William Prynne, 1600-1669
“Bleak indeed, but blazing,” Prynne was one of the martyrs of the seventeenth-century Puritan movement. Yet, as William M. Lamont notes, even in his own party, his fiercely uncompromising character often aroused hatred and contempt.
A Catalogue of the Works of William Prynne, the Puritan lawyer, was published after the Restoration. Appended to it was a Biblical text: “Of making many Books there is no end, and much study (or reading) is a werisomnesse to the flesh.” Across his own copy, Anthony Wood mischievously added: “And ears.”
The joke was mean and unworthy. Twice, in 1634 and in 1637, Prynne had been punished for his pamphlets against Archbishop Laud by the mutilation of his ears. On the second occasion, his ear had been cut so close that a part of his cheek had been sliced too, and he had very nearly lost his life. The sentence that he had hurled back then at his persecutors splendidly captured the resilient strength of Puritanism: “The more I am beat down, the more am I lift up.”
Prynne deserves to be honoured as one of the great seventeenth century martyrs, but Wood’s reaction is far more typical. Both his own and later generations have found it difficult to take him seriously: quite simply, the more Prynne was beat down, the more Prynne was beat down.
Why should this have been so? Prynne had enjoyed a remarkable career. He was born in Swainswick, near Bath, in 1600. He graduated from Oriel College, Oxford, in 1621 and entered Lincoln’s Inn. There he came under the influence of the Puritan lecturer, John Preston. Peter Heylyn, the biographer of Archbishop Laud, acidly observed that Preston had singled Prynne out as “the fittest person to venture upon such Exploits which a more sober and considerate man durst not have appeared in.”
In 1626 Prynne wrote the first of his two hundred pamphlets, against Laud’s efforts to dilute the Calvinist strain in Anglican doctrine. Soon he was writing against other evils of the time: long hair; the drinking of healths; stage plays. Caroline Teddy Boys felt the lash of his scorn:
“...the Barber is their Chaplaine: his Shop, their Chappell: the Looking-Glasse their Bible; and their Haire, and Lockes, their God... Would they not rather have the Common-wealth disturbed, than their Haire disordered?”
After 1637, Prynne’s disfigurement obliged him to wear his hair long, an irony appreciated by opponents. For he had been causing them concern, as is clearly reflected in the correspondence of John Cosin, and in 1634, he went too far. In an attack upon stage plays, Histriomastix, he denounced female actors. This appeared in print at almost the same time as the Queen took part in Mountague’s The Shepherd’s Pastoral at Court, and provided Prynne’s enemies with the pretext for action.
His defence was that his work had been long in preparation and that the date of its publication was still a month earlier than the Queen’s performance. This case is less convincing than it seems to be, since he had inserted additional criticisms of female actors in the Index. Prynne’s objections cannot remove the suspicion that he had in mind the rehearsals of the performance, which took place at the time that the Index was passing through the press. Nevertheless, his conviction represented the triumph of political expediency; Prynne had not directly attacked the Crown, even if he had attacked amusements patronized by it.
Histriomastix is the apotheosis of Puritan insensitivity: bigoted, prolix, hysterical. But it is a crime against literature, not against the state: Samuel Butler characterized Prynne’s weakness as the casting of holy things, not unto dogs, but into doggerel. And one contemporary critic had the wit to see that soured misanthropy on so generalized a scale robbed the attack of particular application:
“it was fitter to be called Anthropomastix then Histriomastix, the scourge of mankind rather then the Kings sacred person.”
Prynne was not cowed by his sufferings. He continued to smuggle pamphlets out of the Tower of London, and in 1637 suffered once more, this time in the company of fellow-Puritans, John Bastwick and Henry Burton. All three had their ears sliced; an additional refinement of cruelty for Prynne was the branding of the initials “S.L.” across his cheeks. To Laud, they stood for “Seditious Libeller”; to Prynne, they stood for “the Stigma of Laud”—surely the most pardonable pun in English history. No single action did more to inflame resentment against Laud than this sentence; the three libellers became the three holy martyrs. Kenelm Digby noted how the Puritans fought to preserve bloody sponges and handkerchiefs from the execution.
As a good Catholic, he could not resist the chance to point the moral: “You may see how Nature leads men to respect the relics of Martyrs.” The three were exiled to the Channel Islands, but were released in triumph in 1640, when the Long Parliament was summoned. Something of the atmosphere of that time is communicated by the diary of a contemporary, Robert Woodford, when he described the return from exile:
“Oh, blessed be the Lord for this day! This day those holy living Martyrs Mr. Burton and Mr. Prynne came to towne and the Lord’s providence brought me out of the Temple to see them. My heart rejoiceth in the Lord for this day; its even like the returne of the captivity from Babilon. There went to meet them about 1,500 or 2,000 horsemen, and about 100 coaches, and the streets were all thronged with people, and there was very great rejoicing.”
