Raiders of the Lost Art
Jonathan Conlin considers the history of heritage panics, from relics to Raphaels.
A new mixed-media installation is currently on show at the National Gallery, consisting of a perspex box, three display panels and a small early sixteenth-century Italian painting of the Madonna and Child. Entitled ‘Save the Raphael’, this thought-provoking piece demonstrates that interactive displays are no longer the preserve of the Science Museum. The routine is straightforward: first look at the painting, then read the panels, drop money into the box and depart endowed with the warm glow that comes from helping to save part of our nation’s heritage.
The juxtaposition of masterpiece and begging bowl will, it is hoped, ensure that Raphael’s Madonna of the Pinks remains in the National Gallery, by raising the £29 million required to trump the Getty Museum. Although the sale has already been negotiated with the painter’s owner, the 8th Duke of Northumberland, the Gallery has secured a temporary export ban until August 27th, buying time to mount the current appeal. The campaign has attracted a good deal of media attention, much of it lavished on the accusations flung back and forth between the Gallery and the Duke. Such invective has done little, however, to overcome a mood of ‘rescue fatigue’.
Suffering under the handicap of being Italian (and therefore less ‘national’), the Madonna of the Pinks also has the misfortune to be sold at a time when the government body charged with preserving our heritage, the National Heritage Lottery Fund, has shifted its priorities away from high-stake, high-art, London-centred appeals. In response both to falling Lottery revenues and accusations that its past grants have given too much to ‘elitist’ London culture, the Fund’s current strategic plan emphasises smaller projects that engage broader ‘publics’ at grass-roots level. Making the case for spending 10 per cent of the Fund’s budget on buying one small foreign painting for a London gallery is going to be difficult.
Since the 1880s campaigns to save paintings ‘for the nation’ have occurred with a depressing frequency, with many of the same impassioned arguments being wheeled out time after time. In the early days the evil despoilers assaulting our heritage were German museums. American plutocrats like Henry Clay Frick and the museums they so richly endowed, however, soon replaced them as cultural bogeymen. Over more than a century the National Gallery acquired a number of its finest works after such public appeals: from Velazquez’ Rokeby Venus (1906) and Holbein’s Duchess of Milan (1909), right up to Stubbs’ Whistlejacket (1997). The National Art Collections Fund, now in its centenary year, led many of these campaigns. All these paintings had been in the collections of British aristocrats, but went to the auctioneer’s block when cheap Canadian wheat, Harcourt’s Death Duties (1894) and twentieth-century ‘supertaxes’ led them to sell the artworks which were often their only liquid assets. Although many paintings were ‘lost’ in this way, the success of such appeals invites us to consider how such ‘foreign’ objects were repackaged as the heritage of a single national community – despite evidence that class and devolutionary pressures were causing that nation to fragment.
When asked what other public space most resembled an art museum, most respondents to a British survey taken in the 1980s opted for ‘church’ or ‘house of the dead’. The juxtaposition of Madonna and money box in the National Gallery heightens this religious aura, redolent as it is of those boxes for ex voto donations placed alongside images of the Madonna in Roman Catholic churches. This parallel reminds us of how the cult of Old Masters like Raphael is just one manifestation of an innately human hunger for objects that mediate a creative persona. Perhaps, therefore, we should not be surprised that the first forms of cultural heritage to inspire ‘heritage panic’ were relics: body parts or other objects associated with Christian martyrs or saints, usually housed in ornate reliquaries that we now venerate in art museums.
Between the ninth and eleventh centuries the Benedictines and other monastic orders expanded across Europe. Relics became a vital source of identity to monasteries and the new lay communities which formed around them; they were the concrete evidence of a compact between those people and ‘their’ saint. Their presence proclaimed that saint’s blessing on the community, protecting them from disease, invasion and famine. At the very least, they attracted donations from local notables. But with some careful marketing – tours of surrounding villages, temporary exhibition at major trade fairs, writing of a new Vita of the relevant saint – relics could tap an apparently limitless revenue stream: pilgrims. The trouble was how to get hold of them. Relic thefts (furta sacra) helped redistribute relics over a broad area, and thieves often claimed that they acted in order to move saintly remains to new locales that would pay them greater respect. But to the dispossessed their ‘translation’ out of the community meant serious financial and cultural loss – and as such was fiercely resisted.
