Is there Now, or Has there Ever Been, A Working Class?

Bryan Palmer looks at the dialogue between Marxism, class struggle and working-class identity in the changing fortunes of working-class history in North America and beyond.

It is a curious conjuncture of our times that the much-proclaimed end of Marxism is somehow related to the end of history as we know it. Who would have thought that history, both as an unfolding process and a set of interpretative writings, would come to an end when Marxism as a ruling ideology in what has passed for socialist political economies crumbled and lost its appeal to many academics? No Marxist ever accorded his or her world view the apparent force and influence – intellectual and practical – that this current coupled understanding of the end of Marxism/history suggests.

At the centre of this linked termination is the long-standing disintegration of Soviet rule. The socio-economic implosion of nationalist, free-market, anti-Semitic, and right-wing powder-kegs throughout Eastern Europe is, oddly, taken as a repudiation of Marxism as an analytic framework, Communism as a I possible way of life, and history as the ordered trajectory of twentieth-century events. What is distressing about the current proclamations of the end of this and the fall of that, is the crudely ideological purpose of the exercise.

No amount of breast-thumping about the demise of Communism can obliterate the human costs in store for the workers of Eastern and once-Soviet Europe. The price of 'freedom' is now being calculated in cultural malaise, the dismantling of fundamental human rights to access to education, health care, and work, and widening confinements for women and targeted minorities. Intellectually, those who close their eyes to these developments, proclaiming with loud confidence all the good that will come with the end of Marxism, seldom know much about either Marxism or the complex relationship of historical materialism and the actual political formations that have, since 1917, proclaimed themselves socialist. They never acknowledge that one variant of Marxism, orthodox Trotskyism, has always held that Soviet power was engaged in a precarious balancing act that could not last forever.

In this Trotskyist view, the original revolutionary workers' state degenerated under the weight of Stalinist bureaucratisation and what remained worthwhile in the socialised economy was persistently eroded over time. Subsequent workers' states were born deformed. Thus, the end of the ostensible socialist order was always in the making: either a political revolution would restore workers democracy in the planned economies of the USSR, its satellites, and various Third World 'socialist' countries, or capitalism would be restored and what remained of the workers' state destroyed.

This is now happening. If Marxism has not fallen and history has not come to its end, there is no denying that the momentous political events of the last decade have registered an intellectual impact among many different constituencies.

Not surprisingly, one area of historiography affected acutely by the so-called end of Marxism/history is the study of the working class. Labour history has always been written by non-Marxists as well as Marxists, but it is obvious that within the study of workers' movements, class formation, and labour politics, Marxism has often found a place. Usually that place has nestled implicitly between the lines of narratives of working-class struggle and workplace or community experience, as in E.P. Thompson's highly influential The Making of the English Working Class (1963) or David Montgomery's more recent study of American workers, The Fall of the House of Labor (1987). The stimulating essays of Herbert G. Gutman, Work, Culture, and Society in Industrializing America (1976) were never scaffolded on an explicit use of Marxist categories and understandings, but neither were they opposed to such a framework. Occasionally, studies such as Mike Davis, Prisoners of the American Dream (1986) appear that orchestrate the history of workers in overtly Marxist ways.

This is not to suggest that non-Marxists have not made important contributions to the study of workers in the past. They undoubtedly have, as the work of countless institutional and economic historians, such as the Webbs in England and the University of Wisconsin-based John R. Commons indicate. But it is undeniable that the 1960s and 1970s saw an important fusion of working-class history and a commitment to the basic tenets of historical materialism. This fuelled the explosion of studies of labour that began to appear in Canada, the United States, and Britain from 1970 on and culminated in efforts to reinterpret historiography and the meaning of class in Marxist terms.

One expression of this process was the populist project of History Workshop, which struggled ultimately to blend socialist and feminist analysis. Another was the acidic debate, with E.P. Thompson brought to the fore at the very moment he was struggling to stop history from ending in a nuclear holocaust, that scrutinised so-called 'culturalist' histories of workers, slaves, and others. Initiated by historians affiliated with the University of Birmingham's Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies, the opening shots in this polemical war lamented the extent to which these 'Thompsonian' texts wandered from the true Marxist analytic path in their superstructural stress on realms of experience once-removed from the all-determining economic base.

From the perspective of the 1990s such debates – not much more than a decade old and never adequately resolved – appear other – worldly. Virtually no-one now queries the watering down of Marxist categories and challenges the orthodoxy of specific interpretative directions. Culturalism, once decried, now seems almost convention, as the acclaim accorded Robert Darnton and revisionist treatment of the French Revolution indicate. What is questioned in the 1990s is something entirely different. Class itself is now routinely interrogated. If it is not denied outright as a historical presence worth looking at, it is judged to be but one of many fluctuating identities in the pluralist swirl of subjective consciousness, which has, of late, replaced what would once have been designated objective social structures, as a priority of historical research. The ways in which former Marxists have distanced themselves from class, as much in historical study as in other realms, is the focus of Ellen Wood's stimulating and award-winning book, The Retreat from Class (1986).

This apostatic drift commenced, as Wood shows, well before the end of Marxism/history became such a media event. In labour history the murmurings of discontent could be discerned in Gareth Stedman Jones' Languages of Class (1983), in which a pioneering reinterpretation of Chartism argued that this apparently archetypal proletarian movement of the 1830s and 1840s was not in fact mobilised by class grievance and discontent, but rather by the political language of eighteenth-century England. American labour historians quickly echoed what was now becoming something of an interpretative thunder, suggesting new ways of reconsidering the old question of 'American exceptionalism'. There was no socialism in the United States, this line of argument went, because the labour movement always spoke in terms of a republican people rather than a class, This position reached its suggestive zenith in the case of England with Patrick Joyce's recent synthetic statement, Visions of the People: Industrial England and the Question of Class, 1840-1914 (1991).