During the Civil War, Parliament entrusted Prynne with a defence of its sovereignty and with the prosecution of Laud. At the close of the War, he denied the legality of the Army’s actions against Parliament; refused to take the Engagement; refused Cromwell’s offer of release from his imprisonment in Pendennis Castle in 1651, which was conditional on his abandonment of attacks against the Commonwealth. When Cromwell did release him in 1653, the release was unconditional. Prynne thenceforth worked untiringly for the return to Parliament of those Members who had been secluded in “Pride’s Purge,” as a preliminary to a return to Monarchy; it was a Royalist who now called him “the Cato of his Age.”
His labours were rewarded in February 1660, when he marched in to Parliament at the head of the re-admitted members, with sword at his side. This was a moment of high drama—alas, tinged with that element of farce that rarely eluded his actions: as Pepys tells us, “his long sword got between Sir William Waller’s short legs, and threw him down, which caused laughter.” Charles II knew Prynne’s value to his cause, and, at the Restoration, rewarded him with the post of the Keeper of the Records in the Tower of London. No post could have been happier for Prynne; those Royalist critics who gleefully recorded his chagrin at not being made a judge were wide of the mark.
This is the time when Maitland described Prynne as an “heroic” figure, burrowing among the ancient records. Prynne records with pride that it was a task “so filthy and unpleasant that Mr. Riley and others would not soil their hands, or clothes, nor indanger their healths to assist me in it.” Anthony Wood recalls how, in 1667, as a young antiquarian, furnished with letters of commendation from the Provost of Oriel College, he went to Prynne to be introduced to the records. Wood says that Prynne “received him with old fasion complements, such as were used in the raigne of King James I” and expressed his delight that so young a man as he “should have inclination towards venerable antiquity.”
There is something very touching in this scene: in life there are few things so selflessly pure as the help given to the young scholar by the old. Prynne died in 1669, a more mellow figure, but not less vigilant: he attacked the Clarendon Code; the banishment of Clarendon moved him to cry: “I pray God this be not a foreigner’s plot.” Pepys records his discomfiture at being seated next to Prynne at a dinner, “who, in discourse with me, fell upon what records he hath of the lust and wicked lives of the nuns heretofore in England, and showed me out of his pocket one wherein 30 nuns for their lust were ejected out of their house.”
It is easy to understand, even from this brief summary of his life, why Prynne should have incurred the hostility of Anglican and Roman Catholic. But why was Prynne suspect to his Puritan colleagues? The truth was that he was no narrow party man. Before the Civil War, he had expressed his admiration for moderate Anglicanism; during the early part of the War, he attacked Charles I as “The Popish Royall Favourite” and championed Presbyterian-ism; by the end, he had attacked both the Independent “new lights” and the Presbyterian theocrats. He deplored the execution of the King and, throughout the Interregnum, worked for the restoration of the Stuarts and attacked clericalism—Independent or Presbyterian.
He declared his faith in moderate Anglicanism at the Restoration. He quarrelled with all the leading Puritans: Burton, Goodwin, Peter, Gillespie, Rutherford, Baxter. Bastwick held Prynne’s friendship until his death, although even their relationship was strained by the disagreements of 1645. There could only be one interpretation for instability on such an heroic scale: that Prynne was the perverse opponent of all governments. This was the interpretation put forward by contemporary pamphleteers: “a constant opponent of all governments “the Spirit of Contradiction “he must scrible something against that Government, what ever it be “such strong monstrous Contradictions and forgetfulnesse, that a man may suppose you change soules as often as you doe shirts.”
Martin Luther had become Baron Corvo: interest in the external fact of persecution shifted to interest in the internal state of mind that could produce these delusions of persecution. One pamphleteer thought that it was a pity that Prynne had not died in 1637, and saved his reputation. To dismiss him as a paranoid personality liberated both his opponents then, and historians afterwards, from the task of taking his arguments seriously.
Is this a luxury that we can afford? Dr. Pocock’s monograph, The Ancient Constitution and The Feudal Law, suggests otherwise: he establishes the importance of Prynne’s antiquarian work. It is time now to do justice to his controversial ideas. It is the purpose of this article to sketch the outlines of a reinterpretation of Prynne, which, it is hoped, more detailed research later will substantiate: one that stresses, in Prynne’s thought, a unity of ends, despite a bewildering variety of means. On this view, he alienated the Puritans, not through being perverse, but through his very Puritanism.
