The Prince and the Mahatma

Noel Carrington recalls how he was a Witness to the Past, as the Prince of Wales toured India in 1921.

It is sixty years since. Edward, Prince of Wales, set out on a tour of India – a tour more extended than that undertaken by his great-nephew Prince Charles, and of course of far greater political significance, for was he not heir to the throne of a monarch who enjoyed the title of Emperor of India? Circumstances were such that equal importance was attached to its success by the British Government in Whitehall and by the Government of India in Delhi: and still more, as I propose to show, by the British community in India at the time. The utter failure of these expectations resulted in. disillusionment and bitterness from which I think Anglo-Indian relations never really recovered.

I had gone to India in 1919, just a year after the Armistice, fresh from Oxford and war service. I went in no official capacity; only as an assistant of my university press which had established educational outposts in that country. I was in fact what was termed a 'boxwallah', though I did enjoy friendly relations with many officials, missionaries and later with Indian intellectuals. I had little enough previous knowledge of India beyond what a student of English history or a reader of Kipling would acquire, but by accident in the spring of that year I had found myself on a voyage to Spain in company with Lionel Curtis, Fellow of All Souls and editor of The Round Table . Curtis, for lack of other audience, gave me a continuous tutorial on his pet subject: a plan to transform the British Empire into a Commonwealth of free nations owing allegiance to the Crown. His scheme for India, under the name of Dyarchy, had, so I gathered, been accepted by the India Office as the basis of a new constitution. He was now, in company with Geoffrey Dawson of The Times , on the way to our smallest colony, Gibraltar, to fit it out with something similar, surely a holiday task in comparison. Like most of my generation I was an adherent of The League of Nations and Curtis showed me how snugly his Commonwealth would fit in. Before we parted on the quay at Gibraltar he assured me that anyone making his career in India would participate in one of the greatest experiences in history.

It happened that in the autumn of the same year, on my sea voyage to India, I was treated to a further seminar by several Indian delegates returning from a conference in London. They seemed almost enthusiastic about this new constitution which Montagu, the Secretary of State, had persuaded the Government to bestow on India. It was a complicated form of power-sharing democracy, which I soon found was regarded by the civil servants with resignation and by the business community with ridicule. 'So many talking shops! ' they scoffed. Of my Indian mentors one, Surendrenath Hanerjee, a grand old man of the Nationalist movement, was soon to become a minister in Bengal and to be knighted – also of course to be nicknamed 'Sir Surrender' by the irreconcilables.

Thus primed when I settled in Bombay, I anticipated that these Montford Reforms (as they were dubbed after Montagu and Chelmsford, the Viceroy) would be the main subject for discussion with the press and in Anglo-Indian society. Far from it. They were being swept from headlines and conversation by the daily reports of the Hunter Commission. This was a judicial body set up by Montagu to enquire into the Punjab Disorders (as they were officially termed) which had broken out earlier in the year, in fact at the very time when Lionel Curtis was blithely enlightening me on India's future.

Now the evidence elicited from Indians, British civilians and Army officers was indeed of a shocking character and it was surprising, at least to those who had not been in India, how little it had been known at the time; both how violent and dangerous the rebellion had been and how bloody its repression. The fact was the government in Simla, caught off balance, had been guilty of something like a 'cover up', playing down both the danger and the casualties involved. It is understandable that England, preoccupied with peace terms, revolutions in Europe and problems of demobilisation at home, gave only half an ear to what was happening in India. Even on the voyage out it had hardly ever been mentioned. Now the daily reports in the Indian press, as they were being relayed to London, came as all the greater shock both to Parliament and the press at home. It was not just General Dyer's almost boastful justification of his shooting at Amritsar (what came to be known in Indian history as the Massacre of Jallianwala Bagh, comparable with St. Bartholomew's); it was the prolonged bullying of the civilian population by Army officers for months after the rising had been suppressed that aroused most public indignation. Even Churchill, staunch friend of our Imperial mission, was moved to term it 'un-English frightfulness'. In India Rabindranath Tagore returned his knighthood to the King and the Nehrus moved to join hands with Gandhi.

The British community in India, usually indifferent to English opinion, was mortified to feel itself' traduced and vilified by its own kith and kin. Had people at home not realised what those in India had gone through in anxiety when city after city rose to riot, loot and murder, evoking memory of the Mutiny, no less? Feelings ran very high. As a newcomer I was advised to keep my mouth shut, though I found that even silence could be interpreted as defection. While I knew that many senior officials had no sympathy with Dyerism, the British community watchword was 'Time to close ranks'. Throughout the next year this bitterness rankled deep. When Dyer himself was mildly censured in the Enquiry Report and relegated to service out of the country, the British in India reacted by opening subscriptions in clubs and press to recompense for his disgrace the man who had been acclaimed as the 'Saviour of the Raj'. So much, said Indians, for the boasted even-handed Justice of Britain!

Such was the atmosphere when towards the end of 1920 it was announced that the Prince Wales would make a tour of India during the cold weather of the next year. This news produced the profoundest sense of relief amongst the British who took it as a pledge that they were not any longer to be spurned and forsaken, and that India was still the jewel in the Imperial Crown. Remembering from Bible-reading days the Parable of the Wicked Husbandmen, I had my reservations, but the old hands assured me, 'It'll change everything. Indians can't resist Royalty. They all love a Tamasha .'

