'Real History' Revives Argentina's Indians
Aidan Rankin examines the struggle of the Wichí Indians of North Argentina who fight back against discrimination in their daily lives.
The Wichí Indians of north Argentina and south-east Bolivia lived there for thousands of years before those countries were named. Throughout this century, they have been dispossessed by non-Indian settlers known as criollos and have seen their lands (which are fertile, when carefully managed) reduced to an inhospitable dust bowl. But now, taking advantage of Argentina's democratic opening, the Wichí are fighting back against the discrimination they experience in their daily lives. They have on several occasions successfully confronted the government of Salta province (where most of them live) and last summer a Wichí representative went to Geneva to address the United Nations Commission on Human Rights.
With the help of 'Survival International, the human rights organisation campaigning for tribal peoples, they have constructed a map of their entire territory and put into writing the rich oral history which reinforces their land claim. This project, whereby a crucial cultural tradition – that of oral communication of a people's history – has come to be written down, has a profound significance for the cause of indigenous peoples' land rights throughout the world.
There are now approximately 40,000 Wichí Before the arrival of the criollos, their society was organised into village communities divided into clans. There was little or no concept of private property and the Wichí were therefore entirely unprepared for criollo notions of ownership which led the settlers to enclose large areas of Indian land.
The Wichí live in a semi-arid region known as the Chaco, part of which is situated in the northern Argentine province of Salta. In the dry winter months they depend on fish from the Pilcomayo River that runs through their territory. They catch over eighteen different species of fish; the commonest are afwukna (catfish), atsá (a kind of salmon) and sichús (white shad) . During the wet summers, they cultivate corn, watermelons, beans and pumpkins and throughout the year they hunt armadillo, deer, peccary and iguana. Their region is also noted for its many varieties of wild honey.
But in the twentieth century this way of life has been systematically destroyed. Well-armed settlers, seeing the lndian land as ideal ranching territory, have upset a fragile ecosystem. Where there were once rich grasslands, dotted with bushes and trees, there is now a virtual desert. In this alien terrain, most of the animals the Indians used to hunt have died out. As the Wichí say. 'Our land is dead, and we are dying of hunger'.
The pain of occupation has been compounded by violence. To protect the areas they have fenced off from their rightful owners, the incoming criollos have resorted to acts of casual cruelty. In the early twentieth century, these were interspersed with bouts of extreme repression in which hundreds of Indians were killed. It is no small wonder that the Wichí call the colonists 'ahatai', which, according to their oral history, 'is like our words for "spirit of the dead" and "the devil".'
Not surprisingly, the most vicious attacks on the Wichí, during the 1920s and 1930s, coincided with a particularly violent and troubled period of Argentine history. The introduction of universal male suffrage under the Saenz Pena law of 1911 and the election of a Radical president, Hippólito Yrigoyen, five years later raised hopes of rapid and far-reaching social reform. But against a background of inept leadership, political corruption and the growth of a reactionary- nationalism, this optimistic spirit soon turned sour in 1930, a 'golpe de estado' (coup d' état) led by the German.-trained General José Uriburu began a cycle of military interventions in Argentine politics that culminated in the 'Dirty War' against left-wing dissidents in the 19'70s and General Galtieri's South Atlantic adventure of 1982. In the Yrigoyen era, savage labour disputes erupted in Buenos Aires as a largely immigrant working-class demanded economic justice and a share in the new nation's great wealth. In January 1919, 700 workers were killed and 4,000 injured in what came to be known as the semana trágica (tragic week). Similar events took place in Patagonia as the government sided with land-owners and industrialists. The oppression of the Wichí was therefore part of a pattern of repression and political disintegration in a society to which they had never asked to belong.
Today, the Wichí are determined that the regional and national authorities recognise their land claim. They are aided by a powerful tradition of oral history, the 'real history' as they call it, which records in faithful detail the colonisation of Thaka Honut (Our Land):
The ahatai have always coveted Thaka Honat, and they have used deceit and violence in order to take it from us ... They didn't plant the trees; they don't keep the bees; the wild animals and fish don't belong to them.... We have always lived here, since the time of creation – we are as much a part of Thaka Honat as the trees that grow on it. Our land belongs to us because we belong to the land
Over the years, the Wichí have used their oral tradition to chronicle the gradual takeover of their land by outsiders armed with false promises backed up by force: Some said they had come. to buy igunna skins and they would go at the end of the season. But soon they set up trading stores and stayed – without mentioning it to us, as though we didn't. exist ... One colonist even threatened us with war. 'Indians, what will you do without weapons if we make war on you?' he asked.
