The Reformation and the Red Light
Nicholas Orme shows how Catholic and Protestant reformers alike campaigned rigorously against medieval attitudes to prostitution which were far less restrictive and oppressive than is often supposed.
Travellers crossing southwards over London Bridge in medieval or in Tudor times, left behind the busy commercial and respectable part of the capital. Once on the South Bank, they entered the notorious district of Southwark. This was the traditional location of various dissolute and disreputable activities which the City did not tolerate within its own walls. Here were the infamous prisons of the Marshalsea and the King's Bench, the bear gardens, and (later on) those houses of ill-fame, the public theatres – the rendezvous for thieves, horse- stealers, coney-catchers and contrivers of treason, as the Corporation of London described them in 1597.
Upstream from London Bridge, running along the foreshore, was the street called Bankside. Anyone scrutinising the buildings in this street would have noticed a number of whitewashed houses. They carried the usual signs by which houses were distinguished in those days – the Boar's Head, the Castle and the Cardinal's Hat – but the signs were painted on the house-fronts, not hung across the street. In these buildings were located the licensed brothels of the City of London: eighteen in number before1506, and afterwards twelve. All were closed in 1546, after an existence which went back to at least the middle of the fourteenth century and possibly to the reign of Henry II.
Until 1546 these brothels were not only tolerated but recognised and regulated by the Crown and the city fathers. Traditional rules governed their activities. The brothel keepers had to allow the women to come, and go freely, and were forbidden to charge them more than 14d. a week for their rooms. No married women, and no women with venereal disease, were allowed to prostitute themselves. They were not supposed to solicit any man who did not approach them willingly. The brothels were closed on holy days and the women banished from the area. The Elizabethan antiquary, John Stow, who recorded these customs, tells us:
I have heard ancient men of good credit report that these single women were forbidden the rites of the Church, so long as they continued that sinful life, and were excluded from Christian burial if they were not reconciled before their death. And therefore there was a plot of ground, called the single women's churchyard, appointed for them, far from the parish church.
What strikes the modern observer is the tolerance with which prostitution was regarded in medieval and early-modern times, not only in London but in dozens of other important towns throughout Europe. The authorities in these towns did not attempt, as they did later on, to harass the prostitutes and drive them off the streets. On the contrary, they sought to regulate the trade, and through this means to moderate its evils. There was a good deal in common between the regulations of the different towns. Generally speaking, brothels were forbidden to function in the central areas where the respectable inhabitants lived. Instead, they were confined to the suburbs along with the lepers and the poor. The women themselves were sometimes restricted in their perambulations, and sometimes not, but it was usual to impose some' distinctive article of dress upon them by which they could be recognised. In Bristol they were made to wear striped hoods, in Geneva red cuffs on their right sleeves, and in Toulouse arm-bands of some contrasting colour.
Sometimes the women were supervised by a warden appointed by the city council. The authorities in Brunswick gave the job to the public hangman. In Paris there was a special officer called le roi des ribauds, or 'king of the ribalds'. In Geneva the street women elected a mother-superior oft their own, la reine du bordel, or 'queen of the' brothel', the building being appropriately sited in the rue des belles filles. On assuming her office the 'queen' took an oath on the gospels before the corporation, exactly like the other city officers. She swore to rule her little community without favour or malice, according to the laws and in conformity with the city magistrates. It is a perfect example of how prostitution was harmonised with the life and laws of the medieval towns.
In their toleration of the sin the medieval town authorities were not necessarily behaving badly by medieval Christian standards. It is true that the medieval Church regarded all sexual relations outside marriage as a mortal sin. This included both adultery between married people and fornication by the unmarried. A layman who admitted fornication to his confessor incurred a stiff penance. The thirteenth-century English writer on confessions, Thomas of Chobham, suggested penance for a whole year. Chaucer's contemporary, the poet William Langland, proposed a fast every Saturday for seven years, which amounts to the same thing. People suspected of fornication or caught in flagrante delicto were liable to be summoned before the Church courts. Readers of Chaucer will remember how the Summoner scoured the countryside in search of bawdy women. The moral code of the medieval Church was therefore perfectly clear.
But the question then arose as to how the moral code should be enforced. It was in the matter of enforcement that the Church showed liberal tendencies, making a specific exception from the operation of its laws in favour ok licensed prostitutes. The Church did not approve of them, of course, but it was also conscious of human frailty. 'The carnal weakness of the present time', lamented Thomas of Chobham, 'is so prone to lust that scarcely anyone can be persuaded or even compelled to remain continent.' If the outlet of prostitution were closed, he argued, something worse might take its place.