For the most part these new writings, emphasising the ways language determines what it is possible for people to think and do, represent a theoretically understated acceptance of certain premises associated with what has come to be known as post-structuralism. Post-structuralism, which originated in France but quickly found acceptance among many Western intellectuals, tends to downplay long-standing concerns with the ways in which societies are divided by seemingly objective productive relations, struggles and antagonisms that historians have traditionally connected to class. Instead, post-structuralism lays stress on how such developments are formed in the rhetoric and representative imagery of an age. This enterprise has been furthered considerably by the emergence of a feminist historiography that grapples even more seriously with the ways in which poststructuralist theory points to the need to recast historical understanding. In Gender and the Politics of History (1988) Joan Scott presented a series of essays, one of which cut to the bone of a certain kind of feminist discontent with the canon of labour history. Writing of The Making of the English Working Class, Scott concluded:

This is pre-eminently a story about men, and class is, in its origin and its expression, constructed as a masculine identity, even when not all the actors are male.

Scott called on historians to appreciate the gendered content of all history and drew heavily on poststructuralist theory to suggest in interesting ways how much of the data historians rely upon is constructed within, and generated out of, particular gendered sensibilities. Thus, she was able to claim that:

The working-class family was created within working-class political discourse, through the particular gendered conception of class evident in (though not invented by) the Chartist program.

This giving preference to discourse over structure marks the theoretical retreat from class in the 1990s, for it is not possible to hold to the premises of historical materialism and accord language, symbolism, imagery, and other acts and forms of representation this determinative capacity. Class as a structure recedes from view; class as a relationship of exploitation and contestation necessarily shrinks. Bluntly put, that is what is happening in many concentric historiographic circles.

To be sure, this is not the entire story: we are not yet to the point where we can only speak of the unmaking of particular national working classes. There are those who agree that Marxism is now at an end – such as Edward and Dorothy Thompson, I think – who nevertheless remain convinced that class at particular points in the historical record was of paramount importance in structuring events and explaining how history moved. They would not agree that Chartism was constructed, one-sidedly, out of the language of eighteenth-century resistance. Nor would Edward Thompson, who has recently published a massive study of eighteenth-century plebeian culture (Customs in Common, 1991), concede some privileged place to language over a host of other forces.

Those other forces include the ways in which the material contexts of people's lives set boundaries and limitations constraining the possibilities of everyday life. Struggle and accommodation, opposition and deference, resistance and acquiescence are made and unmade in this historically-conditioned milieu. It can not be explained, in its entirety, by recourse to a single casual factor, be it a crude economism or a fashionable idealism. That is why interpretative writings such as Stedman Jones' attempt to banish class from our understanding of the making of the Chartist mobilisations have failed to convince many labour historians. Responses to Stedman Jones have proliferated, and he has offered nothing approaching an adequate rejoinder. Whatever the suggestive significance of Stedman Jones' rethinking of Chartism, it is too narrowly conceived and researched actually to excise class as a factor of importance in the political and social upheavals of the second quarter of the nineteenth century.

As Marxism/history are proclaimed at an end in the early 1990s, then, both class as a historical experience and labour history as a particular field have come under increasing question. The political and intellectual journey of Edward and Dorothy Thompson reveals how labour history since 1950 has moved and internally recomposed itself in waves of analytic adjustment. Originally part of the Communist Party Historians Group, the Thompsons were, in their formative years, Marxists struggling to break out of the confinements of various Stalinist interpretative straightjackets. They did this remarkably well, exposing the extent to which Marxism needed to revitalise itself. They opened many Pandora's boxes. Over the course of the 1960s and 1970s, the Marxist content of those boxes got scattered in some pretty high interpretative winds: labour history was redefined and reconceptualised as the history of class formation, a project which opened out into new subject areas and pushed analysis chronologically and thematically in new directions. Under new political pressures in the 1970s and 1980s, Marxism began to exercise less and less hold over people like the Thompsons, and, correspondingly, over those drawn to their analytic premises.

By the 1980s the writing was on the wall. And, as the Wall itself came down, so too, finally, did many commitments and orientations forged in what now seemed, in the 1990s, another time. Marxism, class, often history itself – potent forces a decade or so ago – withered in the eyes of many. The problem is that while there are those, like the Thompsons, who remain sensitive to the value and contribution of historical materialism, appreciating the strength of the presence of class in the past, and thus holding forth the possibility (even if they themselves would deny this) of a renewed Marxism, there are others for whom an eclectic scepticism is now the only order of the day. In the face of the so-called end of Marxism/history, they gravitate to the new idealistic panaceas, in which all is to be understood by recourse to what is now the ultimate interpretative explanation of the hour: in the late 1970s this process was couched in Marxism and went by the name of Althusser; in the 1980s it at least paid whispered lip service to history, and spoke in the confident voice of Foucault. In the early 1990s the signposts are more uncertain. When all is said and done, however, we know there are now new prophetics and pyrotechnics in the making. They may tell us much, as have some of their predecessors. Labour historians should listen to them. But it is doubtful if there is much to be gained from believing that their subject has, like so many Latin American dissidents, disappeared.

Bryan Palmer is Professor of History at Queen's University, Ontario.