The first recorded loss of English heritage occurred in 1058, when the Flemish monk Balgerus stole relics of Saint Lewinna from Sussex. When the locals refused to sell him her body, he tried stealing it, but was thwarted by the Saint’s miraculous intervention. Nevertheless fervent prayer allowed him to overcome this export ban. As there is no mention of Saint Lewinna in any English source, she may well have been invented. Real or not, however, the wonder-working tour of western Flanders on which the monks immediately sent their new relics certainly helped raise funds for their new abbatial church, built in a place they dubbed Bergues-Saint-Winnoc. The relics thus gave the town its name – quite literally, they put the town on the map, much as museums of European art served to lend American cities in the twentieth century a cultural cachet.
It would be impossible to explain the limits of the current Madonna of the Pinks debate without considering such precedents, and in particular our fascination for the ‘aura’ of the original painting. One contributor to a BBC phone-in recommended that a copy be made of the Madonna, and the £29m spent on better schools and hospitals. The fact is that, with today’s technology, we could produce a copy that would be totally indistinguishable to the naked eye. Yet nobody takes this idea seriously: we want to see the very wood and paint which the wondrously talented Raphael touched. We may sneer at those who revered medieval reliquaries. But are we so very different?
The great European art museums established in the early nineteenth century arranged paintings in what seemed to be a decidedly secular ‘visual history of art’. In displaying art heritage that had earlier been looted by French armies, however, museums commemorated military victories, thus becoming shrines to the new nationalisms forged in the Napoleonic Wars. Such a national discourse had appeared in Britain much earlier – in the 1770s – when the Houghton Collection, a collection of Old Master paintings originally formed by Britain’s first Prime Minister Robert Walpole, was sold to Catherine the Great of Russia by Walpole’s impecunious heirs. Its loss at a time when Britain was fighting both France and its American colonies was felt to indicate declining national fortunes. ‘Russia is sacking our palaces and museums,’ Josiah Wedgwood despaired, ‘France and Spain are conquering our outposts, and braving us to our very doors at home.’
This was the first time that the export of Old Master paintings had been perceived in national terms. The fabulously rich collection formed by Charles I in the previous century, for instance, had been sold off by Cromwell without raising much fuss. After the Restoration those few masterpieces that remained, however, especially the Raphael Cartoons, were soon attracting tourists like Celia Fiennes to Hampton Court. By the latter half of the eighteenth century they enjoyed a national reputation, and were appreciated as national heritage. This was made painfully obvious to George III when he moved the Cartoons to his new private quarters at Buckingham House.
In a speech delivered on April 28th, 1777, the radical politician John Wilkes criticised George III’s removal of the Cartoons from public view and urged the government to prevent the dispersal of the Houghton Collection by buying it for display to the nation in the British Museum. Wilkes described such art as ‘an invaluable national treasure’, ‘a common blessing’ – everything but the private property of a King. Contemporaries were surprised to find Wilkes making the case for the nation’s art heritage. After all, he was better known as a king-baiting journalist and demagogic franchise reformer than as a connoisseur. Yet his speech merely represented the translation of his libertarian political views into a new theatre of political action. He was encouraging the middle-class, extra-parliamentary nation to participate in activities (art-viewing and art-stewardship) from which they had previously been excluded by kings and a noble elite who had been tried as heritage stewards – and found wanting.
On the one hand, Wilkes was ‘saving’ an older heritage from George III’s usurpation in treating the Cartoons as his own property. On the other, he was urging parliament to ‘save’ the Houghton Collection as part of a broader scheme of state (not royal) support for the visual arts – something very new indeed. Heritage seemed to move by conservative impulse, but the bandwagon was really a Trojan horse. This was equally true of the 1885 campaign to save another Raphael Madonna when another Duke (of Marlborough) put it on the market. Although Gladstone could claim cross-party parliamentary support for his approval of the record-breaking £70,000 purchase, Irish nationalist MPs like William Redmond refused to accept that displaying such art in the National Gallery implied saving it ‘for the nation’. As Redmond pointed out, the acquisition had been at the cost of all taxpayers, including those living in Ireland and the north of England who were either uninterested or unable to see it.
The establishment of National Galleries in Edinburgh (1850) and Dublin (1854), as well as of East End ‘slum museums’ in the 1880s, implicitly questioned the London Gallery’s claim to preserve the nation’s art heritage in a single, central facility accessible to all classes. The early Victorian belief that London collections ‘virtually represented’ all Britons was under strain at the very time when the Third Reform Act and Irish Home Rulers were threatening the integrity of the nation and the Whig political consensus: what David Cannadine has called ‘government of the people, for the people, by a patrician class’.
