concerned Katherine: ‘She thought there was more matter hid in [the marriage with Hertford] than was yet uttered to the world’, Maitland recalled, ‘and that some of her nobility were partners in the making of that match.’

In the Parliament of 1563 efforts were made to limit the succession to members of four English families. When this failed a bill was proposed that would bring a Great Council into being on Elizabeth’s death, with the power to appoint her heir. This neo-republican proposal has William Cecil’s fingerprints all over it; he would come up with a similar proposal in the 1580s. It got nowhere. But greater success was made with the writing of a book clarifying Katherine’s rights of succession. Composed by John Hales, an MP and friend of Cecil’s, the book attacked the claim of Mary Queen of Scots, drawing attention to a law dating back to the reign of Edward III that excluded from the succession all those born outside the realm of England. It also discussed Henry VIII’s will in Katherine’s favour and quoted Protestant European clerics who ruled that Katherine was married according to church law.

When Elizabeth learned of Hales’ book she was furious about his ‘writing so precisely against the Queen of Scotland’s title’ and he was sent to the Tower. She warned Cecil she was aware that names associated with the production of the book were among his clients. But, as she remarked to the Spanish ambassador, so many senior figures were involved she was forced to overlook their actions. Under such pressure Elizabeth wanted desperately to be able to trust Mary. She proposed that the Queen of Scots marry the man she herself loved, Robert Dudley, and raised him to the title Earl of Leicester to make him a more attractive groom. But instead Mary married her English-born cousin, Lord Darnley, another grandchild of Margaret Tudor. When a son, James, was born, Cecil and his allies redoubled efforts to have Mary excluded from the succession.

New tracts on the succession were published and in October 1566 MPs who supported Katherine threw punches on the floor of the Commons as they fought for the right to debate the succession against the queen’s command. Despite the petitions that followed, Elizabeth declined to name any heir. But her long preferred choice was now to self-destruct. Darnley was murdered and Mary married James Hepburn, Earl of Bothwell, the man believed to be his murderer. Mary was promptly overthrown in a revolt led by her Protestant lords and her infant son, James VI of Scotland (and future James I of England), was crowned in her place. It seemed that Katherine and her supporters had won. But Katherine would never lie beside her Ned again as she had prayed she would. Separated from her husband and elder child for four years, Katherine had fallen into despair.

In January 1568 Katherine's warder. Sir Owen Hopton, sent a letter asking for the royal doctor to help her. But she herself made it clear she had no wish to live. Katherine begged instead that Hopton return to I Iertford her wedding ring and take to him a parting gift: another ring engraved with the words, 'While I lived, Yours'. She died, aged 28. four months before Mary Queen of Scots fled to England. Hertford was freed in 1571, st hoping his elder son, Lord Beauchamp would one day be king. But at Beauchamp fell in love with a genti woman not considered grand enough be future royal consort. Elizabeth, delighted, gave the marriage her blessing Il was an unusual move from the Virgi Queen, who had gained a reputation for sexual jealousy, albeit influenced by the fact the marriage helped destroy Beauchamp's chances for the crown.

Katherine's younger son predeceased Elizabeth, dying in 1600. by which time William Cecil was also dead. His long pursuit of his bête noire, Mary Queen of Scots, had ended with her trial and execution for treason in 1587. But the way was now clear for James VI, her son, who duly succeeded Elizabeth to the English throne in 1603. The old queen had determined that divine right would succeed over parliamentary statute and to King James it seemed this had been achieved. But the struggles over the succession had encouraged the development of a civic consciousness and desire to control the crown that would make the exercise of autocratic rule increasingly difficult. Hertford lived long enough to see how unpopular James became and how Elizabeth’s memory was glorified as a means of criticising her Stuart successor. He died aged 84, over 50 years after Katherine, having found in his last years, the priest who had married them.

The couple’s grandson, William Seymour, buried them together in a magnificent tomb in Salisbury Cathedral: the queen who never was lying above her husband to mark her royal status.

Katherine’s story was forgotten because it runs contrary to the mythology of the Virgin Queen that became an important part of English national identity. Elizabeth’s refusal to tolerate an English, Protestant heir, does not fit with our image of the heroine of the Armada or with the old tales of her rivalry with the Queen of Scots. It was also an inconvenient reminder of the argument that the Stuarts came to the throne illegally. Today, genealogists point to Lady Kinloss as Katherine’s heir, and under the will of Henry VIII, the rightful Queen of England.