The great thinkers and leaders of the Church took the same view. Let us consider two of the most famous by way of example. St Augustine admitted that prostitutes and brothels were evil. He urged that such women should be excluded from the benefits of the Church while they plied their trade. But, he says, if they were re moved, things would be worse – presumably meaning that there would be an upsurge of seduction and rape. Prostitution should therefore be tolerated as a necessary evil. 'If you do away with harlots, the world will be convulsed with lust.'
St Thomas Aquinas held a similar view. He classified sexual offences as worse than theft, and left his readers in no doubt about their sinful nature. At the same time, he was unwilling to rule out prostitution completely. It was, he said, to be compared with a sewer in a palace. If the sewer were removed, the palace would be filled with pollution, Likewise, if prostitution were abolished, the world would be filled with sodomy, which was far worse. Those in authority were right to tolerate lesser evils as a means of avoiding greater ones. Aquinas even justified the taking of money by prostitutes for their services, and argued that the money could be lawfully applied to other uses. We should, of course, beware of over-simplifying medieval attitudes. Examples of both clergy and laity could be mentioned who regarded prostitution with high disfavour. But the predominant attitude was that of Augustine and Aquinas: disapproval but not suppression.
Sexual intercourse outside marriage was not merely an urban phenomenon, of course; it was also a 'country matter'. But in the country- side such intercourse was casual and unorganised; only in the towns did it develop into an organised trade. And 'trade' is an apposite word, for its economic significance often rivalled that of a respectable craft or industry. We do not know much about the rates the women charged. But in 1439 a certain Margery went to the house of Joan Wakelyn in the London parish of St Katherine Colman, 'and by agreement took her to the house of a certain important Lombard, the said Joan receiving 12d. for her wicked and unlawful behaviour'. This was twice the daily wage of a skilled craftsman such as a carpenter or mason; perhaps Joan catered for a high-class clientèle.
In the brothels themselves, sex was not the only commodity for sale. Food arid wine were sold to vary and stimulate the other activities. Gambling was carried on, and naturally in such a way as to relieve the wealthy of more of their money. The women dressed extravagantly, both to enhance their charms and to display their wealth. In 1285 the corporation of London felt it necessary to forbid the common women to wear silk or miniver (the best squirrel fur). A similar intervention was made in Paris in 1446 against prostitutes who wore silver belts, turned-back collars and lengths of miniver on their dresses. These were marks of rank that in general were restricted to the aristocracy and the wealthy burgess élites.
One impact of prostitution on the medieval towns was therefore to sustain the trade in luxuries: wine, spices, jewellery and high-quality cloth. But a great many other people benefited from prostitution besides the dealers in luxury goods. Prostitutes have always been preyed on by numerous other people whose services they need, or whose exploitation they cannot resist. There are the procurers, who tout for custom or arrange the assignation:, as Margery did for Joan Wakelyn in 1439. There are the bullies who give protection from the violence and affrays which accompany organised prostitution. Then, since the women seldom run their brothels themselves, there is a class of brothel-keepers, known in Elizabethan England as bawds. These people have always taken exorbitant sums in return for accommodation.
The bawds themselves were not necessarily the outright owners of the houses they kept. In turn they rented them from landlords, who were often members of the urban elite and thereby came to have their own involvement in 'the wages of sin'. There are few medieval Londoners more famous than Sir William Walworth, the valiant fishmonger who struck down Wat Tyler with his dagger at the climax of the Peasants' Revolt in 1381. It is less well known that his interests included a house on the South Bank which he rented out to Flemish whores who catered, no doubt, for the sailors and merchants who came on business from the Netherlands. Walworth had his French counterpart in Ambroise de Loré, Baron of Juillé and Provost (or mayor) of Paris until his death in 1446, who figures in the delightful Journal of ii Citizen of Paris written in the early fifteenth century:
He always protected loose women, of whom through his laxity Paris had far too many, and got himself a bad reputation with overcome, because it was almost impossible for the law to correct the prostitutes in Paris, since he always protected them and their bawds.
It was quite common for important people to sponsor the street women and to receive, directly or indirectly, some benefits from their trade. In Toulouse the corporation and the university together controlled the 'great abbey' as the chief brothel was called. They received a large sum from the women each year which, they claimed, they applied to the general benefit of the town. In fourteenth- century Avignon the chief brothel, also called the abbey, functioned under the patronage of the Queen of Naples, lady of the town. And in 1469 when Louis XI of France approved the keeping of a brothel in Montpellier by two prominent citizens, he reserved to himself an annual levy of E5 from the premises. So when Aquinas established the lawfulness of money gained by prostitution, he was not being pedantic. He was helping to reassure the consciences of respectable people into whose possession such money might come.