As a non-literate culture, the Wichí have a long and very precise historical memory and a strong sense of place. Recently they have become aware of the advantage this gives them in pressing for the return of their land. In 1987, when the governor of Salta province recognised the settlers' right to the land they had taken and made only trifling concessions to the Indians, the Wichí decided to contact Survival International. together with two anthropologists associated with Survival, they began a project intended to prove conclusively that the criollos are living on stolen land. To do this, the Wichí people worked out a four-pronged strategy: to carry out a census of all the Indians in the region, to make a map of even- village, to record and put in writing the long oral history of Thaka Honat and to construct a large map of the entire region, showing all the places they had ever used and named.
The Survival team spent six months working among the Wichí, who participated in every aspect of the work. They found that the oral history was crucial to the construction of the map, which contained over 1,000 place-names throughout the 400,000 hectares of the contested area. It gives a clear picture of the ancient nature of their residence, and of-their profound knowledge and understanding of the land. The names identify the past and present villages of the Wichí, their hunting, fishing and gathering grounds, gardens, water-sources and places of' religious or cultural significance. Some of the names are tragic or comic reminders of past events. 'Dog's Sighting’ is where thirsty Wichí were led to water by their hunting dogs, 'Sun Dies' where some Wichí who were encamped during a hunting expedition saw an eclipse of the sun, but 'Gun Is Fired' is the place where the shots of the ahatai were first heard and 'Dead Children' where a settler tried to hide the bodies of two Wichí children he had killed.
A problem with the 'real history' has been the lack of a precise chronology of the kind that Westerners understand. Expressions like 'long ago' or 'in the very recent past' take the place of months and years, and no dates attach to the place names listed above. However, the Survival team found that genealogical time was as reliable as conventional dates. Most Wichí historical accounts are prefaced with such indicators as 'in my grandfather's time' or 'my great aunt told me'. There is a strong continuity in the oral tradition that: can cross generations, clans and communities. This way, the Wichí have maintained a collective memory that is much more reliable than the 'official' version of Argentine history.
In August 1991, the report and map were formally presented to the governor of Salta. Later that year, he signed a decree recognising the Wichí's ownership of 400,000 hectares of land and confirming that they should be awarded a single, communal title to the entire area. However, he left office hours later following mid-term elections. The Wichí still have not received title to their land, but the 1991 decree implicitly recognises the validity of the map and the accuracy of Wichí history. If implemented, it would mean that the Wichí would be the legal owners and custodians of their land. Although they do not seek to expel all the criollos from their land, the Indians intend to halt the destructive cattle ranching and to restore the Chaco to its previous ecological balance.
The experience of campaigning has given the Wichí Indians a new political confidence. They have now formed their own organisation called, appropriately, Thaka Honat, through which members of the Indian communities can meet with officials at all levels of' government. In 1994, a Wichí Indian made the trip to Geneva to put his people's case before the United Nations Commission on Human Rights. Like other indigenous peoples, such as the Innu of Canada, Australia's Aborigines and the Yanomami of Brazil, Argentina's long-forgotten Indians have now acquired a political voice. This year, with President Carlos Menem facing re-election, they are especially determined that their demands he listened to at home and abroad.
In spite of their prolonged sufferings and countless letters to the authorities which have gone unanswered, the shy soft-spoken Wichí have retained an optimistic faith in natural justice. They are rightly proud of their history, and believe that soon their attachment to the land that they know so well will be recognised and honoured. When that happens, the Indians of the Chaco will be able to start rebuilding their devastated communities. Meanwhile, the case the Wichi are putting to the world is simple and logical enough:
Thaka Honat does not belong to the ahatai, and it would he wrong for them to own it, because it is the home of our ancestors, who lived here for centuries before any ahatai arrived.