Yet in fact the Prince's tour was something of a gamble. In the aftermath of Amritsar, at the annual general Congress held in the same city, Gandhi had swept into leadership, displacing the veteran Tilak and putting the Moderates of the old guard into retreat. Government was now counting on the Prince's presence – Prince Charming as he was often called – to renew: those ties of loyalty which Indians were believed to feel for the Royal Family. Of equal importance he was to give the new constitution a chance of getting off to a good start. Many of the older political leaders were ready to give it a guarded welcome, as I had gathered from Indian delegates during the voyage out, but Gandhi had carried Congress with him to pledge its allegiance to 'Non-Co-operation'.

Lord Reading, the new Viceroy, eager for reconciliation at every level, was particularly anxious that the Prince's visit should be a success. Relying on his skill as a negotiator he invited Gandhi to a conference at Simla, hoping that by the offer of various concessions the Indian leader could be persuaded to call off, at least for the period of the royal visit, the threat of civil disobedience. Gandhi would concede nothing. He could feel, he said, no real change of heart. For the Prince himself he held no feelings of enmity, but how, as representative of a tyrannous and cruel regime, could he be welcomed by the people of India? The very day that the Prince was due to land at Bombay was chosen by Gandhi for the launching of Civil Disobedience.

The Prince of Wales' message to the people of India on his arrival was: 'I want to know you: I want you to know me'. There was to be little chance of either. At Bombay, as between those who answered the call for a general strike and those who wanted to greet the Prince, there were savage conflicts and riots. The police had to open fire, resulting in many deaths. At this lapse from his creed of non-violence, Gandhi himself was in despair. He fasted, called off civil disobedience and declared that 'the Swaraj I have witnessed during the last two days has stunk in my nostrils'.

To Government it was inconceivable that the tour should not proceed according to schedule. It doubled its security measures and clapped many leading nationalists into jail – including Nehru – but not Gandhi himself at this stage. General strikes and riots, however, occurred in most of the cities visited. Only at the palaces of the Maharajahs could the Prince be sure of a peaceful welcome. Indeed his most successful day was the opening of the Chamber of Princes at Delhi, a body which was already an anachronism, though much was expected of it as a counterpoise to Congress.

Traditionally on such tours the climax had been Christmas week at Calcutta when the festivities of the cold weather 'season' were always at their height. The Prince was to open the great Victoria Memorial Hall at one end of the Maidan, or Calcutta's Hyde Park, while at Government House there would be garden parties, dinners and parades. I was by now living in Calcutta and was summoned to a parade of ex-soldiers. Of this I retain a vivid memory: the Prince moving in a kind of trance, flanked by aides bearing trays of medals, as he dutifully carried the burden of his overloaded programme. And I knew that the greater part of Calcutta was a dead city; the bazaars shuttered up and the people gripped by fear of riots and looting.

I am tempted to recall an incident of a lighter nature which caused a minor scandal in a society so closely governed by protocol. The culminating event for the mem-sahibs and miss-sahibs was the great Ball at Government House. Families of officials were of course assured of their place in the hierarchy, but for those in commerce there had been intensive lobbying for the gilded invitation cards. And still more to be chosen as a partner for the Prince. Alas for the anticipations of those ladies selected for this supreme honour! After one obligatory turn with Her Excellency, the Prince had spotted a pretty girl of no social significance and, having danced with her several times, disappeared from the ballroom. When the tale was told in the clubs on the morrow, younger cynics exclaimed 'What a sell! Good for the Prince', but older men shook their heads and said: 'You don't back a horse that runs out'. Probably none remembered that (as recorded in a recent life) a yet earlier Edward, Prince of Wales, had played much the same trick at the same Government House.

The tour was nearly at an end and I know that many officials heaved a sigh of relief when he had sailed back home to England. Many must have asked themselves whether it had been worth, in political terms, all the expense and anxiety. The Prince and the Mahatma had never met in person but there could be little doubt which of them had come out on top. And what had the Prince seen of real India? He had spent half his time with Maharajahs. What he reported to his family has never, I think, been published. It would be interesting to read. One result was observable. The Government at Delhi hardened its heart, so did the British Government at home, as the threatening speeches of Lloyd George made clear. Anglo-India felt that its Royal Family had been insulted. And Gandhi himself was not slow to take up the challenge in his Young India . 'No Empire intoxicated with the red wine of power and plunder of weaker races has yet lived long in this world, and this British Empire cannot live if there is a just God ruling the universe.' Gandhi himself lived long enough to see his prophecy come true, by which time the Prince had ascended the throne but had already exiled himself into retirement.

S. N. Banerjee, A Nation in the Making , Milford (London, 1925)

  • M. K. Gandhi, Story of my Experiments with Truth , republished by Phoenix Press (London, 1949)
  • Lionel Curtis, Dyarchy , OUP (London, 1920)
  • Jawarharlal Nehru, Autobiography , Lane (now Bodley Head) (London, 1936)
  • Durga Das, India from Curzon to Nehru , Collins (London, 1969)
  • About the Author

    Noel Carrington was a history scholar at Christ Church, Oxford. He has retired from publishing, spent four years in India, and his last book, published in 1978, was about his sister, the artist Dora Carrington.