Prynne attacked Independency as an antisocial force, that denied man’s dependence upon his neighbours, church and country for the fulfilment of his nature. Against such ideas, he quoted Aristotle’s view of man as a social animal. From Aristotle’s praise of the middle-class polity, Prynne also had learnt to value the spirit behind a constitution higher than its external form. It is this that divides Prynne from his fellow-Puritans. With them, he shared an ideal: of an England under a “godly discipline,” where the reprobate majority were disciplined for the glory of God and the good of their souls. Unlike them, he was indifferent as to the means by which this was to be accomplished.
The most formative influences upon the early Prynne were the works of Foxe and Jewel, which, together with the Bible and Erasmus’s Paraphrases, were often chained in churches. Foxe and Jewel were more frequently cited by Prynne in his early pamphlets than any other authorities; and he made a formal present of Foxe’s Acts and Monuments to his parish church at Swainswick. From them, Prynne learned to hope for godly reform by means of the Christian Emperor: on this view, the preamble to the Act in Restraint of Appeals lay at the heart of the English Reformation.
Prynne thus learned to think of ethical reform in the context of moderate Anglicanism: he attacked Laudian High Churchmanship as a deviation from these honoured imperial traditions. His language was, at times, intemperate, but the points that he made were not novel; they had been made as forcibly before by men like John White, Sibbes, Reynolds, Baynes and Gouge—men who were not separatists. It is true that all Laud’s opponents—with the exception of Leighton—said that they were attacking, not episcopacy, but excesses within ep:s:opacy. With many, this was humbug: men like Bastwick were working for Presbyterianism, even in the thirties.
This is not true of Prynne. One reason why he hated plays was that, on stage, men said things that they did not mean. He prized candour so highly that when, in the cases of Hugh Peter and John Durie, he came across examples of this politic acquiescence, he attacked them with the full force of his considerable invective. There is an illuminating exchange between Prynne and Burton on this point.
Burton, writing in the forties, noted that he and Prynne had suffered for opposing bishops. Not so, corrected Prynne: for opposing the excesses of bishops. At this point, Burton threw away his mask: he had been against bishops from the start, but fear had prevented an open profession of opinion. Prynne was outraged by this disingenuousness.
The truth was that, while there were bishops such as Hall, Morton and Usher to continue the traditions of Foxe and Jewel, Prynne saw no reason, in the thirties, to despair of Puritan reform through an Anglican medium. Because Puritanism was his obsessional interest, Prynne largely disregarded the orthodox constitutional grievance against the bishops. He was concerned lest the Laudian bishops should frustrate imperial reform by their iure divino claims for episcopacy, not that they might swell the royal prerogative by absolutist sermons. He did not fear the magistrate’s sovereignty; he welcomed it as the necessary preliminary to the “godly discipline.”
But Charles I disappointed his hopes: he was more of a Nero than a Constantine. By 1641, Prynne had come to suspect that Charles, by his leanings to Rome, was undermining his own imperial mission; that is why Prynne flirted with deposition theories in his defence of the sovereignty of Parliament. By 1641, too, he had lost his faith in the moderate bishops: Hall’s defence of the iure divino claim for episcopacy was, for Prynne, a bitter blow. At this time of disillusionment, Prynne was peculiarly vulnerable to the spirited propaganda of the London Presbyterian ministers: he was won to their view that the ethical reform—which the civil magistrate had shirked—would come through the establishment of a Presbyterian discipline.
But—this is important—Prynne had no doctrinaire attachment to Scottish Presbyterianism: like Coleman, D’Ewes, Lightfoot and other English Puritans, he welcomed it solely as the agency of ethical reform. The Scot, Robert Baillie, knew the contingent nature of bis support, when he instructed his agent to “try the present estate” of Prynne. The attempt to found a moral code—no easy task in the midst of a Civil War—failed; the Westminster Assembly became synonymous with procrastination. The faithful had a ready explanation at hand: that it was Independent hostility that had thwarted the Presbyterian discipline. Prynne accepted at first this interpretation: hence his fierce invective, throughout 1644 and 1645, against Independent “wand-ring-blazing-stars.”
But his patience snapped in 1645: like D’Ewes, Coleman and Lightfoot, he found the cause of the moral breakdown in the nature of Presbyterian theocracy itself. In the Presbyterian ministers’ claim to suspend unexcommunicated scandalous offenders from the Sacrament of the Lord’s Supper, he detected the same exclusivist spirit that underlay the Independent establishment of separate congregations and the Laudian neglect of preaching. Prynne said that “reall speedy reformation in our Church” could not come from that “strict discipline, which really reforms very few or none.”