In the sixteenth century attitudes towards prostitution underwent change. A possible reason for this was an outbreak of venereal disease which caused widespread alarm in western Europe. It is still not certain whether syphilis was present in medieval times but thought of as a kind of leprosy, or whether it was introduced from elsewhere during the '1490s. Syphilis was first identified as such (by contemporaries at any rate), among the French army at Naples in 1495. Its serious character, leading in some cases to madness and death, soon came to be recognised. As early as August 1495 the Emperor Maximilian issued a proclamation warning people against it, and in the following year the parlement of Paris ordered all persons infected by it to leave the city within twenty-four hours. By 1497 measures were being taken against it in places as far apart as Nuremberg and Aberdeen.
Exactly when syphilis was traced to venereal contact seems to be unclear. It may have been traced as early as the 1490s, and the connection was certainly well established by the second half of the sixteenth century. There is no doubt that, since the link was made, syphilis has helped to sway public opinion against prostitution throughout western Europe. At the same time, the fear of syphilis does not appear to have been primarily responsible for changing the medieval attitude of toleration towards licensed prostitution. The general closure of licensed brothels, which took place in sixteenth-century Europe, seems to have had no direct relationship with the spread of the disease or views about it. Sanitary motives are not uppermost in the official pronouncements which ordered the brothels to close. The major force behind their closure was the Reformation.
It is easy to study the Reformation superficially and to assume that it was merely concerned with the clergy and with what went on in church. Historians concentrate their attention on the reinterpretation of theology, the reorganisation of worship, the suppression of monasticism, and the seizure of Church property. Yet the best short definition of the Reformation is probably 'a movement which set out to make society more godly as a whole'. The measures against the clergy were primarily intended to make them more efficient ministers to the souls of the laity. And the changes in worship were meant to increase the faith of the laity: to enable them better to worship God and understand their Christian duties.
As a result, all reformers – Anglicans, Calvinists, Lutherans and Catholics alike – gave a great deal of their attention to the improvement of morality. They sought to bring society nearer to Christian perfection, not merely on Sundays in church but during the week as a whole. There was little difference between Protestants and Catholics after the 1530s in their reformist attitude to ethics. The mural code of the sixteenth-century reformers was not essentially a new one. It was the timeless Christian moral code which had been preached throughout the Middle Ages. The difference in the sixteenth century was the greater zeal of the reformers to make it work. They were determined not to tolerate or to compromise. Like modern radicals they wanted to 'smash' sin and superstition immediately and completely.
No institution was a more obvious target for the moral reformers than the legalised prostitution of the cities. The opening shots in the action were fired by Luther as early as 1520 in his Address to the German Mobility – the first of the great treatises in which he expounded the Protestant point of View:
Is it not a terrible thing [he asks] that we Christians should maintain public brothels, though we all vow chastity in our baptism? I know well all that can be said on this matter, that it is not peculiar to one nation, that it would be difficult to alter, and that it is better thus than that virgins or married women or honourable women should be dishonoured. But should not the spiritual and temporal powers combine to find some means of meeting these difficulties without any such heathen practice? If the people of Israel existed without this scandal, why should not a Christian nation be able to do so? How do so many towns and villages manage to exist without these houses? Why should not great cities be able to do so?
From the very first, therefore, Protestantism set its fare against prostitution. As a result, the diffusion of the Protestant Reformation across Germany was usually accompanied by the closure of the brothels – though there were exceptions. In Nuremberg they survived until 1562. Prostitutes had always been liable to whipping and imprisonment if they failed to obey the regulations on residence and soliciting. Now these penalties were applied in general. A good example of this can be seen at Geneva. The city brothel was shut down when the municipal government agreed to introduce the Reformation in the 1530s. Thereafter convicted prostitutes were put into prison and made to stand in the pillory.
Nor were the prostitutes the only ones to suffer. The German reformers, led by Calvin, set out to suppress all sexual relations outside marriage. Fornication between unmarried people was punished with imprisonment on bread and water for three days and a fine of sixty sous. As attitudes towards sexual deviations became more intolerant, so the penalty increased. In 1546 it became six days imprisonment and five florins, and after Calvin's death in 1564, nine days and a fine at the pleasure of the city council. Adultery between married people was also punished with prison and a fine, with shipping and banishment for serious or habitual offenders. In 1556 Calvin proposed that adultery should carry the death penalty. This was based on the Jewish law laid down in Deuteronomy chapter 22. 'If a man be found lying with a woman married to a husband, they shall both of them die.' The city council would not consent to this, but in 1560 it did execute two male adulterers notorious for their evil lives.