Whereas Redmond wanted the Marlborough Madonna to be taken on tour, so as to allow non-Londoners to see ‘their’ art, some have suggested that, if it is saved, the Northumberland Madonna should be permanently shown in a local museum, as part of the Northumbrian national heritage. Among English regions, the north-east is the most keen to have a regional assembly, a drive for devolution whose heritage aspect is seen in the ongoing campaign to return the eighth-century Lindisfarne Gospels from ‘exile’ in the British Library. The Madonna of the Pinks’ home in this sense is Alnwick, the castle of the Dukes of Northumberland, where it hung in obscurity from 1856 to 1992 (when it was loaned to the National Gallery). Ironically, the current Duke has justified selling the painting at the highest possible price by claiming that the proceeds would save ‘a broader heritage’ for Northumbria, namely his castle.
As a home for the nation’s Old Master heritage, country houses have often got the better of museums. Mid- nineteenth-century followers of Ruskin and – more recently – of Foucault have lambasted museums for being clinical and didactic, ripping art out of its true context in order to display its bleeding carcass: part historical specimen, part imperialist trophy. Overstuffed museums were best left to dirigiste, ‘tax’n’spend’ Continental regimes. Though better than ours, their museums could fortunately be derided as a plot to divert citizens who might otherwise notice how much they missed those age-old traditions of voluntaryism, laissez-faire and parliamentary liberty we Britons cherished as our birthright.
By a sort of rhetorical sleight-of-hand, suggesting minds at work more powerful than those of the aristocrats themselves, country houses have become our national ‘treasure houses’, so much so that museums like the National Gallery feel it necessary to tap all the reserves of knee-jerk patriotism they can unleash in order to save masterpieces. This country house cult first blossomed in the 1830s and 1840s, when houses like Knole served as shrines for pilgrims seeking a vaguely Jacobethan ‘Olden Time’, perceived as an age of classless revelry and gentle paternalism in the manorial hall. After about 1860, however, and especially as declining wealth and growing franchise reform forced their retreat from local and national political leadership, owners of such houses became less hospitable.
An 1894 survey into the effects of declining land rents on aristocratic generosity in granting public access to their houses found the 5th Duke of Northumberland less eager than the 8th to play the heritage card. ‘The owners of all these places act as if they were trustees for the public,’ wrote an observer of Alnwick and Northumbrian houses, ‘but whether they consider themselves as such is another question.’ If aristocrats were aware of this trustee role, they did little to embrace it before 1960. Earl de la Warr spoke for his class when, in 1880, he opposed the toothless Ancient Monuments Bill as the thin end of a wedge of government invasion of property rights. As far as he was concerned the owner of a monument ‘was much in the same position as the owner of a picture by an old master’: once government began meddling, ‘an owner would have to deal with his property as if he were a sort of trustee of it.’
From the Conservative Stafford Northcote to Labour’s Stafford Cripps, Chancellors were equally chary of interfering with the free market in order to protect masterpieces from sale abroad. Cripps’ response to the National Land Fund, brainchild of his predecessor Hugh Dalton, was muted. Established in 1946 to assist state or National Trust acquisition of country houses and their art treasures, this fund failed to realise its objectives – until the loss of Mentmore and other collections in the 1970s led to its relaunching as the National Heritage Memorial Fund in 1980. Even when such state funding and tax breaks for landed estates worked, paintings could seem an expendable part of the package, as art sales by the Duke of Devonshire from the 1960s on made clear.
The social constituency of ‘threatened’ heritage objects may have become broader since Wilkes’ day. More recently, however, their geographical constituency has narrowed. Instead of a single national heritage we seem to want the right to choose between multiple regional heritages, some of which celebrate their ‘foreignness’, rather than seeking assimilation. The Madonna of the Pinks collection box may invite greater public participation in heritage rescue, and could be extended to provide the public with an element of choice: whether to save the Raphael, say, or Joshua Reynolds’ Omai, which the Tate had until recently been trying to save from export. But we may wish to dispose of the rhetoric of ‘national defence’ which has characterised heritage panics for so long.
Although we may balk at the price tag, we still cherish the belief that art heritage has a classless appeal. A distaste for meddling in free trade in art remains strong, as does our desire for visual contact with an original. Most significantly, heritage remains something defined by the risk of imminent loss. If some see that as literally pathetic, a closer look at the long history of heritage makes it clear that rescue always involves making something new out of old objects, changing the way we define the community whose heritage is preserved.
The trouble with the Madonna of the Pinks campaign is not that it employs a rhetoric underpinned by some irrational assumptions. These lie at the root of all heritage. The problem is that the assumptions being made in this case may no longer be ones today’s government, or public, are prepared to make.
- Jonathan Conlin is a Fellow of Sidney Sussex College, Cambridge. He is currently writing a history of the National Gallery.