By 1645, where could Prynne look to for the establishment of his “reall speedy reformation?” Anglicanism and Presbyterianism were alike discredited; he therefore looked for initiative from the Commons, working together with a chastened King and an “unlordly” Anglicanism or Presbyterianism, that recognized lay control. As Baillie remarked bitterly, in September 1645: “Mr. Prin and the Erastian lawyers are now our remora.” The excesses of the Army drove Prynne into the arms of the King; by 1647 he had written a powerful plea for “The Sword of Christian Magistracy.”
He argued strongly in favour of reconciliation with the King on the basis of the Isle of Wight negotiations, and the King’s execution marked the final stage of his return to his old imperial faith. For Prynne believed that the King had expiated all his former faults by martyrdom at the hands of Papists— Prynne became an honoured name at the time of the “Popish Plot” agitation. During the Interregnum, he pursued two aims: the restoration of monarchy, for which he worked indefatigably; the curbing of clerical exclusiveness, whether Anglican, Presbyterian or Independent, by attacks—in letters and pamphlets— upon the ideal of unmixed communion.
The Restoration failed to honour his imperial ideals, and he now attacked the “new Laudianism.” In a speech in the Commons in 1660, he said that he “could not be for bishops, unless they would derive their power from the King and not vaunt themselves to be Iure Divino”: an accurate expression of his philosophy throughout his life, with the important exception of his flirtation, between 1641 and 1644, with Presbyterian clericalism.
In 1660 his answer to the new Laudianism was not, however, Presbyterianism, but the old, imperial Anglican tradition. It was no accident that, in his will, he bequeathed a volume of his works to Dr. Tillotson: for in the appointment, in 1663, as preacher to his own Lincoln’s Inn of Tillotson —the enemy of Laudianism, the champion of mixed communion, sympathetic to the scruples of nonconformists and hostile to those of Papists—Prynne could read the most hopeful sign of the ultimate fulfilment of his Puritan ideals.
When the dogma of Papal Infallibility was pronounced, Lord Acton is reputed to have declared that, if the Pope wished to change his religion, that was his business; he saw no reason why he should change his. Prynne would have approved of this pragmatic approach. His own Puritan ideals were firmly fixed; he was indifferent as to the form in which they should be embodied. He derided controversies about “Precedency, Church government, superfluous Ceremonies and formalities” as “unnecessary contests,” and, in this respect, came close to the spirit of the Tew circle; it is notable that he had a sincere— although unreciprocated—regard for Clarendon.
But his method was entirely different. John Hales, for instance, thought that clerical controversies were a waste of time when set against the broader ethical issues; Prynne agreed, but could not keep his hand out of the controversies. Hales would never have disputed at length with Gillespie, the Presbyterian theocrat; Prynne, on the other hand, warred over minutiae with Gillespie with hair-splitting pedantry, but never lost sight of the real issues at stake. It was paradoxical: Prynne inspected with microscopic passion the texture of every leaf and blade of grass, and did not lose sight of the wood for the trees.
For he swapped text for text with enthusiasm, but his objection was, basically, a pragmatic one: he asked Gillespie why he should value the disciplinary power of excommunication, when it was evident that those countries that lacked it had a more effective moral code than those that had it. Gillespie answered readily that the raising of moral standards would be the natural corollary of a Scottish “sin-searching, sin-discovering and sin-censuring discipline” in England. In the heady atmosphere of 1641, this evasion might have satisfied Prynne; in 1645, he wanted more concrete reassurances.
This does not mean that Prynne’s judgment was superior to that of the Presbyterian ministers: their belief, that moral laxity was the interim product of the delay in setting up the discipline as they wanted it, may have been correct. But the point was that their commitment to their party programme caused them to play down the importance of this moral laxity. Because Prynne was uncommitted, the ethical question stayed in the foreground. If the party programme was not fulfilling the ethical aim, Prynne was too uncompromising, (as Burton had appreciated), and too obsessional, (as Pepys had seen), to mask his impatience.
No wonder his Puritan colleagues hated Prynne—not for his perverseness, but for his unsentimental pragmatism! G. K. Chesterton, in an essay on Shaw, once described twentieth-century Puritanism as a weak and lukewarm torrent into which had melted down “much of that mountainous ice which sparkled in the seventeenth century, bleak indeed, but blazing.” That mountainous ice was incontestably William Prynne: bleak indeed, but blazing; a reproach to a weak and lukewarm torrent.