Parallel changes of attitude can be seen in England, where the licensed brothels in London were closed by Henry VIII in 1546. The royal proclamation on the subject denounces:
...toleration of such dissolute and mis-erable persons as, putting away the fear of Almighty God and the shame of the world, have been suffered to dwell beside London and elsewhere, in common open places called the stews, and there without punishment or correction to exercise their abominable and detestable sin.
There is no evidence that Henry himself had syphilis, and the arguments here are entirely moral and religious rather than medical or sanitary. The bawds who had run the houses and the women who had traded in them were ordered to leave immediately, bag and baggage, and return to their original homes. And the owners of the houses were forbidden to lease them out to anyone else without leave of the King's council.
Of course prostitution survived in Tudor or Stuart London, but under harassment. Convicted prostitutes were whipped and imprisoned, and suspect houses were damaged by the authorities or pulled down. The scene at the end of Shakespeare's Henry IV Part II, when Henry V begins his new order by cleaning the whores out of Cheapside, is an interesting reflection of the change of attitudes. To an Elizabethan writer, prostitution seemed an obvious target for a reformist king; the original Henry V probably never bothered about it.
The Catholic reformers held similar views of morals to their Protestant opponents. In1537 the papal commission of leading churchmen issued its famous report on the Church to Pope Paul III: the Consilium de Emendanda Ecclesia. Predictably, they included among the list of abuses the toleration of prostitution. In Rome, they alleged, loose women walked or rode about the streets as if they were respectable matrons, closely pursued by clerics and members of the cardinals' households. The same point of view was expressed later on in the Council of Trent. The concilar decree on marriage in the twenty-fourth session, in 1563, sought resolutely to stamp out extra-marital sex. 'It is a grievous sin', says the decree, 'for unmarried men to have mistresses. But it is a most grievous sin... for married men also to live in this state of damnation, and to have the audacity to maintain them and keep them, even at home with their own wives.' Women, married or single, who lived in sin were to be warned three times. If they failed to heed these warnings, they were to be rigorously punished. The council specifically mentioned banishment as one of the penalties, just as it was in Geneva.
Simultaneously with this decree, prostitution began to come under pressure in the great cities of Catholic Europe. In Paris the licensed brothels were closed in 1561 by the regency government of the young King Charles IX. In Rome there had already been a perceptible change of attitudes during the short reign of the reformist pope, Marcellus II, in 1555. He ordered the prostitutes to be driven out of the main part of the city and confined in the suburb beyond the Tiber. When Pius V became pope in 1566, he determined to stamp out prostitution altogether. Appropriately he went into action on the feast of St Mary Magdalene, herself a repentant lady of sin. On July 22nd, 1566, he published an edict expelling all prostitutes from the city, to the consternation not only of the underworld but of the social élite itself.
The city council sent a deputation of forty citizens to remonstrate with the pope. The edict would cause a grave economic recession. It would lead to the depopulation of the city, to a slump in the import of luxury goods, to the bankruptcy of respectable tradesmen. The diplomatic corps was troubled, and the ambassadors of Spain, Portugal and Florence added their protests. The pope refused to give way, but in practice he did so a little. Most of the street women were driven from the city. The rest were herded into a segregated area, from which the women were forbidden to leave on pain of whipping and banishment. With the prostitutes out of sight, the pope turned his attention to married life. In 1568 Rome was convulsed by rumours that Pius was planning to introduce the death penalty for adultery. 'Everyone will have to become moral', groaned a contemporary, 'or leave the city.'
In the event, the pope allowed himself to be dissuaded from so drastic a course. He contented himself by punishing adulterers merely with whip- ping, imprisonment and expulsion. This regime lasted until 1586, by which time Pius had been replaced by an even more austere reformer, Sixtus V. In 1586 Sixtus took the field where Pius had drawn back, and introduced the death penalty for adultery and all unnatural vices. Rome was not such an easy city to control as Geneva; the results were not so spectacular. But in their aims and their efforts, the popes of the Counter-Reformation conceded nothing to Calvin at all.
The study of prostitution thus reveals a difference of attitudes which distinguished the later Middle Ages from the Reformation. Throughout the period under discussion, from 1200 to 1600, the code of morals in force was a Christian one. But its interpretation and the way in which it was enforced changed greatly during the sixteenth century. The reformers tried rigorously to impose the moral code on everyone; the medieval clergy hesitated to go so far. Much the same'. was true in other spheres. The reformers set out to obliterate witchcraft, to regulate schools and to censor all books. Some of these matters had never been bothered with before; others, only half-heartedly or only in certain localities. The medieval Church was not nearly so restrictive and oppressive as people today often suppose, and modern liberal churchmen who call for tolerance and understanding are often closer in spirit to the Middle Ages than they are to the Reformation.

